Revisiting Human Information Foraging: Adaptations for LLM-based Chatbots

Background: Information Foraging Theory

Information Foraging Theory is a framework for understanding how people search for and gather information. It proposes that people navigate information environments much like animals forage for food in physical environments. Just as animals seek out the most valuable food sources, people seek out the most valuable information sources to satisfy their informational needs.

The theory suggests that people make decisions about where to search for information and how long to spend on a particular information "patch" based on an assessment of the costs and benefits. They will tend to focus their efforts on areas that are likely to yield the most valuable information, just as animals focus on food sources that provide the greatest nutritional value per unit of effort.

This theory has implications for the design of information systems, as it suggests that people will be more likely to engage with and find value in systems that are structured in a way that aligns with their natural information foraging tendencies. For example, systems that make it easy for users to quickly assess the relevance and value of information sources, and that provide clear pathways to more valuable information, are more likely to be successful.

Plain English Explanation

Information Foraging Theory is all about how people search for and find information, just like how animals search for food. The idea is that people make decisions about where to look for information and how long to spend searching based on how much valuable information they think they'll find.

Just like animals go for the food sources that give them the most nutrition for the least effort, people focus on the information sources that they think will be the most useful to them. The theory suggests that if you design information systems in a way that matches how people naturally search for information, they'll be more likely to use and get value from those systems.

For example, if it's easy for people to quickly tell how useful a particular information source is, and there are clear paths to find more valuable information, they'll be more engaged and successful in their information seeking. The theory gives us a framework for understanding and designing effective information systems.

Technical Explanation

Information Foraging Theory (Chapman et al. 2023, Pirolli and Card 1999) proposes that people navigate information environments similar to how animals forage for food. The theory suggests that people make decisions about where to search for information and how long to spend on a particular information "patch" based on an assessment of the costs and benefits.

Specifically, the theory posits that people will tend to focus their information seeking efforts on areas that are likely to yield the most valuable information, just as animals focus on food sources that provide the greatest nutritional value per unit of effort. This is known as the "information scent" - the perceived value and access cost of information sources.

The implications of this theory for the design of information systems, such as LLM-based chatbots, are that systems that are structured in a way that aligns with people's natural information foraging tendencies will be more engaging and effective. For example, systems that make it easy for users to quickly assess the relevance and value of information sources, and that provide clear pathways to more valuable information, are more likely to be successful.

Critical Analysis

The Information Foraging Theory provides a useful framework for understanding and designing information systems, but it also has some limitations. For example, the theory assumes that people are primarily motivated by the goal of maximizing the value of the information they acquire, which may not always be the case (Hargittai et al. 2022, Selwyn 2004). People may also have other goals, such as social interaction or entertainment, that influence their information-seeking behavior.

Additionally, the theory does not fully account for the role of individual differences, such as cognitive abilities, prior knowledge, and personal preferences, in information foraging (Jia et al. 2023). These factors can significantly impact how people navigate and make decisions within information environments.

Further research is needed to explore the interplay between information foraging and other human factors, such as motivation, emotion, and social context (Fineman et al. 2023). By incorporating a more holistic understanding of human behavior, the Information Foraging Theory could be further refined and applied more effectively to the design of LLM-based chatbots and other information systems.

Conclusion

Information Foraging Theory provides a useful framework for understanding how people search for and gather information, with implications for the design of effective information systems. The theory suggests that people navigate information environments much like animals forage for food, making decisions based on an assessment of the costs and benefits of different information sources.

By aligning the structure and design of information systems with people's natural information foraging tendencies, these systems can be made more engaging and valuable to users. However, the theory also has some limitations, and further research is needed to explore the interplay between information foraging and other human factors that influence information-seeking behavior.

Overall, the Information Foraging Theory offers a valuable perspective for designers and researchers working to create more effective and user-centered information systems, including LLM-based chatbots.