Separating and Learning Latent Confounders to Enhancing User Preferences Modeling

Read original: arXiv:2311.03381 - Published 4/3/2024 by Hangtong Xu, Yuanbo Xu, Yongjian Yang

🤯

Overview

Recommender models aim to predict user preferences for items based on past user feedback.
However, the presence of unmeasured factors can cause the predicted preferences to deviate from the true user preferences.
Existing debiasing models either address specific biases or rely on additional user data, but cannot fully separate true user preferences from unmeasured factors.
The paper proposes a novel framework called SLFR that can identify and disentangle user preferences from unmeasured confounding factors, including the effects of previous recommendation systems.

Plain English Explanation

Recommender systems are designed to suggest products, content, or services that users might like, based on their past behavior and preferences. For example, an e-commerce site might recommend additional items for a user to purchase based on their previous buying history.

The challenge is that there can be many invisible or "unmeasured" factors that influence a user's preferences, beyond just their past interactions with the recommender system. These factors could include the user's mood, their friends' opinions, or even the design of the recommender system itself. All of these unseen elements can cause the system's predictions to deviate from the user's true, underlying preferences.

Existing approaches to address this issue either focus on fixing specific types of biases, or try to incorporate additional data about the user. However, these methods still can't fully separate the user's genuine preferences from the distorting effects of the unmeasured factors.

The researchers in this paper developed a new framework called SLFR that can better distinguish the user's true preferences from the influence of unmeasured confounding factors. This allows the recommender system to make predictions that are more closely aligned with the user's actual wants and needs.

Technical Explanation

The key elements of the SLFR framework are:

Identifying Unmeasured Confounders: The paper proposes treating the previous recommender system itself as a proxy for all the unmeasured confounding factors that may be influencing user preferences. This allows the model to account for the effects of these unseen elements.
Disentangling User Preferences: SLFR uses a neural network architecture to learn separate representations for the user's true preferences and the unmeasured confounding factors. This disentanglement allows the model to make predictions based only on the user's genuine interests, rather than the distorted preferences.
Counterfactual Feedback Estimation: By understanding the user's true preferences and the confounding factors, SLFR can estimate what the user's feedback would have been in the absence of the biasing influences. This "counterfactual" feedback is then used to train the final recommender model.

The researchers evaluated SLFR on five real-world datasets and found that it outperformed existing debiasing approaches. The paper discusses some limitations, such as the reliance on the previous recommender system as a proxy for unmeasured confounders, and suggests areas for future research.

Critical Analysis

The key strength of the SLFR framework is its ability to more accurately model the user's true preferences by disentangling them from the effects of unmeasured confounding factors. This is an important advancement, as real-world recommender systems often suffer from biases and distortions that prevent them from fully capturing user interests.

That said, the paper's reliance on the previous recommender system as a proxy for all unmeasured confounders could be seen as a limitation. While this may work reasonably well in practice, there may be other unmeasured factors beyond the recommender system that also influence user preferences. Further research would be needed to fully understand the extent to which SLFR can account for the complete set of confounding influences.

Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the potential ethical implications of this type of debiasing approach. There are valid concerns about the use of "counterfactual" feedback, as this could potentially be used to manipulate user preferences in ways that may not align with their true interests. Careful consideration of these ethical issues would be an important area for future work.

Conclusion

The SLFR framework represents an important advancement in recommender system research, as it provides a more robust way to model user preferences by accounting for the distorting effects of unmeasured confounding factors. By disentangling true user interests from biasing influences, SLFR can help recommendation engines make suggestions that are better aligned with the user's actual needs and desires.

While the reliance on the previous recommender system as a proxy for confounders is a potential limitation, the overall approach demonstrates the value of carefully considering the complex interplay between user behavior, system design, and unmeasured environmental factors. As recommender systems become increasingly ubiquitous in our digital lives, innovations like SLFR will be crucial for ensuring these systems operate in a fair and user-centric manner.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🤯

Separating and Learning Latent Confounders to Enhancing User Preferences Modeling

Hangtong Xu, Yuanbo Xu, Yongjian Yang

Recommender models aim to capture user preferences from historical feedback and then predict user-specific feedback on candidate items. However, the presence of various unmeasured confounders causes deviations between the user preferences in the historical feedback and the true preferences, resulting in models not meeting their expected performance. Existing debias models either (1) specific to solving one particular bias or (2) directly obtain auxiliary information from user historical feedback, which cannot identify whether the learned preferences are true user preferences or mixed with unmeasured confounders. Moreover, we find that the former recommender system is not only a successor to unmeasured confounders but also acts as an unmeasured confounder affecting user preference modeling, which has always been neglected in previous studies. To this end, we incorporate the effect of the former recommender system and treat it as a proxy for all unmeasured confounders. We propose a novel framework, Separating and Learning Latent Confounders For Recommendation (SLFR), which obtains the representation of unmeasured confounders to identify the counterfactual feedback by disentangling user preferences and unmeasured confounders, then guides the target model to capture the true preferences of users. Extensive experiments in five real-world datasets validate the advantages of our method.

4/3/2024

👀

Mitigating Hidden Confounding Effects for Causal Recommendation

Xinyuan Zhu, Yang Zhang, Fuli Feng, Xun Yang, Dingxian Wang, Xiangnan He

Recommender systems suffer from confounding biases when there exist confounders affecting both item features and user feedback (e.g., like or not). Existing causal recommendation methods typically assume confounders are fully observed and measured, forgoing the possible existence of hidden confounders in real applications. For instance, product quality is a confounder since affecting both item prices and user ratings, but is hidden for the third-party e-commerce platform due to the difficulty of large-scale quality inspection; ignoring it could result in the bias effect of over-recommending high-price items. This work analyzes and addresses the problem from a causal perspective. The key lies in modeling the causal effect of item features on a user's feedback. To mitigate hidden confounding effects, it is compulsory but challenging to estimate the causal effect without measuring the confounder. Towards this goal, we propose a Hidden Confounder Removal (HCR) framework that leverages front-door adjustment to decompose the causal effect into two partial effects, according to the mediators between item features and user feedback. The partial effects are independent from the hidden confounder and identifiable. During training, HCR performs multi-task learning to infer the partial effects from historical interactions. We instantiate HCR for two scenarios and conduct experiments on three real-world datasets. Empirical results show that the HCR framework provides more accurate recommendations, especially for less-active users. We will release the code once accepted.

5/27/2024

A Survey of Latent Factor Models in Recommender Systems

Hind I. Alshbanat, Hafida Benhidour, Said Kerrache

Recommender systems are essential tools in the digital era, providing personalized content to users in areas like e-commerce, entertainment, and social media. Among the many approaches developed to create these systems, latent factor models have proven particularly effective. This survey systematically reviews latent factor models in recommender systems, focusing on their core principles, methodologies, and recent advancements. The literature is examined through a structured framework covering learning data, model architecture, learning strategies, and optimization techniques. The analysis includes a taxonomy of contributions and detailed discussions on the types of learning data used, such as implicit feedback, trust, and content data, various models such as probabilistic, nonlinear, and neural models, and an exploration of diverse learning strategies like online learning, transfer learning, and active learning. Furthermore, the survey addresses the optimization strategies used to train latent factor models, improving their performance and scalability. By identifying trends, gaps, and potential research directions, this survey aims to provide valuable insights for researchers and practitioners looking to advance the field of recommender systems.

5/29/2024

📈

PSLF: A PID Controller-incorporated Second-order Latent Factor Analysis Model for Recommender System

Jialiang Wang, Yan Xia, Ye Yuan

A second-order-based latent factor (SLF) analysis model demonstrates superior performance in graph representation learning, particularly for high-dimensional and incomplete (HDI) interaction data, by incorporating the curvature information of the loss landscape. However, its objective function is commonly bi-linear and non-convex, causing the SLF model to suffer from a low convergence rate. To address this issue, this paper proposes a PID controller-incorporated SLF (PSLF) model, leveraging two key strategies: a) refining learning error estimation by incorporating the PID controller principles, and b) acquiring second-order information insights through Hessian-vector products. Experimental results on multiple HDI datasets indicate that the proposed PSLF model outperforms four state-of-the-art latent factor models based on advanced optimizers regarding convergence rates and generalization performance.

9/4/2024