The Empirical Impact of Forgetting and Transfer in Continual Visual Odometry
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The provided paper explores the empirical impact of forgetting and transfer in continual visual odometry, which is the task of estimating the position and orientation of a camera over time.
- Continual learning is the ability of an AI system to learn new tasks or skills without forgetting previously learned information, which is an important challenge in embodied AI systems.
- The paper investigates how different continual learning approaches affect the performance and memory usage of a visual odometry system as it learns new environments over time.
Plain English Explanation
Continual learning is an important capability for embodied AI systems, like robots or self-driving cars, that need to operate in the real world and adapt to new environments and situations over time. These systems shouldn't forget what they've learned in the past as they take on new tasks. The paper looks at how different approaches to continual learning impact the performance and memory usage of a visual odometry system - a system that can track the position and orientation of a camera as it moves through an environment.
The key idea is that as the visual odometry system encounters new environments, it needs to balance retaining what it's learned previously (to avoid forgetting) and adapting to the new environment (to enable transfer of knowledge). The researchers evaluate different strategies for achieving this balance, and analyze the tradeoffs in terms of the system's accuracy, efficiency, and memory requirements.
For example, one approach might be to completely retrain the system from scratch every time it encounters a new environment. This would allow the system to fully adapt, but it would also mean completely forgetting everything it had learned before. Another approach might be to try to selectively remember and transfer relevant information from past environments, which could improve efficiency but might also lead to forgetting or negative transfer of irrelevant information.
By understanding the empirical impacts of these different continual learning strategies, the researchers aim to inform the design of more effective and adaptable embodied AI systems that can learn and operate in diverse real-world environments over time.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents an empirical study of continual learning for the task of visual odometry - the process of estimating the 6-DOF (degree-of-freedom) pose of a camera as it moves through an environment. The authors evaluate the performance and memory usage of a deep neural network-based visual odometry system as it encounters and learns new environments over time.
The authors consider three main continual learning approaches: 1) Complete retraining, where the system is fully retrained from scratch on each new environment, 2) Selective memory, where the system selectively remembers and transfers relevant knowledge from past environments, and 3) Gradient episodic memory, which uses a rehearsal-based approach to avoid forgetting.
The experiments are conducted on a diverse dataset of indoor and outdoor environments, and the authors measure metrics like pose estimation accuracy, computation time, and memory usage as the visual odometry system continually learns new environments.
The results show that the selective memory approach generally outperforms the other methods in terms of balancing performance, efficiency, and memory requirements. However, the authors also identify key tradeoffs and challenges, such as the need to carefully curate the selective memory to avoid negative transfer, and the inherent tension between maintaining past performance and enabling efficient adaptation to new environments.
Overall, the paper provides valuable empirical insights into the practical challenges of deploying continual learning in embodied AI systems, and highlights important directions for future research in this area.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough and well-designed empirical study of continual learning approaches for visual odometry, and the results offer meaningful insights for the field of embodied AI. However, there are a few key limitations and areas for further exploration that could be considered:
-
The dataset used in the experiments, while diverse, is still relatively small and may not fully capture the breadth of real-world environments and conditions that an embodied AI system would need to adapt to. Evaluating the approaches on larger, more heterogeneous datasets could yield additional insights.
-
The paper focuses on visual odometry as a specific task, but the findings may not necessarily generalize to other embodied AI applications that involve different sensing modalities, action spaces, or learning objectives. Further research is needed to understand the broader applicability of the continual learning approaches.
-
The authors do not explore more advanced continual learning techniques, such as those leveraging [object Object] or [object Object], which have shown promise in related domains. Incorporating such techniques could potentially lead to further improvements in performance and efficiency.
-
While the paper discusses the tradeoffs between maintaining past performance and enabling efficient adaptation, it does not delve into the broader [object Object] and [object Object] implications of continual learning in embodied AI systems. Exploring these aspects could be valuable for real-world deployment.
Overall, the paper makes a valuable contribution to the understanding of continual learning in the context of visual odometry, and the findings can help inform the design of more effective and adaptable embodied AI systems. However, further research is needed to address the limitations and explore the broader implications of these techniques.
Conclusion
This paper presents an empirical study of the impact of different continual learning approaches on the performance and memory usage of a deep neural network-based visual odometry system. The authors evaluate three main continual learning strategies - complete retraining, selective memory, and gradient episodic memory - as the system encounters and learns new environments over time.
The results show that the selective memory approach generally outperforms the other methods in terms of balancing accuracy, efficiency, and memory requirements. However, the authors also identify key tradeoffs and challenges, such as the need to carefully curate the selective memory to avoid negative transfer, and the inherent tension between maintaining past performance and enabling efficient adaptation to new environments.
These findings offer valuable insights for the design of more effective and adaptable embodied AI systems, which need to learn and operate in diverse real-world settings while avoiding catastrophic forgetting. The paper also highlights important directions for future research, such as exploring the use of advanced continual learning techniques and investigating the broader robustness and safety implications of these approaches.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
The Empirical Impact of Forgetting and Transfer in Continual Visual Odometry
Paolo Cudrano, Xiaoyu Luo, Matteo Matteucci
As robotics continues to advance, the need for adaptive and continuously-learning embodied agents increases, particularly in the realm of assistance robotics. Quick adaptability and long-term information retention are essential to operate in dynamic environments typical of humans' everyday lives. A lifelong learning paradigm is thus required, but it is scarcely addressed by current robotics literature. This study empirically investigates the impact of catastrophic forgetting and the effectiveness of knowledge transfer in neural networks trained continuously in an embodied setting. We focus on the task of visual odometry, which holds primary importance for embodied agents in enabling their self-localization. We experiment on the simple continual scenario of discrete transitions between indoor locations, akin to a robot navigating different apartments. In this regime, we observe initial satisfactory performance with high transferability between environments, followed by a specialization phase where the model prioritizes current environment-specific knowledge at the expense of generalization. Conventional regularization strategies and increased model capacity prove ineffective in mitigating this phenomenon. Rehearsal is instead mildly beneficial but with the addition of a substantial memory cost. Incorporating action information, as commonly done in embodied settings, facilitates quicker convergence but exacerbates specialization, making the model overly reliant on its motion expectations and less adept at correctly interpreting visual cues. These findings emphasize the open challenges of balancing adaptation and memory retention in lifelong robotics and contribute valuable insights into the application of a lifelong paradigm on embodied agents.
Read more6/5/2024
0
Learn to Memorize and to Forget: A Continual Learning Perspective of Dynamic SLAM
Baicheng Li, Zike Yan, Dong Wu, Hanqing Jiang, Hongbin Zha
Simultaneous localization and mapping (SLAM) with implicit neural representations has received extensive attention due to the expressive representation power and the innovative paradigm of continual learning. However, deploying such a system within a dynamic environment has not been well-studied. Such challenges are intractable even for conventional algorithms since observations from different views with dynamic objects involved break the geometric and photometric consistency, whereas the consistency lays the foundation for joint optimizing the camera pose and the map parameters. In this paper, we best exploit the characteristics of continual learning and propose a novel SLAM framework for dynamic environments. While past efforts have been made to avoid catastrophic forgetting by exploiting an experience replay strategy, we view forgetting as a desirable characteristic. By adaptively controlling the replayed buffer, the ambiguity caused by moving objects can be easily alleviated through forgetting. We restrain the replay of the dynamic objects by introducing a continually-learned classifier for dynamic object identification. The iterative optimization of the neural map and the classifier notably improves the robustness of the SLAM system under a dynamic environment. Experiments on challenging datasets verify the effectiveness of the proposed framework.
Read more7/19/2024
0
Data-dependent and Oracle Bounds on Forgetting in Continual Learning
Lior Friedman, Ron Meir
In continual learning, knowledge must be preserved and re-used between tasks, maintaining good transfer to future tasks and minimizing forgetting of previously learned ones. While several practical algorithms have been devised for this setting, there have been few theoretical works aiming to quantify and bound the degree of Forgetting in general settings. We provide both data-dependent and oracle upper bounds that apply regardless of model and algorithm choice, as well as bounds for Gibbs posteriors. We derive an algorithm inspired by our bounds and demonstrate empirically that our approach yields improved forward and backward transfer.
Read more6/14/2024
✨
0
Knowledge Accumulation in Continually Learned Representations and the Issue of Feature Forgetting
Timm Hess, Eli Verwimp, Gido M. van de Ven, Tinne Tuytelaars
Continual learning research has shown that neural networks suffer from catastrophic forgetting at the output level, but it is debated whether this is also the case at the level of learned representations. Multiple recent studies ascribe representations a certain level of innate robustness against forgetting -- that they only forget minimally in comparison with forgetting at the output level. We revisit and expand upon the experiments that revealed this difference in forgetting and illustrate the coexistence of two phenomena that affect the quality of continually learned representations: knowledge accumulation and feature forgetting. Taking both aspects into account, we show that, even though forgetting in the representation (i.e. feature forgetting) can be small in absolute terms, when measuring relative to how much was learned during a task, forgetting in the representation tends to be just as catastrophic as forgetting at the output level. Next we show that this feature forgetting is problematic as it substantially slows down the incremental learning of good general representations (i.e. knowledge accumulation). Finally, we study how feature forgetting and knowledge accumulation are affected by different types of continual learning methods.
Read more6/26/2024