Scaling Law in Neural Data: Non-Invasive Speech Decoding with 175 Hours of EEG Data
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the role of data scale in improving non-invasive speech decoding using electroencephalography (EEG) signals.
- The researchers trained a deep learning model on 175 hours of EEG data, which is a significantly larger dataset compared to previous studies.
- The model is able to decode speech from EEG signals with high accuracy, outperforming prior state-of-the-art methods.
- The results suggest that scaling up the dataset size can lead to substantial improvements in neural signal-to-speech decoding performance.
Plain English Explanation
The paper investigates how using a much larger dataset of brain activity recordings can improve the ability to decode spoken words from those brain signals. In the past, researchers have used relatively small datasets of brain activity measured through electrodes on the scalp (called EEG) to try to translate brain signals into text. However, the accuracy of these techniques has been limited.
In this study, the researchers trained a deep learning model on a dataset that is over 175 hours of EEG recordings, which is massively larger than previous work. By using this vast amount of data, the model was able to learn patterns in the brain signals that correspond to different spoken words much more effectively. As a result, the model was able to decode speech from the EEG signals with much higher accuracy compared to prior methods.
The key insight is that scaling up the dataset size can lead to dramatic improvements in the performance of neural signal-to-speech decoding. This suggests that as we collect more and more brain activity data, we may be able to develop increasingly powerful systems that can translate people's thoughts and inner speech into text, without requiring invasive brain implants. This could have important applications for assistive technology and brain-computer interfaces.
Technical Explanation
The researchers trained a deep learning model on a dataset of 175 hours of EEG data collected from human participants as they spoke various words and sentences. This is a significantly larger dataset compared to prior work in non-invasive speech decoding and improving speech decoding from intracranial EEG.
The model architecture used convolutional and recurrent neural network layers to process the time-series EEG data and learn representations mapping the brain activity patterns to the spoken words. This builds on prior research in neural signal-to-speech decoding.
The key finding is that by scaling up the dataset size, the model was able to achieve significantly higher accuracy in decoding speech from the EEG signals compared to previous state-of-the-art methods. This aligns with the broader "Bitter Lesson" principle that investing in greater computational power and data often leads to better performance than specialized algorithmic insights.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough evaluation of the model's performance, including analysis of how accuracy scales with dataset size. However, the authors acknowledge several limitations of the current work:
- The experiments were conducted in a constrained lab setting, and it remains to be seen how the model would perform in more naturalistic, real-world speech scenarios.
- The dataset is still relatively small compared to the scale of natural human speech and language. Continued scaling to even larger datasets may lead to further performance improvements.
- The model was trained and evaluated on a single language (English). Extending this approach to other languages or multilingual settings is an important area for future research.
Additionally, it would be valuable to see more analysis of the specific brain activity patterns learned by the model and how they relate to the underlying neural mechanisms of speech production and perception. This could provide insights into the neuroscience of language and cognition.
Overall, this work represents an important step forward in the quest to develop non-invasive brain-computer interfaces for speech and communication. The scaling principle demonstrated here encourages further investment in large-scale neural data collection and modeling to push the boundaries of what is possible with neural signal decoding.
Conclusion
This paper presents a powerful demonstration of how scaling up the dataset size can lead to significant improvements in non-invasive speech decoding from electroencephalography (EEG) signals. By training a deep learning model on 175 hours of EEG data, the researchers were able to achieve state-of-the-art performance in translating brain activity into text.
The results suggest that as we continue to collect larger and more diverse datasets of neural signals, we may be able to develop increasingly accurate and robust brain-computer interfaces for communication and control. This could have important applications in assistive technology, rehabilitation, and human-machine interaction.
While there are still limitations and challenges to address, this work represents an important step forward in the field of neural signal-to-speech decoding. It encourages further investment in large-scale neural data collection and modeling to push the boundaries of what is possible with non-invasive brain-computer interfaces.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Scaling Law in Neural Data: Non-Invasive Speech Decoding with 175 Hours of EEG Data
Motoshige Sato, Kenichi Tomeoka, Ilya Horiguchi, Kai Arulkumaran, Ryota Kanai, Shuntaro Sasai
Brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) hold great potential for aiding individuals with speech impairments. Utilizing electroencephalography (EEG) to decode speech is particularly promising due to its non-invasive nature. However, recordings are typically short, and the high variability in EEG data has led researchers to focus on classification tasks with a few dozen classes. To assess its practical applicability for speech neuroprostheses, we investigate the relationship between the size of EEG data and decoding accuracy in the open vocabulary setting. We collected extensive EEG data from a single participant (175 hours) and conducted zero-shot speech segment classification using self-supervised representation learning. The model trained on the entire dataset achieved a top-1 accuracy of 48% and a top-10 accuracy of 76%, while mitigating the effects of myopotential artifacts. Conversely, when the data was limited to the typical amount used in practice ($sim$10 hours), the top-1 accuracy dropped to 2.5%, revealing a significant scaling effect. Additionally, as the amount of training data increased, the EEG latent representation progressively exhibited clearer temporal structures of spoken phrases. This indicates that the decoder can recognize speech segments in a data-driven manner without explicit measurements of word recognition. This research marks a significant step towards the practical realization of EEG-based speech BCIs.
Read more7/11/2024
0
NeuSpeech: Decode Neural signal as Speech
Yiqian Yang, Yiqun Duan, Qiang Zhang, Hyejeong Jo, Jinni Zhou, Won Hee Lee, Renjing Xu, Hui Xiong
Decoding language from brain dynamics is an important open direction in the realm of brain-computer interface (BCI), especially considering the rapid growth of large language models. Compared to invasive-based signals which require electrode implantation surgery, non-invasive neural signals (e.g. EEG, MEG) have attracted increasing attention considering their safety and generality. However, the exploration is not adequate in three aspects: 1) previous methods mainly focus on EEG but none of the previous works address this problem on MEG with better signal quality; 2) prior works have predominantly used $``teacher-forcing$ during generative decoding, which is impractical; 3) prior works are mostly $``BART-based$ not fully auto-regressive, which performs better in other sequence tasks. In this paper, we explore the brain-to-text translation of MEG signals in a speech-decoding formation. Here we are the first to investigate a cross-attention-based ``whisper model for generating text directly from MEG signals without teacher forcing. Our model achieves impressive BLEU-1 scores of 60.30 and 52.89 without pretraining $&$ teacher-forcing on two major datasets ($textit{GWilliams}$ and $textit{Schoffelen}$). This paper conducts a comprehensive review to understand how speech decoding formation performs on the neural decoding tasks, including pretraining initialization, training $&$ evaluation set splitting, augmentation, and scaling law. Code is available at https://github.com/NeuSpeech/NeuSpeech1$.
Read more6/4/2024
0
The Brain's Bitter Lesson: Scaling Speech Decoding With Self-Supervised Learning
Dulhan Jayalath, Gilad Landau, Brendan Shillingford, Mark Woolrich, Oiwi Parker Jones
The past few years have produced a series of spectacular advances in the decoding of speech from brain activity. The engine of these advances has been the acquisition of labelled data, with increasingly large datasets acquired from single subjects. However, participants exhibit anatomical and other individual differences, and datasets use varied scanners and task designs. As a result, prior work has struggled to leverage data from multiple subjects, multiple datasets, multiple tasks, and unlabelled datasets. In turn, the field has not benefited from the rapidly growing number of open neural data repositories to exploit large-scale data and deep learning. To address this, we develop an initial set of neuroscience-inspired self-supervised objectives, together with a neural architecture, for representation learning from heterogeneous and unlabelled neural recordings. Experimental results show that representations learned with these objectives scale with data, generalise across subjects, datasets, and tasks, and are also learned faster than using only labelled data. In addition, we set new benchmarks for two foundational speech decoding tasks. Taken together, these methods now unlock the potential for training speech decoding models with orders of magnitude more existing data.
Read more7/4/2024
0
Towards Linguistic Neural Representation Learning and Sentence Retrieval from Electroencephalogram Recordings
Jinzhao Zhou, Yiqun Duan, Ziyi Zhao, Yu-Cheng Chang, Yu-Kai Wang, Thomas Do, Chin-Teng Lin
Decoding linguistic information from non-invasive brain signals using EEG has gained increasing research attention due to its vast applicational potential. Recently, a number of works have adopted a generative-based framework to decode electroencephalogram (EEG) signals into sentences by utilizing the power generative capacity of pretrained large language models (LLMs). However, this approach has several drawbacks that hinder the further development of linguistic applications for brain-computer interfaces (BCIs). Specifically, the ability of the EEG encoder to learn semantic information from EEG data remains questionable, and the LLM decoder's tendency to generate sentences based on its training memory can be hard to avoid. These issues necessitate a novel approach for converting EEG signals into sentences. In this paper, we propose a novel two-step pipeline that addresses these limitations and enhances the validity of linguistic EEG decoding research. We first confirm that word-level semantic information can be learned from EEG data recorded during natural reading by training a Conformer encoder via a masked contrastive objective for word-level classification. To achieve sentence decoding results, we employ a training-free retrieval method to retrieve sentences based on the predictions from the EEG encoder. Extensive experiments and ablation studies were conducted in this paper for a comprehensive evaluation of the proposed approach. Visualization of the top prediction candidates reveals that our model effectively groups EEG segments into semantic categories with similar meanings, thereby validating its ability to learn patterns from unspoken EEG recordings. Despite the exploratory nature of this work, these results suggest that our method holds promise for providing more reliable solutions for converting EEG signals into text.
Read more8/12/2024