A Reproducible Analysis of Sequential Recommender Systems
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper provides a reproducible analysis of sequential recommender systems.
- It examines the performance and behavior of various sequential recommendation models across different datasets and evaluation settings.
- The goal is to enable more reliable and transparent research in the field of sequential recommendation.
Plain English Explanation
Sequential recommender systems are a type of recommendation system that make recommendations based on a user's previous interactions or actions, rather than just their preferences. For example, a sequential recommender might suggest products a user is likely to buy next, based on their past purchase history.
This paper aims to make research on sequential recommender systems more reproducible and replicable. The authors provide a comprehensive analysis of how different sequential recommendation models perform across various datasets and evaluation settings. This allows other researchers to more easily build on and verify the findings.
The paper's key contribution is establishing a framework for conducting reliable and transparent research in this area. By making the analysis reproducible, it enables the community to better understand the strengths, weaknesses, and appropriate use cases of different sequential recommendation techniques.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by reviewing related work in the field of sequential recommendation. It then describes the experimental setup, including the datasets, evaluation metrics, and sequential recommendation models tested.
The authors conduct a series of experiments to assess the performance of these models across different scenarios. This includes evaluating how they handle cold-start users, how their performance varies with dataset size, and how they are affected by changes in the evaluation protocol.
The key insights from the analysis include:
- There is no single "best" sequential recommendation model - performance depends heavily on the specific dataset and evaluation setting.
- Certain models excel at certain tasks (e.g., predicting the next item, generating diverse recommendations) but struggle in other areas.
- The choice of evaluation metrics can significantly impact the perceived performance of these models.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a valuable contribution by establishing a reproducible framework for evaluating sequential recommender systems. This allows the research community to build upon these findings with greater confidence and identify areas that require further exploration.
One limitation of the work is that it focuses primarily on traditional sequential recommendation models, and does not address more recent advancements in areas like neural-based or generative approaches. Extending the analysis to these newer techniques could further enhance the understanding of the field.
Additionally, while the paper highlights the importance of appropriate evaluation protocols, it does not delve deeply into the nuances of different metrics and their suitability for various real-world scenarios. Further research in this direction could provide valuable guidance for practitioners.
Conclusion
This paper presents a comprehensive and reproducible analysis of sequential recommender systems, which is a crucial step in advancing the state of the art in this field. By establishing a transparent and reliable framework for evaluating these models, the authors enable other researchers to build upon their findings and drive more impactful progress in the development of sequential recommendation technologies.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
A Reproducible Analysis of Sequential Recommender Systems
Filippo Betello, Antonio Purificato, Federico Siciliano, Giovanni Trappolini, Andrea Bacciu, Nicola Tonellotto, Fabrizio Silvestri
Sequential Recommender Systems (SRSs) have emerged as a highly efficient approach to recommendation systems. By leveraging sequential data, SRSs can identify temporal patterns in user behaviour, significantly improving recommendation accuracy and relevance.Ensuring the reproducibility of these models is paramount for advancing research and facilitating comparisons between them. Existing works exhibit shortcomings in reproducibility and replicability of results, leading to inconsistent statements across papers. Our work fills these gaps by standardising data pre-processing and model implementations, providing a comprehensive code resource, including a framework for developing SRSs and establishing a foundation for consistent and reproducible experimentation. We conduct extensive experiments on several benchmark datasets, comparing various SRSs implemented in our resource. We challenge prevailing performance benchmarks, offering new insights into the SR domain. For instance, SASRec does not consistently outperform GRU4Rec. On the contrary, when the number of model parameters becomes substantial, SASRec starts to clearly dominate all the other SRSs. This discrepancy underscores the significant impact that experimental configuration has on the outcomes and the importance of setting it up to ensure precise and comprehensive results. Failure to do so can lead to significantly flawed conclusions, highlighting the need for rigorous experimental design and analysis in SRS research. Our code is available at https://github.com/antoniopurificato/recsys_repro_conf.
Read more8/9/2024
0
CSRec: Rethinking Sequential Recommendation from A Causal Perspective
Xiaoyu Liu, Jiaxin Yuan, Yuhang Zhou, Jingling Li, Furong Huang, Wei Ai
The essence of sequential recommender systems (RecSys) lies in understanding how users make decisions. Most existing approaches frame the task as sequential prediction based on users' historical purchase records. While effective in capturing users' natural preferences, this formulation falls short in accurately modeling actual recommendation scenarios, particularly in accounting for how unsuccessful recommendations influence future purchases. Furthermore, the impact of the RecSys itself on users' decisions has not been appropriately isolated and quantitatively analyzed. To address these challenges, we propose a novel formulation of sequential recommendation, termed Causal Sequential Recommendation (CSRec). Instead of predicting the next item in the sequence, CSRec aims to predict the probability of a recommended item's acceptance within a sequential context and backtrack how current decisions are made. Critically, CSRec facilitates the isolation of various factors that affect users' final decisions, especially the influence of the recommender system itself, thereby opening new avenues for the design of recommender systems. CSRec can be seamlessly integrated into existing methodologies. Experimental evaluations on both synthetic and real-world datasets demonstrate that the proposed implementation significantly improves upon state-of-the-art baselines.
Read more9/11/2024
0
Dataset Regeneration for Sequential Recommendation
Mingjia Yin, Hao Wang, Wei Guo, Yong Liu, Suojuan Zhang, Sirui Zhao, Defu Lian, Enhong Chen
The sequential recommender (SR) system is a crucial component of modern recommender systems, as it aims to capture the evolving preferences of users. Significant efforts have been made to enhance the capabilities of SR systems. These methods typically follow the model-centric paradigm, which involves developing effective models based on fixed datasets. However, this approach often overlooks potential quality issues and flaws inherent in the data. Driven by the potential of data-centric AI, we propose a novel data-centric paradigm for developing an ideal training dataset using a model-agnostic dataset regeneration framework called DR4SR. This framework enables the regeneration of a dataset with exceptional cross-architecture generalizability. Additionally, we introduce the DR4SR+ framework, which incorporates a model-aware dataset personalizer to tailor the regenerated dataset specifically for a target model. To demonstrate the effectiveness of the data-centric paradigm, we integrate our framework with various model-centric methods and observe significant performance improvements across four widely adopted datasets. Furthermore, we conduct in-depth analyses to explore the potential of the data-centric paradigm and provide valuable insights. The code can be found at https://github.com/USTC-StarTeam/DR4SR.
Read more9/12/2024
📶
0
TruthSR: Trustworthy Sequential Recommender Systems via User-generated Multimodal Content
Meng Yan, Haibin Huang, Ying Liu, Juan Zhao, Xiyue Gao, Cai Xu, Ziyu Guan, Wei Zhao
Sequential recommender systems explore users' preferences and behavioral patterns from their historically generated data. Recently, researchers aim to improve sequential recommendation by utilizing massive user-generated multi-modal content, such as reviews, images, etc. This content often contains inevitable noise. Some studies attempt to reduce noise interference by suppressing cross-modal inconsistent information. However, they could potentially constrain the capturing of personalized user preferences. In addition, it is almost impossible to entirely eliminate noise in diverse user-generated multi-modal content. To solve these problems, we propose a trustworthy sequential recommendation method via noisy user-generated multi-modal content. Specifically, we explicitly capture the consistency and complementarity of user-generated multi-modal content to mitigate noise interference. We also achieve the modeling of the user's multi-modal sequential preferences. In addition, we design a trustworthy decision mechanism that integrates subjective user perspective and objective item perspective to dynamically evaluate the uncertainty of prediction results. Experimental evaluation on four widely-used datasets demonstrates the superior performance of our model compared to state-of-the-art methods. The code is released at https://github.com/FairyMeng/TrustSR.
Read more4/29/2024