Debiased Distribution Compression

Overview

• This paper introduces a new suite of compression methods for summarizing target distributions using biased input sequences, such as Markov chains that converge to the wrong distribution.
• The key methods presented are Stein Kernel Thinning (SKT), Low-rank SKT, Stein Recombination, and Stein Cholesky, which aim to provide succinct and accurate posterior summaries while overcoming biases.
• The underlying techniques involve new guarantees for the quality of simplex-weighted coresets, the spectral decay of kernel matrices, and the covering numbers of Stein kernel Hilbert spaces.

Plain English Explanation

When trying to summarize or compress a target distribution !link, the input data you have access to may be biased and not representative of the true distribution. This can happen, for example, if you're using a Markov chain Monte Carlo method that hasn't fully converged to the target distribution.

The new compression methods introduced in this paper can work with these biased input sequences and still provide a concise summary of the target distribution. The key ideas are:

1. Stein Kernel Thinning (SKT): Given a set of biased points, SKT can return a smaller set of equal-weighted points that are close to the target distribution, even if the original points were far off.
2. Low-rank SKT: For larger-scale compression tasks, this variant achieves the same guarantees as SKT but in sub-quadratic time, using an adaptive low-rank debiasing procedure.
3. Stein Recombination and Stein Cholesky: These methods can provide even greater parsimony (using fewer points) than SKT, while still matching its guarantees, by exploiting the structure of the downstream task (e.g., if it supports simplex or constant-preserving weights).

The key insights behind these methods involve new theoretical results about the properties of Stein kernel Hilbert spaces and how to efficiently summarize distributions in these spaces, even when the input data is biased.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces a suite of compression methods that can work with biased input sequences, such as Markov chains that have not fully converged to the target distribution !link.

Stein Kernel Thinning (SKT): Given $n$ biased points, SKT can return $\sqrt{n}$ equal-weighted points that have a maximum mean discrepancy (MMD) of $\widetilde{O}(n^{-1/2})$ to the target distribution $\mathbb{P}$. This is achieved by leveraging the Stein discrepancy and the Stein kernel Hilbert space to debias the input points.

Low-rank SKT: For larger-scale compression tasks, this variant achieves the same guarantees as SKT but in sub-quadratic time, using an adaptive low-rank debiasing procedure that may be of independent interest.

Stein Recombination and Stein Cholesky: These methods can provide even greater parsimony (using fewer points) than SKT, while still matching its guarantees, by exploiting the structure of the downstream task. Specifically, if the downstream task supports simplex or constant-preserving weights, these methods can return as few as $\mathrm{poly-log}(n)$ weighted points that still accurately summarize the target distribution.

Underlying these advances are new theoretical results, including:

• Guarantees for the quality of simplex-weighted coresets
• Characterization of the spectral decay of kernel matrices in Stein kernel Hilbert spaces
• Bounds on the covering numbers of Stein kernel Hilbert spaces

The authors demonstrate that these techniques can provide succinct and accurate posterior summaries, even in the presence of biases due to burn-in, approximate Markov chain Monte Carlo, and tempering.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling set of techniques for compressing biased input sequences to accurately summarize target distributions. The theoretical guarantees and the empirical results suggest that these methods can be powerful tools for dealing with the common issue of biased input data in practical applications.

That said, the paper does not address a few potential limitations and areas for further research:

• The performance of these methods may depend on the specific structure of the Stein kernel Hilbert space and the target distribution. It would be valuable to understand the sensitivity of these techniques to different problem settings.
• The paper focuses on compression for a single target distribution. It may be interesting to investigate how these methods could be extended to handle multiple target distributions or evolving distributions over time !link.
• The theoretical analysis provides asymptotic guarantees, but it would be helpful to have a better understanding of the finite-sample behavior and practical convergence rates of these algorithms !link.

Overall, this paper makes an important contribution to the field of distribution summarization and compression, particularly in the context of biased input data. The new techniques introduced here have the potential to significantly improve the performance of downstream tasks that rely on accurate representations of target distributions.

Conclusion

This paper presents a suite of new compression methods that can effectively summarize target distributions using biased input sequences, such as Markov chains that have not fully converged to the true distribution. The key techniques, including Stein Kernel Thinning, Low-rank SKT, Stein Recombination, and Stein Cholesky, leverage insights about Stein kernel Hilbert spaces to debias and compress the input data while providing strong theoretical guarantees.

These methods have the potential to significantly improve the performance of a wide range of downstream tasks that rely on accurate representations of probability distributions, particularly in the presence of biased or limited input data. The theoretical advances and empirical results demonstrated in this paper suggest that these techniques could become valuable tools for practitioners working with complex distributions in fields like Bayesian inference, generative modeling, and reinforcement learning.