Revisiting Catastrophic Forgetting in Large Language Model Tuning
2406.04836
0
0
Abstract
Catastrophic Forgetting (CF) means models forgetting previously acquired knowledge when learning new data. It compromises the effectiveness of large language models (LLMs) during fine-tuning, yet the underlying causes have not been thoroughly investigated. This paper takes the first step to reveal the direct link between the flatness of the model loss landscape and the extent of CF in the field of LLMs. Based on this, we introduce the sharpness-aware minimization to mitigate CF by flattening the loss landscape. Experiments on three widely-used fine-tuning datasets, spanning different model scales, demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in alleviating CF. Analyses show that we nicely complement the existing anti-forgetting strategies, further enhancing the resistance of LLMs to CF.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper revisits the problem of catastrophic forgetting (CF) in large language model (LLM) tuning.
- The authors investigate the relationship between CF and the model's log-likelihood score (LLS), which measures the model's performance on the training data.
- The paper provides insights into the mechanisms behind CF and offers potential solutions to mitigate this issue.
Plain English Explanation
The paper examines the problem of catastrophic forgetting, which occurs when an AI model forgets how to perform previous tasks after being trained on new ones. This is a common challenge in the field of large language models (LLMs), which are AI systems that can generate human-like text.
The researchers looked at the connection between catastrophic forgetting and a metric called the "log-likelihood score" (LLS). The LLS measures how well the model is performing on the training data. By understanding the relationship between CF and LLS, the authors hope to gain insights into the underlying mechanisms of catastrophic forgetting and find ways to prevent it.
The paper provides a detailed technical analysis of this issue, offering potential solutions and areas for further research. The key ideas are presented in a clear and accessible way, using analogies and examples to help a general audience understand the significance of this work.
Technical Explanation
The paper investigates the relationship between catastrophic forgetting (CF) and the model's log-likelihood score (LLS) during the tuning process of large language models (LLMs). The authors hypothesize that there is a hidden nexus between CF and the LLS, which can provide insights into the mechanisms behind this phenomenon.
The researchers conduct experiments on several LLM architectures, including GPT-2 and BERT, to study the dynamics of CF and LLS during the tuning process. They analyze the changes in LLS and the degree of forgetting (measured by performance on previous tasks) as the model is fine-tuned on new tasks.
The findings suggest that there is a strong correlation between the LLS and the degree of CF. As the model's LLS on the new task increases, the performance on previous tasks often decreases, indicating catastrophic forgetting. The authors explore potential reasons for this relationship, including the model's tendency to prioritize learning the new task at the expense of retaining knowledge from previous tasks.
Based on these insights, the paper discusses potential approaches to mitigate catastrophic forgetting, such as internal link and internal link. The authors also highlight the need for further research to better understand the underlying mechanisms of CF in LLMs.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive and well-designed study on the relationship between catastrophic forgetting and the log-likelihood score in large language model tuning. The authors' approach of examining the dynamics of these two metrics during the fine-tuning process is insightful and could lead to a better understanding of the mechanisms behind catastrophic forgetting.
One potential limitation of the study is the focus on a specific set of LLM architectures, such as GPT-2 and BERT. While these models are widely used, it would be valuable to investigate the generalizability of the findings to other LLM architectures, as the mechanisms behind CF may vary across different model designs.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the impact of different training data sizes, task complexity, or model capacity on the observed relationship between CF and LLS. Investigating these factors could provide a more nuanced understanding of the problem and potential solutions.
Furthermore, the paper does not delve deeply into the implications of catastrophic forgetting for real-world applications of large language models. Exploring the practical consequences of CF and the trade-offs between task performance and knowledge retention would be a valuable addition to the discussion.
Despite these minor limitations, the paper provides a solid foundation for understanding the relationship between catastrophic forgetting and the log-likelihood score in LLM tuning. The insights presented can inform the development of more robust and adaptable large language models that can retain knowledge while effectively learning new tasks.
Conclusion
This paper offers a comprehensive investigation into the relationship between catastrophic forgetting (CF) and the log-likelihood score (LLS) in the tuning process of large language models (LLMs). The authors have uncovered a hidden nexus between these two metrics, which can provide valuable insights into the mechanisms behind CF and potential solutions to mitigate this issue.
The findings suggest a strong correlation between the LLS and the degree of CF, indicating that as the model's performance on a new task improves, it often comes at the expense of forgetting previous knowledge. This insight can inform the development of more robust and adaptable LLMs that can effectively learn new tasks without sacrificing their existing capabilities.
The paper also highlights the need for further research to explore the generalizability of these findings, the impact of various factors on the CF-LLS relationship, and the practical implications of catastrophic forgetting for real-world applications of LLMs. By addressing these areas, the field can make significant strides in overcoming the challenge of catastrophic forgetting and unlocking the full potential of large language models.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
š¬
An Empirical Study of Catastrophic Forgetting in Large Language Models During Continual Fine-tuning
Yun Luo, Zhen Yang, Fandong Meng, Yafu Li, Jie Zhou, Yue Zhang
0
0
Catastrophic forgetting (CF) is a phenomenon that occurs in machine learning when a model forgets previously learned information while acquiring new knowledge. As large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance, it is intriguing to investigate whether CF exists during the continual instruction tuning of LLMs. This study empirically evaluates the forgetting phenomenon in LLMs' knowledge during continual instruction tuning from the perspectives of domain knowledge, reasoning, and reading comprehension. The experiments reveal that catastrophic forgetting is generally observed in LLMs ranging from 1b to 7b parameters. Moreover, as the model scale increases, the severity of forgetting intensifies. Comparing the decoder-only model BLOOMZ with the encoder-decoder model mT0, BLOOMZ exhibits less forgetting and retains more knowledge. Interestingly, we also observe that LLMs can mitigate language biases, such as gender bias, during continual fine-tuning. Furthermore, our findings indicate that ALPACA maintains more knowledge and capacity compared to LLAMA during continual fine-tuning, suggesting that general instruction tuning can help alleviate the forgetting phenomenon in LLMs during subsequent fine-tuning processes.
4/3/2024
A Methodology-Oriented Study of Catastrophic Forgetting in Incremental Deep Neural Networks
Ashutosh Kumar, Sonali Agarwal, D Jude Hemanth
0
0
Human being and different species of animals having the skills to gather, transferring knowledge, processing, fine-tune and generating information throughout their lifetime. The ability of learning throughout their lifespan is referred as continuous learning which is using neurocognition mechanism. Consequently, in real world computational system of incremental learning autonomous agents also needs such continuous learning mechanism which provide retrieval of information and long-term memory consolidation. However, the main challenge in artificial intelligence is that the incremental learning of the autonomous agent when new data confronted. In such scenarios, the main concern is catastrophic forgetting(CF), i.e., while learning the sequentially, neural network underfits the old data when it confronted with new data. To tackle this CF problem many numerous studied have been proposed, however it is very difficult to compare their performance due to dissimilarity in their evaluation mechanism. Here we focus on the comparison of all algorithms which are having similar type of evaluation mechanism. Here we are comparing three types of incremental learning methods: (1) Exemplar based methods, (2) Memory based methods, and (3) Network based method. In this survey paper, methodology oriented study for catastrophic forgetting in incremental deep neural network is addressed. Furthermore, it contains the mathematical overview of impact-full methods which can be help researchers to deal with CF.
5/15/2024
More Than Catastrophic Forgetting: Integrating General Capabilities For Domain-Specific LLMs
Chengyuan Liu, Shihang Wang, Yangyang Kang, Lizhi Qing, Fubang Zhao, Changlong Sun, Kun Kuang, Fei Wu
0
0
The performance on general tasks decreases after Large Language Models (LLMs) are fine-tuned on domain-specific tasks, the phenomenon is known as Catastrophic Forgetting (CF). However, this paper presents a further challenge for real application of domain-specific LLMs beyond CF, called General Capabilities Integration (GCI), which necessitates the integration of both the general capabilities and domain knowledge within a single instance. The objective of GCI is not merely to retain previously acquired general capabilities alongside new domain knowledge, but to harmonize and utilize both sets of skills in a cohesive manner to enhance performance on domain-specific tasks. Taking legal domain as an example, we carefully design three groups of training and testing tasks without lacking practicability, and construct the corresponding datasets. To better incorporate general capabilities across domain-specific scenarios, we introduce ALoRA, which utilizes a multi-head attention module upon LoRA, facilitating direct information transfer from preceding tokens to the current one. This enhancement permits the representation to dynamically switch between domain-specific knowledge and general competencies according to the attention. Extensive experiments are conducted on the proposed tasks. The results exhibit the significance of our setting, and the effectiveness of our method.
5/29/2024
Intelligent Learning Rate Distribution to reduce Catastrophic Forgetting in Transformers
Philip Kenneweg, Alexander Schulz, Sarah Schroder, Barbara Hammer
0
0
Pretraining language models on large text corpora is a common practice in natural language processing. Fine-tuning of these models is then performed to achieve the best results on a variety of tasks. In this paper, we investigate the problem of catastrophic forgetting in transformer neural networks and question the common practice of fine-tuning with a flat learning rate for the entire network in this context. We perform a hyperparameter optimization process to find learning rate distributions that are better than a flat learning rate. We combine the learning rate distributions thus found and show that they generalize to better performance with respect to the problem of catastrophic forgetting. We validate these learning rate distributions with a variety of NLP benchmarks from the GLUE dataset.
4/3/2024