On the Sample Efficiency of Abstractions and Potential-Based Reward Shaping in Reinforcement Learning
2404.07826
0
0
🏅
Abstract
The use of Potential Based Reward Shaping (PBRS) has shown great promise in the ongoing research effort to tackle sample inefficiency in Reinforcement Learning (RL). However, the choice of the potential function is critical for this technique to be effective. Additionally, RL techniques are usually constrained to use a finite horizon for computational limitations. This introduces a bias when using PBRS, thus adding an additional layer of complexity. In this paper, we leverage abstractions to automatically produce a good potential function. We analyse the bias induced by finite horizons in the context of PBRS producing novel insights. Finally, to asses sample efficiency and performance impact, we evaluate our approach on four environments including a goal-oriented navigation task and three Arcade Learning Environments (ALE) games demonstrating that we can reach the same level of performance as CNN-based solutions with a simple fully-connected network.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Reinforcement Learning (RL) can suffer from sample inefficiency, where the agent requires a large number of training samples to learn effectively.
- Potential Based Reward Shaping (PBRS) is a technique that can help address this issue, but the choice of the potential function is critical for its effectiveness.
- RL methods are often constrained to a finite horizon due to computational limitations, which can introduce bias when using PBRS.
- This paper proposes leveraging abstractions to automatically produce a good potential function and analyzes the bias introduced by finite horizons in the context of PBRS.
- The approach is evaluated on four environments, including a goal-oriented navigation task and three Arcade Learning Environment (ALE) games, demonstrating performance comparable to CNN-based solutions with a simple fully-connected network.
Plain English Explanation
Reinforcement Learning (RL) is a powerful technique for training artificial agents to perform tasks, but it can often be slow and inefficient, requiring the agent to try many different actions before it learns an effective strategy. Potential Based Reward Shaping (PBRS) is a method that can help address this problem by providing the agent with additional information to guide its learning process.
The key to PBRS is the potential function, which is a mathematical expression that encodes information about the task the agent is trying to learn. However, choosing the right potential function can be tricky, and if it's not done well, it can actually make the agent's learning less efficient.
Another challenge in RL is that the agents are often constrained to a finite time horizon, meaning they can only consider a certain number of future steps when making decisions. This can introduce biases that can further complicate the use of PBRS.
This paper proposes a way to automatically generate a good potential function by using abstractions, which are high-level representations of the task that capture the key elements without getting bogged down in the details. The researchers also analyze how the finite time horizon affects the use of PBRS, providing insights that can help overcome this challenge.
The researchers evaluate their approach on a variety of tasks, including a goal-oriented navigation problem and several classic video game environments. They show that their method can achieve performance comparable to more complex, CNN-based solutions using a simple, fully-connected neural network. This suggests that their approach to PBRS and time horizon handling can be an effective way to make RL more sample-efficient and practical.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a novel approach to leveraging Potential Based Reward Shaping (PBRS) to address the sample inefficiency of Reinforcement Learning (RL) agents. The key contributions are:
-
Automated Potential Function Generation: The researchers develop a method to automatically produce a good potential function by leveraging abstractions of the task. This addresses the critical challenge of choosing an effective potential function for PBRS.
-
Finite Horizon Bias Analysis: The paper provides a detailed analysis of the bias introduced when using PBRS in the context of RL techniques that are constrained to a finite horizon due to computational limitations. This yields novel insights into overcoming this challenge.
-
Empirical Evaluation: The proposed approach is evaluated on four environments, including a goal-oriented navigation task and three Arcade Learning Environment (ALE) games. The results demonstrate that the method can achieve performance comparable to more complex, CNN-based solutions using a simple, fully-connected neural network.
The researchers first introduce the concept of PBRS and explain how it can be leveraged to improve sample efficiency in RL. They then describe their approach to automatically generating a potential function by using abstractions of the task, which capture the high-level structure without getting bogged down in low-level details.
Next, the paper delves into the analysis of the bias introduced by finite horizons when using PBRS. The researchers provide a detailed mathematical treatment of this issue and offer insights into how to mitigate the negative effects.
To assess the practical impact of their contributions, the researchers evaluate their approach on four diverse environments. This includes a goal-oriented navigation task, as well as three games from the Arcade Learning Environment (ALE). The results demonstrate that their method can match the performance of more complex, CNN-based solutions using a simple, fully-connected neural network, highlighting the potential for significant improvements in sample efficiency.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to leveraging Potential Based Reward Shaping (PBRS) to address the sample inefficiency of Reinforcement Learning (RL) agents. The key strength of the work is the researchers' ability to tackle two important challenges in a principled manner:
-
Automated Potential Function Generation: The ability to automatically generate an effective potential function is a significant contribution, as the choice of the potential function is critical for the success of PBRS. By leveraging abstractions, the researchers provide a systematic way to produce a good potential function, avoiding the need for manual tuning.
-
Finite Horizon Bias Analysis: The detailed analysis of the bias introduced by finite horizons when using PBRS is a novel contribution that provides valuable insights. This is an important consideration, as RL techniques are often constrained to finite horizons due to computational limitations.
However, the paper does not address the potential scalability issues of the proposed approach. As the complexity of the task increases, the process of generating and optimizing the potential function may become more computationally demanding. Additionally, the paper does not explore the robustness of the method to variations in the task or environment, which would be important for real-world applications.
Furthermore, the paper focuses on relatively simple environments, such as the goal-oriented navigation task and ALE games. While these are valuable benchmarks, it would be informative to see how the method performs on more complex, real-world tasks that require richer sensory inputs and more sophisticated decision-making.
Overall, the paper makes valuable contributions to the field of Reinforcement Learning by proposing a principled approach to leveraging PBRS and addressing the bias introduced by finite horizons. However, further research is needed to address the scalability and robustness of the method, as well as its applicability to more complex, real-world problems.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to leveraging Potential Based Reward Shaping (PBRS) to improve the sample efficiency of Reinforcement Learning (RL) agents. The key innovations include an automated method for generating effective potential functions and a detailed analysis of the bias introduced by the finite horizons commonly used in RL due to computational constraints.
The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach through experiments on four diverse environments, including a goal-oriented navigation task and three Arcade Learning Environment (ALE) games. The results show that their method can achieve performance comparable to more complex, CNN-based solutions using a simple, fully-connected neural network, suggesting significant potential for improving sample efficiency in RL.
While the paper makes valuable contributions to the field, further research is needed to address the scalability and robustness of the approach, as well as its applicability to more complex, real-world problems. Nevertheless, this work represents an important step forward in the ongoing effort to make RL more practical and effective for a wide range of applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Efficient Reinforcement Learning via Large Language Model-based Search
Siddhant Bhambri, Amrita Bhattacharjee, Huan Liu, Subbarao Kambhampati
0
0
Reinforcement Learning (RL) suffers from sample inefficiency in sparse reward domains, and the problem is pronounced if there are stochastic transitions. To improve the sample efficiency, reward shaping is a well-studied approach to introduce intrinsic rewards that can help the RL agent converge to an optimal policy faster. However, designing a useful reward shaping function specific to each problem is challenging, even for domain experts. They would either have to rely on task-specific domain knowledge or provide an expert demonstration independently for each task. Given, that Large Language Models (LLMs) have rapidly gained prominence across a magnitude of natural language tasks, we aim to answer the following question: Can we leverage LLMs to construct a reward shaping function that can boost the sample efficiency of an RL agent? In this work, we aim to leverage off-the-shelf LLMs to generate a guide policy by solving a simpler deterministic abstraction of the original problem that can then be used to construct the reward shaping function for the downstream RL agent. Given the ineffectiveness of directly prompting LLMs, we propose MEDIC: a framework that augments LLMs with a Model-based feEDback critIC, which verifies LLM-generated outputs, to generate a possibly sub-optimal but valid plan for the abstract problem. Our experiments across domains from the BabyAI environment suite show 1) the effectiveness of augmenting LLMs with MEDIC, 2) a significant improvement in the sample complexity of PPO and A2C-based RL agents when guided by our LLM-generated plan, and finally, 3) pave the direction for further explorations of how these models can be used to augment existing RL pipelines.
5/27/2024
Efficient Preference-based Reinforcement Learning via Aligned Experience Estimation
Fengshuo Bai, Rui Zhao, Hongming Zhang, Sijia Cui, Ying Wen, Yaodong Yang, Bo Xu, Lei Han
0
0
Preference-based reinforcement learning (PbRL) has shown impressive capabilities in training agents without reward engineering. However, a notable limitation of PbRL is its dependency on substantial human feedback. This dependency stems from the learning loop, which entails accurate reward learning compounded with value/policy learning, necessitating a considerable number of samples. To boost the learning loop, we propose SEER, an efficient PbRL method that integrates label smoothing and policy regularization techniques. Label smoothing reduces overfitting of the reward model by smoothing human preference labels. Additionally, we bootstrap a conservative estimate $widehat{Q}$ using well-supported state-action pairs from the current replay memory to mitigate overestimation bias and utilize it for policy learning regularization. Our experimental results across a variety of complex tasks, both in online and offline settings, demonstrate that our approach improves feedback efficiency, outperforming state-of-the-art methods by a large margin. Ablation studies further reveal that SEER achieves a more accurate Q-function compared to prior work.
5/30/2024
New!Beyond Human Preferences: Exploring Reinforcement Learning Trajectory Evaluation and Improvement through LLMs
Zichao Shen, Tianchen Zhu, Qingyun Sun, Shiqi Gao, Jianxin Li
0
0
Reinforcement learning (RL) faces challenges in evaluating policy trajectories within intricate game tasks due to the difficulty in designing comprehensive and precise reward functions. This inherent difficulty curtails the broader application of RL within game environments characterized by diverse constraints. Preference-based reinforcement learning (PbRL) presents a pioneering framework that capitalizes on human preferences as pivotal reward signals, thereby circumventing the need for meticulous reward engineering. However, obtaining preference data from human experts is costly and inefficient, especially under conditions marked by complex constraints. To tackle this challenge, we propose a LLM-enabled automatic preference generation framework named LLM4PG , which harnesses the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) to abstract trajectories, rank preferences, and reconstruct reward functions to optimize conditioned policies. Experiments on tasks with complex language constraints demonstrated the effectiveness of our LLM-enabled reward functions, accelerating RL convergence and overcoming stagnation caused by slow or absent progress under original reward structures. This approach mitigates the reliance on specialized human knowledge and demonstrates the potential of LLMs to enhance RL's effectiveness in complex environments in the wild.
7/1/2024
🖼️
Best Response Shaping
Milad Aghajohari, Tim Cooijmans, Juan Agustin Duque, Shunichi Akatsuka, Aaron Courville
0
0
We investigate the challenge of multi-agent deep reinforcement learning in partially competitive environments, where traditional methods struggle to foster reciprocity-based cooperation. LOLA and POLA agents learn reciprocity-based cooperative policies by differentiation through a few look-ahead optimization steps of their opponent. However, there is a key limitation in these techniques. Because they consider a few optimization steps, a learning opponent that takes many steps to optimize its return may exploit them. In response, we introduce a novel approach, Best Response Shaping (BRS), which differentiates through an opponent approximating the best response, termed the detective. To condition the detective on the agent's policy for complex games we propose a state-aware differentiable conditioning mechanism, facilitated by a question answering (QA) method that extracts a representation of the agent based on its behaviour on specific environment states. To empirically validate our method, we showcase its enhanced performance against a Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) opponent, which serves as an approximation to the best response in the Coin Game. This work expands the applicability of multi-agent RL in partially competitive environments and provides a new pathway towards achieving improved social welfare in general sum games.
4/11/2024