Quantum Mini-Apps: A Framework for Developing and Benchmarking Quantum-HPC Applications

Overview

• As quantum hardware and its integration into high-performance computing (HPC) systems become more mature and widespread, there is a need to develop robust techniques for building, characterizing, and benchmarking quantum-HPC applications and middleware systems.
• This requires a better understanding of how quantum and classical workload tasks and components interact, couple, and execute.
• The paper identifies six quantum-HPC execution "motifs" - recurring execution patterns with distinct coupling and interaction modes.
• These motifs serve as the basis for a suite of quantum "mini-apps" - simplified application prototypes that capture the essential characteristics of production systems.
• A mini-app framework is introduced to enable the creation and execution of these mini-apps across heterogeneous quantum-HPC infrastructure, supporting performance characterization and middleware development.

Plain English Explanation

As quantum computing becomes more advanced and is integrated into powerful HPC (high-performance computing) systems, researchers need ways to thoroughly test and evaluate how quantum and classical (traditional) computing components work together.

The paper identifies six common "patterns" or "motifs" of how quantum and classical tasks and parts interact and run together. These motifs provide a foundation for creating simplified quantum "mini-apps" - small-scale versions of real-world quantum-HPC applications.

The researchers also developed a framework that allows these mini-apps to be easily run and tested across different quantum-HPC hardware setups. This helps researchers better understand the performance characteristics of quantum-HPC systems and develop the middleware (software) needed to effectively manage them.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a systematic approach to understanding and characterizing the interactions between quantum and classical computing components in hybrid quantum-HPC systems. It identifies six key "quantum-HPC execution motifs" - recurring patterns of how quantum and classical workloads couple and execute together.

These motifs are:

1. Quantum preprocessing/postprocessing
2. Quantum subroutine offload
3. Quantum-classical feedback loop
4. Quantum-classical co-processing
5. Quantum-classical workflow
6. Quantum ensemble

To support research and development in this area, the authors introduce a "quantum mini-app framework" that provides the necessary abstractions and mechanisms for creating, executing, and analyzing these simplified quantum application prototypes across diverse quantum-HPC infrastructures. This framework enables performance characterization, middleware development, and other critical studies for advancing the state of quantum-HPC systems.

The mini-app framework supports features like quantum circuit synthesis, emulation, and execution; integration with classical components; and instrumentation for performance analysis. This helps researchers study topics like quantum algorithm benchmarking, quantum hardware characterization, and the impact of quantum circuit imperfections.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a valuable framework for advancing quantum-HPC research and development, but it does not address some important considerations. For example, the motifs and mini-apps may not fully capture the complexity of real-world quantum-HPC applications, which could involve more dynamic interactions and unpredictable behavior.

Additionally, the framework focuses on performance characterization, but it does not explore the challenges of programming, compiling, and orchestrating quantum-HPC workloads in production environments. Further research is needed to address these practical challenges.

Finally, the paper does not discuss the potential security and privacy implications of integrating quantum computing into HPC systems, which could be an important area for future study.

Conclusion

This paper presents a structured approach to understanding and prototyping quantum-HPC applications through the identification of key execution motifs and the development of a mini-app framework. This work lays important groundwork for advancing the state of quantum-HPC research and development, helping to unlock the potential of hybrid quantum-classical computing for scientific and industrial applications. As quantum hardware and software continue to evolve, techniques like those described in this paper will be crucial for ensuring the reliable and efficient integration of quantum capabilities into high-performance computing ecosystems.