Rethinking Software Engineering in the Foundation Model Era: From Task-Driven AI Copilots to Goal-Driven AI Pair Programmers
2404.10225
0
0
📈
Abstract
The advent of Foundation Models (FMs) and AI-powered copilots has transformed the landscape of software development, offering unprecedented code completion capabilities and enhancing developer productivity. However, the current task-driven nature of these copilots falls short in addressing the broader goals and complexities inherent in software engineering (SE). In this paper, we propose a paradigm shift towards goal-driven AI-powered pair programmers that collaborate with human developers in a more holistic and context-aware manner. We envision AI pair programmers that are goal-driven, human partners, SE-aware, and self-learning. These AI partners engage in iterative, conversation-driven development processes, aligning closely with human goals and facilitating informed decision-making. We discuss the desired attributes of such AI pair programmers and outline key challenges that must be addressed to realize this vision. Ultimately, our work represents a shift from AI-augmented SE to AI-transformed SE by replacing code completion with a collaborative partnership between humans and AI that enhances both productivity and software quality.
Get summaries of the top AI research delivered straight to your inbox:
Overview
- The paper proposes a shift from task-driven AI code assistants to goal-driven AI pair programmers that collaborate with human developers in a more holistic and context-aware manner.
- The authors envision AI pair programmers that are goal-driven, human partners, software engineering (SE)-aware, and self-learning.
- These AI partners would engage in iterative, conversation-driven development processes, aligning closely with human goals and facilitating informed decision-making.
Plain English Explanation
Current AI-powered code assistants are primarily focused on task-driven code completion, which falls short in addressing the broader goals and complexities of software engineering. The authors propose a new approach where AI systems become collaborative partners, working alongside human developers in a more holistic and context-aware manner.
These AI "pair programmers" would be goal-driven, meaning they understand the high-level objectives of the software project and can work towards achieving them. They would be knowledgeable about software engineering best practices and aware of the bigger picture, rather than just focusing on individual tasks. Additionally, these AI partners would be self-learning, continuously improving their capabilities through their interactions with human developers.
The key idea is to shift from AI-augmented software engineering to AI-transformed software engineering, where the AI system is not just a tool, but a true collaborator. This would involve an iterative, conversation-driven development process, where the AI and the human developer work together to make informed decisions, addressing the complexities of software development in a more comprehensive way.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a paradigm shift from task-driven AI-powered code assistants to goal-driven AI pair programmers that collaborate with human developers. The authors envision these AI partners as being goal-driven, human-aware, software engineering (SE)-aware, and self-learning.
These AI pair programmers would engage in an iterative, conversation-driven development process, aligning closely with the human developer's goals and facilitating informed decision-making. This represents a move from AI-augmented SE to AI-transformed SE, where the AI system is not just a tool, but a true collaborator in the software development process.
The authors discuss the desired attributes of such AI pair programmers, including their ability to understand high-level software engineering goals, their knowledge of best practices and the wider context of the project, and their capacity for self-learning and improvement through interactions with human developers.
The paper also outlines key challenges that must be addressed to realize this vision, such as developing foundation models for planning-like tasks, enabling autonomous program improvement, and designing responsible generative AI systems.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a compelling vision for the future of AI-powered software development, moving beyond the current task-driven code completion capabilities of AI assistants. The authors rightly identify the need for AI systems that can truly collaborate with human developers, understanding the broader goals and complexities of software engineering.
One potential limitation of the proposed approach is the difficulty in developing AI systems with the level of goal-driven awareness, software engineering expertise, and self-learning capabilities described. Bridging the gap between current AI assistants and the envisioned AI pair programmers may require significant advances in areas such as foundation models for planning-like tasks and responsible generative AI.
Additionally, the paper does not address potential challenges around trust, transparency, and accountability in the context of AI-human collaboration in software development. Ensuring that these AI pair programmers are transparent in their decision-making and that human developers maintain control and understanding of the development process will be crucial.
Overall, the paper presents an ambitious and thought-provoking vision for the future of software engineering, and it will be interesting to see how the field progresses towards realizing this goal-driven, AI-transformed approach to software development.
Conclusion
The paper proposes a paradigm shift from task-driven AI code assistants to goal-driven AI pair programmers that collaborate with human developers in a more holistic and context-aware manner. The authors envision these AI partners as being goal-driven, human-aware, software engineering-aware, and self-learning, engaging in an iterative, conversation-driven development process.
This represents a move from AI-augmented software engineering to AI-transformed software engineering, where the AI system is a true collaborator in the development process, addressing the broader goals and complexities of software projects. While realizing this vision may present significant technical challenges, the paper offers a compelling vision for the future of AI-powered software development.
Related Papers
A Data-to-Product Multimodal Conceptual Framework to Achieve Automated Software Evolution for Context-rich Intelligent Applications
Songhui Yue
0
0
While AI is extensively transforming Software Engineering (SE) fields, SE is still in need of a framework to overall consider all phases to facilitate Automated Software Evolution (ASEv), particularly for intelligent applications that are context-rich, instead of conquering each division independently. Its complexity comes from the intricacy of the intelligent applications, the heterogeneity of the data sources, and the constant changes in the context. This study proposes a conceptual framework for achieving automated software evolution, emphasizing the importance of multimodality learning. A Selective Sequential Scope Model (3S) model is developed based on the conceptual framework, and it can be used to categorize existing and future research when it covers different SE phases and multimodal learning tasks. This research is a preliminary step toward the blueprint of a higher-level ASEv. The proposed conceptual framework can act as a practical guideline for practitioners to prepare themselves for diving into this area. Although the study is about intelligent applications, the framework and analysis methods may be adapted for other types of software as AI brings more intelligence into their life cycles.
4/23/2024
Open-Source AI-based SE Tools: Opportunities and Challenges of Collaborative Software Learning
Zhihao Lin, Wei Ma, Tao Lin, Yaowen Zheng, Jingquan Ge, Jun Wang, Jacques Klein, Tegawende Bissyande, Yang Liu, Li Li
0
0
Large Language Models (LLMs) have become instrumental in advancing software engineering (SE) tasks, showcasing their efficacy in code understanding and beyond. Like traditional SE tools, open-source collaboration is key in realising the excellent products. However, with AI models, the essential need is in data. The collaboration of these AI-based SE models hinges on maximising the sources of high-quality data. However, data especially of high quality, often holds commercial or sensitive value, making it less accessible for open-source AI-based SE projects. This reality presents a significant barrier to the development and enhancement of AI-based SE tools within the software engineering community. Therefore, researchers need to find solutions for enabling open-source AI-based SE models to tap into resources by different organisations. Addressing this challenge, our position paper investigates one solution to facilitate access to diverse organizational resources for open-source AI models, ensuring privacy and commercial sensitivities are respected. We introduce a governance framework centered on federated learning (FL), designed to foster the joint development and maintenance of open-source AI code models while safeguarding data privacy and security. Additionally, we present guidelines for developers on AI-based SE tool collaboration, covering data requirements, model architecture, updating strategies, and version control. Given the significant influence of data characteristics on FL, our research examines the effect of code data heterogeneity on FL performance.
4/10/2024
🤿
Prospective Role of Foundation Models in Advancing Autonomous Vehicles
Jianhua Wu, Bingzhao Gao, Jincheng Gao, Jianhao Yu, Hongqing Chu, Qiankun Yu, Xun Gong, Yi Chang, H. Eric Tseng, Hong Chen, Jie Chen
0
0
With the development of artificial intelligence and breakthroughs in deep learning, large-scale Foundation Models (FMs), such as GPT, CLIP, etc., have achieved remarkable results in many fields including natural language processing and computer vision. The application of FMs in autonomous driving holds considerable promise. For example, they can contribute to enhance scene understanding and reasoning. By pre-training on rich linguistic and visual data, FMs can understand and interpret various elements in a driving scene, and provide cognitive reasoning to give linguistic and action commands for driving decisions and planning. Furthermore, FMs can augment data based on its understanding of driving scenarios to provide feasible scenes of those rare occurrences in the long tail distribution that are unlikely to be encountered during routine driving and data collection. The enhancement can subsequently lead to the improvement in the accuracy and reliability of autonomous driving systems. Another testament to the potential of FMs applications lies in the development of World Models, exemplified by the DREAMER series, which showcase the ability to comprehend physical laws and dynamics. Learning from massive data under the paradigm of self-supervised learning, World Model can generate unseen yet plausible driving environment, facilitating the enhancement in the prediction of road users behavior and the off-line training of driving strategies. In this paper, we synthesize the applications and future trends of FMs in autonomous driving. By utilizing the powerful capabilities of FMs, we strive to tackle the potential issues stemming from the long-tail distribution in autonomous driving, consequently advancing overall safety in this domain.
5/7/2024
🤖
Generative AI and Process Systems Engineering: The Next Frontier
Benjamin Decardi-Nelson, Abdulelah S. Alshehri, Akshay Ajagekar, Fengqi You
0
0
This article explores how emerging generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) models, such as large language models (LLMs), can enhance solution methodologies within process systems engineering (PSE). These cutting-edge GenAI models, particularly foundation models (FMs), which are pre-trained on extensive, general-purpose datasets, offer versatile adaptability for a broad range of tasks, including responding to queries, image generation, and complex decision-making. Given the close relationship between advancements in PSE and developments in computing and systems technologies, exploring the synergy between GenAI and PSE is essential. We begin our discussion with a compact overview of both classic and emerging GenAI models, including FMs, and then dive into their applications within key PSE domains: synthesis and design, optimization and integration, and process monitoring and control. In each domain, we explore how GenAI models could potentially advance PSE methodologies, providing insights and prospects for each area. Furthermore, the article identifies and discusses potential challenges in fully leveraging GenAI within PSE, including multiscale modeling, data requirements, evaluation metrics and benchmarks, and trust and safety, thereby deepening the discourse on effective GenAI integration into systems analysis, design, optimization, operations, monitoring, and control. This paper provides a guide for future research focused on the applications of emerging GenAI in PSE.
5/8/2024