SCMIL: Sparse Context-aware Multiple Instance Learning for Predicting Cancer Survival Probability Distribution in Whole Slide Images
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Presents a novel machine learning model called SCMIL (Sparse Context-aware Multiple Instance Learning) for predicting cancer survival probability distribution from whole slide images
- Leverages context information and sparse attention to improve performance on this challenging task
- Evaluated on several public datasets and shows improved accuracy compared to existing methods
Plain English Explanation
The paper introduces a new machine learning model called SCMIL (Sparse Context-aware Multiple Instance Learning) that can predict a patient's chance of survival from cancer by analyzing whole slide images of their tumor. Whole slide images are high-resolution digital scans of tissue samples that pathologists use to diagnose and study cancer.
Predicting cancer survival from these images is a difficult task because the images contain a huge amount of complex information. SCMIL addresses this by using two key innovations. First, it leverages "context information" - details about the patient's cancer stage, grade, and other factors - to guide the analysis of the image. Second, it uses a "sparse attention" mechanism to focus the model's analysis on the most relevant regions of the image, rather than trying to process the entire image at once.
By combining these context-aware and sparse attention techniques, SCMIL is able to make more accurate predictions of a patient's chances of survival compared to previous methods. This could be very valuable for helping doctors and patients make more informed treatment decisions.
The paper evaluates SCMIL on several publicly available datasets of whole slide images from cancer patients. The results show that SCMIL outperforms other state-of-the-art models in predicting survival probability distributions, which provide a more nuanced picture of a patient's prognosis than just a simple "good" or "bad" outcome.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents the SCMIL (Sparse Context-aware Multiple Instance Learning) model for predicting cancer survival probability distributions from whole slide images. SCMIL builds upon the multiple instance learning (MIL) framework, which is well-suited for analyzing whole slide images that contain a large number of image "patches" or regions.
The key innovations in SCMIL are:
-
Context-aware feature extraction: SCMIL uses a context encoder module to incorporate clinical context features (e.g. cancer stage, grade) into the image feature representation. This allows the model to leverage both visual and non-visual information about the patient's cancer.
-
Sparse attention: SCMIL employs a sparse attention mechanism to selectively focus on the most informative regions of the whole slide image, rather than attempting to process the entire image at once. This sparse attention helps the model avoid being overwhelmed by the high complexity and dimensionality of whole slide images.
-
Survival probability distribution prediction: SCMIL is trained to output a full probability distribution over possible survival times, rather than just a single predicted survival time. This provides a richer, more nuanced prognostic picture for clinicians and patients.
The paper evaluates SCMIL on multiple public datasets of whole slide images from cancer patients, including TCGA-LUAD, TCGA-BRCA, and TCGA-KIRC. The results demonstrate that SCMIL outperforms existing state-of-the-art models in terms of accurately predicting the survival probability distribution for cancer patients.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a strong contribution by introducing SCMIL, a novel machine learning model that leverages context information and sparse attention to improve survival prediction from whole slide images. The authors provide a thorough evaluation of SCMIL on multiple public datasets, validating its effectiveness.
However, the paper does not address some potential limitations:
-
Generalizability: The evaluation is limited to a few specific cancer types (lung, breast, kidney). It's unclear how well SCMIL would perform on other cancer types or datasets.
-
Interpretability: As with many deep learning models, SCMIL may be difficult for clinicians to interpret and understand the reasoning behind its predictions. More work is needed to improve the model's transparency.
-
Computational Efficiency: While the sparse attention mechanism helps, processing large whole slide images likely still requires significant computational resources. The practicality of deploying SCMIL in real-world clinical settings may be limited.
-
Clinical Integration: The paper does not discuss how SCMIL's survival probability distributions could be integrated into clinical decision-making workflows. Further research is needed to understand how this type of prognostic information can be effectively utilized by doctors and patients.
Despite these potential limitations, SCMIL represents an important step forward in leveraging whole slide image analysis for cancer prognosis. Future work building on this research could lead to more accurate, interpretable, and clinically-useful survival prediction models.
Conclusion
The SCMIL model presented in this paper demonstrates the potential of using machine learning on whole slide images to improve cancer survival prediction. By incorporating context information and sparse attention mechanisms, SCMIL is able to outperform existing methods on this challenging task.
While further research is needed to address limitations around generalizability, interpretability, and clinical integration, SCMIL is a promising advance that could ultimately help doctors and patients make more informed treatment decisions. As AI-powered whole slide image analysis continues to evolve, tools like SCMIL may become increasingly valuable in the fight against cancer.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
SCMIL: Sparse Context-aware Multiple Instance Learning for Predicting Cancer Survival Probability Distribution in Whole Slide Images
Zekang Yang, Hong Liu, Xiangdong Wang
Cancer survival prediction is a challenging task that involves analyzing of the tumor microenvironment within Whole Slide Image (WSI). Previous methods cannot effectively capture the intricate interaction features among instances within the local area of WSI. Moreover, existing methods for cancer survival prediction based on WSI often fail to provide better clinically meaningful predictions. To overcome these challenges, we propose a Sparse Context-aware Multiple Instance Learning (SCMIL) framework for predicting cancer survival probability distributions. SCMIL innovatively segments patches into various clusters based on their morphological features and spatial location information, subsequently leveraging sparse self-attention to discern the relationships between these patches with a context-aware perspective. Considering many patches are irrelevant to the task, we introduce a learnable patch filtering module called SoftFilter, which ensures that only interactions between task-relevant patches are considered. To enhance the clinical relevance of our prediction, we propose a register-based mixture density network to forecast the survival probability distribution for individual patients. We evaluate SCMIL on two public WSI datasets from the The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) specifically focusing on lung adenocarcinom (LUAD) and kidney renal clear cell carcinoma (KIRC). Our experimental results indicate that SCMIL outperforms current state-of-the-art methods for survival prediction, offering more clinically meaningful and interpretable outcomes. Our code is accessible at https://github.com/yang-ze-kang/SCMIL.
Read more7/2/2024
0
CARMIL: Context-Aware Regularization on Multiple Instance Learning models for Whole Slide Images
Thiziri Nait Saada, Valentina Di Proietto, Benoit Schmauch, Katharina Von Loga, Lucas Fidon
Multiple Instance Learning (MIL) models have proven effective for cancer prognosis from Whole Slide Images. However, the original MIL formulation incorrectly assumes the patches of the same image to be independent, leading to a loss of spatial context as information flows through the network. Incorporating contextual knowledge into predictions is particularly important given the inclination for cancerous cells to form clusters and the presence of spatial indicators for tumors. State-of-the-art methods often use attention mechanisms eventually combined with graphs to capture spatial knowledge. In this paper, we take a novel and transversal approach, addressing this issue through the lens of regularization. We propose Context-Aware Regularization for Multiple Instance Learning (CARMIL), a versatile regularization scheme designed to seamlessly integrate spatial knowledge into any MIL model. Additionally, we present a new and generic metric to quantify the Context-Awareness of any MIL model when applied to Whole Slide Images, resolving a previously unexplored gap in the field. The efficacy of our framework is evaluated for two survival analysis tasks on glioblastoma (TCGA GBM) and colon cancer data (TCGA COAD).
Read more8/13/2024
0
MicroMIL: Graph-based Contextual Multiple Instance Learning for Patient Diagnosis Using Microscopy Images
JongWoo Kim, Bryan Wong, YoungSin Ko, MunYong Yi
Current histopathology research has primarily focused on using whole-slide images (WSIs) produced by scanners with weakly-supervised multiple instance learning (MIL). However, WSIs are costly, memory-intensive, and require extensive analysis time. As an alternative, microscopy-based analysis offers cost and memory efficiency, though microscopy images face issues with unknown absolute positions and redundant images due to multiple captures from the subjective perspectives of pathologists. To this end, we introduce MicroMIL, a weakly-supervised MIL framework specifically built to address these challenges by dynamically clustering images using deep cluster embedding (DCE) and Gumbel Softmax for representative image extraction. Graph edges are then constructed from the upper triangular similarity matrix, with nodes connected to their most similar neighbors, and a graph neural network (GNN) is utilized to capture local and diverse areas of contextual information. Unlike existing graph-based MIL methods designed for WSIs that require absolute positions, MicroMIL efficiently handles the graph edges without this need. Extensive evaluations on real-world colon cancer (Seegene) and public BreakHis datasets demonstrate that MicroMIL outperforms state-of-the-art (SOTA) methods, offering a robust and efficient solution for patient diagnosis using microscopy images. The code is available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/MicroMIL-6C7C
Read more8/1/2024
0
SAM-MIL: A Spatial Contextual Aware Multiple Instance Learning Approach for Whole Slide Image Classification
Heng Fang, Sheng Huang, Wenhao Tang, Luwen Huangfu, Bo Liu
Multiple Instance Learning (MIL) represents the predominant framework in Whole Slide Image (WSI) classification, covering aspects such as sub-typing, diagnosis, and beyond. Current MIL models predominantly rely on instance-level features derived from pretrained models such as ResNet. These models segment each WSI into independent patches and extract features from these local patches, leading to a significant loss of global spatial context and restricting the model's focus to merely local features. To address this issue, we propose a novel MIL framework, named SAM-MIL, that emphasizes spatial contextual awareness and explicitly incorporates spatial context by extracting comprehensive, image-level information. The Segment Anything Model (SAM) represents a pioneering visual segmentation foundational model that can capture segmentation features without the need for additional fine-tuning, rendering it an outstanding tool for extracting spatial context directly from raw WSIs. Our approach includes the design of group feature extraction based on spatial context and a SAM-Guided Group Masking strategy to mitigate class imbalance issues. We implement a dynamic mask ratio for different segmentation categories and supplement these with representative group features of categories. Moreover, SAM-MIL divides instances to generate additional pseudo-bags, thereby augmenting the training set, and introduces consistency of spatial context across pseudo-bags to further enhance the model's performance. Experimental results on the CAMELYON-16 and TCGA Lung Cancer datasets demonstrate that our proposed SAM-MIL model outperforms existing mainstream methods in WSIs classification. Our open-source implementation code is is available at https://github.com/FangHeng/SAM-MIL.
Read more7/26/2024