Social Capital and Persistence in Computer Science of Google's Computer Science Summer Institute (CSSI) Students
0
💬
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Computer science (CS) continues to have low levels of gender and racial diversity.
- Education and workforce support programs aim to promote underrepresented students' persistence in CS.
- These programs teach skills, inform of career options, and grow students' network in CS.
- Studies show these programs' effectiveness in improving participants' confidence and attitudes towards CS jobs.
- However, the long-term impact of these programs on participants' social capital and persistence in CS is still unexplored.
Plain English Explanation
The paper explores how a computer science (CS) support program can help build up underrepresented students' social capital and influence their long-term persistence in the field.
While CS is a lucrative and growing field, it still lacks diversity in terms of gender and race. To address this, various education and workforce programs have been created to support underrepresented students and help them continue pursuing CS.
These programs teach technical skills, inform students about career options, and help them build a network in the CS community. Research has shown that these programs can positively impact participants' confidence in their CS abilities and their attitudes towards CS-related jobs.
However, the lasting impact of these programs on students' social capital (their access to relationships and resources) and how that affects their long-term persistence in CS has not yet been explored.
Motivated by the idea that demographic factors influence access to social capital, and that social capital in turn impacts CS persistence, this study focuses on Google's Computer Science Summer Institute (CSSI) program. The researchers interviewed CSSI participants 2-5 years after the program to understand how it influenced their social capital and long-term commitment to CS.
Technical Explanation
The study focused on Google's Computer Science Summer Institute (CSSI), a 3-week program that provides graduating high school students with an introduction to computer science. The researchers conducted interviews with CSSI participants who were 2-5 years out of the program to explore the long-term impact on their social capital and persistence in CS.
Through thematic analysis, the researchers identified three key elements of the CSSI program that influenced students' social capital development:
- Mentorship centered on socioemotional support
- Opportunities for collaboration
- Time for fun social activities
The study found that the social capital built through these program elements ultimately supported participants' persistence in CS, as it helped them progress towards internships and develop a desire to "pay it forward" by supporting others in the field.
Critical Analysis
The study provides valuable insights into how CS support programs can foster the long-term persistence of underrepresented students through the development of social capital. By focusing on the CSSI program's specific elements that contributed to social capital building, the researchers offer concrete design recommendations for future programs.
However, the study is limited by its reliance on self-reported data from interviews, which could be subject to biases. Additionally, the research does not compare the CSSI participants' outcomes to a control group, so it's unclear how the program's impact compares to students who did not participate.
Further research could explore the differences in social capital and persistence between CSSI participants and non-participants, as well as investigate how the program's long-term effects may vary based on factors such as participants' initial levels of confidence, network connections, or socioeconomic status.
Conclusion
This study suggests that CS support programs can positively impact underrepresented students' long-term persistence in the field by deliberately fostering the development of their social capital. The researchers' recommendations for program design, such as incorporating mentorship, collaboration, and social activities, provide valuable guidance for educators and policymakers seeking to improve diversity and inclusion in computer science.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
💬
0
Social Capital and Persistence in Computer Science of Google's Computer Science Summer Institute (CSSI) Students
Marjan Naghshbandi, Sharon Ferguson, Alison Olechowski
While a lucrative and growing field, low levels of gender and racial diversity in CS remain prevalent. Education and workforce support programs with the intention to promote underrepresented students' persistence in CS exist, which teach skills, inform of career options, and grow students' network in CS. Studies demonstrate these programs' effectiveness as it relates to changes in affective outcomes, such as participants' confidence in CS skills and attitudes towards CS jobs. However, programs' longitudinal impact on participants' build-up of social capital in CS, and the resulting social capital's influence on their persistence in CS, remain unexplored. Motivated by the literature that associates demographic identifiers with access to social capital, and students' access to developmental relationships and career resources (social capital) in CS with their persistence, this study explores a CS support program's impact on persistence through capital building. We focus on Google's CSSI, which provided graduating high school students with a 3-week-long introduction to CS. We use interviews with participants who are now 2-5 years out of the program to study CSSI's impact on their social capital and long-term CS persistence. Thematic analysis reveals three program elements that influenced students' build-up of social capital, and that the resulting persistence was realized through students' progress towards internships and goals for paying-it-forward in CS. These findings inform our recommendations that future support programs and educational settings consider mentorship centered on socioemotional support, opportunities for collaboration, and time for fun social activities. Additional suggestions center on engaging socially-oriented individuals with CS support programs. These insights inform CS educators on design choices that can encourage the persistence of underrepresented students in CS.
Read more7/22/2024
🌐
0
Software Engineering Through Community-Engaged Learning and an Inclusive Network
Nowshin Nawar Arony, Kezia Devathasan, Ze Shi Li, Daniela Damian
Retaining diverse, underrepresented students in computer science and software engineering programs is a significant concern for universities. In this chapter, we describe the INSPIRE: STEM for Social Impact program at the University of Victoria, Canada, which leverages the three principles of self-determination theory competence, relatedness, and autonomy in the design of strategies to empower women and other underrepresented groups in using software and other engineering solutions to approach sustainability, community-driven problems. We also describe lessons learned from a first successful year that involved over 30 students, 6 community partners (sustainability problem owners), and over 20 industry and academic mentors and reached out to more than 200 solution end users in our communities. Finally, we provide recommendations for universities and organizations who may want to adopt our approach. In the program 24 diverse students (in terms of gender, sexual orientation, ethnicity, academic standing, and background) divided into six teams paired with six community partners worked on solving society impactful problems and developed solutions for a number of respective community partners. Each team was supported by an experienced upper year student and mentors from industry and community throughout the program. The experiential learning approach of the program allowed the students to learn a variety of soft and technical skills while developing a solution that has a social and/or environmental impact. Having a diverse team and creating a solution for real end users motivated the students to actively collaborate with their peers, community partners, and mentors resulting in the development of an inclusive network. A network of like minded people is crucial in empowering underrepresented individuals and inspiring them to remain in the computer science and software engineering fields.
Read more8/13/2024
📉
0
Programming Skills are Not Enough: a Greedy Strategy to Attract More Girls to Study Computer Science
Tiziana Catarci, Luca Podo, Daniel Raffini, Paola Velardi
It has been observed in many studies that female students in general are unwilling to undertake a course of study in ICT. Recent literature has also pointed out that undermining the prejudices of girls with respect to these disciplines is very difficult in adolescence, suggesting that, to be effective, awareness programs on computer disciplines should be offered in pre-school or lower school age. On the other hand, even assuming that large-scale computer literacy programs can be immediately activated in lower schools and kindergartens, we can't wait for >15-20 years before we can appreciate the effectiveness of these programs. The scarcity of women in ICT has a tangible negative impact on countries' technological innovation, which requires immediate action. In this paper, we describe a strategy, and the details of a number of programs coordinated by the Engineering and Computer Science Departments at Sapienza University, to make high school girl students aware of the importance of new technologies and ICT. In addition to describing the theoretical approach, the paper offers some project examples.
Read more9/12/2024
0
Improving engagement, diversity, and retention in computer science with RadGrad: Results of a case study
Philip M. Johnson, Carleton Moore, Peter Leong, Seungoh Paek
RadGrad is a curriculum initiative implemented via an application that combines features of social networks, degree planners, individual learning plans, and serious games. RadGrad redefines traditional meanings of progress and success in the undergraduate computer science degree program in an attempt to improve engagement, retention, and diversity. In this paper, we describe the RadGrad Project and report on an evaluation study designed to assess the impact of RadGrad on student engagement, diversity, and retention. We also present opportunities and challenges that result from the use of the system.
Read more7/26/2024