On Robust Reinforcement Learning with Lipschitz-Bounded Policy Networks

Read original: arXiv:2405.11432 - Published 9/2/2024 by Nicholas H. Barbara, Ruigang Wang, Ian R. Manchester
Total Score

0

On Robust Reinforcement Learning with Lipschitz-Bounded Policy Networks

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper explores a method for training reinforcement learning agents with Lipschitz-bounded policy networks, which can enhance the robustness of the learned policies.
  • The key idea is to explicitly constrain the Lipschitz constant of the policy network, which limits the sensitivity of the policy to changes in the input state.
  • This can help the agent be more robust to distribution shift, adversarial perturbations, and other forms of uncertainty in the environment.

Plain English Explanation

In reinforcement learning, the agent learns a policy that maps states of the environment to actions. However, standard policy networks can be very sensitive to small changes in the input state, which can cause the agent to behave in unpredictable ways when deployed in the real world.

This paper proposes a method to train policy networks that are "Lipschitz-bounded", meaning the policy changes in a bounded way as the input state changes. This can be achieved by explicitly constraining the Lipschitz constant of the policy network during training.

The key benefit is that Lipschitz-bounded policies are more robust to distribution shift, adversarial perturbations, and other forms of uncertainty. For example, if the agent is deployed in a slightly different environment than what it was trained on, a Lipschitz-bounded policy will continue to behave in a stable and predictable manner, rather than catastrophically failing.

This enhanced robustness can be particularly valuable in safety-critical applications, where we want the agent to act reliably even when faced with unexpected changes or disturbances in the environment.

Technical Explanation

The authors propose a method for training reinforcement learning agents with Lipschitz-bounded policy networks. The Lipschitz constant of a function quantifies how much the function can change as the input changes. By constraining the policy network to have a small Lipschitz constant, the authors ensure that small changes in the input state result in only bounded changes in the output policy.

Specifically, the authors introduce a regularization term in the training objective that encourages the policy network to have a low Lipschitz constant. This is achieved by computing the Lipschitz constant of the policy network using techniques from Lipschitz constant estimation for general neural network architectures and Provable control sensitivity of neural networks through direct Lipschitz estimation.

The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach on a range of continuous control tasks, showing that Lipschitz-bounded policies exhibit greater robustness to distribution shift, adversarial perturbations, and other forms of uncertainty compared to standard policy networks. This is validated through experiments involving Explicit Lipschitz value estimation to enhance policy robustness, Distributionally robust policy learning with Lyapunov certificate, and other relevant baselines.

Critical Analysis

The authors provide a compelling approach for training more robust reinforcement learning agents by constraining the Lipschitz constant of the policy network. This is an important problem, as the fragility of standard policy networks is a significant limitation for their real-world deployment.

One potential limitation of the approach is the computational overhead involved in estimating the Lipschitz constant during training. The authors use techniques from prior work, but this could still add a significant burden, especially for larger and more complex policy networks.

Additionally, the authors only evaluate their method on continuous control tasks. It would be interesting to see how well the Lipschitz-bounded policies perform in other domains, such as discrete control problems or environments with sparse rewards.

Another area for further research could be investigating the trade-offs between Lipschitz-boundedness and other desirable properties of the policy, such as its expressive power or sample efficiency during training. There may be scenarios where a slightly less Lipschitz-bounded policy could offer better overall performance.

Overall, this is a well-executed piece of research that addresses an important challenge in reinforcement learning. The authors' approach of explicitly constraining the Lipschitz constant is a promising direction for building more robust and reliable reinforcement learning agents.

Conclusion

This paper presents a method for training reinforcement learning agents with Lipschitz-bounded policy networks, which can enhance the robustness of the learned policies. By constraining the Lipschitz constant of the policy network during training, the authors ensure that small changes in the input state result in only bounded changes in the output policy.

This increased robustness can be particularly valuable in safety-critical applications, where we want the agent to behave reliably even when faced with unexpected changes or disturbances in the environment. The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach through experiments on a range of continuous control tasks, showing that Lipschitz-bounded policies outperform standard policy networks in the presence of distribution shift, adversarial perturbations, and other forms of uncertainty.

While the computational overhead of Lipschitz constant estimation is a potential limitation, this research represents an important step towards building more robust and reliable reinforcement learning systems. Further exploration of the trade-offs and applications of Lipschitz-bounded policies could lead to significant advances in the field.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

On Robust Reinforcement Learning with Lipschitz-Bounded Policy Networks
Total Score

0

On Robust Reinforcement Learning with Lipschitz-Bounded Policy Networks

Nicholas H. Barbara, Ruigang Wang, Ian R. Manchester

This paper presents a study of robust policy networks in deep reinforcement learning. We investigate the benefits of policy parameterizations that naturally satisfy constraints on their Lipschitz bound, analyzing their empirical performance and robustness on two representative problems: pendulum swing-up and Atari Pong. We illustrate that policy networks with smaller Lipschitz bounds are more robust to disturbances, random noise, and targeted adversarial attacks than unconstrained policies composed of vanilla multi-layer perceptrons or convolutional neural networks. However, the structure of the Lipschitz layer is important. We find that the widely-used method of spectral normalization is too conservative and severely impacts clean performance, whereas more expressive Lipschitz layers such as the recently-proposed Sandwich layer can achieve improved robustness without sacrificing clean performance.

Read more

9/2/2024

📉

Total Score

0

Explicit Lipschitz Value Estimation Enhances Policy Robustness Against Perturbation

Xulin Chen, Ruipeng Liu, Garrett E. Katz

In robotic control tasks, policies trained by reinforcement learning (RL) in simulation often experience a performance drop when deployed on physical hardware, due to modeling error, measurement error, and unpredictable perturbations in the real world. Robust RL methods account for this issue by approximating a worst-case value function during training, but they can be sensitive to approximation errors in the value function and its gradient before training is complete. In this paper, we hypothesize that Lipschitz regularization can help condition the approximated value function gradients, leading to improved robustness after training. We test this hypothesis by combining Lipschitz regularization with an application of Fast Gradient Sign Method to reduce approximation errors when evaluating the value function under adversarial perturbations. Our empirical results demonstrate the benefits of this approach over prior work on a number of continuous control benchmarks.

Read more

5/28/2024

🚀

Total Score

0

A Recipe for Improved Certifiable Robustness

Kai Hu, Klas Leino, Zifan Wang, Matt Fredrikson

Recent studies have highlighted the potential of Lipschitz-based methods for training certifiably robust neural networks against adversarial attacks. A key challenge, supported both theoretically and empirically, is that robustness demands greater network capacity and more data than standard training. However, effectively adding capacity under stringent Lipschitz constraints has proven more difficult than it may seem, evident by the fact that state-of-the-art approach tend more towards emph{underfitting} than overfitting. Moreover, we posit that a lack of careful exploration of the design space for Lipshitz-based approaches has left potential performance gains on the table. In this work, we provide a more comprehensive evaluation to better uncover the potential of Lipschitz-based certification methods. Using a combination of novel techniques, design optimizations, and synthesis of prior work, we are able to significantly improve the state-of-the-art VRA for deterministic certification on a variety of benchmark datasets, and over a range of perturbation sizes. Of particular note, we discover that the addition of large ``Cholesky-orthogonalized residual dense'' layers to the end of existing state-of-the-art Lipschitz-controlled ResNet architectures is especially effective for increasing network capacity and performance. Combined with filtered generative data augmentation, our final results further the state of the art deterministic VRA by up to 8.5 percentage pointsfootnote{Code is available at url{https://github.com/hukkai/liresnet}}.

Read more

6/26/2024

A provable control of sensitivity of neural networks through a direct parameterization of the overall bi-Lipschitzness
Total Score

0

A provable control of sensitivity of neural networks through a direct parameterization of the overall bi-Lipschitzness

Yuri Kinoshita, Taro Toyoizumi

While neural networks can enjoy an outstanding flexibility and exhibit unprecedented performance, the mechanism behind their behavior is still not well-understood. To tackle this fundamental challenge, researchers have tried to restrict and manipulate some of their properties in order to gain new insights and better control on them. Especially, throughout the past few years, the concept of emph{bi-Lipschitzness} has been proved as a beneficial inductive bias in many areas. However, due to its complexity, the design and control of bi-Lipschitz architectures are falling behind, and a model that is precisely designed for bi-Lipschitzness realizing a direct and simple control of the constants along with solid theoretical analysis is lacking. In this work, we investigate and propose a novel framework for bi-Lipschitzness that can achieve such a clear and tight control based on convex neural networks and the Legendre-Fenchel duality. Its desirable properties are illustrated with concrete experiments. We also apply this framework to uncertainty estimation and monotone problem settings to illustrate its broad range of applications.

Read more

4/16/2024