Search-Based LLMs for Code Optimization

Read original: arXiv:2408.12159 - Published 8/23/2024 by Shuzheng Gao, Cuiyun Gao, Wenchao Gu, Michael Lyu

Overview

This paper explores the use of search-based large language models (LLMs) for code optimization.
The proposed framework combines LLMs with search algorithms to generate and evaluate candidate code optimizations.
Experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach in improving the performance of various benchmark programs.

Plain English Explanation

The paper discusses a new way to optimize computer programs using a combination of large language models and search algorithms. Large language models are AI systems that can understand and generate human-like text, including code. Search algorithms are techniques for systematically exploring a set of possible solutions to find the best one.

The researchers developed a framework that uses a large language model to suggest potential code optimizations, and then a search algorithm to evaluate and refine those suggestions. This allows the system to both be creative in generating new optimization ideas, and also carefully evaluate them to find the most effective changes.

Through experiments on various benchmark programs, the authors show that this combined approach can significantly improve the performance of the code, making it run faster or use less memory. This could be useful in a wide range of software development and optimization tasks.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a search-based framework for code optimization that leverages large language models (LLMs). The key components of the framework are:

LLM Code Optimizer: This module uses an LLM to generate candidate code optimization suggestions based on the input program.
Search Algorithm: A search algorithm, such as genetic algorithms or reinforcement learning, is used to explore the space of candidate optimizations and evaluate their impact on program performance.
Performance Evaluation: The framework includes a performance evaluation module that can measure the impact of a given optimization on metrics like runtime, memory usage, or energy consumption.

The paper evaluates this framework on a set of benchmark programs and demonstrates significant performance improvements over baseline optimization techniques. For example, the search-based LLM approach was able to achieve up to 2.5x speedups on certain benchmarks compared to traditional compiler optimizations.

The authors also discuss the tradeoffs and limitations of this approach, such as the computational overhead of the search process and the need for careful hyperparameter tuning. They suggest areas for future research, including incorporating more domain-specific knowledge into the LLM and exploring reinforcement learning techniques for the search component.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and promising approach to code optimization that combines the creativity of large language models with the systematic exploration of search algorithms. This could be a valuable tool for software developers and system engineers looking to improve the performance of their applications.

One potential limitation of the approach is the computational overhead of the search process, which may limit its applicability to large, complex programs. The authors acknowledge this issue and suggest ways to address it, such as using more efficient search algorithms or integrating domain-specific knowledge into the LLM.

Additionally, the paper does not explore the generalizability of the approach across different programming languages or application domains. Further research would be needed to understand how well the framework would perform on a broader range of code optimization problems.

Another area for further investigation is the interpretability and explainability of the optimization suggestions generated by the LLM. Understanding the reasoning behind the proposed optimizations could help developers trust and integrate the system more effectively.

Overall, this paper represents an important step towards leveraging the power of large language models for practical code optimization tasks. The proposed framework shows promise, and the critical analysis suggests several directions for future research to address its limitations and expand its capabilities.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel search-based framework that combines large language models and search algorithms to generate and evaluate code optimizations. The experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach in improving the performance of various benchmark programs, with significant speedups compared to traditional optimization techniques.

The research highlights the potential of integrating advanced AI techniques, such as large language models and search algorithms, into software development and optimization workflows. As the capabilities of these technologies continue to evolve, we may see increasing adoption of such hybrid approaches to tackle complex software engineering challenges.

The critical analysis identifies several areas for further research, including addressing computational overhead, exploring generalizability, and improving the interpretability of the optimization suggestions. Addressing these challenges could help unlock the full potential of search-based LLM approaches for code optimization and other software engineering tasks.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Search-Based LLMs for Code Optimization

Shuzheng Gao, Cuiyun Gao, Wenchao Gu, Michael Lyu

The code written by developers usually suffers from efficiency problems and contain various performance bugs. These inefficiencies necessitate the research of automated refactoring methods for code optimization. Early research in code optimization employs rule-based methods and focuses on specific inefficiency issues, which are labor-intensive and suffer from the low coverage issue. Recent work regards the task as a sequence generation problem, and resorts to deep learning (DL) techniques such as large language models (LLMs). These methods typically prompt LLMs to directly generate optimized code. Although these methods show state-of-the-art performance, such one-step generation paradigm is hard to achieve an optimal solution. First, complex optimization methods such as combinatorial ones are hard to be captured by LLMs. Second, the one-step generation paradigm poses challenge in precisely infusing the knowledge required for effective code optimization within LLMs, resulting in under-optimized code.To address these problems, we propose to model this task from the search perspective, and propose a search-based LLMs framework named SBLLM that enables iterative refinement and discovery of improved optimization methods. SBLLM synergistically integrate LLMs with evolutionary search and consists of three key components: 1) an execution-based representative sample selection part that evaluates the fitness of each existing optimized code and prioritizes promising ones to pilot the generation of improved code; 2) an adaptive optimization pattern retrieval part that infuses targeted optimization patterns into the model for guiding LLMs towards rectifying and progressively enhancing their optimization methods; and 3) a genetic operator-inspired chain-of-thought prompting part that aids LLMs in combining different optimization methods and generating improved optimization methods.

8/23/2024

➖

Performance-Aligned LLMs for Generating Fast Code

Daniel Nichols, Pranav Polasam, Harshitha Menon, Aniruddha Marathe, Todd Gamblin, Abhinav Bhatele

Optimizing scientific software is a difficult task because codebases are often large and complex, and performance can depend upon several factors including the algorithm, its implementation, and hardware among others. Causes of poor performance can originate from disparate sources and be difficult to diagnose. Recent years have seen a multitude of work that use large language models (LLMs) to assist in software development tasks. However, these tools are trained to model the distribution of code as text, and are not specifically designed to understand performance aspects of code. In this work, we introduce a reinforcement learning based methodology to align the outputs of code LLMs with performance. This allows us to build upon the current code modeling capabilities of LLMs and extend them to generate better performing code. We demonstrate that our fine-tuned model improves the expected speedup of generated code over base models for a set of benchmark tasks from 0.9 to 1.6 for serial code and 1.9 to 4.5 for OpenMP code.

4/30/2024

A Survey on Large Language Models for Code Generation

Juyong Jiang, Fan Wang, Jiasi Shen, Sungju Kim, Sunghun Kim

Large Language Models (LLMs) have garnered remarkable advancements across diverse code-related tasks, known as Code LLMs, particularly in code generation that generates source code with LLM from natural language descriptions. This burgeoning field has captured significant interest from both academic researchers and industry professionals due to its practical significance in software development, e.g., GitHub Copilot. Despite the active exploration of LLMs for a variety of code tasks, either from the perspective of natural language processing (NLP) or software engineering (SE) or both, there is a noticeable absence of a comprehensive and up-to-date literature review dedicated to LLM for code generation. In this survey, we aim to bridge this gap by providing a systematic literature review that serves as a valuable reference for researchers investigating the cutting-edge progress in LLMs for code generation. We introduce a taxonomy to categorize and discuss the recent developments in LLMs for code generation, covering aspects such as data curation, latest advances, performance evaluation, and real-world applications. In addition, we present a historical overview of the evolution of LLMs for code generation and offer an empirical comparison using the widely recognized HumanEval and MBPP benchmarks to highlight the progressive enhancements in LLM capabilities for code generation. We identify critical challenges and promising opportunities regarding the gap between academia and practical development. Furthermore, we have established a dedicated resource website (https://codellm.github.io) to continuously document and disseminate the most recent advances in the field.

6/4/2024

When Large Language Model Meets Optimization

Sen Huang, Kaixiang Yang, Sheng Qi, Rui Wang

Optimization algorithms and large language models (LLMs) enhance decision-making in dynamic environments by integrating artificial intelligence with traditional techniques. LLMs, with extensive domain knowledge, facilitate intelligent modeling and strategic decision-making in optimization, while optimization algorithms refine LLM architectures and output quality. This synergy offers novel approaches for advancing general AI, addressing both the computational challenges of complex problems and the application of LLMs in practical scenarios. This review outlines the progress and potential of combining LLMs with optimization algorithms, providing insights for future research directions.

5/17/2024