Socially Optimal Energy Usage via Adaptive Pricing
2310.13254
0
0
Abstract
A central challenge in using price signals to coordinate the electricity consumption of a group of users is the operator's lack of knowledge of the users due to privacy concerns. In this paper, we develop a two-time-scale incentive mechanism that alternately updates between the users and a system operator. As long as the users can optimize their own consumption subject to a given price, the operator does not need to know or attempt to learn any private information of the users for price design. Users adjust their consumption following the price and the system redesigns the price based on the users' consumption. We show that under mild assumptions, this iterative process converges to the social welfare solution. In particular, the cost of the users need not always be convex and its consumption can be the output of a machine learning-based load control algorithm.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper presents a framework for optimizing energy usage in a decentralized demand response system using adaptive pricing.
- The goal is to achieve socially optimal energy usage by having consumers adjust their consumption in response to dynamic pricing signals.
- The authors develop iterative algorithms for updating prices to incentivize consumers to shift their usage in a way that maximizes overall social welfare.
Plain English Explanation
The paper tackles the challenge of managing energy demand in a smart grid system. In a typical electricity grid, energy prices are often fixed, leading to inefficient usage patterns. Some consumers may use too much energy during peak times, putting strain on the system, while others may not use enough during off-peak times.
The researchers propose a dynamic pricing approach to address this problem. Their idea is to have the energy provider continuously adjust prices based on real-time demand. When demand is high, prices would go up, encouraging consumers to use less. When demand is low, prices would go down, encouraging more usage.
The goal is to find the optimal prices that balance supply and demand, ensuring the overall system operates as efficiently as possible. This is known as achieving "socially optimal" energy usage, meaning the best outcome for society as a whole.
To do this, the researchers developed mathematical algorithms that the energy provider can use to iteratively update prices. These algorithms analyze consumer behavior and gradually adjust prices to incentivize consumers to shift their usage to times when it is more beneficial for the system.
Over time, this adaptive pricing approach should lead to a more balanced and efficient use of energy across the grid, benefiting both consumers and the energy provider. Consumers pay prices that better reflect the true costs of providing electricity, while the provider can better manage demand and avoid expensive infrastructure upgrades.
Technical Explanation
The paper formulates the problem of optimizing energy usage in a decentralized demand response system as a global optimization problem. The goal is to find prices that maximize the total social welfare, which is the sum of consumer utility and the provider's revenue, subject to constraints on energy supply and demand.
The authors develop two iterative pricing update algorithms to solve this optimization problem in a decentralized manner. The first algorithm, called Gradient Projection, uses gradient information to gradually update prices towards the optimal solution. The second algorithm, called Dual Decomposition, decomposes the problem into subproblems that can be solved in parallel by individual consumers.
Both algorithms are proved to converge to the optimal prices under certain technical conditions. Simulation results demonstrate that the adaptive pricing approach can achieve significant improvements in social welfare compared to fixed pricing schemes, by incentivizing consumers to shift their usage patterns.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a rigorous mathematical framework for optimizing energy usage through adaptive pricing, with solid theoretical guarantees on the convergence of the proposed algorithms. However, the analysis assumes relatively simple models of consumer behavior and grid constraints that may not fully capture the complexity of real-world energy systems.
For example, the paper does not address issues like user heterogeneity, uncertainty in demand forecasts, or the potential for strategic gaming by consumers. Additionally, the practical implementation of such a system would likely face challenges around data collection, computational requirements, and user acceptance of dynamic pricing.
Further research is needed to explore these practical considerations and extend the proposed approach to more realistic settings. Pilot studies or field trials could also provide valuable insights into the real-world performance and user experience of an adaptive pricing-based demand response system.
Conclusion
Overall, the paper presents a promising framework for achieving socially optimal energy usage through the use of adaptive pricing. By continuously adjusting prices to better align supply and demand, the proposed approach has the potential to improve the efficiency and sustainability of energy systems.
The theoretical foundations and simulation results demonstrate the viability of this approach, but more work is needed to address the practical challenges of implementation and real-world deployment. As energy systems become increasingly complex and decentralized, adaptive pricing strategies like the ones explored in this paper may play a crucial role in managing demand and optimizing resource utilization.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Network-Aware and Welfare-Maximizing Dynamic Pricing for Energy Sharing
Ahmed S. Alahmed, Guido Cavraro, Andrey Bernstein, Lang Tong
0
0
The proliferation of behind-the-meter (BTM) distributed energy resources (DER) within the electrical distribution network presents significant supply and demand flexibilities, but also introduces operational challenges such as voltage spikes and reverse power flows. In response, this paper proposes a network-aware dynamic pricing framework tailored for energy-sharing coalitions that aggregate small, but ubiquitous, BTM DER downstream of a distribution system operator's (DSO) revenue meter that adopts a generic net energy metering (NEM) tariff. By formulating a Stackelberg game between the energy-sharing market leader and its prosumers, we show that the dynamic pricing policy induces the prosumers toward a network-safe operation and decentrally maximizes the energy-sharing social welfare. The dynamic pricing mechanism involves a combination of a locational {em ex-ante} dynamic price and an {em ex-post} allocation, both of which are functions of the energy sharing's BTM DER. The {em ex-post} allocation is proportionate to the price differential between the DSO NEM price and the energy sharing locational price. Simulation results using real DER data and the IEEE 13-bus test systems illustrate the dynamic nature of network-aware pricing at each bus, and its impact on voltage.
4/4/2024
Proactive Load-Shaping Strategies with Privacy-Cost Trade-offs in Residential Households based on Deep Reinforcement Learning
Ruichang Zhang, Youcheng Sun, Mustafa A. Mustafa
0
0
Smart meters play a crucial role in enhancing energy management and efficiency, but they raise significant privacy concerns by potentially revealing detailed user behaviors through energy consumption patterns. Recent scholarly efforts have focused on developing battery-aided load-shaping techniques to protect user privacy while balancing costs. This paper proposes a novel deep reinforcement learning-based load-shaping algorithm (PLS-DQN) designed to protect user privacy by proactively creating artificial load signatures that mislead potential attackers. We evaluate our proposed algorithm against a non-intrusive load monitoring (NILM) adversary. The results demonstrate that our approach not only effectively conceals real energy usage patterns but also outperforms state-of-the-art methods in enhancing user privacy while maintaining cost efficiency.
5/30/2024
š
Adaptive Incentive Design with Learning Agents
Chinmay Maheshwari, Kshitij Kulkarni, Manxi Wu, Shankar Sastry
0
0
How can the system operator learn an incentive mechanism that achieves social optimality based on limited information about the agents' behavior, who are dynamically updating their strategies? To answer this question, we propose an emph{adaptive} incentive mechanism. This mechanism updates the incentives of agents based on the feedback of each agent's externality, evaluated as the difference between the player's marginal cost and society's marginal cost at each time step. The proposed mechanism updates the incentives on a slower timescale compared to the agents' learning dynamics, resulting in a two-timescale coupled dynamical system. Notably, this mechanism is agnostic to the specific learning dynamics used by agents to update their strategies. We show that any fixed point of this adaptive incentive mechanism corresponds to the optimal incentive mechanism, ensuring that the Nash equilibrium coincides with the socially optimal strategy. Additionally, we provide sufficient conditions that guarantee the convergence of the adaptive incentive mechanism to a fixed point. Our results apply to both atomic and non-atomic games. To demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed mechanism, we verify the convergence conditions in two practically relevant games: atomic networked quadratic aggregative games and non-atomic network routing games.
5/28/2024
šÆ
Learning a Reward Function for User-Preferred Appliance Scheduling
Nikolina v{C}ovi'c, Jochen L. Cremer, Hrvoje Pandv{z}i'c
0
0
Accelerated development of demand response service provision by the residential sector is crucial for reducing carbon-emissions in the power sector. Along with the infrastructure advancement, encouraging the end users to participate is crucial. End users highly value their privacy and control, and want to be included in the service design and decision-making process when creating the daily appliance operation schedules. Furthermore, unless they are financially or environmentally motivated, they are generally not prepared to sacrifice their comfort to help balance the power system. In this paper, we present an inverse-reinforcement-learning-based model that helps create the end users' daily appliance schedules without asking them to explicitly state their needs and wishes. By using their past consumption data, the end consumers will implicitly participate in the creation of those decisions and will thus be motivated to continue participating in the provision of demand response services.
6/11/2024