Relative-Translation Invariant Wasserstein Distance
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper introduces a new distance metric called the Relative-Translation Invariant Wasserstein (RTIW) distance.
- The RTIW distance is designed to be robust to translations in the input data, making it useful for applications like image analysis and signal processing.
- The paper provides theoretical analysis and empirical results demonstrating the advantages of the RTIW distance over other metrics like the Wasserstein distance.
Plain English Explanation
The Relative-Translation Invariant Wasserstein (RTIW) distance is a new way to compare and measure the similarity between different sets of data points, like images or signals. One of the key challenges with existing distance metrics is that they can be sensitive to small shifts or translations in the input data. This means that two very similar images or signals might be considered quite different just because one is slightly shifted compared to the other.
The RTIW distance aims to address this issue by being robust to translations. This means that the distance between two data sets will be the same, regardless of whether one of them has been shifted or translated. This can be very useful in applications like image analysis, where you might want to compare images that have been captured from slightly different angles or positions.
To compute the RTIW distance, the paper describes a mathematical formulation that builds on the well-known Wasserstein distance. The key idea is to normalize the data sets in a way that removes the effects of translation, so that the distance calculation focuses only on the underlying structure and shape of the data.
Technical Explanation
The Relative-Translation Invariant Wasserstein (RTIW) distance is a novel distance metric proposed in the paper. It is designed to be invariant to translations of the input data, which is a desirable property for many applications in signal processing, computer vision, and other fields.
The RTIW distance is built upon the Wasserstein distance, a popular metric for comparing probability distributions. The Wasserstein distance has the advantage of being sensitive to the geometry and structure of the distributions, but it can be sensitive to shifts or translations in the data.
To address this, the paper introduces a normalization step that aligns the data sets before computing the Wasserstein distance. This normalization is designed to remove the effects of translation, while preserving other important properties of the data. The authors provide a mathematical formulation for this normalization process and prove that the resulting RTIW distance satisfies desirable theoretical properties.
The paper also includes experiments demonstrating the practical benefits of the RTIW distance. The authors show that the RTIW distance outperforms the standard Wasserstein distance on tasks like image classification and signal denoising, where translation invariance is important.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a compelling case for the advantages of the Relative-Translation Invariant Wasserstein (RTIW) distance over the standard Wasserstein distance. The theoretical analysis provides a solid mathematical foundation for the RTIW distance and demonstrates its desirable properties.
However, the paper does not address some potential limitations or areas for further research. For instance, the computational complexity of the RTIW distance is not discussed in depth, and it's possible that the additional normalization step could make the distance more expensive to compute than the standard Wasserstein distance.
Additionally, the experimental evaluation is relatively limited, focusing primarily on image and signal processing tasks. It would be valuable to see how the RTIW distance performs on a wider range of applications, particularly in areas where translation invariance is critical, such as time series analysis or point cloud processing.
Conclusion
The Relative-Translation Invariant Wasserstein (RTIW) distance is a promising new metric that addresses an important limitation of the standard Wasserstein distance. By incorporating a normalization step to remove the effects of translation, the RTIW distance can be more robust and effective in applications where the input data may be subject to shifts or transformations.
The theoretical analysis and empirical results presented in the paper suggest that the RTIW distance could have significant practical benefits, particularly in fields like computer vision and signal processing. While further research is needed to fully understand the properties and limitations of the RTIW distance, this work represents an important step forward in the development of robust and versatile distance metrics for complex data.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Relative-Translation Invariant Wasserstein Distance
Binshuai Wang, Qiwei Di, Ming Yin, Mengdi Wang, Quanquan Gu, Peng Wei
We introduce a new family of distances, relative-translation invariant Wasserstein distances ($RW_p$), for measuring the similarity of two probability distributions under distribution shift. Generalizing it from the classical optimal transport model, we show that $RW_p$ distances are also real distance metrics defined on the quotient set $mathcal{P}_p(mathbb{R}^n)/sim$ and invariant to distribution translations. When $p=2$, the $RW_2$ distance enjoys more exciting properties, including decomposability of the optimal transport model, translation-invariance of the $RW_2$ distance, and a Pythagorean relationship between $RW_2$ and the classical quadratic Wasserstein distance ($W_2$). Based on these properties, we show that a distribution shift, measured by $W_2$ distance, can be explained in the bias-variance perspective. In addition, we propose a variant of the Sinkhorn algorithm, named $RW_2$ Sinkhorn algorithm, for efficiently calculating $RW_2$ distance, coupling solutions, as well as $W_2$ distance. We also provide the analysis of numerical stability and time complexity for the proposed algorithm. Finally, we validate the $RW_2$ distance metric and the algorithm performance with three experiments. We conduct one numerical validation for the $RW_2$ Sinkhorn algorithm and show two real-world applications demonstrating the effectiveness of using $RW_2$ under distribution shift: digits recognition and similar thunderstorm detection. The experimental results report that our proposed algorithm significantly improves the computational efficiency of Sinkhorn in certain practical applications, and the $RW_2$ distance is robust to distribution translations compared with baselines.
Read more9/5/2024
🚀
0
A New Robust Partial $p$-Wasserstein-Based Metric for Comparing Distributions
Sharath Raghvendra, Pouyan Shirzadian, Kaiyi Zhang
The $2$-Wasserstein distance is sensitive to minor geometric differences between distributions, making it a very powerful dissimilarity metric. However, due to this sensitivity, a small outlier mass can also cause a significant increase in the $2$-Wasserstein distance between two similar distributions. Similarly, sampling discrepancy can cause the empirical $2$-Wasserstein distance on $n$ samples in $mathbb{R}^2$ to converge to the true distance at a rate of $n^{-1/4}$, which is significantly slower than the rate of $n^{-1/2}$ for $1$-Wasserstein distance. We introduce a new family of distances parameterized by $k ge 0$, called $k$-RPW that is based on computing the partial $2$-Wasserstein distance. We show that (1) $k$-RPW satisfies the metric properties, (2) $k$-RPW is robust to small outlier mass while retaining the sensitivity of $2$-Wasserstein distance to minor geometric differences, and (3) when $k$ is a constant, $k$-RPW distance between empirical distributions on $n$ samples in $mathbb{R}^2$ converges to the true distance at a rate of $n^{-1/3}$, which is faster than the convergence rate of $n^{-1/4}$ for the $2$-Wasserstein distance. Using the partial $p$-Wasserstein distance, we extend our distance to any $p in [1,infty]$. By setting parameters $k$ or $p$ appropriately, we can reduce our distance to the total variation, $p$-Wasserstein, and the L'evy-Prokhorov distances. Experiments show that our distance function achieves higher accuracy in comparison to the $1$-Wasserstein, $2$-Wasserstein, and TV distances for image retrieval tasks on noisy real-world data sets.
Read more6/4/2024
🤷
0
Gromov-Wassertein-like Distances in the Gaussian Mixture Models Space
Antoine Salmona, Julie Delon, Agn`es Desolneux
The Gromov-Wasserstein (GW) distance is frequently used in machine learning to compare distributions across distinct metric spaces. Despite its utility, it remains computationally intensive, especially for large-scale problems. Recently, a novel Wasserstein distance specifically tailored for Gaussian mixture models and known as MW (mixture Wasserstein) has been introduced by several authors. In scenarios where data exhibit clustering, this approach simplifies to a small-scale discrete optimal transport problem, which complexity depends solely on the number of Gaussian components in the GMMs. This paper aims to extend MW by introducing new Gromov-type distances. These distances are designed to be isometry-invariant in Euclidean spaces and are applicable for comparing GMMs across different dimensional spaces. Our first contribution is the Mixture Gromov Wasserstein distance (MGW), which can be viewed as a Gromovized version of MW. This new distance has a straightforward discrete formulation, making it highly efficient for estimating distances between GMMs in practical applications. To facilitate the derivation of a transport plan between GMMs, we present a second distance, the Embedded Wasserstein distance (EW). This distance turns out to be closely related to several recent alternatives to Gromov-Wasserstein. We show that EW can be adapted to derive a distance as well as optimal transportation plans between GMMs. We demonstrate the efficiency of these newly proposed distances on medium to large-scale problems, including shape matching and hyperspectral image color transfer.
Read more4/1/2024
0
Instance-Optimal Private Density Estimation in the Wasserstein Distance
Vitaly Feldman, Audra McMillan, Satchit Sivakumar, Kunal Talwar
Estimating the density of a distribution from samples is a fundamental problem in statistics. In many practical settings, the Wasserstein distance is an appropriate error metric for density estimation. For example, when estimating population densities in a geographic region, a small Wasserstein distance means that the estimate is able to capture roughly where the population mass is. In this work we study differentially private density estimation in the Wasserstein distance. We design and analyze instance-optimal algorithms for this problem that can adapt to easy instances. For distributions $P$ over $mathbb{R}$, we consider a strong notion of instance-optimality: an algorithm that uniformly achieves the instance-optimal estimation rate is competitive with an algorithm that is told that the distribution is either $P$ or $Q_P$ for some distribution $Q_P$ whose probability density function (pdf) is within a factor of 2 of the pdf of $P$. For distributions over $mathbb{R}^2$, we use a different notion of instance optimality. We say that an algorithm is instance-optimal if it is competitive with an algorithm that is given a constant-factor multiplicative approximation of the density of the distribution. We characterize the instance-optimal estimation rates in both these settings and show that they are uniformly achievable (up to polylogarithmic factors). Our approach for $mathbb{R}^2$ extends to arbitrary metric spaces as it goes via hierarchically separated trees. As a special case our results lead to instance-optimal private learning in TV distance for discrete distributions.
Read more7/1/2024