Sketch and shift: a robust decoder for compressive clustering
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a new decoder called "Sketch and Shift" for compressive clustering, which aims to improve upon the limitations of existing methods.
- Compressive clustering is a technique that uses a small number of random linear measurements to cluster high-dimensional data, which can be more efficient than traditional clustering algorithms.
- The authors demonstrate that the popular CL-OMPR algorithm for compressive clustering can fail in certain cases, and propose Sketch and Shift as a more robust alternative.
Plain English Explanation
Imagine you have a large collection of data points that you want to organize into groups or clusters. Each data point has many different characteristics, so the full dataset is very high-dimensional and difficult to work with. Compressive clustering offers a solution by using a small number of random linear measurements to capture the essential structure of the data, allowing you to cluster it more efficiently.
However, the authors of this paper found that a popular compressive clustering algorithm called CL-OMPR can sometimes fail to accurately cluster the data, even when the underlying structure is relatively simple. To address this, they developed a new decoder called "Sketch and Shift" that is more robust to these types of failures.
The key idea behind Sketch and Shift is to first "sketch" the data by taking a small number of random linear measurements, and then "shift" these measurements in a way that makes it easier to identify the true cluster structure. This shifting process helps the algorithm overcome some of the limitations of CL-OMPR and other existing compressive clustering methods.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by providing background on compressive clustering and the CL-OMPR algorithm. CL-OMPR is a popular approach that uses a technique called Orthogonal Matching Pursuit (OMP) to reconstruct the cluster centroids from the compressed measurements.
The authors then illustrate and diagnose the failure cases of CL-OMPR, showing that it can struggle when the clusters are not well-separated or when there is a significant difference in cluster sizes. They provide theoretical analysis to explain why CL-OMPR can fail in these scenarios.
To address these limitations, the paper introduces the Sketch and Shift decoder. The key steps are:
- Sketching the data by taking a small number of random linear measurements.
- Shifting these sketched measurements in a carefully designed way to make the cluster structure more prominent.
- Applying a robust clustering algorithm, such as K-means, to the shifted sketches to recover the cluster centroids.
The authors provide theoretical guarantees for the Sketch and Shift decoder, showing that it can accurately recover the cluster centroids even in challenging scenarios where CL-OMPR fails. They also demonstrate the practical effectiveness of Sketch and Shift through experiments on both synthetic and real-world datasets.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough analysis of the limitations of the CL-OMPR algorithm and proposes a novel solution in the form of the Sketch and Shift decoder. The authors carefully justify the need for their approach and provide strong theoretical and empirical evidence to support its advantages.
One potential limitation of the Sketch and Shift decoder is that it requires the user to specify the number of clusters in advance, which may not always be known. It would be interesting to see if the authors could extend their method to handle cases where the number of clusters is unknown, for example by incorporating techniques like distributed least squares or self-organizing clustering systems.
Additionally, while the paper demonstrates the effectiveness of Sketch and Shift on several datasets, it would be valuable to see how the method performs on a wider range of real-world applications and under different types of data distributions and noise patterns.
Overall, this paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of compressive clustering by proposing a novel and robust decoding algorithm that addresses important limitations of existing methods. The clear explanations and thorough analysis make the work accessible to a broader audience, and the insights gained could potentially inspire further advancements in this area.
Conclusion
This paper introduces the Sketch and Shift decoder, a new approach for compressive clustering that aims to overcome the limitations of the popular CL-OMPR algorithm. By carefully sketching and shifting the data, Sketch and Shift is able to more reliably recover the true cluster structure, even in challenging scenarios where CL-OMPR fails.
The authors provide a strong theoretical and empirical foundation for their work, demonstrating the advantages of Sketch and Shift over existing methods. While the approach still has some potential limitations, such as the requirement to know the number of clusters in advance, it represents a significant step forward in the field of compressive clustering and could have important implications for a wide range of data analysis and machine learning applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Sketch and shift: a robust decoder for compressive clustering
Ayoub Belhadji, R'emi Gribonval
Compressive learning is an emerging approach to drastically reduce the memory footprint of large-scale learning, by first summarizing a large dataset into a low-dimensional sketch vector, and then decoding from this sketch the latent information needed for learning. In light of recent progress on information preservation guarantees for sketches based on random features, a major objective is to design easy-to-tune algorithms (called decoders) to robustly and efficiently extract this information. To address the underlying non-convex optimization problems, various heuristics have been proposed. In the case of compressive clustering, the standard heuristic is CL-OMPR, a variant of sliding Frank-Wolfe. Yet, CL-OMPR is hard to tune, and the examination of its robustness was overlooked. In this work, we undertake a scrutinized examination of CL-OMPR to circumvent its limitations. In particular, we show how this algorithm can fail to recover the clusters even in advantageous scenarios. To gain insight, we show how the deficiencies of this algorithm can be attributed to optimization difficulties related to the structure of a correlation function appearing at core steps of the algorithm. To address these limitations, we propose an alternative decoder offering substantial improvements over CL-OMPR. Its design is notably inspired from the mean shift algorithm, a classic approach to detect the local maxima of kernel density estimators. The proposed algorithm can extract clustering information from a sketch of the MNIST dataset that is 10 times smaller than previously.
Read more6/18/2024
✅
0
Debiased Distribution Compression
Lingxiao Li, Raaz Dwivedi, Lester Mackey
Modern compression methods can summarize a target distribution $mathbb{P}$ more succinctly than i.i.d. sampling but require access to a low-bias input sequence like a Markov chain converging quickly to $mathbb{P}$. We introduce a new suite of compression methods suitable for compression with biased input sequences. Given $n$ points targeting the wrong distribution and quadratic time, Stein kernel thinning (SKT) returns $sqrt{n}$ equal-weighted points with $widetilde{O}(n^{-1/2})$ maximum mean discrepancy (MMD) to $mathbb{P}$. For larger-scale compression tasks, low-rank SKT achieves the same feat in sub-quadratic time using an adaptive low-rank debiasing procedure that may be of independent interest. For downstream tasks that support simplex or constant-preserving weights, Stein recombination and Stein Cholesky achieve even greater parsimony, matching the guarantees of SKT with as few as $text{poly-log}(n)$ weighted points. Underlying these advances are new guarantees for the quality of simplex-weighted coresets, the spectral decay of kernel matrices, and the covering numbers of Stein kernel Hilbert spaces. In our experiments, our techniques provide succinct and accurate posterior summaries while overcoming biases due to burn-in, approximate Markov chain Monte Carlo, and tempering.
Read more8/2/2024
0
Learning the Positions in CountSketch
Yi Li, Honghao Lin, Simin Liu, Ali Vakilian, David P. Woodruff
We consider sketching algorithms which first compress data by multiplication with a random sketch matrix, and then apply the sketch to quickly solve an optimization problem, e.g., low-rank approximation and regression. In the learning-based sketching paradigm proposed by~cite{indyk2019learning}, the sketch matrix is found by choosing a random sparse matrix, e.g., CountSketch, and then the values of its non-zero entries are updated by running gradient descent on a training data set. Despite the growing body of work on this paradigm, a noticeable omission is that the locations of the non-zero entries of previous algorithms were fixed, and only their values were learned. In this work, we propose the first learning-based algorithms that also optimize the locations of the non-zero entries. Our first proposed algorithm is based on a greedy algorithm. However, one drawback of the greedy algorithm is its slower training time. We fix this issue and propose approaches for learning a sketching matrix for both low-rank approximation and Hessian approximation for second order optimization. The latter is helpful for a range of constrained optimization problems, such as LASSO and matrix estimation with a nuclear norm constraint. Both approaches achieve good accuracy with a fast running time. Moreover, our experiments suggest that our algorithm can still reduce the error significantly even if we only have a very limited number of training matrices.
Read more4/12/2024
0
Robust Clustering on High-Dimensional Data with Stochastic Quantization
Anton Kozyriev, Vladimir Norkin
This paper addresses the limitations of traditional vector quantization (clustering) algorithms, particularly K-Means and its variant K-Means++, and explores the Stochastic Quantization (SQ) algorithm as a scalable alternative for high-dimensional unsupervised and semi-supervised learning problems. Some traditional clustering algorithms suffer from inefficient memory utilization during computation, necessitating the loading of all data samples into memory, which becomes impractical for large-scale datasets. While variants such as Mini-Batch K-Means partially mitigate this issue by reducing memory usage, they lack robust theoretical convergence guarantees due to the non-convex nature of clustering problems. In contrast, the Stochastic Quantization algorithm provides strong theoretical convergence guarantees, making it a robust alternative for clustering tasks. We demonstrate the computational efficiency and rapid convergence of the algorithm on an image classification problem with partially labeled data, comparing model accuracy across various ratios of labeled to unlabeled data. To address the challenge of high dimensionality, we trained Triplet Network to encode images into low-dimensional representations in a latent space, which serve as a basis for comparing the efficiency of both the Stochastic Quantization algorithm and traditional quantization algorithms. Furthermore, we enhance the algorithm's convergence speed by introducing modifications with an adaptive learning rate.
Read more9/6/2024