A Unified Linear Programming Framework for Offline Reward Learning from Human Demonstrations and Feedback
2405.12421
0
0
š
Abstract
Inverse Reinforcement Learning (IRL) and Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) are pivotal methodologies in reward learning, which involve inferring and shaping the underlying reward function of sequential decision-making problems based on observed human demonstrations and feedback. Most prior work in reward learning has relied on prior knowledge or assumptions about decision or preference models, potentially leading to robustness issues. In response, this paper introduces a novel linear programming (LP) framework tailored for offline reward learning. Utilizing pre-collected trajectories without online exploration, this framework estimates a feasible reward set from the primal-dual optimality conditions of a suitably designed LP, and offers an optimality guarantee with provable sample efficiency. Our LP framework also enables aligning the reward functions with human feedback, such as pairwise trajectory comparison data, while maintaining computational tractability and sample efficiency. We demonstrate that our framework potentially achieves better performance compared to the conventional maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) approach through analytical examples and numerical experiments.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a novel linear programming (LP) framework for offline reward learning, which aims to infer and shape the underlying reward function of sequential decision-making problems.
- The framework utilizes pre-collected trajectories without online exploration and offers an optimality guarantee with provable sample efficiency.
- It also enables aligning the reward functions with human feedback, such as pairwise trajectory comparison data, while maintaining computational tractability.
Plain English Explanation
The research paper discusses two important methods in the field of reward learning: Inverse Reinforcement Learning (IRL) and Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF). These methods aim to figure out the underlying reward function that drives a decision-making system, based on observing how humans make decisions or provide feedback.
Previous work in this area has often relied on making assumptions about how people make decisions or express their preferences. This can lead to issues with the robustness and reliability of the inferred reward functions.
To address this, the paper introduces a new linear programming (LP) framework for learning reward functions from pre-collected data, without needing to actively explore and interact with the environment. This framework can estimate a set of feasible reward functions that are consistent with the observed human demonstrations and feedback, and it provides guarantees about the optimality and sample efficiency of the learned rewards.
The key advantage of this approach is that it can incorporate human feedback, such as comparisons between different decision-making trajectories, to help align the learned reward functions with human preferences. This is done in a computationally efficient way, without sacrificing the desirable properties of the framework.
Through examples and experiments, the paper demonstrates that this LP-based approach can potentially outperform the more conventional maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) method for reward learning.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a novel linear programming (LP) framework for offline reward learning, which aims to infer and shape the underlying reward function of sequential decision-making problems based on observed human demonstrations and feedback.
Unlike previous work that has relied on prior knowledge or assumptions about decision or preference models, this framework utilizes pre-collected trajectories without the need for online exploration. The key idea is to estimate a feasible reward set from the primal-dual optimality conditions of a suitably designed LP problem.
This approach offers an optimality guarantee with provable sample efficiency, meaning that the learned reward functions are guaranteed to be optimal given the available data, and the required amount of data is theoretically bounded.
Moreover, the LP framework enables aligning the reward functions with human feedback, such as pairwise trajectory comparison data. This is achieved while maintaining computational tractability and sample efficiency, addressing the potential robustness issues of previous methods that relied on stronger assumptions.
The paper demonstrates the potential benefits of this LP-based approach through analytical examples and numerical experiments, showing that it can potentially outperform the conventional maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) approach for reward learning.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel and promising approach to the challenge of reward learning from human demonstrations and feedback. The introduction of the LP-based framework addresses some key limitations of prior work, which relied on stronger assumptions about decision or preference models.
One potential area for further research could be exploring the robustness of the learned reward functions to distribution shift or noisy feedback. While the framework offers optimality guarantees, it would be valuable to understand how it performs in real-world scenarios where the data may not perfectly match the underlying assumptions.
Additionally, the paper focuses on offline reward learning, where the trajectories are pre-collected. It could be interesting to investigate how this approach can be extended to online and iterative settings, where the agent can actively interact with the environment and learn from feedback in a more dynamic manner.
Furthermore, the paper does not delve into the practical workflow of deploying this framework in real-world applications, such as the integration with other components of the RLHF pipeline. Exploring these practical considerations could help bridge the gap between the theoretical advancements and their practical implementation.
Overall, this paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of reward learning by introducing a novel, theoretically grounded framework that addresses important limitations of prior work. Further research and practical applications of this approach have the potential to advance the state of the art in reinforcement learning from human feedback.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel linear programming (LP) framework for offline reward learning, which aims to infer and shape the underlying reward function of sequential decision-making problems based on observed human demonstrations and feedback.
The key advantages of this framework are its ability to estimate a feasible reward set with optimality guarantees and provable sample efficiency, as well as its capacity to align the learned reward functions with human feedback, such as pairwise trajectory comparisons, while maintaining computational tractability.
The paper demonstrates the potential benefits of this approach through analytical examples and numerical experiments, suggesting that it can outperform the conventional maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) method for reward learning.
The introduction of this LP-based framework represents an important advancement in the field of reward learning, which has broader implications for the development of reinforcement learning systems that can better align with human preferences and values.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
šļø
Offline Inverse RL: New Solution Concepts and Provably Efficient Algorithms
Filippo Lazzati, Mirco Mutti, Alberto Maria Metelli
0
0
Inverse reinforcement learning (IRL) aims to recover the reward function of an expert agent from demonstrations of behavior. It is well-known that the IRL problem is fundamentally ill-posed, i.e., many reward functions can explain the demonstrations. For this reason, IRL has been recently reframed in terms of estimating the feasible reward set (Metelli et al., 2021), thus, postponing the selection of a single reward. However, so far, the available formulations and algorithmic solutions have been proposed and analyzed mainly for the online setting, where the learner can interact with the environment and query the expert at will. This is clearly unrealistic in most practical applications, where the availability of an offline dataset is a much more common scenario. In this paper, we introduce a novel notion of feasible reward set capturing the opportunities and limitations of the offline setting and we analyze the complexity of its estimation. This requires the introduction an original learning framework that copes with the intrinsic difficulty of the setting, for which the data coverage is not under control. Then, we propose two computationally and statistically efficient algorithms, IRLO and PIRLO, for addressing the problem. In particular, the latter adopts a specific form of pessimism to enforce the novel desirable property of inclusion monotonicity of the delivered feasible set. With this work, we aim to provide a panorama of the challenges of the offline IRL problem and how they can be fruitfully addressed.
6/7/2024
š
Online Iterative Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback with General Preference Model
Chenlu Ye, Wei Xiong, Yuheng Zhang, Nan Jiang, Tong Zhang
0
0
We study Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) under a general preference oracle. In particular, we do not assume that there exists a reward function and the preference signal is drawn from the Bradley-Terry model as most of the prior works do. We consider a standard mathematical formulation, the reverse-KL regularized minimax game between two LLMs for RLHF under general preference oracle. The learning objective of this formulation is to find a policy so that it is consistently preferred by the KL-regularized preference oracle over any competing LLMs. We show that this framework is strictly more general than the reward-based one, and propose sample-efficient algorithms for both the offline learning from a pre-collected preference dataset and online learning where we can query the preference oracle along the way of training. Empirical studies verify the effectiveness of the proposed framework.
4/26/2024
š§
RLHF Workflow: From Reward Modeling to Online RLHF
Hanze Dong, Wei Xiong, Bo Pang, Haoxiang Wang, Han Zhao, Yingbo Zhou, Nan Jiang, Doyen Sahoo, Caiming Xiong, Tong Zhang
0
0
We present the workflow of Online Iterative Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) in this technical report, which is widely reported to outperform its offline counterpart by a large margin in the recent large language model (LLM) literature. However, existing open-source RLHF projects are still largely confined to the offline learning setting. In this technical report, we aim to fill in this gap and provide a detailed recipe that is easy to reproduce for online iterative RLHF. In particular, since online human feedback is usually infeasible for open-source communities with limited resources, we start by constructing preference models using a diverse set of open-source datasets and use the constructed proxy preference model to approximate human feedback. Then, we discuss the theoretical insights and algorithmic principles behind online iterative RLHF, followed by a detailed practical implementation. Our trained LLM, LLaMA-3-8B-SFR-Iterative-DPO-R, achieves impressive performance on LLM chatbot benchmarks, including AlpacaEval-2, Arena-Hard, and MT-Bench, as well as other academic benchmarks such as HumanEval and TruthfulQA. We have shown that supervised fine-tuning (SFT) and iterative RLHF can obtain state-of-the-art performance with fully open-source datasets. Further, we have made our models, curated datasets, and comprehensive step-by-step code guidebooks publicly available. Please refer to https://github.com/RLHFlow/RLHF-Reward-Modeling and https://github.com/RLHFlow/Online-RLHF for more detailed information.
6/13/2024
š
A Survey of Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback
Timo Kaufmann, Paul Weng, Viktor Bengs, Eyke Hullermeier
0
0
Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) is a variant of reinforcement learning (RL) that learns from human feedback instead of relying on an engineered reward function. Building on prior work on the related setting of preference-based reinforcement learning (PbRL), it stands at the intersection of artificial intelligence and human-computer interaction. This positioning offers a promising avenue to enhance the performance and adaptability of intelligent systems while also improving the alignment of their objectives with human values. The training of large language models (LLMs) has impressively demonstrated this potential in recent years, where RLHF played a decisive role in directing the model's capabilities toward human objectives. This article provides a comprehensive overview of the fundamentals of RLHF, exploring the intricate dynamics between RL agents and human input. While recent focus has been on RLHF for LLMs, our survey adopts a broader perspective, examining the diverse applications and wide-ranging impact of the technique. We delve into the core principles that underpin RLHF, shedding light on the symbiotic relationship between algorithms and human feedback, and discuss the main research trends in the field. By synthesizing the current landscape of RLHF research, this article aims to provide researchers as well as practitioners with a comprehensive understanding of this rapidly growing field of research.
5/1/2024