A Short and General Duality Proof for Wasserstein Distributionally Robust Optimization
0
🛠️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a general duality result for Wasserstein distributionally robust optimization (DRO) that applies to various settings, including Markov decision processes and multistage stochastic programming.
- The authors show that their duality result relies on an "interchangeability principle" that is satisfied if certain measurable projection and weak measurable selection conditions are met.
- The paper also extends the analysis to other optimization problems, such as infinity-Wasserstein DRO, risk-averse optimization, and globalized distributionally robust counterparts.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses a mathematical framework called "Wasserstein distributionally robust optimization" (Wasserstein DRO). This framework allows researchers to develop optimization models that are resilient to uncertainty in the underlying probability distribution of the problem.
The key idea is that instead of assuming a single, known probability distribution, the Wasserstein DRO framework considers a set of "nearby" probability distributions. The optimization problem is then designed to perform well across this set of distributions, rather than just for a single assumed distribution.
The authors of this paper show that this Wasserstein DRO framework has a fundamental "duality" property - the optimization problem can be rewritten in an equivalent, but simpler, form. This duality result holds for a wide range of optimization problems, including those involving Markov decision processes and multistage stochastic programming.
The authors demonstrate that this duality result relies on an "interchangeability principle" that is satisfied under certain technical conditions. They also show how the Wasserstein DRO framework can be extended to other optimization problems, such as those involving infinity-Wasserstein distances, risk-averse optimization, and "globalized" distributionally robust counterparts.
Technical Explanation
The paper establishes a general duality result for Wasserstein distributionally robust optimization (DRO) problems. The authors show that this duality result holds for any Kantorovich transport cost, measurable loss function, and nominal probability distribution.
The key to the authors' proof is an "interchangeability principle" that is inherent in existing duality results for Wasserstein DRO. The authors demonstrate that this interchangeability principle holds if and only if certain measurable projection and weak measurable selection conditions are satisfied.
To illustrate the broad applicability of their approach, the authors provide a detailed treatment of duality results in two specific settings: distributionally robust Markov decision processes and distributionally robust multistage stochastic programming. They also extend their analysis to other optimization problems, such as infinity-Wasserstein DRO, risk-averse optimization, and globalized distributionally robust counterparts.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a strong theoretical foundation for Wasserstein DRO, but its practical implications may be limited by the technical conditions required for the interchangeability principle to hold. The authors acknowledge that verifying these conditions may be challenging in some applications.
Additionally, the paper does not provide any empirical evaluation of the proposed duality results. While the theoretical analysis is rigorous, it would be helpful to see how the duality formulation performs compared to other Wasserstein DRO approaches in real-world optimization problems.
Further research could also explore the computational efficiency of solving the duality-based Wasserstein DRO problems, as the reformulation may lead to more tractable optimization problems in certain cases.
Conclusion
This paper makes an important theoretical contribution to the field of Wasserstein DRO by establishing a general duality result that holds across a wide range of optimization problems. The authors' insights into the interchangeability principle provide a deeper understanding of the underlying mathematical structure of Wasserstein DRO, which could inform the development of more efficient and robust optimization algorithms in the future.
While the technical conditions required for the duality result may limit its immediate practical applicability, the paper lays the groundwork for further exploration of Wasserstein DRO and its connections to other optimization frameworks, such as Gromov-Wasserstein distance and risk-averse optimization.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🛠️
0
A Short and General Duality Proof for Wasserstein Distributionally Robust Optimization
Luhao Zhang, Jincheng Yang, Rui Gao
We present a general duality result for Wasserstein distributionally robust optimization that holds for any Kantorovich transport cost, measurable loss function, and nominal probability distribution. Assuming an interchangeability principle inherent in existing duality results, our proof only uses one-dimensional convex analysis. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the interchangeability principle holds if and only if certain measurable projection and weak measurable selection conditions are satisfied. To illustrate the broader applicability of our approach, we provide a rigorous treatment of duality results in distributionally robust Markov decision processes and distributionally robust multistage stochastic programming. Additionally, we extend our analysis to other problems such as infinity-Wasserstein distributionally robust optimization, risk-averse optimization, and globalized distributionally robust counterpart.
Read more6/6/2024
🔍
0
Robust $Q$-learning Algorithm for Markov Decision Processes under Wasserstein Uncertainty
Ariel Neufeld, Julian Sester
We present a novel $Q$-learning algorithm tailored to solve distributionally robust Markov decision problems where the corresponding ambiguity set of transition probabilities for the underlying Markov decision process is a Wasserstein ball around a (possibly estimated) reference measure. We prove convergence of the presented algorithm and provide several examples also using real data to illustrate both the tractability of our algorithm as well as the benefits of considering distributional robustness when solving stochastic optimal control problems, in particular when the estimated distributions turn out to be misspecified in practice.
Read more6/21/2024
0
New!Wasserstein Distributionally Robust Multiclass Support Vector Machine
Michael Ibrahim, Heraldo Rozas, Nagi Gebraeel
We study the problem of multiclass classification for settings where data features $mathbf{x}$ and their labels $mathbf{y}$ are uncertain. We identify that distributionally robust one-vs-all (OVA) classifiers often struggle in settings with imbalanced data. To address this issue, we use Wasserstein distributionally robust optimization to develop a robust version of the multiclass support vector machine (SVM) characterized by the Crammer-Singer (CS) loss. First, we prove that the CS loss is bounded from above by a Lipschitz continuous function for all $mathbf{x} in mathcal{X}$ and $mathbf{y} in mathcal{Y}$, then we exploit strong duality results to express the dual of the worst-case risk problem, and we show that the worst-case risk minimization problem admits a tractable convex reformulation due to the regularity of the CS loss. Moreover, we develop a kernel version of our proposed model to account for nonlinear class separation, and we show that it admits a tractable convex upper bound. We also propose a projected subgradient method algorithm for a special case of our proposed linear model to improve scalability. Our numerical experiments demonstrate that our model outperforms state-of-the art OVA models in settings where the training data is highly imbalanced. We also show through experiments on popular real-world datasets that our proposed model often outperforms its regularized counterpart as the first accounts for uncertain labels unlike the latter.
Read more9/16/2024
🛠️
0
Nonlinear Distributionally Robust Optimization
Mohammed Rayyan Sheriff, Peyman Mohajerin Esfahani
This article focuses on a class of distributionally robust optimization (DRO) problems where, unlike the growing body of the literature, the objective function is potentially nonlinear in the distribution. Existing methods to optimize nonlinear functions in probability space use the Frechet derivatives, which present both theoretical and computational challenges. Motivated by this, we propose an alternative notion for the derivative and corresponding smoothness based on Gateaux (G)-derivative for generic risk measures. These concepts are explained via three running risk measure examples of variance, entropic risk, and risk on finite support sets. We then propose a G-derivative based Frank-Wolfe (FW) algorithm for generic nonlinear optimization problems in probability spaces and establish its convergence under the proposed notion of smoothness in a completely norm-independent manner. We use the set-up of the FW algorithm to devise a methodology to compute a saddle point of the nonlinear DRO problem. Finally, we validate our theoretical results on two cases of the entropic and variance risk measures in the context of portfolio selection problems. In particular, we analyze their regularity conditions and sufficient statistic, compute the respective FW-oracle in various settings, and confirm the theoretical outcomes through numerical validation.
Read more6/11/2024