Road to Serenity: Individual Variations in the Efficacy of Unobtrusive Respiratory Guidance for Driving Stress Regulation
0
🗣️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Driving requires cognitive functions like attention and decision-making, which can be impacted by stress
- Automated vehicles may introduce new sources of stress from non-driving tasks
- Relaxation techniques are needed to help regulate stress without distracting from driving
- Tactile wearables have shown promise for stress regulation through respiratory guidance, but individual variations may affect their efficacy
Plain English Explanation
Driving requires your brain to focus and make quick decisions. Stress can negatively impact these cognitive functions. As self-driving cars become more common, new sources of stress may arise from tasks not related to driving. Techniques are needed to help reduce stress without distracting the driver.
Wearable devices that provide tactile guidance, like vibrations, have been effective at helping people regulate their breathing to manage stress. This can be helpful for driving. However, people may respond to these devices differently based on their individual characteristics, like their driving habits or personality.
This study looked at how well people could follow tactile breathing guidance while driving under different stress levels. The researchers also explored how individual factors influenced the effectiveness of the stress-reducing technique.
Technical Explanation
The study assessed the use of slow-breathing tactile guidance in 85 participants under varying stress levels. Physiological, behavioral, and subjective data were collected to evaluate the participants' ability to follow the guidance and adjust their breathing while driving.
Logistic regression analysis was used to explore the influence of individual variations, such as driving habits, behavior, and personality, on the efficacy of the stress regulation technique. The researchers also examined the impact of factors related to the perceived criticality of the driving context.
The results showed that participants could follow the tactile breathing guidance and adjust their breathing while driving. However, the subjective effectiveness of the technique depended on individual variations in the ability to efficiently use the guidance, as well as the attentional cost of doing so. The study also found an influence of factors related to the evaluation of the driving context's criticality.
Critical Analysis
The study provides valuable insights into the use of tactile wearables for stress regulation in demanding driving contexts. However, the authors acknowledge that individual and contextual variations can significantly impact the efficacy of such techniques.
Further research is needed to explore the interplay between individual factors, such as personality and driving behavior, and the design and implementation of these stress-reduction interventions. Additionally, the study's findings highlight the importance of considering the driver's subjective evaluation of the driving context when developing and deploying these technologies.
While the study offers a promising approach, the authors note that more work is required to fully understand the complex relationship between stress, cognitive functions, and the use of wearable devices in demanding driving scenarios.
Conclusion
This study investigated the use of tactile wearables for stress regulation in driving contexts, finding that while participants could follow the breathing guidance, the subjective efficacy of the technique depended on individual and contextual factors. The results suggest that considering individual variations and the driver's perception of the driving context are crucial in designing and deploying such stress-management technologies in demanding driving situations. Further research is needed to build on these insights and develop more effective and personalized solutions for managing stress in autonomous and semi-autonomous vehicles.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🗣️
0
Road to Serenity: Individual Variations in the Efficacy of Unobtrusive Respiratory Guidance for Driving Stress Regulation
A. J. Bequet, C. Jallais, J. Quick, D. Ndiaye, A. R. Hidalgo-Munoz
Stress impacts driving-related cognitive functions like attention and decision-making, and may arise in automated vehicles due to non-driving tasks. Unobtrusive relaxation techniques are needed to regulate stress without distracting from driving. Tactile wearables have shown efficacy in stress regulation through respiratory guidance, but individual variations may affect their efficacy. This study assessed slow-breathing tactile guidance under different stress levels on 85 participants. Physiological, behavioral and subjective data were collected. The influence of individual variations (e.g., driving habits and behavior, personality) using logistic regression analysis was explored. Participants could follow the guidance and adjust breathing while driving, but subjective efficacy depended on individual variations linked to different efficiency in using the technique, in relation with its attentional cost. An influence of factors linked to the evaluation of context criticality was also found. The results suggest that considering individual and contextual variations is crucial in designing and using such techniques in demanding driving contexts. In this line some design recommendations and insights for further studies are provided.
Read more6/17/2024
0
Improving Engagement and Efficacy of mHealth Micro-Interventions for Stress Coping: an In-The-Wild Study
Chaya Ben Yehuda, Ran Gilad-Bachrach, Yarin Udi
Sustaining long-term user engagement with mobile health (mHealth) interventions while preserving their high efficacy remains an ongoing challenge in real-world well-being applications. To address this issue, we introduce a new algorithm, the Personalized, Context-Aware Recommender (PCAR), for intervention selection and evaluate its performance in a field experiment. In a four-week, in-the-wild experiment involving 29 parents of young children, we delivered personalized stress-reducing micro-interventions through a mobile chatbot. We assessed their impact on stress reduction using momentary stress level ecological momentary assessments (EMAs) before and after each intervention. Our findings demonstrate the superiority of PCAR intervention selection in enhancing the engagement and efficacy of mHealth micro-interventions to stress coping compared to random intervention selection and a control group that did not receive any intervention. Furthermore, we show that even brief, one-minute interventions can significantly reduce perceived stress levels (p=0.001). We observe that individuals are most receptive to one-minute interventions during transitional periods between activities, such as transitioning from afternoon activities to bedtime routines. Our study contributes to the literature by introducing a personalized context-aware intervention selection algorithm that improves engagement and efficacy of mHealth interventions, identifying key timing for stress interventions, and offering insights into mechanisms to improve stress coping.
Read more7/17/2024
🗣️
0
Decoding Pedestrian Stress on Urban Streets using Electrodermal Activity Monitoring in Virtual Immersive Reality
Mohsen Nazemi, Bara Rababah, Daniel Ramos, Tangxu Zhao, Bilal Farooq
The pedestrian stress level is shown to significantly influence human cognitive processes and, subsequently, decision-making, e.g., the decision to select a gap and cross a street. This paper systematically studies the stress experienced by a pedestrian when crossing a street under different experimental manipulations by monitoring the ElectroDermal Activity (EDA) using the Galvanic Skin Response (GSR) sensor. To fulfil the research objectives, a dynamic and immersive virtual reality (VR) platform was used, which is suitable for eliciting and capturing pedestrian's emotional responses in conjunction with monitoring their EDA. A total of 171 individuals participated in the experiment, tasked to cross a two-way street at mid-block with no signal control. Mixed effects models were employed to compare the influence of socio-demographics, social influence, vehicle technology, environment, road design, and traffic variables on the stress levels of the participants. The results indicated that having a street median in the middle of the road operates as a refuge and significantly reduced stress. Younger participants were (18-24 years) calmer than the relatively older participants (55-65 years). Arousal levels were higher when it came to the characteristics of the avatar (virtual pedestrian) in the simulation, especially for those avatars with adventurous traits. The pedestrian location influenced stress since the stress was higher on the street while crossing than waiting on the sidewalk. Significant causes of arousal were fear of accidents and an actual accident for pedestrians. The estimated random effects show a high degree of physical and mental learning by the participants while going through the scenarios.
Read more8/22/2024
0
Seamless Monitoring of Stress Levels Leveraging a Universal Model for Time Sequences
Davide Gabrielli, Bardh Prenkaj, Paola Velardi
Monitoring the stress level in patients with neurodegenerative diseases can help manage symptoms, improve patient's quality of life, and provide insight into disease progression. In the literature, ECG, actigraphy, speech, voice, and facial analysis have proven effective at detecting patients' emotions. On the other hand, these tools are invasive and do not integrate smoothly into the patient's daily life. HRV has also been proven to effectively indicate stress conditions, especially in combination with other signals. However, when HRV is derived from less invasive devices than the ECG, like smartwatches and bracelets, the quality of measurements significantly degrades. This paper presents a methodology for stress detection from a smartwatch based on a universal model for time series, UniTS, which we fine-tuned for the task. We cast the problem as anomaly detection rather than classification to favor model adaptation to individual patients and allow the clinician to maintain greater control over the system's predictions. We demonstrate that our proposed model considerably surpasses 12 top-performing methods on 3 benchmark datasets. Furthermore, unlike other state-of-the-art systems, UniTS enables seamless monitoring, as it shows comparable performance when using signals from invasive or lightweight devices.
Read more7/8/2024