RCAgent: Cloud Root Cause Analysis by Autonomous Agents with Tool-Augmented Large Language Models
0
💬
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Large language models (LLMs) have been actively explored for cloud root cause analysis (RCA)
- Current methods are still reliant on manual workflow settings and do not fully utilize LLMs' decision-making and environment interaction capabilities
- Presents RCAgent, a tool-augmented LLM autonomous agent framework for practical and privacy-aware industrial RCA usage
Plain English Explanation
RCAgent is a new tool that uses large language models (LLMs) to help with root cause analysis (RCA) in cloud computing environments. Current RCA methods often require a lot of manual work and don't take full advantage of what LLMs can do, like make decisions and interact with their environment.
RCAgent is designed to be more autonomous and private for industrial use cases. It uses a custom LLM model, not the popular GPT families, and can gather data and do comprehensive analysis with various tools. RCAgent has some unique enhancements, like "Self-Consistency" for planning out actions, and ways to manage context, stabilize the system, and bring in domain knowledge.
The researchers show that RCAgent performs better than previous methods across different RCA tasks, like predicting root causes, solutions, evidence, and responsibilities. It works well for both standard RCA tasks and new, uncovered ones. RCAgent has already been integrated into the diagnosis and troubleshooting workflow for a major cloud computing platform.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents RCAgent, a framework that combines large language models (LLMs) with various tools to enable autonomous and privacy-aware root cause analysis (RCA) in industrial cloud computing environments.
Unlike previous approaches that rely on manual workflow settings, RCAgent is designed to leverage the full decision-making and environment interaction capabilities of LLMs. It runs on a custom-built LLM model, rather than the popular GPT families, and can engage in free-form data collection and comprehensive analysis using a suite of tools.
The key enhancements in RCAgent include:
- Self-Consistency: A unique mechanism for generating coherent and reliable action trajectories
- Context Management: Methods for effectively managing context information
- Stabilization: Techniques to stabilize the LLM's behavior and outputs
- Domain Knowledge Integration: Ways to seamlessly incorporate relevant domain knowledge
The researchers evaluate RCAgent across a range of RCA tasks, including predicting root causes, solutions, evidence, and responsibilities. They find that RCAgent outperforms the ReAct baseline consistently, as validated by both automated metrics and human evaluations.
Importantly, RCAgent demonstrates strong performance not only on standard RCA tasks, but also on emerging, uncovered tasks. The framework has already been integrated into the diagnosis and issue discovery workflow of the Real-time Compute Platform for Apache Flink on Alibaba Cloud.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach to leveraging large language models for autonomous and privacy-aware root cause analysis in industrial cloud computing environments. The researchers have made several notable advancements, such as the Self-Consistency mechanism and the integration of domain knowledge, which appear to contribute to the framework's strong performance.
However, the paper does not provide much detail on the specific LLM model used, the scale of the experiments, or the nature of the industrial datasets and use cases. More information on these aspects would help readers better understand the practical applicability and limitations of the RCAgent framework.
Additionally, the paper does not explore potential biases or fairness concerns that may arise from the use of large language models in such mission-critical applications. As LLMs can often reflect societal biases, it would be important to investigate the fairness and transparency of the RCAgent system, especially when it is being integrated into real-world industrial workflows.
Further research could also examine the long-term scalability and robustness of the RCAgent framework, as well as its ability to adapt to evolving cloud environments and new types of RCA tasks. Exploring these areas could help strengthen the practical viability and trustworthiness of the proposed approach.
Conclusion
The RCAgent framework presented in this paper represents a significant advancement in the use of large language models for autonomous and privacy-aware root cause analysis in industrial cloud computing environments. By incorporating unique enhancements like Self-Consistency and domain knowledge integration, the researchers have demonstrated RCAgent's ability to outperform previous methods across a range of RCA tasks.
The successful integration of RCAgent into the Alibaba Cloud platform suggests its practical relevance and potential to transform how cloud-based root cause analysis is conducted. However, further research is needed to address potential biases, scalability concerns, and other limitations to ensure the long-term reliability and trustworthiness of this LLM-driven approach.
Overall, the RCAgent framework represents an important step forward in leveraging the power of large language models to tackle complex real-world problems in a more autonomous and privacy-aware manner.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
💬
0
RCAgent: Cloud Root Cause Analysis by Autonomous Agents with Tool-Augmented Large Language Models
Zefan Wang, Zichuan Liu, Yingying Zhang, Aoxiao Zhong, Jihong Wang, Fengbin Yin, Lunting Fan, Lingfei Wu, Qingsong Wen
Large language model (LLM) applications in cloud root cause analysis (RCA) have been actively explored recently. However, current methods are still reliant on manual workflow settings and do not unleash LLMs' decision-making and environment interaction capabilities. We present RCAgent, a tool-augmented LLM autonomous agent framework for practical and privacy-aware industrial RCA usage. Running on an internally deployed model rather than GPT families, RCAgent is capable of free-form data collection and comprehensive analysis with tools. Our framework combines a variety of enhancements, including a unique Self-Consistency for action trajectories, and a suite of methods for context management, stabilization, and importing domain knowledge. Our experiments show RCAgent's evident and consistent superiority over ReAct across all aspects of RCA -- predicting root causes, solutions, evidence, and responsibilities -- and tasks covered or uncovered by current rules, as validated by both automated metrics and human evaluations. Furthermore, RCAgent has already been integrated into the diagnosis and issue discovery workflow of the Real-time Compute Platform for Apache Flink of Alibaba Cloud.
Read more8/6/2024
🤔
0
LogRCA: Log-based Root Cause Analysis for Distributed Services
Thorsten Wittkopp, Philipp Wiesner, Odej Kao
To assist IT service developers and operators in managing their increasingly complex service landscapes, there is a growing effort to leverage artificial intelligence in operations. To speed up troubleshooting, log anomaly detection has received much attention in particular, dealing with the identification of log events that indicate the reasons for a system failure. However, faults often propagate extensively within systems, which can result in a large number of anomalies being detected by existing approaches. In this case, it can remain very challenging for users to quickly identify the actual root cause of a failure. We propose LogRCA, a novel method for identifying a minimal set of log lines that together describe a root cause. LogRCA uses a semi-supervised learning approach to deal with rare and unknown errors and is designed to handle noisy data. We evaluated our approach on a large-scale production log data set of 44.3 million log lines, which contains 80 failures, whose root causes were labeled by experts. LogRCA consistently outperforms baselines based on deep learning and statistical analysis in terms of precision and recall to detect candidate root causes. In addition, we investigated the impact of our deployed data balancing approach, demonstrating that it considerably improves performance on rare failures.
Read more5/24/2024
💬
0
Causal Agent based on Large Language Model
Kairong Han, Kun Kuang, Ziyu Zhao, Junjian Ye, Fei Wu
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved significant success across various domains. However, the inherent complexity of causal problems and causal theory poses challenges in accurately describing them in natural language, making it difficult for LLMs to comprehend and use them effectively. Causal methods are not easily conveyed through natural language, which hinders LLMs' ability to apply them accurately. Additionally, causal datasets are typically tabular, while LLMs excel in handling natural language data, creating a structural mismatch that impedes effective reasoning with tabular data. This lack of causal reasoning capability limits the development of LLMs. To address these challenges, we have equipped the LLM with causal tools within an agent framework, named the Causal Agent, enabling it to tackle causal problems. The causal agent comprises tools, memory, and reasoning modules. In the tools module, the causal agent applies causal methods to align tabular data with natural language. In the reasoning module, the causal agent employs the ReAct framework to perform reasoning through multiple iterations with the tools. In the memory module, the causal agent maintains a dictionary instance where the keys are unique names and the values are causal graphs. To verify the causal ability of the causal agent, we established a benchmark consisting of four levels of causal problems: variable level, edge level, causal graph level, and causal effect level. We generated a test dataset of 1.3K using ChatGPT-3.5 for these four levels of issues and tested the causal agent on the datasets. Our methodology demonstrates remarkable efficacy on the four-level causal problems, with accuracy rates all above 80%. For further insights and implementation details, our code is accessible via the GitHub repository https://github.com/Kairong-Han/Causal_Agent.
Read more8/14/2024
0
RCInvestigator: Towards Better Investigation of Anomaly Root Causes in Cloud Computing Systems
Shuhan Liu, Yunfan Zhou, Lu Ying, Yuan Tian, Jue Zhang, Shandan Zhou, Weiwei Cui, Qingwei Lin, Thomas Moscibroda, Haidong Zhang, Di Weng, Yingcai Wu
Finding the root causes of anomalies in cloud computing systems quickly is crucial to ensure availability and efficiency since accurate root causes can guide engineers to take appropriate actions to address the anomalies and maintain customer satisfaction. However, it is difficult to investigate and identify the root causes based on large-scale and high-dimension monitoring data collected from complex cloud computing environments. Due to the inherently dynamic characteristics of cloud computing systems, the existing approaches in practice largely rely on manual analyses for flexibility and reliability, but massive unpredictable factors and high data complexity make the process time-consuming. Despite recent advances in automated detection and investigation approaches, the speed and quality of root cause analyses remain limited by the lack of expert involvement in these approaches. The limitations found in the current solutions motivate us to propose a visual analytics approach that facilitates the interactive investigation of the anomaly root causes in cloud computing systems. We identified three challenges, namely, a) modeling databases for the root cause investigation, b) inferring root causes from large-scale time series, and c) building comprehensible investigation results. In collaboration with domain experts, we addressed these challenges with RCInvestigator, a novel visual analytics system that establishes a tight collaboration between human and machine and assists experts in investigating the root causes of cloud computing system anomalies. We evaluated the effectiveness of RCInvestigator through two use cases based on real-world data and received positive feedback from experts.
Read more5/27/2024