N-Agent Ad Hoc Teamwork
2404.10740
0
0
Abstract
Current approaches to learning cooperative behaviors in multi-agent settings assume relatively restrictive settings. In standard fully cooperative multi-agent reinforcement learning, the learning algorithm controls textit{all} agents in the scenario, while in ad hoc teamwork, the learning algorithm usually assumes control over only a $textit{single}$ agent in the scenario. However, many cooperative settings in the real world are much less restrictive. For example, in an autonomous driving scenario, a company might train its cars with the same learning algorithm, yet once on the road, these cars must cooperate with cars from another company. Towards generalizing the class of scenarios that cooperative learning methods can address, we introduce $N$-agent ad hoc teamwork, in which a set of autonomous agents must interact and cooperate with dynamically varying numbers and types of teammates at evaluation time. This paper formalizes the problem, and proposes the $textit{Policy Optimization with Agent Modelling}$ (POAM) algorithm. POAM is a policy gradient, multi-agent reinforcement learning approach to the NAHT problem, that enables adaptation to diverse teammate behaviors by learning representations of teammate behaviors. Empirical evaluation on StarCraft II tasks shows that POAM improves cooperative task returns compared to baseline approaches, and enables out-of-distribution generalization to unseen teammates.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces the N-Agent Ad Hoc Teamwork (NAHT) problem, which explores how a team of AI agents can collaborate effectively without prior coordination.
- The NAHT problem is motivated by real-world scenarios where agents must work together to achieve a common goal, but may have limited knowledge of each other's capabilities and strategies.
- The paper proposes a novel framework for tackling the NAHT problem, which involves developing adaptive agents that can quickly learn to coordinate and cooperate with unfamiliar teammates.
Plain English Explanation
The paper is about a problem in AI called "N-Agent Ad Hoc Teamwork" (NAHT). This problem looks at how a group of AI agents can work together effectively, even if they haven't coordinated beforehand.
This is an important issue because in the real world, there are many situations where different AI systems or robots might need to collaborate to achieve a common goal, but they may not have much information about each other's abilities or how they operate. The paper aims to develop a framework that allows these AI agents to quickly learn how to coordinate and cooperate with unfamiliar teammates.
The key idea is to create "adaptive" agents that can adjust their behavior and strategies on the fly in order to work well with whomever they're teamed up with, even if that changes over time. This could have applications in areas like smart help, collaborative beamforming, and multi-agent planning.
Technical Explanation
The paper formulates the NAHT problem as a cooperative multi-agent decision-making scenario, where a team of agents must work together to achieve a shared objective, but they have limited prior coordination or knowledge of each other's capabilities.
The key technical contribution is a novel framework for developing "adaptive" agents that can learn to coordinate and cooperate effectively with unfamiliar teammates. This involves:
- Modeling the NAHT problem as a partially observable Markov decision process (POMDP) that captures the uncertainty about teammates' strategies and capabilities.
- Designing learning algorithms that allow agents to quickly adapt their behavior based on observations of their teammates' actions and the team's joint performance.
- Incorporating strategic reasoning capabilities that enable agents to anticipate their teammates' likely actions and plan accordingly.
The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of this approach through experiments in simulated multi-agent domains, showing that the adaptive agents can outperform non-adaptive baselines in terms of task completion and team performance.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a valuable contribution by formalizing the NAHT problem and proposing a principled framework for addressing it. However, the authors acknowledge several limitations and avenues for future research:
- The experiments are limited to relatively simple scenarios, and it's unclear how well the approach would scale to more complex, real-world settings with a larger number of agents and environmental dynamics.
- The learning and adaptation mechanisms rely on having a model of the POMDP environment, which may not always be available in practice. Developing model-free approaches could broaden the applicability of the framework.
- The paper focuses on cooperative scenarios, but many real-world multi-agent interactions involve elements of competition or mixed motives. Extending the framework to handle these more adversarial settings would be an important next step.
Overall, the NAHT problem and the proposed solution represent an important step towards more flexible and robust multi-agent collaboration. However, as with any research, there are opportunities to build upon this work and address its current limitations, as highlighted by the authors' own discussion of future directions.
Conclusion
This paper introduces the N-Agent Ad Hoc Teamwork (NAHT) problem, which explores how AI agents can effectively collaborate without prior coordination. The authors propose a novel framework for developing "adaptive" agents that can quickly learn to coordinate and cooperate with unfamiliar teammates, demonstrating promising results in simulated experiments.
The NAHT problem and the proposed solution have significant implications for the field of multi-agent systems, with potential applications in areas like strategic opponent modeling, collaborative beamforming, and adaptive multi-agent planning. As the authors note, there are still opportunities to further develop and refine the framework, but this work represents an important step towards more flexible and robust multi-agent collaboration.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Open Ad Hoc Teamwork with Cooperative Game Theory
Jianhong Wang, Yang Li, Yuan Zhang, Wei Pan, Samuel Kaski
0
0
Ad hoc teamwork poses a challenging problem, requiring the design of an agent to collaborate with teammates without prior coordination or joint training. Open ad hoc teamwork (OAHT) further complicates this challenge by considering environments with a changing number of teammates, referred to as open teams. One promising solution in practice to this problem is leveraging the generalizability of graph neural networks to handle an unrestricted number of agents with various agent-types, named graph-based policy learning (GPL). However, its joint Q-value representation over a coordination graph lacks convincing explanations. In this paper, we establish a new theory to understand the representation of the joint Q-value for OAHT and its learning paradigm, through the lens of cooperative game theory. Building on our theory, we propose a novel algorithm named CIAO, based on GPL's framework, with additional provable implementation tricks that can facilitate learning. The demos of experimental results are available on https://sites.google.com/view/ciao2024, and the code of experiments is published on https://github.com/hsvgbkhgbv/CIAO.
6/12/2024
Leveraging Large Language Model for Heterogeneous Ad Hoc Teamwork Collaboration
Xinzhu Liu, Peiyan Li, Wenju Yang, Di Guo, Huaping Liu
0
0
Compared with the widely investigated homogeneous multi-robot collaboration, heterogeneous robots with different capabilities can provide a more efficient and flexible collaboration for more complex tasks. In this paper, we consider a more challenging heterogeneous ad hoc teamwork collaboration problem where an ad hoc robot joins an existing heterogeneous team for a shared goal. Specifically, the ad hoc robot collaborates with unknown teammates without prior coordination, and it is expected to generate an appropriate cooperation policy to improve the efficiency of the whole team. To solve this challenging problem, we leverage the remarkable potential of the large language model (LLM) to establish a decentralized heterogeneous ad hoc teamwork collaboration framework that focuses on generating reasonable policy for an ad hoc robot to collaborate with original heterogeneous teammates. A training-free hierarchical dynamic planner is developed using the LLM together with the newly proposed Interactive Reflection of Thoughts (IRoT) method for the ad hoc agent to adapt to different teams. We also build a benchmark testing dataset to evaluate the proposed framework in the heterogeneous ad hoc multi-agent tidying-up task. Extensive comparison and ablation experiments are conducted in the benchmark to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed framework. We have also employed the proposed framework in physical robots in a real-world scenario. The experimental videos can be found at https://youtu.be/wHYP5T2WIp0.
6/19/2024
Aligning Individual and Collective Objectives in Multi-Agent Cooperation
Yang Li, Wenhao Zhang, Jianhong Wang, Shao Zhang, Yali Du, Ying Wen, Wei Pan
0
0
Among the research topics in multi-agent learning, mixed-motive cooperation is one of the most prominent challenges, primarily due to the mismatch between individual and collective goals. The cutting-edge research is focused on incorporating domain knowledge into rewards and introducing additional mechanisms to incentivize cooperation. However, these approaches often face shortcomings such as the effort on manual design and the absence of theoretical groundings. To close this gap, we model the mixed-motive game as a differentiable game for the ease of illuminating the learning dynamics towards cooperation. More detailed, we introduce a novel optimization method named textbf{textit{A}}ltruistic textbf{textit{G}}radient textbf{textit{A}}djustment (textbf{textit{AgA}}) that employs gradient adjustments to progressively align individual and collective objectives. Furthermore, we theoretically prove that AgA effectively attracts gradients to stable fixed points of the collective objective while considering individual interests, and we validate these claims with empirical evidence. We evaluate the effectiveness of our algorithm AgA through benchmark environments for testing mixed-motive collaboration with small-scale agents such as the two-player public good game and the sequential social dilemma games, Cleanup and Harvest, as well as our self-developed large-scale environment in the game StarCraft II.
5/24/2024
Efficient Adaptation in Mixed-Motive Environments via Hierarchical Opponent Modeling and Planning
Yizhe Huang, Anji Liu, Fanqi Kong, Yaodong Yang, Song-Chun Zhu, Xue Feng
0
0
Despite the recent successes of multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) algorithms, efficiently adapting to co-players in mixed-motive environments remains a significant challenge. One feasible approach is to hierarchically model co-players' behavior based on inferring their characteristics. However, these methods often encounter difficulties in efficient reasoning and utilization of inferred information. To address these issues, we propose Hierarchical Opponent modeling and Planning (HOP), a novel multi-agent decision-making algorithm that enables few-shot adaptation to unseen policies in mixed-motive environments. HOP is hierarchically composed of two modules: an opponent modeling module that infers others' goals and learns corresponding goal-conditioned policies, and a planning module that employs Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) to identify the best response. Our approach improves efficiency by updating beliefs about others' goals both across and within episodes and by using information from the opponent modeling module to guide planning. Experimental results demonstrate that in mixed-motive environments, HOP exhibits superior few-shot adaptation capabilities when interacting with various unseen agents, and excels in self-play scenarios. Furthermore, the emergence of social intelligence during our experiments underscores the potential of our approach in complex multi-agent environments.
6/13/2024