Simplifying Deep Temporal Difference Learning
0
🤿
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Q-learning is a foundational algorithm in reinforcement learning (RL)
- TD algorithms like Q-learning with off-policy data or non-linear function approximation (e.g., deep neural networks) require stabilization techniques like replay buffers and target networks
- These stabilization techniques can harm sample efficiency and introduce overhead
- This paper investigates whether it's possible to simplify and accelerate TD training while maintaining stability
Plain English Explanation
Reinforcement learning is a type of machine learning where an agent learns by interacting with an environment and receiving rewards or punishments. Q-learning is a key algorithm in this field that has played a foundational role.
However, when using Q-learning with data from outside the agent's own experiences (off-policy data) or with complex function approximators like deep neural networks, the training process can become unstable. To address this, researchers have developed techniques like replay buffers and target networks.
While these techniques can help stabilize training, they can also have downsides. Replay buffers take up memory and add complexity, while target networks can reduce the efficiency of the learning process.
This paper investigates whether it's possible to simplify the training process and make it more efficient, without sacrificing the stability that the additional techniques provide. The key idea is to use regularization techniques like Layer Normalization to stabilize the training, rather than relying on replay buffers and target networks.
The researchers found that by using online, parallelized sampling enabled by vectorized environments, they could stabilize training without needing a replay buffer. They then developed a new algorithm called PQN (Pure Q-learning Network) that is simpler and faster than more complex methods, while still maintaining good performance on a variety of benchmark tasks.
Technical Explanation
The paper investigates whether it's possible to accelerate and simplify temporal difference (TD) training, such as Q-learning, while maintaining stability. Traditionally, TD algorithms with off-policy data or non-linear function approximation (like deep neural networks) require additional techniques like replay buffers and target networks to stabilize training.
The key theoretical contribution of this paper is demonstrating that regularization techniques, such as Layer Normalization, can yield provably convergent TD algorithms without the need for a target network, even with off-policy data. This is the first time this result has been shown.
Empirically, the researchers found that online, parallelized sampling enabled by vectorized environments can stabilize training without the need for a replay buffer. Motivated by these findings, the authors propose PQN, a simplified deep online Q-Learning algorithm.
Surprisingly, PQN is competitive with more complex methods like Rainbow in Atari, R2D2 in Hanabi, QMix in Smax, and PPO-RNN in Craftax, while being up to 50x faster than traditional DQN without sacrificing sample efficiency.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to simplifying TD training without sacrificing stability. The theoretical and empirical results are impressive, and the proposed PQN algorithm appears to be a viable alternative to more complex RL methods.
One potential limitation is that the paper focuses on a specific set of benchmark tasks, and it's unclear how well the PQN algorithm would generalize to a wider range of environments and problems. Additionally, the paper doesn't explore the potential for further optimizations or variations of the PQN algorithm.
It would be interesting to see how PQN compares to other recent developments in RL, such as Implicit Q-Learning or Orthogonal Q-Learning, which also aim to simplify and stabilize TD training.
Overall, this paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of RL by demonstrating that it's possible to simplify and accelerate TD training without sacrificing stability, which could have significant implications for the development of more efficient and practical RL systems.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to simplifying and accelerating temporal difference (TD) training, such as Q-learning, while maintaining stability. The key theoretical contribution is demonstrating that regularization techniques can yield provably convergent TD algorithms without the need for a target network, even with off-policy data.
Empirically, the authors show that online, parallelized sampling enabled by vectorized environments can stabilize training without the need for a replay buffer. Motivated by these findings, they propose PQN, a simplified deep online Q-Learning algorithm that is competitive with more complex methods while being significantly faster.
The simplicity and efficiency of PQN could make it a viable alternative to more complex RL algorithms, especially in domains where sample efficiency and computational resources are crucial. This research represents an important step forward in the development of more practical and accessible RL systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤿
0
Simplifying Deep Temporal Difference Learning
Matteo Gallici, Mattie Fellows, Benjamin Ellis, Bartomeu Pou, Ivan Masmitja, Jakob Nicolaus Foerster, Mario Martin
Q-learning played a foundational role in the field reinforcement learning (RL). However, TD algorithms with off-policy data, such as Q-learning, or nonlinear function approximation like deep neural networks require several additional tricks to stabilise training, primarily a replay buffer and target networks. Unfortunately, the delayed updating of frozen network parameters in the target network harms the sample efficiency and, similarly, the replay buffer introduces memory and implementation overheads. In this paper, we investigate whether it is possible to accelerate and simplify TD training while maintaining its stability. Our key theoretical result demonstrates for the first time that regularisation techniques such as LayerNorm can yield provably convergent TD algorithms without the need for a target network, even with off-policy data. Empirically, we find that online, parallelised sampling enabled by vectorised environments stabilises training without the need of a replay buffer. Motivated by these findings, we propose PQN, our simplified deep online Q-Learning algorithm. Surprisingly, this simple algorithm is competitive with more complex methods like: Rainbow in Atari, R2D2 in Hanabi, QMix in Smax, PPO-RNN in Craftax, and can be up to 50x faster than traditional DQN without sacrificing sample efficiency. In an era where PPO has become the go-to RL algorithm, PQN reestablishes Q-learning as a viable alternative. We make our code available at: https://github.com/mttga/purejaxql.
Read more7/9/2024
🤿
0
An Analysis of Quantile Temporal-Difference Learning
Mark Rowland, R'emi Munos, Mohammad Gheshlaghi Azar, Yunhao Tang, Georg Ostrovski, Anna Harutyunyan, Karl Tuyls, Marc G. Bellemare, Will Dabney
We analyse quantile temporal-difference learning (QTD), a distributional reinforcement learning algorithm that has proven to be a key component in several successful large-scale applications of reinforcement learning. Despite these empirical successes, a theoretical understanding of QTD has proven elusive until now. Unlike classical TD learning, which can be analysed with standard stochastic approximation tools, QTD updates do not approximate contraction mappings, are highly non-linear, and may have multiple fixed points. The core result of this paper is a proof of convergence to the fixed points of a related family of dynamic programming procedures with probability 1, putting QTD on firm theoretical footing. The proof establishes connections between QTD and non-linear differential inclusions through stochastic approximation theory and non-smooth analysis.
Read more5/21/2024
🏅
0
Temporal Difference Learning with Compressed Updates: Error-Feedback meets Reinforcement Learning
Aritra Mitra, George J. Pappas, Hamed Hassani
In large-scale distributed machine learning, recent works have studied the effects of compressing gradients in stochastic optimization to alleviate the communication bottleneck. These works have collectively revealed that stochastic gradient descent (SGD) is robust to structured perturbations such as quantization, sparsification, and delays. Perhaps surprisingly, despite the surge of interest in multi-agent reinforcement learning, almost nothing is known about the analogous question: Are common reinforcement learning (RL) algorithms also robust to similar perturbations? We investigate this question by studying a variant of the classical temporal difference (TD) learning algorithm with a perturbed update direction, where a general compression operator is used to model the perturbation. Our work makes three important technical contributions. First, we prove that compressed TD algorithms, coupled with an error-feedback mechanism used widely in optimization, exhibit the same non-asymptotic theoretical guarantees as their SGD counterparts. Second, we show that our analysis framework extends seamlessly to nonlinear stochastic approximation schemes that subsume Q-learning. Third, we prove that for multi-agent TD learning, one can achieve linear convergence speedups with respect to the number of agents while communicating just $tilde{O}(1)$ bits per iteration. Notably, these are the first finite-time results in RL that account for general compression operators and error-feedback in tandem with linear function approximation and Markovian sampling. Our proofs hinge on the construction of novel Lyapunov functions that capture the dynamics of a memory variable introduced by error-feedback.
Read more6/5/2024
0
Adaptive $Q$-Network: On-the-fly Target Selection for Deep Reinforcement Learning
Th'eo Vincent, Fabian Wahren, Jan Peters, Boris Belousov, Carlo D'Eramo
Deep Reinforcement Learning (RL) is well known for being highly sensitive to hyperparameters, requiring practitioners substantial efforts to optimize them for the problem at hand. In recent years, the field of automated Reinforcement Learning (AutoRL) has grown in popularity by trying to address this issue. However, these approaches typically hinge on additional samples to select well-performing hyperparameters, hindering sample-efficiency and practicality in RL. Furthermore, most AutoRL methods are heavily based on already existing AutoML methods, which were originally developed neglecting the additional challenges inherent to RL due to its non-stationarities. In this work, we propose a new approach for AutoRL, called Adaptive $Q$-Network (AdaQN), that is tailored to RL to take into account the non-stationarity of the optimization procedure without requiring additional samples. AdaQN learns several $Q$-functions, each one trained with different hyperparameters, which are updated online using the $Q$-function with the smallest approximation error as a shared target. Our selection scheme simultaneously handles different hyperparameters while coping with the non-stationarity induced by the RL optimization procedure and being orthogonal to any critic-based RL algorithm. We demonstrate that AdaQN is theoretically sound and empirically validate it in MuJoCo control problems, showing benefits in sample-efficiency, overall performance, training stability, and robustness to stochasticity.
Read more5/28/2024