A smoothed-Bayesian approach to frequency recovery from sketched data

Overview

• Presents a novel statistical perspective on recovering the frequency of a symbol in a large dataset using only a compressed representation (or "sketch") obtained via random hashing
• Proposes a "smoothed-Bayesian" method that overcomes the computational limitations of existing Bayesian nonparametric (BNP) approaches when dealing with large-scale data from realistic distributions
• Provides rigorous frequentist properties for the single hash function case, and introduces a multi-view learning approach for sketches with multiple hash functions
• Validates the method on synthetic and real data, comparing performance to existing alternatives

Plain English Explanation

When working with large datasets, it can be useful to summarize the data using a compressed representation, or "sketch." This allows you to perform certain analyses more efficiently, without needing to process the entire dataset. One common task is estimating the frequency of a particular symbol or value in the dataset.

Traditional algorithmic approaches have been used for this problem, but recent works have proposed Bayesian nonparametric (BNP) methods that can provide more informative frequency estimates by making modeling assumptions about the distribution of the sketched data.

In this paper, the authors take a different approach. They propose a "smoothed-Bayesian" method that is designed in a frequentist framework, rather than a Bayesian one. This allows them to overcome the computational limitations of the BNP approaches when dealing with large-scale data from realistic distributions, including those with "power-law" tail behaviors.

For sketches obtained with a single hash function, the authors' approach is supported by rigorous mathematical properties, including being unbiased and optimal under a squared error loss function within a certain class of estimators. For sketches with multiple hash functions, they introduce an approach based on "multi-view" learning to construct computationally efficient frequency estimators.

The authors validate their method on both synthetic and real-world data, comparing its performance to that of existing alternatives.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a novel "smoothed-Bayesian" method for estimating the frequency of a symbol in a large dataset using only a compressed "sketch" of the data, obtained via random hashing. This departs from traditional algorithmic approaches and recent Bayesian nonparametric (BNP) methods.

For sketches obtained with a single hash function, the authors show that their approach has desirable frequentist properties, including unbiasedness and optimality under a squared error loss function within a class of linear estimators. This is in contrast to the computational limitations of existing BNP methods when dealing with large-scale data from realistic distributions.

For sketches with multiple hash functions, the authors introduce a multi-view learning approach to construct computationally efficient frequency estimators. This allows them to leverage the additional information provided by the multiple hash functions.

The experimental validation on synthetic and real-world data demonstrates that the proposed method outperforms existing alternatives, including the BNP approaches. The authors highlight the method's ability to handle large-scale data from distributions with power-law tail behaviors, which are common in many real-world datasets.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a well-designed and rigorous statistical approach to the problem of frequency estimation from compressed data sketches. The authors' focus on overcoming the computational limitations of existing Bayesian methods is a practical and important contribution, as the ability to scale to large datasets is crucial for many real-world applications.

One potential limitation of the work is that the theoretical analysis is primarily focused on the single hash function case. While the authors introduce a multi-view learning approach for the multiple hash function scenario, a more comprehensive theoretical analysis of this case would be valuable. Additionally, the authors do not explore the sensitivity of their method to the choice of hyperparameters or the impact of the underlying data distribution on performance.

Further research could also investigate the robustness of the smoothed-Bayesian approach to noise or adversarial perturbations in the sketched data, as well as its applicability to other related tasks, such as distribution compression or distributed least squares estimation. Exploring the connections to sample-efficient neural likelihood-free Bayesian inference could also be an interesting direction for future work.

Overall, the paper presents a novel and promising approach to a fundamental problem at the intersection of computer science and information theory, with the potential for significant impact in various data-intensive applications.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a novel "smoothed-Bayesian" method for estimating the frequency of a symbol in a large dataset using only a compressed "sketch" of the data, obtained via random hashing. The proposed approach overcomes the computational limitations of existing Bayesian nonparametric methods, while providing rigorous frequentist properties for the single hash function case and a multi-view learning approach for sketches with multiple hash functions.

The experimental validation demonstrates the method's ability to outperform existing alternatives, particularly on large-scale data from realistic distributions with power-law tail behaviors. This work represents an important contribution to the field, with potential applications in a wide range of data-intensive tasks where efficient data summarization and analysis are crucial.