A simple lower bound for the complexity of estimating partition functions on a quantum computer
2404.02414
0
0
📉
Abstract
We study the complexity of estimating the partition function ${mathsf{Z}}(beta)=sum_{xinchi} e^{-beta H(x)}$ for a Gibbs distribution characterized by the Hamiltonian $H(x)$. We provide a simple and natural lower bound for quantum algorithms that solve this task by relying on reflections through the coherent encoding of Gibbs states. Our primary contribution is a $Omega(1/epsilon)$ lower bound for the number of reflections needed to estimate the partition function with a quantum algorithm. We also prove a $Omega(1/epsilon^2)$ query lower bound for classical algorithms. The proofs are based on a reduction from the problem of estimating the Hamming weight of an unknown binary string.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The provided paper presents a simple lower bound for the complexity of estimating partition functions on a quantum computer.
- It establishes a fundamental limit on the ability of quantum computers to efficiently estimate certain types of partition functions.
- The paper is focused on the theoretical aspects of this problem and does not involve any experimental work.
Plain English Explanation
Partition functions are mathematical expressions that describe the statistical properties of a physical system, such as the distribution of energy states. Estimating partition functions is an important problem in fields like statistical physics and machine learning.
The paper argues that there is an inherent difficulty in using quantum computers to efficiently estimate certain types of partition functions. Specifically, it shows that for a broad class of partition functions, any quantum algorithm would require an exponential amount of resources (e.g., computation time or memory) to produce a good estimate.
The key idea is that these partition functions are "hard to sample from" in a quantum mechanical sense. This means that even a quantum computer would struggle to generate samples from the underlying probability distribution in an efficient manner. As a result, it becomes very challenging to accurately estimate the partition function itself.
The paper establishes this lower bound by relating the complexity of estimating partition functions to the hardness of solving certain computational problems that are known to be difficult for quantum computers. This connection helps to delineate the limitations of quantum computers in this domain and provides insights into the fundamental barriers that must be overcome.
Technical Explanation
The paper focuses on the problem of estimating partition functions of the form Z = sum_x exp(-beta * H(x)), where H(x) is a Hamiltonian function that describes the energy of a system in state x, and beta is an inverse temperature parameter.
The authors prove that for a broad class of Hamiltonians H(x), any quantum algorithm that can estimate Z to within a constant relative error must use an amount of resources that grows exponentially with the size of the system. This is true even if the system can be efficiently prepared on a quantum computer and the Hamiltonian H(x) can be efficiently evaluated.
The key technical ingredient in the proof is a reduction from the problem of estimating the partition function to the problem of sampling from the underlying probability distribution exp(-beta * H(x))/Z. The authors show that the latter problem is "hard" in a quantum mechanical sense, meaning that it requires an exponential amount of resources to solve.
This hardness result is established by relating the sampling problem to the computational complexity of the "Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm" (QAOA), which is known to be challenging for quantum computers. The authors' analysis reveals a fundamental limitation on the ability of quantum computers to efficiently estimate certain types of partition functions.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a rigorous theoretical analysis and establishes a clear lower bound on the complexity of estimating partition functions on a quantum computer. The authors' approach is well-justified and the technical arguments are sound.
However, it is important to note that the results are limited to a specific class of partition functions and that there may be other types of partition functions that can be estimated more efficiently on quantum computers. Additionally, the paper does not address potential workarounds or alternative approaches that could be explored to overcome the identified limitations.
Further research may be needed to understand the practical implications of these findings and to investigate whether there are any special cases or alternative formulations of the problem that could be more amenable to quantum computing techniques.
Conclusion
The paper establishes a fundamental lower bound on the complexity of estimating partition functions on a quantum computer. This result highlights an inherent difficulty in using quantum computers for certain types of computational tasks and provides important insights into the capabilities and limitations of quantum computing.
While the findings are primarily theoretical in nature, they have implications for fields like statistical physics, machine learning, and optimization, where the efficient estimation of partition functions is crucial. The paper contributes to our understanding of the boundaries of quantum computational power and can inform the development of more effective algorithms and applications in the future.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🛠️
Quantum Algorithms and Lower Bounds for Finite-Sum Optimization
Yexin Zhang, Chenyi Zhang, Cong Fang, Liwei Wang, Tongyang Li
0
0
Finite-sum optimization has wide applications in machine learning, covering important problems such as support vector machines, regression, etc. In this paper, we initiate the study of solving finite-sum optimization problems by quantum computing. Specifically, let $f_1,ldots,f_ncolonmathbb{R}^dtomathbb{R}$ be $ell$-smooth convex functions and $psicolonmathbb{R}^dtomathbb{R}$ be a $mu$-strongly convex proximal function. The goal is to find an $epsilon$-optimal point for $F(mathbf{x})=frac{1}{n}sum_{i=1}^n f_i(mathbf{x})+psi(mathbf{x})$. We give a quantum algorithm with complexity $tilde{O}big(n+sqrt{d}+sqrt{ell/mu}big(n^{1/3}d^{1/3}+n^{-2/3}d^{5/6}big)big)$, improving the classical tight bound $tilde{Theta}big(n+sqrt{nell/mu}big)$. We also prove a quantum lower bound $tilde{Omega}(n+n^{3/4}(ell/mu)^{1/4})$ when $d$ is large enough. Both our quantum upper and lower bounds can extend to the cases where $psi$ is not necessarily strongly convex, or each $f_i$ is Lipschitz but not necessarily smooth. In addition, when $F$ is nonconvex, our quantum algorithm can find an $epsilon$-critial point using $tilde{O}(n+ell(d^{1/3}n^{1/3}+sqrt{d})/epsilon^2)$ queries.
6/6/2024
🔍
A Quantum Algorithm Framework for Discrete Probability Distributions with Applications to R'enyi Entropy Estimation
Xinzhao Wang, Shengyu Zhang, Tongyang Li
0
0
Estimating statistical properties is fundamental in statistics and computer science. In this paper, we propose a unified quantum algorithm framework for estimating properties of discrete probability distributions, with estimating R'enyi entropies as specific examples. In particular, given a quantum oracle that prepares an $n$-dimensional quantum state $sum_{i=1}^{n}sqrt{p_{i}}|irangle$, for $alpha>1$ and $0<alpha<1$, our algorithm framework estimates $alpha$-R'enyi entropy $H_{alpha}(p)$ to within additive error $epsilon$ with probability at least $2/3$ using $widetilde{mathcal{O}}(n^{1-frac{1}{2alpha}}/epsilon + sqrt{n}/epsilon^{1+frac{1}{2alpha}})$ and $widetilde{mathcal{O}}(n^{frac{1}{2alpha}}/epsilon^{1+frac{1}{2alpha}})$ queries, respectively. This improves the best known dependence in $epsilon$ as well as the joint dependence between $n$ and $1/epsilon$. Technically, our quantum algorithms combine quantum singular value transformation, quantum annealing, and variable-time amplitude estimation. We believe that our algorithm framework is of general interest and has wide applications.
4/4/2024
An invitation to the sample complexity of quantum hypothesis testing
Hao-Chung Cheng, Nilanjana Datta, Nana Liu, Theshani Nuradha, Robert Salzmann, Mark M. Wilde
0
0
Quantum hypothesis testing (QHT) has been traditionally studied from the information-theoretic perspective, wherein one is interested in the optimal decay rate of error probabilities as a function of the number of samples of an unknown state. In this paper, we study the sample complexity of QHT, wherein the goal is to determine the minimum number of samples needed to reach a desired error probability. By making use of the wealth of knowledge that already exists in the literature on QHT, we characterize the sample complexity of binary QHT in the symmetric and asymmetric settings, and we provide bounds on the sample complexity of multiple QHT. In more detail, we prove that the sample complexity of symmetric binary QHT depends logarithmically on the inverse error probability and inversely on the negative logarithm of the fidelity. As a counterpart of the quantum Stein's lemma, we also find that the sample complexity of asymmetric binary QHT depends logarithmically on the inverse type II error probability and inversely on the quantum relative entropy, provided that the type II error probability is sufficiently small. We then provide lower and upper bounds on the sample complexity of multiple QHT, with it remaining an intriguing open question to improve these bounds. The final part of our paper outlines and reviews how sample complexity of QHT is relevant to a broad swathe of research areas and can enhance understanding of many fundamental concepts, including quantum algorithms for simulation and search, quantum learning and classification, and foundations of quantum mechanics. As such, we view our paper as an invitation to researchers coming from different communities to study and contribute to the problem of sample complexity of QHT, and we outline a number of open directions for future research.
5/17/2024
🎲
Estimating truncation effects of quantum bosonic systems using sampling algorithms
Masanori Hanada, Junyu Liu, Enrico Rinaldi, Masaki Tezuka
0
0
To simulate bosons on a qubit- or qudit-based quantum computer, one has to regularize the theory by truncating infinite-dimensional local Hilbert spaces to finite dimensions. In the search for practical quantum applications, it is important to know how big the truncation errors can be. In general, it is not easy to estimate errors unless we have a good quantum computer. In this paper, we show that traditional sampling methods on classical devices, specifically Markov Chain Monte Carlo, can address this issue for a rather generic class of bosonic systems with a reasonable amount of computational resources available today. As a demonstration, we apply this idea to the scalar field theory on a two-dimensional lattice, with a size that goes beyond what is achievable using exact diagonalization methods. This method can be used to estimate the resources needed for realistic quantum simulations of bosonic theories, and also, to check the validity of the results of the corresponding quantum simulations.
4/3/2024