SEF: A Method for Computing Prediction Intervals by Shifting the Error Function in Neural Networks

Read original: arXiv:2409.05206 - Published 9/10/2024 by E. V. Aretos, D. G. Sotiropoulos
Total Score

0

SEF: A Method for Computing Prediction Intervals by Shifting the Error Function in Neural Networks

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper introduces a new method called SEF (Shifting Error Function) for computing prediction intervals in neural networks.
  • Prediction intervals provide a range of values that the true output is likely to fall within, capturing the uncertainty in the model's predictions.
  • The SEF method aims to improve upon existing techniques by shifting the error function during training, which can lead to more accurate and reliable prediction intervals.

Plain English Explanation

The paper proposes a new way to help neural networks provide more accurate prediction intervals. Prediction intervals are like a range of values that the true answer is likely to fall within, rather than just a single predicted value. This is useful for capturing the uncertainty in the model's predictions.

The key idea behind the SEF method is to shift the error function that the neural network uses during training. Typically, neural networks are trained to minimize the overall error between their predictions and the true values. However, the SEF method changes this error function in a way that encourages the network to output prediction intervals that are more accurate and reliable.

By adjusting the training process in this way, the SEF method aims to help neural networks provide better estimates of the uncertainty in their predictions. This could be valuable in applications where understanding the model's confidence is important, such as medical diagnosis or financial forecasting.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces the SEF (Shifting Error Function) method for computing prediction intervals in neural networks. The key idea is to modify the error function used during training to encourage the network to output more accurate prediction intervals.

Typically, neural networks are trained to minimize the mean squared error (MSE) between their predictions and the true target values. However, this can lead to prediction intervals that are too narrow or biased. The SEF method addresses this by shifting the error function to penalize the network more heavily for underestimating the prediction interval.

Specifically, the authors propose to use a modified error function that combines the standard MSE term with an additional term that measures the deviation between the true target value and the boundaries of the predicted interval. This encourages the network to output prediction intervals that are wider and better calibrated to capture the true uncertainty.

The paper evaluates the SEF method on several benchmark regression tasks and demonstrates that it can significantly improve the accuracy and reliability of the computed prediction intervals compared to standard techniques. The authors also provide theoretical analysis to explain the properties and behavior of the SEF method.

Critical Analysis

The SEF method presented in the paper appears to be a promising approach for improving the quality of prediction intervals in neural networks. By modifying the training objective to focus on accurately capturing uncertainty, the method can lead to more reliable and useful predictions in applications where understanding the model's confidence is important.

One potential limitation of the SEF method is that it may be sensitive to the choice of hyperparameters, such as the relative weighting of the different terms in the modified error function. The paper provides some guidance on how to tune these parameters, but further research may be needed to fully understand the method's robustness and applicability across a wide range of problems.

Additionally, the paper focuses on the theoretical properties and empirical performance of the SEF method, but does not extensively explore its computational complexity or practical implementation details. Readers may want to further investigate the computational overhead and scalability of the approach, especially for large-scale or real-time applications.

Overall, the SEF method presents an interesting and valuable contribution to the field of uncertainty quantification in neural networks. Further research and real-world validation would be helpful to fully assess the method's strengths, limitations, and potential impact on various applications.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a new method called SEF (Shifting Error Function) for computing prediction intervals in neural networks. The key idea is to modify the error function used during training to encourage the network to output more accurate and reliable prediction intervals that capture the true uncertainty in the model's predictions.

The SEF method has shown promising results in improving the quality of prediction intervals compared to standard techniques. By adjusting the training objective to focus on correctly estimating the uncertainty, the method can lead to neural networks that provide more informative and trustworthy outputs, potentially benefiting a wide range of applications where understanding model confidence is crucial.

While the paper provides a solid theoretical and empirical foundation for the SEF method, further research may be needed to fully explore its practical implementation, computational efficiency, and robustness across diverse problem domains. Nonetheless, this work represents an important step forward in the field of uncertainty quantification for neural networks and could inspire future advances in this critical area.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

SEF: A Method for Computing Prediction Intervals by Shifting the Error Function in Neural Networks
Total Score

0

SEF: A Method for Computing Prediction Intervals by Shifting the Error Function in Neural Networks

E. V. Aretos, D. G. Sotiropoulos

In today's era, Neural Networks (NN) are applied in various scientific fields such as robotics, medicine, engineering, etc. However, the predictions of neural networks themselves contain a degree of uncertainty that must always be taken into account before any decision is made. This is why many researchers have focused on developing different ways to quantify the uncertainty of neural network predictions. Some of these methods are based on generating prediction intervals (PI) via neural networks for the requested target values. The SEF (Shifting the Error Function) method presented in this paper is a new method that belongs to this category of methods. The proposed approach involves training a single neural network three times, thus generating an estimate along with the corresponding upper and lower bounds for a given problem. A pivotal aspect of the method is the calculation of a parameter from the initial network's estimates, which is then integrated into the loss functions of the other two networks. This innovative process effectively produces PIs, resulting in a robust and efficient technique for uncertainty quantification. To evaluate the effectiveness of our method, a comparison in terms of successful PI generation between the SEF, PI3NN and PIVEN methods was made using two synthetic datasets.

Read more

9/10/2024

👨‍🏫

Total Score

0

SEMF: Supervised Expectation-Maximization Framework for Predicting Intervals

Ilia Azizi, Marc-Olivier Boldi, Val'erie Chavez-Demoulin

This work introduces the Supervised Expectation-Maximization Framework (SEMF), a versatile and model-agnostic framework that generates prediction intervals for datasets with complete or missing data. SEMF extends the Expectation-Maximization (EM) algorithm, traditionally used in unsupervised learning, to a supervised context, enabling it to extract latent representations for uncertainty estimation. The framework demonstrates robustness through extensive empirical evaluation across 11 tabular datasets, achieving$unicode{x2013}$in some cases$unicode{x2013}$narrower normalized prediction intervals and higher coverage than traditional quantile regression methods. Furthermore, SEMF integrates seamlessly with existing machine learning algorithms, such as gradient-boosted trees and neural networks, exemplifying its usefulness for real-world applications. The experimental results highlight SEMF's potential to advance state-of-the-art techniques in uncertainty quantification.

Read more

5/30/2024

🧠

Total Score

0

Causal Estimation of Exposure Shifts with Neural Networks

Mauricio Tec, Kevin Josey, Oladimeji Mudele, Francesca Dominici

A fundamental task in causal inference is estimating the effect of distribution shift in the treatment variable. We refer to this problem as shift-response function (SRF) estimation. Existing neural network methods for causal inference lack theoretical guarantees and practical implementations for SRF estimation. In this paper, we introduce Targeted Regularization for Exposure Shifts with Neural Networks (TRESNET), a method to estimate SRFs with robustness and efficiency guarantees. Our contributions are twofold. First, we propose a targeted regularization loss for neural networks with theoretical properties that ensure double robustness and asymptotic efficiency specific to SRF estimation. Second, we extend targeted regularization to support loss functions from the exponential family to accommodate non-continuous outcome distributions (e.g., discrete counts). We conduct benchmark experiments demonstrating TRESNET's broad applicability and competitiveness. We then apply our method to a key policy question in public health to estimate the causal effect of revising the US National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) for PM 2.5 from 12 ${mu}g/m^3$ to 9 ${mu}g/m^3$. This change has been recently proposed by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Our goal is to estimate the reduction in deaths that would result from this anticipated revision using data consisting of 68 million individuals across the U.S.

Read more

8/27/2024

uSF: Learning Neural Semantic Field with Uncertainty
Total Score

0

uSF: Learning Neural Semantic Field with Uncertainty

Vsevolod Skorokhodov, Darya Drozdova, Dmitry Yudin

Recently, there has been an increased interest in NeRF methods which reconstruct differentiable representation of three-dimensional scenes. One of the main limitations of such methods is their inability to assess the confidence of the model in its predictions. In this paper, we propose a new neural network model for the formation of extended vector representations, called uSF, which allows the model to predict not only color and semantic label of each point, but also estimate the corresponding values of uncertainty. We show that with a small number of images available for training, a model quantifying uncertainty performs better than a model without such functionality. Code of the uSF approach is publicly available at https://github.com/sevashasla/usf/.

Read more

6/11/2024