Reducing False Discoveries in Statistically-Significant Regional-Colocation Mining: A Summary of Results

Read original: arXiv:2407.02536 - Published 7/4/2024 by Subhankar Ghosh, Jayant Gupta, Arun Sharma, Shuai An, Shashi Shekhar
Total Score

0

Reducing False Discoveries in Statistically-Significant Regional-Colocation Mining: A Summary of Results

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper proposes a novel approach to reduce false discoveries in statistically-significant regional-colocation mining, a technique used to identify spatial patterns in data.
  • The authors introduce a statistical framework that incorporates spatial information and provides a principled way to control the false discovery rate, which is the expected proportion of false positive results among the reported significant discoveries.
  • The proposed method is evaluated on both synthetic and real-world datasets, demonstrating its effectiveness in improving the reliability of regional-colocation mining results.

Plain English Explanation

Researchers often analyze spatial data, such as the locations of different features or events, to identify patterns and relationships. One common technique is called regional-colocation mining, which looks for areas where certain features tend to occur together.

However, this approach can sometimes produce false positive results, where the identified patterns are just due to chance rather than representing true underlying relationships. The authors of this paper developed a new statistical framework to address this issue.

Their method incorporates spatial information and provides a more principled way to control the false discovery rate. This means they can better distinguish between real patterns and random coincidences, leading to more reliable results from the regional-colocation mining process.

The researchers tested their approach on both artificial data and real-world datasets, and found that it outperformed existing methods in reducing false discoveries while still identifying the meaningful spatial patterns. This could be helpful for a variety of applications, such as understanding the relationships between different geographic features or analyzing the spatial distribution of events.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces a statistical framework for reducing false discoveries in statistically-significant regional-colocation mining. The key elements are:

  1. Spatial Information: The proposed method incorporates spatial information, such as the proximity and arrangement of features, into the statistical analysis. This allows it to better distinguish between true spatial patterns and random co-occurrences.

  2. False Discovery Rate Control: The framework provides a principled way to control the false discovery rate, which is the expected proportion of false positive results among the reported significant discoveries. This helps ensure the reliability of the identified patterns.

  3. Evaluation: The authors evaluate their approach on both synthetic and real-world datasets, including climate data and geographic features. The results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method in reducing false discoveries while maintaining the ability to identify meaningful spatial patterns.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a well-designed statistical framework that addresses an important challenge in spatial data analysis. By incorporating spatial information and controlling the false discovery rate, the proposed method can generate more reliable results from regional-colocation mining.

However, the authors acknowledge that their approach has some limitations. For example, it may be computationally intensive for large-scale datasets, and the performance may depend on the specific spatial characteristics of the data. Additionally, the paper does not explore the potential impact of factors such as spatial heterogeneity or the presence of spatial dependencies on the method's effectiveness.

Further research could investigate ways to optimize the computational efficiency of the framework, as well as its robustness to different spatial data characteristics. Comparisons with other false discovery rate control methods, such as those used in few-shot resampling, could also provide valuable insights.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel statistical framework for reducing false discoveries in statistically-significant regional-colocation mining. By incorporating spatial information and providing a principled way to control the false discovery rate, the proposed method can generate more reliable results, which could be beneficial for a range of applications involving spatial data analysis.

The evaluation on both synthetic and real-world datasets demonstrates the effectiveness of the approach, but also highlights potential areas for further research and development. Overall, this work represents an important contribution to improving the reliability and robustness of spatial pattern identification techniques.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Reducing False Discoveries in Statistically-Significant Regional-Colocation Mining: A Summary of Results
Total Score

0

Reducing False Discoveries in Statistically-Significant Regional-Colocation Mining: A Summary of Results

Subhankar Ghosh, Jayant Gupta, Arun Sharma, Shuai An, Shashi Shekhar

Given a set emph{S} of spatial feature types, its feature instances, a study area, and a neighbor relationship, the goal is to find pairs $$ such that emph{C} is a statistically significant regional-colocation pattern in $r_{g}$. This problem is important for applications in various domains including ecology, economics, and sociology. The problem is computationally challenging due to the exponential number of regional colocation patterns and candidate regions. Previously, we proposed a miner cite{10.1145/3557989.3566158} that finds statistically significant regional colocation patterns. However, the numerous simultaneous statistical inferences raise the risk of false discoveries (also known as the multiple comparisons problem) and carry a high computational cost. We propose a novel algorithm, namely, multiple comparisons regional colocation miner (MultComp-RCM) which uses a Bonferroni correction. Theoretical analysis, experimental evaluation, and case study results show that the proposed method reduces both the false discovery rate and computational cost.

Read more

7/4/2024

Towards Statistically Significant Taxonomy Aware Co-location Pattern Detection
Total Score

0

Towards Statistically Significant Taxonomy Aware Co-location Pattern Detection

Subhankar Ghosh, Arun Sharma, Jayant Gupta, Shashi Shekhar

Given a collection of Boolean spatial feature types, their instances, a neighborhood relation (e.g., proximity), and a hierarchical taxonomy of the feature types, the goal is to find the subsets of feature types or their parents whose spatial interaction is statistically significant. This problem is for taxonomy-reliant applications such as ecology (e.g., finding new symbiotic relationships across the food chain), spatial pathology (e.g., immunotherapy for cancer), retail, etc. The problem is computationally challenging due to the exponential number of candidate co-location patterns generated by the taxonomy. Most approaches for co-location pattern detection overlook the hierarchical relationships among spatial features, and the statistical significance of the detected patterns is not always considered, leading to potential false discoveries. This paper introduces two methods for incorporating taxonomies and assessing the statistical significance of co-location patterns. The baseline approach iteratively checks the significance of co-locations between leaf nodes or their ancestors in the taxonomy. Using the Benjamini-Hochberg procedure, an advanced approach is proposed to control the false discovery rate. This approach effectively reduces the risk of false discoveries while maintaining the power to detect true co-location patterns. Experimental evaluation and case study results show the effectiveness of the approach.

Read more

7/8/2024

Efficient Discovery of Significant Patterns with Few-Shot Resampling
Total Score

0

Efficient Discovery of Significant Patterns with Few-Shot Resampling

Leonardo Pellegrina, Fabio Vandin

Significant pattern mining is a fundamental task in mining transactional data, requiring to identify patterns significantly associated with the value of a given feature, the target. In several applications, such as biomedicine, basket market analysis, and social networks, the goal is to discover patterns whose association with the target is defined with respect to an underlying population, or process, of which the dataset represents only a collection of observations, or samples. A natural way to capture the association of a pattern with the target is to consider its statistical significance, assessing its deviation from the (null) hypothesis of independence between the pattern and the target. While several algorithms have been proposed to find statistically significant patterns, it remains a computationally demanding task, and for complex patterns such as subgroups, no efficient solution exists. We present FSR, an efficient algorithm to identify statistically significant patterns with rigorous guarantees on the probability of false discoveries. FSR builds on a novel general framework for mining significant patterns that captures some of the most commonly considered patterns, including itemsets, sequential patterns, and subgroups. FSR uses a small number of resampled datasets, obtained by assigning i.i.d. labels to each transaction, to rigorously bound the supremum deviation of a quality statistic measuring the significance of patterns. FSR builds on novel tight bounds on the supremum deviation that require to mine a small number of resampled datasets, while providing a high effectiveness in discovering significant patterns. As a test case, we consider significant subgroup mining, and our evaluation on several real datasets shows that FSR is effective in discovering significant subgroups, while requiring a small number of resampled datasets.

Read more

6/18/2024

Predicting unobserved climate time series data at distant areas via spatial correlation using reservoir computing
Total Score

0

Predicting unobserved climate time series data at distant areas via spatial correlation using reservoir computing

Shihori Koyama, Daisuke Inoue, Hiroaki Yoshida, Kazuyuki Aihara, Gouhei Tanaka

Collecting time series data spatially distributed in many locations is often important for analyzing climate change and its impacts on ecosystems. However, comprehensive spatial data collection is not always feasible, requiring us to predict climate variables at some locations. This study focuses on a prediction of climatic elements, specifically near-surface temperature and pressure, at a target location apart from a data observation point. Our approach uses two prediction methods: reservoir computing (RC), known as a machine learning framework with low computational requirements, and vector autoregression models (VAR), recognized as a statistical method for analyzing time series data. Our results show that the accuracy of the predictions degrades with the distance between the observation and target locations. We quantitatively estimate the distance in which effective predictions are possible. We also find that in the context of climate data, a geographical distance is associated with data correlation, and a strong data correlation significantly improves the prediction accuracy with RC. In particular, RC outperforms VAR in predicting highly correlated data within the predictive range. These findings suggest that machine learning-based methods can be used more effectively to predict climatic elements in remote locations by assessing the distance to them from the data observation point in advance. Our study on low-cost and accurate prediction of climate variables has significant value for climate change strategies.

Read more

6/6/2024