Causal Estimation of Exposure Shifts with Neural Networks
0
🧠
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Causal inference is a fundamental task in machine learning.
- One specific problem is estimating the effect of distribution shift in the treatment variable, known as shift-response function (SRF) estimation.
- Existing neural network methods lack theoretical guarantees and practical implementations for SRF estimation.
Plain English Explanation
Causal inference is the process of understanding how changes in one variable affect changes in another variable. This is an important problem in machine learning, with many real-world applications.
One specific causal inference task is estimating the effect of a shift in the distribution of the treatment variable. For example, if a new policy changes the distribution of a treatment (like a medication or an environmental intervention), we want to know how that will affect the outcome (like health or mortality). This problem is known as shift-response function (SRF) estimation.
Unfortunately, existing neural network methods for causal inference lack the theoretical guarantees and practical implementations needed to reliably estimate SRFs. This paper introduces a new method called TRESNET that addresses these limitations.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a new method called Targeted Regularization for Exposure Shifts with Neural Networks (TRESNET) for estimating SRFs. TRESNET has two key contributions:
-
Targeted Regularization Loss: The authors develop a new regularization loss function for neural networks that provides theoretical guarantees of double robustness and asymptotic efficiency specifically for SRF estimation.
-
Exponential Family Support: TRESNET extends the targeted regularization approach to support loss functions from the exponential family, allowing it to handle non-continuous outcome distributions (e.g., discrete counts).
The paper demonstrates TRESNET's broad applicability and competitiveness through benchmark experiments. It then applies the method to estimate the causal effect of revising the US National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) for PM 2.5 from 12 μg/m^3 to 9 μg/m^3, using data on 68 million individuals across the U.S.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough technical explanation of the TRESNET method and its theoretical properties. The authors carefully address the limitations of existing neural network approaches for causal inference and SRF estimation.
One potential concern is the reliance on certain assumptions, such as the availability of data on the full distribution of the treatment variable. In real-world settings, this information may not always be accessible, which could limit the practical applicability of the method.
Additionally, while the paper demonstrates TRESNET's performance on benchmark datasets, further validation on diverse, real-world datasets would help establish its robustness and generalizability.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel method, TRESNET, for estimating shift-response functions (SRFs) in causal inference problems. The key innovations are a targeted regularization loss function with strong theoretical guarantees, as well as the ability to handle non-continuous outcome distributions.
The work addresses an important gap in the field of causal inference, providing a principled approach to a challenging problem. If successful, TRESNET could have significant implications for policy decisions and interventions in fields like public health, where understanding the causal impact of distribution shifts is crucial.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🧠
0
Causal Estimation of Exposure Shifts with Neural Networks
Mauricio Tec, Kevin Josey, Oladimeji Mudele, Francesca Dominici
A fundamental task in causal inference is estimating the effect of distribution shift in the treatment variable. We refer to this problem as shift-response function (SRF) estimation. Existing neural network methods for causal inference lack theoretical guarantees and practical implementations for SRF estimation. In this paper, we introduce Targeted Regularization for Exposure Shifts with Neural Networks (TRESNET), a method to estimate SRFs with robustness and efficiency guarantees. Our contributions are twofold. First, we propose a targeted regularization loss for neural networks with theoretical properties that ensure double robustness and asymptotic efficiency specific to SRF estimation. Second, we extend targeted regularization to support loss functions from the exponential family to accommodate non-continuous outcome distributions (e.g., discrete counts). We conduct benchmark experiments demonstrating TRESNET's broad applicability and competitiveness. We then apply our method to a key policy question in public health to estimate the causal effect of revising the US National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) for PM 2.5 from 12 ${mu}g/m^3$ to 9 ${mu}g/m^3$. This change has been recently proposed by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Our goal is to estimate the reduction in deaths that would result from this anticipated revision using data consisting of 68 million individuals across the U.S.
Read more8/27/2024
0
Uplift Modeling Under Limited Supervision
George Panagopoulos, Daniele Malitesta, Fragkiskos D. Malliaros, Jun Pang
Estimating causal effects in e-commerce tends to involve costly treatment assignments which can be impractical in large-scale settings. Leveraging machine learning to predict such treatment effects without actual intervention is a standard practice to diminish the risk. However, existing methods for treatment effect prediction tend to rely on training sets of substantial size, which are built from real experiments and are thus inherently risky to create. In this work we propose a graph neural network to diminish the required training set size, relying on graphs that are common in e-commerce data. Specifically, we view the problem as node regression with a restricted number of labeled instances, develop a two-model neural architecture akin to previous causal effect estimators, and test varying message-passing layers for encoding. Furthermore, as an extra step, we combine the model with an acquisition function to guide the creation of the training set in settings with extremely low experimental budget. The framework is flexible since each step can be used separately with other models or treatment policies. The experiments on real large-scale networks indicate a clear advantage of our methodology over the state of the art, which in many cases performs close to random, underlining the need for models that can generalize with limited supervision to reduce experimental risks.
Read more9/4/2024
0
Doubly Robust Causal Effect Estimation under Networked Interference via Targeted Learning
Weilin Chen, Ruichu Cai, Zeqin Yang, Jie Qiao, Yuguang Yan, Zijian Li, Zhifeng Hao
Causal effect estimation under networked interference is an important but challenging problem. Available parametric methods are limited in their model space, while previous semiparametric methods, e.g., leveraging neural networks to fit only one single nuisance function, may still encounter misspecification problems under networked interference without appropriate assumptions on the data generation process. To mitigate bias stemming from misspecification, we propose a novel doubly robust causal effect estimator under networked interference, by adapting the targeted learning technique to the training of neural networks. Specifically, we generalize the targeted learning technique into the networked interference setting and establish the condition under which an estimator achieves double robustness. Based on the condition, we devise an end-to-end causal effect estimator by transforming the identified theoretical condition into a targeted loss. Moreover, we provide a theoretical analysis of our designed estimator, revealing a faster convergence rate compared to a single nuisance model. Extensive experimental results on two real-world networks with semisynthetic data demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed estimators.
Read more7/8/2024
0
Neural Networks with Causal Graph Constraints: A New Approach for Treatment Effects Estimation
Roger Pros, Jordi Vitri`a
In recent years, there has been a growing interest in using machine learning techniques for the estimation of treatment effects. Most of the best-performing methods rely on representation learning strategies that encourage shared behavior among potential outcomes to increase the precision of treatment effect estimates. In this paper we discuss and classify these models in terms of their algorithmic inductive biases and present a new model, NN-CGC, that considers additional information from the causal graph. NN-CGC tackles bias resulting from spurious variable interactions by implementing novel constraints on models, and it can be integrated with other representation learning methods. We test the effectiveness of our method using three different base models on common benchmarks. Our results indicate that our model constraints lead to significant improvements, achieving new state-of-the-art results in treatment effects estimation. We also show that our method is robust to imperfect causal graphs and that using partial causal information is preferable to ignoring it.
Read more4/19/2024