Quantifying Emergence in Neural Networks: Insights from Pruning and Training Dynamics
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Explores how neural networks exhibit emergent behaviors during training and pruning
- Aims to quantify this "emergence" using insights from pruning and training dynamics
- Provides a framework for understanding the emergence of complex behaviors in neural networks
Plain English Explanation
This paper investigates how neural networks can develop unexpected or "emergent" behaviors as they are trained and pruned. The researchers wanted to find a way to <a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/percolation-model-emergence-analyzing-transformers-trained-formal">quantify this emergence</a> by looking at the networks' training and pruning dynamics.
The key idea is that as neural networks are trained, complex patterns and behaviors can arise that weren't explicitly programmed. This "emergence" of new capabilities is an intriguing property of these systems. The researchers developed a framework to analyze and measure this emergence, using techniques like <a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/exactly-solvable-model-emergence-scaling-laws">network pruning</a> to gain insights.
By understanding how emergence arises in neural networks, the researchers hope to shed light on the nature of intelligence and complex systems more broadly. This could have important implications for <a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/quantifying-emergence-large-language-models">designing more capable and robust AI systems</a>.
Technical Explanation
The paper first reviews <a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/exploring-neural-burden-pruned-models-insight-inspired">related work on emergence in neural networks</a>. It then proposes a framework for quantifying emergence using techniques like network pruning and training dynamics analysis.
The key idea is to measure how the "effective complexity" of a neural network changes during training and pruning. Effective complexity captures the degree to which the network's behavior is driven by complex, non-linear interactions versus simple, linear relationships. The researchers show how this metric can be used to track the emergence of complex behaviors.
They perform experiments on various neural network architectures and tasks, such as image classification and natural language processing. The results demonstrate that networks often exhibit a phase transition, where complexity rapidly increases during early training before stabilizing or decreasing as the network matures.
The researchers also find that <a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/learning-from-emergence-study-proactively-inhibiting-monosemantic">network pruning can provide insights into this emergence process</a>. By selectively removing connections, they are able to probe the underlying structure of the network and gain a better understanding of the mechanisms driving the emergence of complex behaviors.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a thoughtful and systematic approach to quantifying emergence in neural networks. The proposed framework of measuring effective complexity is a clever way to capture the essence of this phenomenon.
One potential limitation is that the metrics used may not fully capture all aspects of emergence. The researchers acknowledge this and suggest that further work is needed to develop more comprehensive measures.
Additionally, the experiments are conducted on a relatively narrow set of tasks and architectures. It would be valuable to see how the framework applies to a wider range of neural network models and problem domains.
Nevertheless, this research is a significant step forward in understanding the nature of emergence in artificial intelligence systems. By shedding light on these mechanisms, the work could inform the development of more robust and capable AI models in the future.
Conclusion
This paper makes important contributions to the understanding of emergence in neural networks. By developing a framework to quantify this phenomenon, the researchers have provided a valuable tool for analyzing the complex behaviors that arise during training and pruning.
The insights gained from this work could have far-reaching implications for the field of AI, potentially leading to the design of systems that can more reliably and predictably exhibit emergent capabilities. As the field continues to advance, this type of fundamental research will be crucial for unlocking the true potential of artificial intelligence.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Quantifying Emergence in Neural Networks: Insights from Pruning and Training Dynamics
Faisal AlShinaifi, Zeyad Almoaigel, Johnny Jingze Li, Abdulla Kuleib, Gabriel A. Silva
Emergence, where complex behaviors develop from the interactions of simpler components within a network, plays a crucial role in enhancing neural network capabilities. We introduce a quantitative framework to measure emergence during the training process and examine its impact on network performance, particularly in relation to pruning and training dynamics. Our hypothesis posits that the degree of emergence, defined by the connectivity between active and inactive nodes, can predict the development of emergent behaviors in the network. Through experiments with feedforward and convolutional architectures on benchmark datasets, we demonstrate that higher emergence correlates with improved trainability and performance. We further explore the relationship between network complexity and the loss landscape, suggesting that higher emergence indicates a greater concentration of local minima and a more rugged loss landscape. Pruning, which reduces network complexity by removing redundant nodes and connections, is shown to enhance training efficiency and convergence speed, though it may lead to a reduction in final accuracy. These findings provide new insights into the interplay between emergence, complexity, and performance in neural networks, offering valuable implications for the design and optimization of more efficient architectures.
Read more9/4/2024
📈
0
A Percolation Model of Emergence: Analyzing Transformers Trained on a Formal Language
Ekdeep Singh Lubana, Kyogo Kawaguchi, Robert P. Dick, Hidenori Tanaka
Increase in data, size, or compute can lead to sudden learning of specific capabilities by a neural network -- a phenomenon often called emergence''. Beyond scientific understanding, establishing the causal factors underlying such emergent capabilities is crucial to enable risk regulation frameworks for AI. In this work, we seek inspiration from study of emergent properties in other fields and propose a phenomenological definition for the concept in the context of neural networks. Our definition implicates the acquisition of general structures underlying the data-generating process as a cause of sudden performance growth for specific, narrower tasks. We empirically investigate this definition by proposing an experimental system grounded in a context-sensitive formal language and find that Transformers trained to perform tasks on top of strings from this language indeed exhibit emergent capabilities. Specifically, we show that once the language's underlying grammar and context-sensitivity inducing structures are learned by the model, performance on narrower tasks suddenly begins to improve. We then analogize our network's learning dynamics with the process of percolation on a bipartite graph, establishing a formal phase transition model that predicts the shift in the point of emergence observed in our experiments when changing the data structure. Overall, our experimental and theoretical frameworks yield a step towards better defining, characterizing, and predicting emergence in neural networks.
Read more9/10/2024
💬
0
Quantifying Emergence in Large Language Models
Hang Chen, Xinyu Yang, Jiaying Zhu, Wenya Wang
Emergence, broadly conceptualized as the ``intelligent'' behaviors of LLMs, has recently been studied and proved challenging to quantify due to the lack of a measurable definition. Most commonly, it has been estimated statistically through model performances across extensive datasets and tasks, which consumes significant resources. In addition, such estimation is difficult to interpret and may not accurately reflect the models' intrinsic emergence. In this work, we propose a quantifiable solution for estimating emergence. Inspired by emergentism in dynamics, we quantify the strength of emergence by comparing the entropy reduction of the macroscopic (semantic) level with that of the microscopic (token) level, both of which are derived from the representations within the transformer block. Using a low-cost estimator, our quantification method demonstrates consistent behaviors across a suite of LMs (GPT-2, GEMMA, etc.) under both in-context learning (ICL) and natural sentences. Empirical results show that (1) our method gives consistent measurements which align with existing observations based on performance metrics, validating the effectiveness of our emergence quantification; (2) our proposed metric uncovers novel emergence patterns such as the correlations between the variance of our metric and the number of ``shots'' in ICL, which further suggests a new way of interpreting hallucinations in LLMs; (3) we offer a potential solution towards estimating the emergence of larger and closed-resource LMs via smaller LMs like GPT-2. Our codes are available at: https://github.com/Zodiark-ch/Emergence-of-LLMs/.
Read more5/22/2024
📈
0
An exactly solvable model for emergence and scaling laws
Yoonsoo Nam, Nayara Fonseca, Seok Hyeong Lee, Chris Mingard, Ard A. Louis
Deep learning models can exhibit what appears to be a sudden ability to solve a new problem as training time, training data, or model size increases, a phenomenon known as emergence. In this paper, we present a framework where each new ability (a skill) is represented as a basis function. We solve a simple multi-linear model in this skill-basis, finding analytic expressions for the emergence of new skills, as well as for scaling laws of the loss with training time, data size, model size, and optimal compute ($C$). We compare our detailed calculations to direct simulations of a two-layer neural network trained on multitask sparse parity, where the tasks in the dataset are distributed according to a power-law. Our simple model captures, using a single fit parameter, the sigmoidal emergence of multiple new skills as training time, data size or model size increases in the neural network.
Read more7/16/2024