Promoting Fairness in Link Prediction with Graph Enhancement

Read original: arXiv:2409.08658 - Published 9/16/2024 by Yezi Liu, Hanning Chen, Mohsen Imani
Total Score

0

Promoting Fairness in Link Prediction with Graph Enhancement

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • The paper focuses on promoting fairness in link prediction tasks using graph enhancement techniques.
  • It introduces a new graph enhancement method to mitigate bias and improve fairness in link prediction models.
  • The proposed approach involves modifying the graph structure to reduce unfairness while preserving the original graph properties.
  • Experiments on real-world datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of the method in achieving improved fairness without compromising prediction performance.

Plain English Explanation

Link prediction is a common task in network analysis, where the goal is to identify new connections or relationships between entities in a graph or network. However, standard link prediction models can sometimes exhibit unfairness, favoring certain groups or individuals over others.

To address this issue, the researchers developed a graph enhancement technique that modifies the underlying graph structure in a way that promotes fairness. The key idea is to introduce additional edges or connections in the graph that help to balance the representation of different groups, without significantly altering the original graph properties.

By enhancing the graph in this way, the link prediction model is then trained on the modified graph, which encourages it to make fairer predictions. The researchers tested their approach on real-world datasets and found that it was able to achieve improved fairness in the link predictions, while still maintaining good overall prediction performance.

This research is important because it demonstrates a practical way to incorporate fairness considerations into graph-based machine learning models, which is crucial for ensuring these models are equitable and do not reinforce or exacerbate societal biases.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces a graph enhancement method to promote fairness in link prediction tasks. The key steps are:

  1. Defining Fairness Metrics: The authors define fairness metrics based on the demographic parity and equal opportunity principles, which capture the degree of disparity in link prediction performance across different subgroups.

  2. Graph Enhancement: The proposed graph enhancement technique modifies the input graph by adding new edges in a way that reduces the fairness metrics, without significantly altering the original graph properties. This is achieved by solving an optimization problem that balances fairness and graph similarity.

  3. Link Prediction Model Training: The link prediction model is then trained on the enhanced graph, which encourages it to make fairer predictions by accounting for the modified graph structure.

The authors evaluate their approach on real-world datasets and demonstrate that the graph enhancement method is able to achieve improved fairness in link prediction, as measured by the defined fairness metrics, while maintaining comparable overall prediction performance to standard link prediction models.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and promising approach for promoting fairness in link prediction tasks. The graph enhancement technique is a clever way to incorporate fairness considerations into the model without significantly changing the underlying data distribution.

However, the paper does not address potential limitations or edge cases of the proposed method. For example, the graph enhancement approach may not work as well on highly imbalanced or sparse graphs, where there are limited opportunities to add new edges. Additionally, the optimization problem for determining the new edges could become computationally expensive for large-scale graphs.

Furthermore, the paper focuses solely on fairness metrics based on demographic parity and equal opportunity, which may not capture all aspects of fairness. Other fairness notions, such as individual fairness or counterfactual fairness, could also be considered to provide a more comprehensive fairness evaluation.

Despite these potential limitations, the paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of fair graph neural networks and fair machine learning more broadly. The proposed graph enhancement technique offers a practical way to mitigate bias in link prediction models and can inspire further research in this important area.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel graph enhancement method for promoting fairness in link prediction tasks. By modifying the input graph structure to reduce unfairness, the link prediction model is encouraged to make fairer predictions without significantly compromising overall performance.

The findings of this research are significant, as they demonstrate a practical approach for incorporating fairness considerations into graph-based machine learning models. This is crucial for ensuring these models are equitable and do not perpetuate or exacerbate societal biases.

While the paper has some potential limitations, it represents an important step forward in the field of fair machine learning and opens up avenues for further research and development in this area.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Promoting Fairness in Link Prediction with Graph Enhancement
Total Score

0

Promoting Fairness in Link Prediction with Graph Enhancement

Yezi Liu, Hanning Chen, Mohsen Imani

Link prediction is a crucial task in network analysis, but it has been shown to be prone to biased predictions, particularly when links are unfairly predicted between nodes from different sensitive groups. In this paper, we study the fair link prediction problem, which aims to ensure that the predicted link probability is independent of the sensitive attributes of the connected nodes. Existing methods typically incorporate debiasing techniques within graph embeddings to mitigate this issue. However, training on large real-world graphs is already challenging, and adding fairness constraints can further complicate the process. To overcome this challenge, we propose FairLink, a method that learns a fairness-enhanced graph to bypass the need for debiasing during the link predictor's training. FairLink maintains link prediction accuracy by ensuring that the enhanced graph follows a training trajectory similar to that of the original input graph. Meanwhile, it enhances fairness by minimizing the absolute difference in link probabilities between node pairs within the same sensitive group and those between node pairs from different sensitive groups. Our extensive experiments on multiple large-scale graphs demonstrate that FairLink not only promotes fairness but also often achieves link prediction accuracy comparable to baseline methods. Most importantly, the enhanced graph exhibits strong generalizability across different GNN architectures.

Read more

9/16/2024

🧠

Total Score

0

Networked Inequality: Preferential Attachment Bias in Graph Neural Network Link Prediction

Arjun Subramonian, Levent Sagun, Yizhou Sun

Graph neural network (GNN) link prediction is increasingly deployed in citation, collaboration, and online social networks to recommend academic literature, collaborators, and friends. While prior research has investigated the dyadic fairness of GNN link prediction, the within-group (e.g., queer women) fairness and rich get richer dynamics of link prediction remain underexplored. However, these aspects have significant consequences for degree and power imbalances in networks. In this paper, we shed light on how degree bias in networks affects Graph Convolutional Network (GCN) link prediction. In particular, we theoretically uncover that GCNs with a symmetric normalized graph filter have a within-group preferential attachment bias. We validate our theoretical analysis on real-world citation, collaboration, and online social networks. We further bridge GCN's preferential attachment bias with unfairness in link prediction and propose a new within-group fairness metric. This metric quantifies disparities in link prediction scores within social groups, towards combating the amplification of degree and power disparities. Finally, we propose a simple training-time strategy to alleviate within-group unfairness, and we show that it is effective on citation, social, and credit networks.

Read more

6/6/2024

🧠

Total Score

0

Fair Graph Neural Network with Supervised Contrastive Regularization

Mahdi Tavassoli Kejani (UT3), Fadi Dornaika (IMT), Jean-Michel Loubes (IMT)

In recent years, Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have made significant advancements, particularly in tasks such as node classification, link prediction, and graph representation. However, challenges arise from biases that can be hidden not only in the node attributes but also in the connections between entities. Therefore, ensuring fairness in graph neural network learning has become a critical problem. To address this issue, we propose a novel model for training fairness-aware GNN, which enhances the Counterfactual Augmented Fair Graph Neural Network Framework (CAF). Our approach integrates Supervised Contrastive Loss and Environmental Loss to enhance both accuracy and fairness. Experimental validation on three real datasets demonstrates the superiority of our proposed model over CAF and several other existing graph-based learning methods.

Read more

4/10/2024

Fair Augmentation for Graph Collaborative Filtering
Total Score

0

Fair Augmentation for Graph Collaborative Filtering

Ludovico Boratto, Francesco Fabbri, Gianni Fenu, Mirko Marras, Giacomo Medda

Recent developments in recommendation have harnessed the collaborative power of graph neural networks (GNNs) in learning users' preferences from user-item networks. Despite emerging regulations addressing fairness of automated systems, unfairness issues in graph collaborative filtering remain underexplored, especially from the consumer's perspective. Despite numerous contributions on consumer unfairness, only a few of these works have delved into GNNs. A notable gap exists in the formalization of the latest mitigation algorithms, as well as in their effectiveness and reliability on cutting-edge models. This paper serves as a solid response to recent research highlighting unfairness issues in graph collaborative filtering by reproducing one of the latest mitigation methods. The reproduced technique adjusts the system fairness level by learning a fair graph augmentation. Under an experimental setup based on 11 GNNs, 5 non-GNN models, and 5 real-world networks across diverse domains, our investigation reveals that fair graph augmentation is consistently effective on high-utility models and large datasets. Experiments on the transferability of the fair augmented graph open new issues for future recommendation studies. Source code: https://github.com/jackmedda/FA4GCF.

Read more

8/23/2024