Singular-limit analysis of gradient descent with noise injection
2404.12293
0
0
Abstract
We study the limiting dynamics of a large class of noisy gradient descent systems in the overparameterized regime. In this regime the set of global minimizers of the loss is large, and when initialized in a neighbourhood of this zero-loss set a noisy gradient descent algorithm slowly evolves along this set. In some cases this slow evolution has been related to better generalisation properties. We characterize this evolution for the broad class of noisy gradient descent systems in the limit of small step size. Our results show that the structure of the noise affects not just the form of the limiting process, but also the time scale at which the evolution takes place. We apply the theory to Dropout, label noise and classical SGD (minibatching) noise, and show that these evolve on different two time scales. Classical SGD even yields a trivial evolution on both time scales, implying that additional noise is required for regularization. The results are inspired by the training of neural networks, but the theorems apply to noisy gradient descent of any loss that has a non-trivial zero-loss set.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Explores the behavior of gradient descent with noise injection, a technique used in machine learning to improve optimization and generalization.
- Provides a mathematical analysis of the "singular limit" case, where the noise injection becomes infinitesimally small.
- Investigates the convergence and stability properties of this system in the singular limit.
Plain English Explanation
Gradient descent is a fundamental optimization algorithm used in machine learning to train models like neural networks. It works by iteratively adjusting the model's parameters in the direction that reduces the error or "loss" function. However, this process can sometimes get stuck in suboptimal regions of the parameter space.
To address this, researchers have explored adding a small amount of random noise, or "noise injection," to the gradient updates. This can help the optimization process escape from local minima and explore a wider range of the parameter space, potentially leading to better solutions.
This paper takes a deep dive into the mathematical properties of gradient descent with noise injection in the limit where the noise becomes infinitesimally small. The authors analyze the stability and convergence of this "singular limit" case, providing insights into how the noise injection affects the optimization dynamics.
While the analysis is quite technical, the key idea is to understand how the addition of a tiny amount of noise can dramatically change the behavior of the optimization process, guiding it towards better solutions. This work contributes to our fundamental understanding of how noise can be leveraged to improve machine learning algorithms.
Technical Explanation
The paper analyzes the behavior of gradient descent with noise injection in the "singular limit" case, where the noise variance approaches zero. The authors derive a set of ordinary differential equations that govern the dynamics of this system in the singular limit.
They show that the singular limit dynamics can exhibit both stable and unstable behaviors, depending on the properties of the objective function being optimized. In the non-degenerate case, where the objective function is well-behaved, the noise injection can lead to stable convergence to stationary points.
However, in the degenerate case, where the objective function has "flat" regions, the noise injection can cause the optimization process to exhibit unstable, divergent behavior. The authors provide a detailed mathematical characterization of these stability properties.
This analysis sheds light on how the interplay between the objective function and the noise injection affects the optimization dynamics. It contributes to our understanding of the time scales at which gradient-based optimization algorithms converge, and how noise can be leveraged to improve convergence and generalization in machine learning models.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a rigorous mathematical analysis of gradient descent with noise injection, but it is important to note that the results are derived in the singular limit case, where the noise variance approaches zero. In practical machine learning scenarios, the noise variance is typically finite, and the behavior of the optimization process may differ from the singular limit analysis.
Additionally, the analysis focuses on the stability and convergence properties of the system, but does not directly address the issue of generalization performance. While the noise injection may improve optimization, its impact on the ability of the trained model to generalize to unseen data is not explicitly considered.
Further research could explore the interplay between noise injection, optimization dynamics, and generalization in more realistic, non-singular settings. Investigating the implications of this work for the design and tuning of noise-injected optimization algorithms in practical machine learning applications would also be a valuable direction for future study.
Conclusion
This paper presents a detailed mathematical analysis of gradient descent with noise injection in the singular limit case. It provides insights into the stability and convergence properties of this optimization process, shedding light on how the introduction of a small amount of noise can dramatically impact the dynamics of the system.
While the analysis is technical, the key takeaway is that noise injection can be a powerful tool for guiding optimization towards better solutions, but its effects must be carefully considered in the context of the specific objective function and optimization landscape. This work contributes to our fundamental understanding of how noise can be leveraged to improve the performance of machine learning algorithms.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔗
Stochastic Collapse: How Gradient Noise Attracts SGD Dynamics Towards Simpler Subnetworks
Feng Chen, Daniel Kunin, Atsushi Yamamura, Surya Ganguli
0
0
In this work, we reveal a strong implicit bias of stochastic gradient descent (SGD) that drives overly expressive networks to much simpler subnetworks, thereby dramatically reducing the number of independent parameters, and improving generalization. To reveal this bias, we identify invariant sets, or subsets of parameter space that remain unmodified by SGD. We focus on two classes of invariant sets that correspond to simpler (sparse or low-rank) subnetworks and commonly appear in modern architectures. Our analysis uncovers that SGD exhibits a property of stochastic attractivity towards these simpler invariant sets. We establish a sufficient condition for stochastic attractivity based on a competition between the loss landscape's curvature around the invariant set and the noise introduced by stochastic gradients. Remarkably, we find that an increased level of noise strengthens attractivity, leading to the emergence of attractive invariant sets associated with saddle-points or local maxima of the train loss. We observe empirically the existence of attractive invariant sets in trained deep neural networks, implying that SGD dynamics often collapses to simple subnetworks with either vanishing or redundant neurons. We further demonstrate how this simplifying process of stochastic collapse benefits generalization in a linear teacher-student framework. Finally, through this analysis, we mechanistically explain why early training with large learning rates for extended periods benefits subsequent generalization.
5/30/2024
🎲
Convergence Rates for Stochastic Approximation: Biased Noise with Unbounded Variance, and Applications
Rajeeva L. Karandikar, M. Vidyasagar
0
0
In this paper, we study the convergence properties of the Stochastic Gradient Descent (SGD) method for finding a stationary point of a given objective function $J(cdot)$. The objective function is not required to be convex. Rather, our results apply to a class of ``invex'' functions, which have the property that every stationary point is also a global minimizer. First, it is assumed that $J(cdot)$ satisfies a property that is slightly weaker than the Kurdyka-Lojasiewicz (KL) condition, denoted here as (KL'). It is shown that the iterations $J({boldsymbol theta}_t)$ converge almost surely to the global minimum of $J(cdot)$. Next, the hypothesis on $J(cdot)$ is strengthened from (KL') to the Polyak-Lojasiewicz (PL) condition. With this stronger hypothesis, we derive estimates on the rate of convergence of $J({boldsymbol theta}_t)$ to its limit. Using these results, we show that for functions satisfying the PL property, the convergence rate of SGD is the same as the best-possible rate for convex functions. While some results along these lines have been published in the past, our contributions contain two distinct improvements. First, the assumptions on the stochastic gradient are more general than elsewhere, and second, our convergence is almost sure, and not in expectation. We also study SGD when only function evaluations are permitted. In this setting, we determine the ``optimal'' increments or the size of the perturbations. Using the same set of ideas, we establish the global convergence of the Stochastic Approximation (SA) algorithm under more general assumptions on the measurement error, compared to the existing literature. We also derive bounds on the rate of convergence of the SA algorithm under appropriate assumptions.
5/14/2024
➖
High-probability Convergence Bounds for Nonlinear Stochastic Gradient Descent Under Heavy-tailed Noise
Aleksandar Armacki, Pranay Sharma, Gauri Joshi, Dragana Bajovic, Dusan Jakovetic, Soummya Kar
0
0
We study high-probability convergence guarantees of learning on streaming data in the presence of heavy-tailed noise. In the proposed scenario, the model is updated in an online fashion, as new information is observed, without storing any additional data. To combat the heavy-tailed noise, we consider a general framework of nonlinear stochastic gradient descent (SGD), providing several strong results. First, for non-convex costs and component-wise nonlinearities, we establish a convergence rate arbitrarily close to $mathcal{O}left(t^{-frac{1}{4}}right)$, whose exponent is independent of noise and problem parameters. Second, for strongly convex costs and a broader class of nonlinearities, we establish convergence of the last iterate to the optimum, with a rate $mathcal{O}left(t^{-zeta} right)$, where $zeta in (0,1)$ depends on problem parameters, noise and nonlinearity. As we show analytically and numerically, $zeta$ can be used to inform the preferred choice of nonlinearity for given problem settings. Compared to state-of-the-art, who only consider clipping, require bounded noise moments of order $eta in (1,2]$, and establish convergence rates whose exponents go to zero as $eta rightarrow 1$, we provide high-probability guarantees for a much broader class of nonlinearities and symmetric density noise, with convergence rates whose exponents are bounded away from zero, even when the noise has finite first moment only. Moreover, in the case of strongly convex functions, we demonstrate analytically and numerically that clipping is not always the optimal nonlinearity, further underlining the value of our general framework.
4/22/2024
A Clipped Trip: the Dynamics of SGD with Gradient Clipping in High-Dimensions
Noah Marshall, Ke Liang Xiao, Atish Agarwala, Elliot Paquette
0
0
The success of modern machine learning is due in part to the adaptive optimization methods that have been developed to deal with the difficulties of training large models over complex datasets. One such method is gradient clipping: a practical procedure with limited theoretical underpinnings. In this work, we study clipping in a least squares problem under streaming SGD. We develop a theoretical analysis of the learning dynamics in the limit of large intrinsic dimension-a model and dataset dependent notion of dimensionality. In this limit we find a deterministic equation that describes the evolution of the loss. We show that with Gaussian noise clipping cannot improve SGD performance. Yet, in other noisy settings, clipping can provide benefits with tuning of the clipping threshold. In these cases, clipping biases updates in a way beneficial to training which cannot be recovered by SGD under any schedule. We conclude with a discussion about the links between high-dimensional clipping and neural network training.
6/18/2024