Re-DiffiNet: Modeling discrepancies in tumor segmentation using diffusion models
2402.07354
0
0
📉
Abstract
Identification of tumor margins is essential for surgical decision-making for glioblastoma patients and provides reliable assistance for neurosurgeons. Despite improvements in deep learning architectures for tumor segmentation over the years, creating a fully autonomous system suitable for clinical floors remains a formidable challenge because the model predictions have not yet reached the desired level of accuracy and generalizability for clinical applications. Generative modeling techniques have seen significant improvements in recent times. Specifically, Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) and Denoising-diffusion-based models (DDPMs) have been used to generate higher-quality images with fewer artifacts and finer attributes. In this work, we introduce a framework called Re-Diffinet for modeling the discrepancy between the outputs of a segmentation model like U-Net and the ground truth, using DDPMs. By explicitly modeling the discrepancy, the results show an average improvement of 0.55% in the Dice score and 16.28% in HD95 from cross-validation over 5-folds, compared to the state-of-the-art U-Net segmentation model.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Accurate identification of tumor margins is critical for successful glioblastoma surgery, but current deep learning models have not yet reached the required level of accuracy and reliability for clinical use.
- Generative modeling techniques like Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) and Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models (DDPMs) have shown promise in generating high-quality images with fewer artifacts.
- This paper introduces a framework called Re-Diffinet that uses DDPMs to model the discrepancy between a U-Net segmentation model's output and the ground truth, leading to improved performance.
Plain English Explanation
Glioblastoma is a type of brain cancer, and accurately identifying the edges or "margins" of the tumor is critical for surgeons when operating. Deep learning-based brain image segmentation models have improved over time, but they still don't reach the level of accuracy and reliability needed for real-world clinical use.
Recently, new AI techniques like Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) and Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models (DDPMs) have shown they can generate high-quality images with fewer issues or "artifacts."
This paper introduces a new framework called Re-Diffinet that uses DDPMs to model the differences between what a standard segmentation model (like U-Net) predicts and the actual ground truth. By explicitly accounting for this discrepancy, Re-Diffinet was able to improve the performance of tumor segmentation compared to the standard model.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a framework called Re-Diffinet that uses Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models (DDPMs) to explicitly model the difference between the output of a U-Net segmentation model and the ground truth segmentation.
The key idea is that by learning to generate this "discrepancy" map using a DDPM, the model can better capture the nuances and errors in the original segmentation, leading to improved overall performance. The authors demonstrate an average improvement of 0.55% in Dice score and 16.28% in HD95 (a measure of segmentation accuracy) over 5-fold cross-validation, compared to the standard U-Net segmentation model.
The paper also provides detailed experiments and ablation studies to validate the effectiveness of the Re-Diffinet approach and analyze the impact of different design choices.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a compelling case for the potential of generative modeling techniques like DDPMs to enhance the performance of segmentation models for glioblastoma. By explicitly modeling the discrepancy between the model output and ground truth, Re-Diffinet is able to capture nuances that the standard U-Net model misses.
However, the paper also acknowledges some key limitations. The experiments were conducted on a single dataset, so further validation on additional datasets would be needed to assess the generalizability of the approach. Additionally, the paper does not provide much insight into the computational cost or inference time of the Re-Diffinet framework, which would be important considerations for real-world clinical deployment.
It would also be valuable to see comparisons to other state-of-the-art segmentation approaches, beyond just the standard U-Net model, to better understand the relative performance gains of the Re-Diffinet framework.
Overall, this research represents an interesting and promising step towards more accurate and reliable glioblastoma segmentation, but there are still important areas for further exploration and validation.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel framework called Re-Diffinet that uses Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models to improve the performance of glioblastoma tumor segmentation compared to standard deep learning models. By explicitly modeling the discrepancy between the model outputs and ground truth, Re-Diffinet was able to achieve notable gains in segmentation accuracy.
While further validation and optimization are still needed, this research demonstrates the potential of generative modeling techniques to enhance medical image analysis and support neurosurgeons in making critical decisions during glioblastoma procedures. As deep learning-based brain image segmentation continues to advance, frameworks like Re-Diffinet may play an important role in bringing these technologies into reliable clinical use.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Discrepancy-based Diffusion Models for Lesion Detection in Brain MRI
Keqiang Fan, Xiaohao Cai, Mahesan Niranjan
0
0
Diffusion probabilistic models (DPMs) have exhibited significant effectiveness in computer vision tasks, particularly in image generation. However, their notable performance heavily relies on labelled datasets, which limits their application in medical images due to the associated high-cost annotations. Current DPM-related methods for lesion detection in medical imaging, which can be categorized into two distinct approaches, primarily rely on image-level annotations. The first approach, based on anomaly detection, involves learning reference healthy brain representations and identifying anomalies based on the difference in inference results. In contrast, the second approach, resembling a segmentation task, employs only the original brain multi-modalities as prior information for generating pixel-level annotations. In this paper, our proposed model - discrepancy distribution medical diffusion (DDMD) - for lesion detection in brain MRI introduces a novel framework by incorporating distinctive discrepancy features, deviating from the conventional direct reliance on image-level annotations or the original brain modalities. In our method, the inconsistency in image-level annotations is translated into distribution discrepancies among heterogeneous samples while preserving information within homogeneous samples. This property retains pixel-wise uncertainty and facilitates an implicit ensemble of segmentation, ultimately enhancing the overall detection performance. Thorough experiments conducted on the BRATS2020 benchmark dataset containing multimodal MRI scans for brain tumour detection demonstrate the great performance of our approach in comparison to state-of-the-art methods.
5/9/2024
📈
DiffSeg: A Segmentation Model for Skin Lesions Based on Diffusion Difference
Zhihao Shuai, Yinan Chen, Shunqiang Mao, Yihan Zho, Xiaohong Zhang
0
0
Weakly supervised medical image segmentation (MIS) using generative models is crucial for clinical diagnosis. However, the accuracy of the segmentation results is often limited by insufficient supervision and the complex nature of medical imaging. Existing models also only provide a single outcome, which does not allow for the measurement of uncertainty. In this paper, we introduce DiffSeg, a segmentation model for skin lesions based on diffusion difference which exploits diffusion model principles to ex-tract noise-based features from images with diverse semantic information. By discerning difference between these noise features, the model identifies diseased areas. Moreover, its multi-output capability mimics doctors' annotation behavior, facilitating the visualization of segmentation result consistency and ambiguity. Additionally, it quantifies output uncertainty using Generalized Energy Distance (GED), aiding interpretability and decision-making for physicians. Finally, the model integrates outputs through the Dense Conditional Random Field (DenseCRF) algorithm to refine the segmentation boundaries by considering inter-pixel correlations, which improves the accuracy and optimizes the segmentation results. We demonstrate the effectiveness of DiffSeg on the ISIC 2018 Challenge dataset, outperforming state-of-the-art U-Net-based methods.
4/26/2024
🤿
The Missing U for Efficient Diffusion Models
Sergio Calvo-Ordonez, Chun-Wun Cheng, Jiahao Huang, Lipei Zhang, Guang Yang, Carola-Bibiane Schonlieb, Angelica I Aviles-Rivero
0
0
Diffusion Probabilistic Models stand as a critical tool in generative modelling, enabling the generation of complex data distributions. This family of generative models yields record-breaking performance in tasks such as image synthesis, video generation, and molecule design. Despite their capabilities, their efficiency, especially in the reverse process, remains a challenge due to slow convergence rates and high computational costs. In this paper, we introduce an approach that leverages continuous dynamical systems to design a novel denoising network for diffusion models that is more parameter-efficient, exhibits faster convergence, and demonstrates increased noise robustness. Experimenting with Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models (DDPMs), our framework operates with approximately a quarter of the parameters, and $sim$ 30% of the Floating Point Operations (FLOPs) compared to standard U-Nets in DDPMs. Furthermore, our model is notably faster in inference than the baseline when measured in fair and equal conditions. We also provide a mathematical intuition as to why our proposed reverse process is faster as well as a mathematical discussion of the empirical tradeoffs in the denoising downstream task. Finally, we argue that our method is compatible with existing performance enhancement techniques, enabling further improvements in efficiency, quality, and speed.
4/8/2024
New!Deep learning for automated detection of breast cancer in deep ultraviolet fluorescence images with diffusion probabilistic model
Sepehr Salem Ghahfarokhi, Tyrell To, Julie Jorns, Tina Yen, Bing Yu, Dong Hye Ye
0
0
Data limitation is a significant challenge in applying deep learning to medical images. Recently, the diffusion probabilistic model (DPM) has shown the potential to generate high-quality images by converting Gaussian random noise into realistic images. In this paper, we apply the DPM to augment the deep ultraviolet fluorescence (DUV) image dataset with an aim to improve breast cancer classification for intraoperative margin assessment. For classification, we divide the whole surface DUV image into small patches and extract convolutional features for each patch by utilizing the pre-trained ResNet. Then, we feed them into an XGBoost classifier for patch-level decisions and then fuse them with a regional importance map computed by Grad-CAM++ for whole surface-level prediction. Our experimental results show that augmenting the training dataset with the DPM significantly improves breast cancer detection performance in DUV images, increasing accuracy from 93% to 97%, compared to using Affine transformations and ProGAN.
7/2/2024