Solving Collaborative Dec-POMDPs with Deep Reinforcement Learning Heuristics
2211.15411
0
0
🤿
Abstract
WQMIX, QMIX, QTRAN, and VDN are SOTA algorithms for Dec-POMDP. All of them cannot solve complex agents' cooperation domains. We give an algorithm to solve such problems. In the first stage, we solve a single-agent problem and get a policy. In the second stage, we solve the multi-agent problem with the single-agent policy. SA2MA has a clear advantage over all competitors in complex agents' cooperative domains.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper introduces a new algorithm called SA2MA to solve complex cooperation problems among agents in Dec-POMDP settings.
- It compares SA2MA to state-of-the-art algorithms like WQMIX, QMIX, QTRAN, and VDN and claims it outperforms them in complex cooperative domains.
Plain English Explanation
The paper tackles the challenge of getting multiple intelligent agents to work together effectively, which is a common problem in a field called Dec-POMDP. Existing algorithms like WQMIX, QMIX, QTRAN, and VDN struggle to solve complex cooperative problems involving many agents.
The paper proposes a new algorithm called SA2MA that takes a two-stage approach. First, it solves the problem for a single agent, then it uses that solution to help solve the full multi-agent problem. The authors claim this gives SA2MA a clear advantage over the existing algorithms, especially for complex cooperative scenarios.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a new algorithm called SA2MA (Single-Agent to Multi-Agent) to address the limitations of existing state-of-the-art Dec-POMDP algorithms like WQMIX, QMIX, QTRAN, and VDN in complex cooperative domains.
The key idea behind SA2MA is to break down the problem into two stages. In the first stage, it solves a single-agent problem to obtain a policy. In the second stage, it uses that single-agent policy to help solve the full multi-agent problem. The authors claim this approach gives SA2MA a clear advantage over the competing algorithms, especially in complex cooperative scenarios.
The paper includes experiments comparing the performance of SA2MA to the other algorithms across various Dec-POMDP environments. The results show that SA2MA outperforms the state-of-the-art methods, demonstrating its effectiveness in solving complex cooperative problems.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a compelling solution to the challenge of multi-agent cooperation in Dec-POMDP settings. The key innovation of the SA2MA algorithm, breaking the problem into a two-stage approach, seems promising and the experimental results support its advantages over existing methods.
However, the paper does not address potential limitations or caveats of the SA2MA approach. For example, it would be helpful to understand how the performance of SA2MA scales as the number of agents or the complexity of the environment increases. Additionally, the paper could explore potential drawbacks or failure modes of the two-stage design.
Further research could also investigate the generalizability of SA2MA to a wider range of multi-agent cooperation problems beyond the Dec-POMDP domain. Exploring the algorithm's performance in other settings or its extensibility to related problem formulations could help establish its broader applicability.
Overall, the paper presents a valuable contribution to the field of multi-agent reinforcement learning and warrants further investigation and development.
Conclusion
The paper introduces a new algorithm called SA2MA that demonstrates clear advantages over state-of-the-art methods for solving complex cooperative problems in Dec-POMDP settings. By taking a two-stage approach of first solving a single-agent problem and then leveraging that solution to tackle the full multi-agent problem, SA2MA outperforms existing algorithms like WQMIX, QMIX, QTRAN, and VDN.
This research represents a valuable contribution to the field of multi-agent reinforcement learning and could have significant implications for the development of more effective cooperative AI systems. Further exploration of the SA2MA algorithm's capabilities, limitations, and broader applicability could lead to even more exciting advancements in this important area of study.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🛠️
Optimizing Agent Collaboration through Heuristic Multi-Agent Planning
Nitsan Soffair
0
0
The SOTA algorithms for addressing QDec-POMDP issues, QDec-FP and QDec-FPS, are unable to effectively tackle problems that involve different types of sensing agents. We propose a new algorithm that addresses this issue by requiring agents to adopt the same plan if one agent is unable to take a sensing action but the other can. Our algorithm performs significantly better than both QDec-FP and QDec-FPS in these types of situations.
6/4/2024
Approximate Dec-POMDP Solving Using Multi-Agent A*
Wietze Koops, Sebastian Junges, Nils Jansen
0
0
We present an A*-based algorithm to compute policies for finite-horizon Dec-POMDPs. Our goal is to sacrifice optimality in favor of scalability for larger horizons. The main ingredients of our approach are (1) using clustered sliding window memory, (2) pruning the A* search tree, and (3) using novel A* heuristics. Our experiments show competitive performance to the state-of-the-art. Moreover, for multiple benchmarks, we achieve superior performance. In addition, we provide an A* algorithm that finds upper bounds for the optimum, tailored towards problems with long horizons. The main ingredient is a new heuristic that periodically reveals the state, thereby limiting the number of reachable beliefs. Our experiments demonstrate the efficacy and scalability of the approach.
5/10/2024
Prioritized Soft Q-Decomposition for Lexicographic Reinforcement Learning
Finn Rietz, Erik Schaffernicht, Stefan Heinrich, Johannes Andreas Stork
0
0
Reinforcement learning (RL) for complex tasks remains a challenge, primarily due to the difficulties of engineering scalar reward functions and the inherent inefficiency of training models from scratch. Instead, it would be better to specify complex tasks in terms of elementary subtasks and to reuse subtask solutions whenever possible. In this work, we address continuous space lexicographic multi-objective RL problems, consisting of prioritized subtasks, which are notoriously difficult to solve. We show that these can be scalarized with a subtask transformation and then solved incrementally using value decomposition. Exploiting this insight, we propose prioritized soft Q-decomposition (PSQD), a novel algorithm for learning and adapting subtask solutions under lexicographic priorities in continuous state-action spaces. PSQD offers the ability to reuse previously learned subtask solutions in a zero-shot composition, followed by an adaptation step. Its ability to use retained subtask training data for offline learning eliminates the need for new environment interaction during adaptation. We demonstrate the efficacy of our approach by presenting successful learning, reuse, and adaptation results for both low- and high-dimensional simulated robot control tasks, as well as offline learning results. In contrast to baseline approaches, PSQD does not trade off between conflicting subtasks or priority constraints and satisfies subtask priorities during learning. PSQD provides an intuitive framework for tackling complex RL problems, offering insights into the inner workings of the subtask composition.
5/3/2024
N-Agent Ad Hoc Teamwork
Caroline Wang, Arrasy Rahman, Ishan Durugkar, Elad Liebman, Peter Stone
0
0
Current approaches to learning cooperative behaviors in multi-agent settings assume relatively restrictive settings. In standard fully cooperative multi-agent reinforcement learning, the learning algorithm controls textit{all} agents in the scenario, while in ad hoc teamwork, the learning algorithm usually assumes control over only a $textit{single}$ agent in the scenario. However, many cooperative settings in the real world are much less restrictive. For example, in an autonomous driving scenario, a company might train its cars with the same learning algorithm, yet once on the road, these cars must cooperate with cars from another company. Towards generalizing the class of scenarios that cooperative learning methods can address, we introduce $N$-agent ad hoc teamwork, in which a set of autonomous agents must interact and cooperate with dynamically varying numbers and types of teammates at evaluation time. This paper formalizes the problem, and proposes the $textit{Policy Optimization with Agent Modelling}$ (POAM) algorithm. POAM is a policy gradient, multi-agent reinforcement learning approach to the NAHT problem, that enables adaptation to diverse teammate behaviors by learning representations of teammate behaviors. Empirical evaluation on StarCraft II tasks shows that POAM improves cooperative task returns compared to baseline approaches, and enables out-of-distribution generalization to unseen teammates.
4/17/2024