Pseudo-label Learning with Calibrated Confidence Using an Energy-based Model
2404.09585
0
0
Abstract
In pseudo-labeling (PL), which is a type of semi-supervised learning, pseudo-labels are assigned based on the confidence scores provided by the classifier; therefore, accurate confidence is important for successful PL. In this study, we propose a PL algorithm based on an energy-based model (EBM), which is referred to as the energy-based PL (EBPL). In EBPL, a neural network-based classifier and an EBM are jointly trained by sharing their feature extraction parts. This approach enables the model to learn both the class decision boundary and input data distribution, enhancing confidence calibration during network training. The experimental results demonstrate that EBPL outperforms the existing PL method in semi-supervised image classification tasks, with superior confidence calibration error and recognition accuracy.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a semi-supervised learning method called "Pseudo-label Learning with Calibrated Confidence Using an Energy-based Model" (PLC-EBM).
- The key ideas are using an energy-based model to estimate well-calibrated confidence scores for unlabeled data, and then using these confidence scores to guide the pseudo-labeling process.
- The method aims to improve the performance of semi-supervised learning by addressing the challenge of overconfident pseudo-labels, which can hinder learning.
Plain English Explanation
In machine learning, there are often situations where we have a lot of unlabeled data (data without known answers) but only a small amount of labeled data (data with known answers). Semi-supervised learning is a way to leverage the unlabeled data to improve the model's performance, even with limited labeled data.
One common semi-supervised technique is "pseudo-labeling", where the model makes its best guess at the labels for the unlabeled data and then uses those guesses, or "pseudo-labels", to help train the model. However, the model can sometimes be overly confident in its pseudo-labels, leading to problems during training.
The PLC-EBM method proposed in this paper tries to address this issue. It uses a special type of model called an "energy-based model" to estimate how confident the model is in its pseudo-labels. This allows the method to use the more reliable pseudo-labels and discard the less reliable ones, leading to better overall performance.
The key insight is that energy-based models can provide well-calibrated confidence scores, meaning the model's estimated confidence levels accurately reflect how likely the pseudo-labels are to be correct. This helps the semi-supervised learning process by ensuring the model focuses on the most trustworthy pseudo-labels.
Technical Explanation
The PLC-EBM method consists of two main components: an energy-based model (EBM) and a pseudo-labeling process.
The EBM is trained to estimate the "energy" or likelihood of each data point belonging to each class. These energy values are then converted into well-calibrated confidence scores using a temperature scaling approach, similar to the technique described in the Calibration-Aware Bayesian Learning paper.
The pseudo-labeling process then uses these confidence scores to selectively include or exclude unlabeled data points during training. Specifically, unlabeled data points with high confidence scores are used as pseudo-labels, while those with low confidence scores are discarded.
The authors evaluate PLC-EBM on several semi-supervised image classification benchmarks and show that it outperforms other state-of-the-art semi-supervised learning methods, particularly when the amount of labeled data is limited.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough evaluation of the PLC-EBM method, including comparisons to various baseline approaches. The authors also discuss several limitations and potential future research directions.
One limitation is that the method relies on the energy-based model's ability to produce well-calibrated confidence scores. While the authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their temperature scaling approach, there may be other ways to improve the confidence calibration, such as the techniques explored in the Energy-Calibrated VAE: A "Free Lunch" Lunch for Test-Time Scoring paper.
Additionally, the paper focuses on image classification tasks, and it would be interesting to see how the PLC-EBM method performs on other types of problems, such as sequence labeling tasks or medical applications.
Overall, the PLC-EBM method presents a promising approach to addressing the challenge of overconfident pseudo-labels in semi-supervised learning, and the paper contributes valuable insights to the field.
Conclusion
The PLC-EBM method proposed in this paper offers a novel solution to the problem of overconfident pseudo-labels in semi-supervised learning. By leveraging an energy-based model to estimate well-calibrated confidence scores, the method is able to selectively include the most reliable pseudo-labels during training, leading to improved performance.
The results demonstrate the effectiveness of PLC-EBM on various image classification benchmarks, particularly when the amount of labeled data is limited. While the method is currently focused on image tasks, the underlying principles could potentially be applied to other domains, opening up interesting avenues for future research.
Overall, this paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of semi-supervised learning, highlighting the importance of confidence calibration and providing a practical approach to addressing a key challenge in this area.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
On Calibration of Speech Classification Models: Insights from Energy-Based Model Investigations
Yaqian Hao, Chenguang Hu, Yingying Gao, Shilei Zhang, Junlan Feng
0
0
For speech classification tasks, deep learning models often achieve high accuracy but exhibit shortcomings in calibration, manifesting as classifiers exhibiting overconfidence. The significance of calibration lies in its critical role in guaranteeing the reliability of decision-making within deep learning systems. This study explores the effectiveness of Energy-Based Models in calibrating confidence for speech classification tasks by training a joint EBM integrating a discriminative and a generative model, thereby enhancing the classifiers calibration and mitigating overconfidence. Experimental evaluations conducted on three speech classification tasks specifically: age, emotion, and language recognition. Our findings highlight the competitive performance of EBMs in calibrating the speech classification models. This research emphasizes the potential of EBMs in speech classification tasks, demonstrating their ability to enhance calibration without sacrificing accuracy.
6/27/2024
EPL: Evidential Prototype Learning for Semi-supervised Medical Image Segmentation
Yuanpeng He
0
0
Although current semi-supervised medical segmentation methods can achieve decent performance, they are still affected by the uncertainty in unlabeled data and model predictions, and there is currently a lack of effective strategies that can explore the uncertain aspects of both simultaneously. To address the aforementioned issues, we propose Evidential Prototype Learning (EPL), which utilizes an extended probabilistic framework to effectively fuse voxel probability predictions from different sources and achieves prototype fusion utilization of labeled and unlabeled data under a generalized evidential framework, leveraging voxel-level dual uncertainty masking. The uncertainty not only enables the model to self-correct predictions but also improves the guided learning process with pseudo-labels and is able to feed back into the construction of hidden features. The method proposed in this paper has been experimented on LA, Pancreas-CT and TBAD datasets, achieving the state-of-the-art performance in three different labeled ratios, which strongly demonstrates the effectiveness of our strategy.
4/10/2024
Potential Energy based Mixture Model for Noisy Label Learning
Zijia Wang, Wenbin Yang, Zhisong Liu, Zhen Jia
0
0
Training deep neural networks (DNNs) from noisy labels is an important and challenging task. However, most existing approaches focus on the corrupted labels and ignore the importance of inherent data structure. To bridge the gap between noisy labels and data, inspired by the concept of potential energy in physics, we propose a novel Potential Energy based Mixture Model (PEMM) for noise-labels learning. We innovate a distance-based classifier with the potential energy regularization on its class centers. Embedding our proposed classifier with existing deep learning backbones, we can have robust networks with better feature representations. They can preserve intrinsic structures from the data, resulting in a superior noisy tolerance. We conducted extensive experiments to analyze the efficiency of our proposed model on several real-world datasets. Quantitative results show that it can achieve state-of-the-art performance.
5/3/2024
📉
Pearls from Pebbles: Improved Confidence Functions for Auto-labeling
Harit Vishwakarma (Yi), Reid (Yi), Chen, Sui Jiet Tay, Satya Sai Srinath Namburi, Frederic Sala, Ramya Korlakai Vinayak
0
0
Auto-labeling is an important family of techniques that produce labeled training sets with minimum manual labeling. A prominent variant, threshold-based auto-labeling (TBAL), works by finding a threshold on a model's confidence scores above which it can accurately label unlabeled data points. However, many models are known to produce overconfident scores, leading to poor TBAL performance. While a natural idea is to apply off-the-shelf calibration methods to alleviate the overconfidence issue, such methods still fall short. Rather than experimenting with ad-hoc choices of confidence functions, we propose a framework for studying the emph{optimal} TBAL confidence function. We develop a tractable version of the framework to obtain texttt{Colander} (Confidence functions for Efficient and Reliable Auto-labeling), a new post-hoc method specifically designed to maximize performance in TBAL systems. We perform an extensive empirical evaluation of our method texttt{Colander} and compare it against methods designed for calibration. texttt{Colander} achieves up to 60% improvements on coverage over the baselines while maintaining auto-labeling error below $5%$ and using the same amount of labeled data as the baselines.
4/26/2024