Programming Skills are Not Enough: a Greedy Strategy to Attract More Girls to Study Computer Science

Read original: arXiv:2302.06304 - Published 9/12/2024 by Tiziana Catarci, Luca Podo, Daniel Raffini, Paola Velardi
Total Score

0

📉

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper discusses the challenge of getting female high school students interested in information and communication technology (ICT) fields.
  • It describes programs coordinated by the Engineering and Computer Science Departments at Sapienza University to raise awareness among high school girls about the importance of new technologies and ICT.
  • The paper covers both the theoretical approach and provides examples of specific projects.

Plain English Explanation

Many studies have found that female students are generally unwilling to pursue courses of study in ICT fields. Researchers have also discovered that it is very difficult to change the biases and prejudices that girls develop towards these disciplines during adolescence. This suggests that awareness programs about computer-related subjects should be offered at the pre-school or early school age, before these negative perceptions become ingrained.

However, even if large-scale computer literacy programs can be quickly implemented in lower schools and kindergartens, it will still take 15-20 years before we can see the full effects of these efforts. In the meantime, the lack of women in ICT fields is having a tangible negative impact on technological innovation in many countries, which requires more immediate action.

This paper outlines a strategy and details several programs run by the Engineering and Computer Science Departments at Sapienza University to make high school girls more aware of the importance of new technologies and ICT. The paper covers both the theoretical framework behind these initiatives as well as providing specific examples of the projects.

Technical Explanation

The paper describes a multi-pronged approach taken by the Engineering and Computer Science Departments at Sapienza University to increase awareness and interest in ICT fields among high school girls.

Key elements of their strategy include:

  • Offering exposure and education about ICT disciplines starting at the pre-school and lower school ages, before negative perceptions about these fields become deeply rooted in adolescence.
  • Designing awareness programs to proactively counter the prejudices that many girls develop towards computer science and related subjects.
  • Implementing targeted programs at the high school level to demonstrate the exciting and rewarding nature of careers in ICT fields.
  • Leveraging social capital and role models to inspire and encourage young women to pursue educational and professional paths in technology.

The paper provides several concrete examples of the programs coordinated by the university departments, such as interactive workshops, coding camps, and mentorship initiatives. These are designed to actively engage high school girls and showcase the varied opportunities available in ICT.

Critical Analysis

The paper rightly points out the urgent need to address the longstanding gender imbalance in ICT fields, which has significant negative consequences for technological innovation. The authors' multi-faceted approach of starting interventions at an early age and providing targeted programs for high school students is well-founded.

However, the paper does not delve deeply into potential limitations or challenges of the proposed strategy. For example, it does not address issues around scaling up the university's initiatives to reach a wider population of students. There is also no discussion of how to sustain girls' interest and engagement in ICT beyond the high school years and into higher education and careers.

Additionally, while the paper references relevant research on gender biases and social capital, it could benefit from a more thorough grounding in the existing literature on barriers and interventions for increasing female participation in STEM fields. A more critical examination of the underlying causes and potential solutions would strengthen the analysis.

Conclusion

This paper outlines a comprehensive strategy and specific programs implemented by Sapienza University to raise awareness and interest in ICT among high school girls. By starting interventions early and providing targeted initiatives at the secondary school level, the university is working to counter the prevalent biases and misconceptions that prevent many young women from pursuing educational and professional paths in technology.

While the paper could be strengthened by a more critical examination of the approach and its limitations, it represents an important step towards addressing the significant gender imbalance in ICT fields. Inspiring and equipping the next generation of female technologists has crucial implications for driving innovation and progress in our increasingly digital world.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

📉

Total Score

0

Programming Skills are Not Enough: a Greedy Strategy to Attract More Girls to Study Computer Science

Tiziana Catarci, Luca Podo, Daniel Raffini, Paola Velardi

It has been observed in many studies that female students in general are unwilling to undertake a course of study in ICT. Recent literature has also pointed out that undermining the prejudices of girls with respect to these disciplines is very difficult in adolescence, suggesting that, to be effective, awareness programs on computer disciplines should be offered in pre-school or lower school age. On the other hand, even assuming that large-scale computer literacy programs can be immediately activated in lower schools and kindergartens, we can't wait for >15-20 years before we can appreciate the effectiveness of these programs. The scarcity of women in ICT has a tangible negative impact on countries' technological innovation, which requires immediate action. In this paper, we describe a strategy, and the details of a number of programs coordinated by the Engineering and Computer Science Departments at Sapienza University, to make high school girl students aware of the importance of new technologies and ICT. In addition to describing the theoretical approach, the paper offers some project examples.

Read more

9/12/2024

FemQuest -- An Interactive Multiplayer Game to Engage Girls in Programming
Total Score

0

FemQuest -- An Interactive Multiplayer Game to Engage Girls in Programming

Michael Holly, Lisa Habich, Maria Seiser, Florian Glawogger, Kevin Innerebner, Sandra Kupsa, Philipp Einwallner, Johanna Pirker

In recent decades, computer science (CS) has undergone remarkable growth and diversification. Creating attractive, social, or hands-on games has already been identified as a possible approach to get teenagers and young adults interested in CS. However, overcoming the global gap between the interest and participation of men and women in CS is still a worldwide problem. To address this challenge, we present a multiplayer game that is used in a workshop setting to motivate girls to program through a 3D game environment. The paper aims to expand the educational landscape within computer science education by offering a motivating and engaging platform for young women to explore programming quests in a collaborative environment. The study involved 235 girls and 50 coaches for the workshop evaluation and a subset of 20 participants for an in-game analysis. In this paper, we explore the engagement in programming and assess the cognitive workload while playing and solving programming quests within the game, as well as the learning experience and the outcome. The results show that the positive outcomes of the workshop underscore the effectiveness of a game-based collaborative learning approach to get girls interested in computer science activities. The variety of solutions found for the different tasks demonstrates the creativity and problem-solving skills of the participants and underlines the effectiveness of the workshop in promoting critical thinking and computational skills.

Read more

7/29/2024

💬

Total Score

0

Social Capital and Persistence in Computer Science of Google's Computer Science Summer Institute (CSSI) Students

Marjan Naghshbandi, Sharon Ferguson, Alison Olechowski

While a lucrative and growing field, low levels of gender and racial diversity in CS remain prevalent. Education and workforce support programs with the intention to promote underrepresented students' persistence in CS exist, which teach skills, inform of career options, and grow students' network in CS. Studies demonstrate these programs' effectiveness as it relates to changes in affective outcomes, such as participants' confidence in CS skills and attitudes towards CS jobs. However, programs' longitudinal impact on participants' build-up of social capital in CS, and the resulting social capital's influence on their persistence in CS, remain unexplored. Motivated by the literature that associates demographic identifiers with access to social capital, and students' access to developmental relationships and career resources (social capital) in CS with their persistence, this study explores a CS support program's impact on persistence through capital building. We focus on Google's CSSI, which provided graduating high school students with a 3-week-long introduction to CS. We use interviews with participants who are now 2-5 years out of the program to study CSSI's impact on their social capital and long-term CS persistence. Thematic analysis reveals three program elements that influenced students' build-up of social capital, and that the resulting persistence was realized through students' progress towards internships and goals for paying-it-forward in CS. These findings inform our recommendations that future support programs and educational settings consider mentorship centered on socioemotional support, opportunities for collaboration, and time for fun social activities. Additional suggestions center on engaging socially-oriented individuals with CS support programs. These insights inform CS educators on design choices that can encourage the persistence of underrepresented students in CS.

Read more

7/22/2024

Gender of Recruiter Makes a Difference: A study into Cybersecurity Graduate Recruitment
Total Score

0

Gender of Recruiter Makes a Difference: A study into Cybersecurity Graduate Recruitment

Joanne L. Hall, Asha Rao

An ever-widening workforce gap exists in the global cybersecurity industry but diverse talent is underutilized. The global cybersecurity workforce is only 25% female. Much research exists on the effect of gender bias on the hiring of women into the technical workforce, but little on how the gender of the recruiter (gender difference) affects recruitment decisions. This research reveals differences between the non-technical skills sought by female vs non-female cybersecurity recruiters. The former look for recruits with people-focused skills while the latter look for task-focused skills, highlighting the need for gender diversity in recruitment panels. Recruiters are increasingly seeking non-technical (soft) skills in technical graduate recruits. This requires STEM curriculum in Universities to adapt to match. Designing an industry-ready cybersecurity curriculum requires knowledge of these non-technical skills. An online survey of cybersecurity professionals was used to determine the most sought after non-technical skills in the field. Analysis of the data reveals distinct gender differences in the non-technical skills most valued in a recruit, based on the gender of the recruiter (not the recruited). The gender differences discovered do not correspond to the higher proportion of women employed in non-technical cybersecurity roles.

Read more

8/13/2024