Redesigning graph filter-based GNNs to relax the homophily assumption

Read original: arXiv:2409.08676 - Published 9/16/2024 by Samuel Rey, Madeline Navarro, Victor M. Tenorio, Santiago Segarra, Antonio G. Marques

💬

Overview

Graph neural networks (GNNs) are powerful tools for learning from data defined on irregular domains, like social networks.
GNNs typically assume the data has a homophilic structure, where connected nodes are similar.
However, many real-world applications involve heterophilic data, where connected nodes can be dissimilar, and GNNs often perform poorly in these cases.
This paper presents a new GNN architecture designed to address the limitations of the homophily assumption and perform well on both homophilic and heterophilic data.

Plain English Explanation

Graph neural networks (GNNs) are a type of machine learning model that can work with data represented as a network or graph, where the data points are nodes and the connections between them are edges. GNNs have become a popular approach for tasks like predicting properties of molecules or analyzing social networks.

The way GNNs work is by assuming that connected nodes in the graph are similar to each other, a property known as homophily. This allows GNNs to learn patterns in the data by propagating information between similar nodes.

However, many real-world graphs don't actually have this homophilic structure, where connected nodes are dissimilar (a property known as heterophily). In these cases, standard GNNs can perform poorly because they're making the wrong assumptions about the data.

This paper introduces a new GNN architecture that is designed to work well on both homophilic and heterophilic data. The key idea is to rethink how the graph "filters" used in GNNs operate, resulting in a more flexible and powerful model that can adapt to different data structures.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a new convolutional layer for GNNs that aims to address the limitations of the homophily assumption.

The traditional approach in GNNs is to use graph convolution filters that propagate information between similar, connected nodes. However, the authors argue that this can lead to "oversmoothing" where the node representations become too similar, hampering the model's ability to learn from heterophilic data.

Instead, the proposed convolutional layer reinterprets the role of the graph filters. Rather than directly mixing node features, the filters are used to modulate the aggregation of neighboring node features. This allows the model to learn a more flexible, adaptive aggregation scheme that can handle both homophilic and heterophilic data structures.

From a theoretical standpoint, the authors show that this new convolutional layer preserves the desirable property of permutation equivariance, meaning the model's predictions are invariant to how the nodes are ordered in the graph.

The paper evaluates the proposed GNN architecture on both homophilic and heterophilic benchmark datasets, comparing it to several state-of-the-art GNN models. The results demonstrate that the new architecture is able to outperform the baselines on a range of tasks, showcasing its ability to learn effectively from diverse graph structures.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a compelling case for the need to move beyond the homophily assumption in GNNs, and the proposed architecture represents a promising step in that direction.

One potential limitation is that the model may still struggle with more extreme cases of heterophily, where the graph structure provides little useful signal for the task at hand. The authors acknowledge this and suggest exploring ways to incorporate additional domain knowledge or inductive biases to further enhance the model's performance.

Additionally, the paper focuses on transductive learning tasks, where the model is evaluated on the same graph it was trained on. It would be interesting to see how the proposed architecture fares on inductive learning tasks, where the model needs to generalize to new, unseen graph structures.

Overall, this paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of graph representation learning by introducing a more flexible and robust GNN architecture. By challenging the homophily assumption, the authors open up new avenues for research and development in this rapidly evolving area of machine learning.

Conclusion

This paper presents a new GNN architecture that aims to overcome the limitations of the homophily assumption, which underpins many standard GNN models. By rethinking the role of graph convolution filters, the proposed approach is able to learn effective representations from both homophilic and heterophilic data structures.

The results demonstrate the architecture's strong performance on a range of benchmark tasks, suggesting it could be a useful tool for tackling real-world problems that involve complex, diverse graph-structured data. As the field of graph representation learning continues to evolve, this work highlights the importance of developing models that can adapt to the rich variety of data structures encountered in practice.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

💬

New!Redesigning graph filter-based GNNs to relax the homophily assumption

Samuel Rey, Madeline Navarro, Victor M. Tenorio, Santiago Segarra, Antonio G. Marques

Graph neural networks (GNNs) have become a workhorse approach for learning from data defined over irregular domains, typically by implicitly assuming that the data structure is represented by a homophilic graph. However, recent works have revealed that many relevant applications involve heterophilic data where the performance of GNNs can be notably compromised. To address this challenge, we present a simple yet effective architecture designed to mitigate the limitations of the homophily assumption. The proposed architecture reinterprets the role of graph filters in convolutional GNNs, resulting in a more general architecture while incorporating a stronger inductive bias than GNNs based on filter banks. The proposed convolutional layer enhances the expressive capacity of the architecture enabling it to learn from both homophilic and heterophilic data and preventing the issue of oversmoothing. From a theoretical standpoint, we show that the proposed architecture is permutation equivariant. Finally, we show that the proposed GNNs compares favorably relative to several state-of-the-art baselines in both homophilic and heterophilic datasets, showcasing its promising potential.

9/16/2024

🧠

Incorporating Heterophily into Graph Neural Networks for Graph Classification

Jiayi Yang, Sourav Medya, Wei Ye

Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) often assume strong homophily for graph classification, seldom considering heterophily, which means connected nodes tend to have different class labels and dissimilar features. In real-world scenarios, graphs may have nodes that exhibit both homophily and heterophily. Failing to generalize to this setting makes many GNNs underperform in graph classification. In this paper, we address this limitation by identifying three effective designs and develop a novel GNN architecture called IHGNN (short for Incorporating Heterophily into Graph Neural Networks). These designs include the combination of integration and separation of the ego- and neighbor-embeddings of nodes, adaptive aggregation of node embeddings from different layers, and differentiation between different node embeddings for constructing the graph-level readout function. We empirically validate IHGNN on various graph datasets and demonstrate that it outperforms the state-of-the-art GNNs for graph classification.

5/10/2024

Heterophilous Distribution Propagation for Graph Neural Networks

Zhuonan Zheng, Sheng Zhou, Hongjia Xu, Ming Gu, Yilun Xu, Ao Li, Yuhong Li, Jingjun Gu, Jiajun Bu

Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have achieved remarkable success in various graph mining tasks by aggregating information from neighborhoods for representation learning. The success relies on the homophily assumption that nearby nodes exhibit similar behaviors, while it may be violated in many real-world graphs. Recently, heterophilous graph neural networks (HeterGNNs) have attracted increasing attention by modifying the neural message passing schema for heterophilous neighborhoods. However, they suffer from insufficient neighborhood partition and heterophily modeling, both of which are critical but challenging to break through. To tackle these challenges, in this paper, we propose heterophilous distribution propagation (HDP) for graph neural networks. Instead of aggregating information from all neighborhoods, HDP adaptively separates the neighbors into homophilous and heterphilous parts based on the pseudo assignments during training. The heterophilous neighborhood distribution is learned with orthogonality-oriented constraint via a trusted prototype contrastive learning paradigm. Both the homophilous and heterophilous patterns are propagated with a novel semantic-aware message passing mechanism. We conduct extensive experiments on 9 benchmark datasets with different levels of homophily. Experimental results show that our method outperforms representative baselines on heterophilous datasets.

6/3/2024

Exploring the Potential of Large Language Models for Heterophilic Graphs

Yuxia Wu, Shujie Li, Yuan Fang, Chuan Shi

Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) are essential for various graph-based learning tasks. Notably, classical GNN architectures operate under the assumption of homophily, which posits that connected nodes are likely to share similar features. However, this assumption limits the effectiveness of GNNs in handling heterophilic graphs where connected nodes often exhibit dissimilar characteristics. Existing approaches for homophily graphs such as non-local neighbor extension and architectural refinement overlook the rich textual data associated with nodes, which could unlock deeper insights into these heterophilic contexts. With advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs), there is significant promise to enhance GNNs by leveraging the extensive open-world knowledge within LLMs to more effectively interpret and utilize textual data for characterizing heterophilic graphs. In this work, we explore the potential of LLMs for modeling heterophilic graphs and propose a novel two-stage framework: LLM-enhanced edge discriminator and LLM-guided edge reweighting. Specifically, in the first stage, we fine-tune the LLM to better identify homophilic and heterophilic edges based on the textual information of their nodes. In the second stage, we adaptively manage message propagation in GNNs for different edge types based on node features, structures, and heterophilic or homophilic characteristics. To cope with the computational demands when deploying LLMs in practical scenarios, we further explore model distillation techniques to fine-tune smaller, more efficient models that maintain competitive performance. Extensive experiments validate the effectiveness of our framework, demonstrating the feasibility of using LLMs to enhance GNNs for node classification on heterophilic graphs.

8/27/2024