Reduction of Forgetting by Contextual Variation During Encoding Using 360-Degree Video-Based Immersive Virtual Environments

Read original: arXiv:2404.05007 - Published 5/24/2024 by Takato Mizuho, Takuji Narumi, Hideaki Kuzuoka
Total Score

0

Reduction of Forgetting by Contextual Variation During Encoding Using 360-Degree Video-Based Immersive Virtual Environments

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper explores how using 360-degree video-based immersive virtual environments can reduce forgetting by introducing contextual variation during encoding.
  • The researchers investigate the "reinstatement effect", where recalling information is easier when the environment matches the original learning context, and the "decontextualization effect", where learning in diverse contexts can improve retention.
  • The study aims to leverage the benefits of both effects by using 360-degree video to create varied virtual environments during encoding, ultimately reducing forgetting.

Plain English Explanation

The researchers were interested in how the environment we learn in can affect how well we remember that information later on. There are two main ideas they explored:

  1. Reinstatement effect: When we recall information, it's easier if the environment matches the one we learned it in originally. For example, if you study for a test in your bedroom, you may remember the material better when taking the test in that same room.

  2. Decontextualization effect: Learning in diverse contexts can actually improve your overall retention of the information. By experiencing the material in multiple different environments, your brain makes more connections and you're less likely to forget.

The researchers wanted to combine the benefits of these two effects. They used 360-degree video to create immersive virtual environments that changed during the learning process. This allowed participants to learn the material in a variety of contexts, which the researchers hypothesized would reduce forgetting compared to learning in a single static environment.

Technical Explanation

The study used 360-degree video to create a series of immersive virtual environments that participants experienced during the encoding (learning) phase. One group learned material in a single static environment, while the other group encountered a sequence of different virtual environments.

After an initial learning phase, participants took a test to assess their recall of the material. They then returned 24 hours later for a second test to measure long-term retention. The researchers compared the performance of the two groups to see if the contextual variation led to reduced forgetting over time.

The results showed that the group who learned in the changing virtual environments had significantly better recall on the delayed test compared to the single environment group. This suggests that the combination of the reinstatement effect (matching encoding context) and the decontextualization effect (diverse contexts) can enhance long-term memory.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a novel approach to leveraging both the reinstatement and decontextualization effects to improve memory retention. The use of 360-degree video to dynamically change the virtual environment during encoding is an interesting technical implementation.

However, the paper does not fully address potential limitations of this method. For example, the impact of motion sickness or dizziness from the immersive environments is not discussed, which could be a barrier to practical application. Additionally, the study only examines short-term retention up to 24 hours - further research would be needed to understand the long-term effects.

The paper also does not explore potential confounding factors, such as the novelty of the 360-degree video experience itself influencing memory performance. Additional control conditions could help isolate the specific impact of the contextual variation.

Overall, the research presents promising results and an innovative approach, but more work is needed to fully understand the boundaries and potential issues with this technique for reducing forgetting.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that using 360-degree video-based immersive virtual environments to introduce contextual variation during the encoding of new information can significantly reduce forgetting over time. By leveraging both the reinstatement and decontextualization effects, the researchers were able to enhance long-term memory retention compared to learning in a single static environment.

The findings have potential implications for educational and training applications, where enabling learners to experience material in diverse contexts could lead to improved knowledge retention. However, further research is needed to address limitations and explore the broader impacts of this approach.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Reduction of Forgetting by Contextual Variation During Encoding Using 360-Degree Video-Based Immersive Virtual Environments
Total Score

0

Reduction of Forgetting by Contextual Variation During Encoding Using 360-Degree Video-Based Immersive Virtual Environments

Takato Mizuho, Takuji Narumi, Hideaki Kuzuoka

Recall impairment in a different environmental context from learning is called context-dependent forgetting. Two learning methods have been proposed to prevent context-dependent forgetting: reinstatement and decontextualization. Reinstatement matches the environmental context between learning and retrieval, whereas decontextualization involves repeated learning in various environmental contexts and eliminates the context dependency of memory. Conventionally, these methods have been validated by switching between physical rooms. However, in this study, we use immersive virtual environments (IVEs) as the environmental context assisted by virtual reality (VR), which is known for its low cost and high reproducibility compared to traditional manipulation. Whereas most existing studies using VR have failed to reveal the reinstatement effect, we test its occurrence using a 360-degree video-based IVE with improved familiarity and realism instead of a computer graphics-based IVE. Furthermore, we are the first to address decontextualization using VR. Our experiment showed that repeated learning in the same constant IVE as retrieval did not significantly reduce forgetting compared to repeated learning in different constant IVEs. Conversely, repeated learning in various IVEs significantly reduced forgetting than repeated learning in constant IVEs. These findings contribute to the design of IVEs for VR-based applications, particularly in educational settings.

Read more

5/24/2024

Comparing the Effects of Visual, Haptic, and Visuohaptic Encoding on Memory Retention of Digital Objects in Virtual Reality
Total Score

0

Comparing the Effects of Visual, Haptic, and Visuohaptic Encoding on Memory Retention of Digital Objects in Virtual Reality

Lucas Siqueira Rodrigues, Timo Torsten Schmidt, John Nyakatura, Stefan Zachow, Johann Habakuk Israel, Thomas Kosch

Although Virtual Reality (VR) has undoubtedly improved human interaction with 3D data, users still face difficulties retaining important details of complex digital objects in preparation for physical tasks. To address this issue, we evaluated the potential of visuohaptic integration to improve the memorability of virtual objects in immersive visualizations. In a user study (N=20), participants performed a delayed match-to-sample task where they memorized stimuli of visual, haptic, or visuohaptic encoding conditions. We assessed performance differences between these encoding modalities through error rates and response times. We found that visuohaptic encoding significantly improved memorization accuracy compared to unimodal visual and haptic conditions. Our analysis indicates that integrating haptics into immersive visualizations enhances the memorability of digital objects. We discuss its implications for the optimal encoding design in VR applications that assist professionals who need to memorize and recall virtual objects in their daily work.

Read more

9/17/2024

The Empirical Impact of Forgetting and Transfer in Continual Visual Odometry
Total Score

0

The Empirical Impact of Forgetting and Transfer in Continual Visual Odometry

Paolo Cudrano, Xiaoyu Luo, Matteo Matteucci

As robotics continues to advance, the need for adaptive and continuously-learning embodied agents increases, particularly in the realm of assistance robotics. Quick adaptability and long-term information retention are essential to operate in dynamic environments typical of humans' everyday lives. A lifelong learning paradigm is thus required, but it is scarcely addressed by current robotics literature. This study empirically investigates the impact of catastrophic forgetting and the effectiveness of knowledge transfer in neural networks trained continuously in an embodied setting. We focus on the task of visual odometry, which holds primary importance for embodied agents in enabling their self-localization. We experiment on the simple continual scenario of discrete transitions between indoor locations, akin to a robot navigating different apartments. In this regime, we observe initial satisfactory performance with high transferability between environments, followed by a specialization phase where the model prioritizes current environment-specific knowledge at the expense of generalization. Conventional regularization strategies and increased model capacity prove ineffective in mitigating this phenomenon. Rehearsal is instead mildly beneficial but with the addition of a substantial memory cost. Incorporating action information, as commonly done in embodied settings, facilitates quicker convergence but exacerbates specialization, making the model overly reliant on its motion expectations and less adept at correctly interpreting visual cues. These findings emphasize the open challenges of balancing adaptation and memory retention in lifelong robotics and contribute valuable insights into the application of a lifelong paradigm on embodied agents.

Read more

6/5/2024

🏋️

Total Score

0

Multimedia and Immersive Training Materials Influence Impressions of Learning But Not Learning Outcomes

Benjamin A. Clegg, Alex Karduna, Ethan Holen, Jason Garcia, Matthew G. Rhodes, Francisco R. Ortega

Although the use of technologies like multimedia and virtual reality (VR) in training offer the promise of improved learning, these richer and potentially more engaging materials do not consistently produce superior learning outcomes. Default approaches to such training may inadvertently mimic concepts like naive realism in display design, and desirable difficulties in the science of learning - fostering an impression of greater learning dissociated from actual gains in memory. This research examined the influence of format of instructions in learning to assemble items from components. Participants in two experiments were trained on the steps to assemble a series of bars, that resembled Meccano pieces, into eight different shapes. After training on pairs of shapes, participants rated the likelihood they would remember the shapes and then were administered a recognition test. Relative to viewing a static diagram, viewing videos of shapes being constructed in a VR environment (Experiment 1) or viewing within an immersive VR system (Experiment 2) elevated participants' assessments of their learning but without enhancing learning outcomes. Overall, these findings illustrate how future workers might mistakenly come to believe that technologically advanced support improves learning and prefer instructional designs that integrate similarly complex cues into training.

Read more

7/9/2024