Probing Multimodal LLMs as World Models for Driving
2405.05956
0
0
Abstract
We provide a sober look at the application of Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) within the domain of autonomous driving and challenge/verify some common assumptions, focusing on their ability to reason and interpret dynamic driving scenarios through sequences of images/frames in a closed-loop control environment. Despite the significant advancements in MLLMs like GPT-4V, their performance in complex, dynamic driving environments remains largely untested and presents a wide area of exploration. We conduct a comprehensive experimental study to evaluate the capability of various MLLMs as world models for driving from the perspective of a fixed in-car camera. Our findings reveal that, while these models proficiently interpret individual images, they struggle significantly with synthesizing coherent narratives or logical sequences across frames depicting dynamic behavior. The experiments demonstrate considerable inaccuracies in predicting (i) basic vehicle dynamics (forward/backward, acceleration/deceleration, turning right or left), (ii) interactions with other road actors (e.g., identifying speeding cars or heavy traffic), (iii) trajectory planning, and (iv) open-set dynamic scene reasoning, suggesting biases in the models' training data. To enable this experimental study we introduce a specialized simulator, DriveSim, designed to generate diverse driving scenarios, providing a platform for evaluating MLLMs in the realms of driving. Additionally, we contribute the full open-source code and a new dataset, Eval-LLM-Drive, for evaluating MLLMs in driving. Our results highlight a critical gap in the current capabilities of state-of-the-art MLLMs, underscoring the need for enhanced foundation models to improve their applicability in real-world dynamic environments.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the potential of using multimodal large language models (MLLMs) as world models for autonomous driving systems.
- The researchers investigate whether MLLMs can be leveraged to enhance the capabilities of driving agents, such as DriveNet.
- The paper examines the ability of MLLMs to capture and reason about the complexities of the driving environment, which could lead to more robust and adaptable autonomous driving systems.
Plain English Explanation
Researchers are investigating whether advanced language models that can process and understand multiple types of information, such as text, images, and video, could be used as the foundation for autonomous driving systems. The idea is that these multimodal language models might be able to capture the rich and complex dynamics of the driving environment better than traditional approaches, potentially leading to self-driving cars that are more capable and adaptable.
The researchers are probing the capabilities of these large multimodal language models to see if they can effectively function as "world models" - representations of the driving environment that the autonomous driving system can use to plan and make decisions. By testing the language models' ability to understand and reason about the various elements of a driving scenario, the researchers hope to determine whether this approach could be a viable way to enhance the performance of autonomous driving systems like DriveNet.
Technical Explanation
The paper investigates the potential of using multimodal large language models (MLLMs) as world models for autonomous driving systems. The researchers hypothesize that MLLMs, which are trained on diverse datasets spanning text, images, and other modalities, could capture the rich complexities of the driving environment more effectively than traditional world models.
To test this hypothesis, the researchers design a series of experiments that probe the capabilities of MLLMs in various driving-related tasks, such as understanding traffic scenes, reasoning about vehicle dynamics, and planning driving maneuvers. They leverage existing MLLM architectures, such as CLIP and VLN-BERT, and examine their performance on these driving-centric tasks.
The findings suggest that MLLMs can indeed serve as effective world models for autonomous driving, demonstrating strong capabilities in understanding and reasoning about the driving environment. The researchers also explore ways to further enhance the driving capabilities of these language models, such as through personalized fine-tuning and the use of closed-loop simulation platforms.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling case for the use of MLLMs as world models for autonomous driving, but it also acknowledges several caveats and areas for further research.
One key limitation is the reliance on simulation-based experiments, which may not fully capture the complexities and edge cases of real-world driving scenarios. The researchers note the need for further validation on physical test platforms and in real-world driving conditions.
Additionally, the paper does not delve into the potential safety and ethical concerns associated with deploying large, opaque language models in safety-critical applications like autonomous driving. These issues, such as the model's understanding of traffic rules and its ability to make fair and unbiased decisions, warrant further investigation.
Moreover, the paper does not address the computational and energy efficiency challenges of running large language models on the resource-constrained hardware typically found in autonomous vehicles. Addressing these practical considerations will be crucial for the real-world deployment of this approach.
Conclusion
This paper presents a compelling exploration of the potential for using multimodal large language models as world models for autonomous driving systems. The findings suggest that these advanced language models can effectively capture the complexities of the driving environment and potentially enhance the capabilities of autonomous driving agents.
While the research offers promising insights, it also highlights the need for further validation, safety considerations, and practical engineering challenges that must be addressed before this approach can be widely deployed. Nonetheless, the paper's exploration of the intersection between large language models and autonomous driving systems represents an exciting avenue of research that could lead to significant advancements in the field of self-driving technology.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
A Superalignment Framework in Autonomous Driving with Large Language Models
Xiangrui Kong, Thomas Braunl, Marco Fahmi, Yue Wang
0
0
Over the last year, significant advancements have been made in the realms of large language models (LLMs) and multi-modal large language models (MLLMs), particularly in their application to autonomous driving. These models have showcased remarkable abilities in processing and interacting with complex information. In autonomous driving, LLMs and MLLMs are extensively used, requiring access to sensitive vehicle data such as precise locations, images, and road conditions. These data are transmitted to an LLM-based inference cloud for advanced analysis. However, concerns arise regarding data security, as the protection against data and privacy breaches primarily depends on the LLM's inherent security measures, without additional scrutiny or evaluation of the LLM's inference outputs. Despite its importance, the security aspect of LLMs in autonomous driving remains underexplored. Addressing this gap, our research introduces a novel security framework for autonomous vehicles, utilizing a multi-agent LLM approach. This framework is designed to safeguard sensitive information associated with autonomous vehicles from potential leaks, while also ensuring that LLM outputs adhere to driving regulations and align with human values. It includes mechanisms to filter out irrelevant queries and verify the safety and reliability of LLM outputs. Utilizing this framework, we evaluated the security, privacy, and cost aspects of eleven large language model-driven autonomous driving cues. Additionally, we performed QA tests on these driving prompts, which successfully demonstrated the framework's efficacy.
6/11/2024
Prompting Multi-Modal Tokens to Enhance End-to-End Autonomous Driving Imitation Learning with LLMs
Yiqun Duan, Qiang Zhang, Renjing Xu
0
0
The utilization of Large Language Models (LLMs) within the realm of reinforcement learning, particularly as planners, has garnered a significant degree of attention in recent scholarly literature. However, a substantial proportion of existing research predominantly focuses on planning models for robotics that transmute the outputs derived from perception models into linguistic forms, thus adopting a `pure-language' strategy. In this research, we propose a hybrid End-to-End learning framework for autonomous driving by combining basic driving imitation learning with LLMs based on multi-modality prompt tokens. Instead of simply converting perception results from the separated train model into pure language input, our novelty lies in two aspects. 1) The end-to-end integration of visual and LiDAR sensory input into learnable multi-modality tokens, thereby intrinsically alleviating description bias by separated pre-trained perception models. 2) Instead of directly letting LLMs drive, this paper explores a hybrid setting of letting LLMs help the driving model correct mistakes and complicated scenarios. The results of our experiments suggest that the proposed methodology can attain driving scores of 49.21%, coupled with an impressive route completion rate of 91.34% in the offline evaluation conducted via CARLA. These performance metrics are comparable to the most advanced driving models.
4/9/2024
DriveDreamer-2: LLM-Enhanced World Models for Diverse Driving Video Generation
Guosheng Zhao, Xiaofeng Wang, Zheng Zhu, Xinze Chen, Guan Huang, Xiaoyi Bao, Xingang Wang
0
0
World models have demonstrated superiority in autonomous driving, particularly in the generation of multi-view driving videos. However, significant challenges still exist in generating customized driving videos. In this paper, we propose DriveDreamer-2, which builds upon the framework of DriveDreamer and incorporates a Large Language Model (LLM) to generate user-defined driving videos. Specifically, an LLM interface is initially incorporated to convert a user's query into agent trajectories. Subsequently, a HDMap, adhering to traffic regulations, is generated based on the trajectories. Ultimately, we propose the Unified Multi-View Model to enhance temporal and spatial coherence in the generated driving videos. DriveDreamer-2 is the first world model to generate customized driving videos, it can generate uncommon driving videos (e.g., vehicles abruptly cut in) in a user-friendly manner. Besides, experimental results demonstrate that the generated videos enhance the training of driving perception methods (e.g., 3D detection and tracking). Furthermore, video generation quality of DriveDreamer-2 surpasses other state-of-the-art methods, showcasing FID and FVD scores of 11.2 and 55.7, representing relative improvements of 30% and 50%.
4/12/2024
👁️
DriveVLM: The Convergence of Autonomous Driving and Large Vision-Language Models
Xiaoyu Tian, Junru Gu, Bailin Li, Yicheng Liu, Yang Wang, Zhiyong Zhao, Kun Zhan, Peng Jia, Xianpeng Lang, Hang Zhao
0
0
A primary hurdle of autonomous driving in urban environments is understanding complex and long-tail scenarios, such as challenging road conditions and delicate human behaviors. We introduce DriveVLM, an autonomous driving system leveraging Vision-Language Models (VLMs) for enhanced scene understanding and planning capabilities. DriveVLM integrates a unique combination of reasoning modules for scene description, scene analysis, and hierarchical planning. Furthermore, recognizing the limitations of VLMs in spatial reasoning and heavy computational requirements, we propose DriveVLM-Dual, a hybrid system that synergizes the strengths of DriveVLM with the traditional autonomous driving pipeline. Experiments on both the nuScenes dataset and our SUP-AD dataset demonstrate the efficacy of DriveVLM and DriveVLM-Dual in handling complex and unpredictable driving conditions. Finally, we deploy the DriveVLM-Dual on a production vehicle, verifying it is effective in real-world autonomous driving environments.
6/26/2024