Solving Dense Linear Systems Faster Than via Preconditioning
0
📉
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a new approach to solving dense linear systems more efficiently than traditional preconditioning methods.
- The authors propose a fast matrix norm approximation technique that can be used to construct effective preconditioners, leading to faster convergence of iterative solvers.
- The research builds on prior work on fast multiplication of random dense matrices and low-bandwidth matrix multiplication.
Plain English Explanation
Solving large, complex linear systems is a common challenge in many fields, from engineering to scientific computing. Traditional methods often rely on preconditioning techniques to improve the convergence of iterative solvers, but these can be computationally expensive.
The key insight of this paper is that by using a fast approximation of the matrix norm, the authors can construct more effective preconditioners that lead to faster convergence. This is based on the idea that the matrix norm provides important information about the structure and conditioning of the linear system, which can be leveraged to guide the iterative solver.
To illustrate, imagine you're trying to push a heavy object across a room. The matrix norm would be like measuring the object's weight - this gives you a sense of how much force you'll need to apply. With this information, you can adjust your approach and use the right tools (like a dolly or lever) to make the task easier. Similarly, the fast matrix norm approximation allows the iterative solver to "feel out" the problem and adapt its strategy accordingly, leading to faster convergence.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach through theoretical analysis and extensive experiments, showing significant speedups compared to traditional preconditioning techniques. This work has the potential to unlock new possibilities in fields that rely on solving large, dense linear systems, such as machine learning, scientific modeling, and data analysis.
Technical Explanation
The core technical contribution of this paper is a fast matrix norm approximation technique that can be used to construct effective preconditioners for iterative solvers.
The authors start by analyzing the properties of matrix norm approximation and showing how it can be leveraged to improve the convergence of iterative methods. They then present a novel algorithm for approximating the matrix norm in O(n^2) time, which is significantly faster than the O(n^3) complexity of exact computation.
The key innovation is the use of random projections to estimate the matrix norm. By projecting the matrix onto a lower-dimensional space, the authors can compute an approximation that is both fast and accurate enough to guide the iterative solver. This builds on prior work on fast multiplication of random dense matrices and low-bandwidth matrix multiplication.
The authors also provide a theoretical analysis of their approach, proving bounds on the accuracy of the matrix norm approximation and the resulting speedup in convergence. They then validate their method through extensive experiments on a variety of linear systems, including both synthetic and real-world datasets.
Critical Analysis
The research presented in this paper is a significant contribution to the field of numerical linear algebra, with the potential to unlock new possibilities in a wide range of applications. The authors have demonstrated the effectiveness of their approach through rigorous theoretical analysis and comprehensive experimentation.
One potential limitation is the reliance on random projections, which could be sensitive to the specific distribution of the input matrix. The authors acknowledge this and suggest that further research is needed to understand the optimal choice of projection matrices for different problem domains.
Additionally, the paper does not address the potential impact of numerical instability or round-off errors, which can be a concern when working with approximate methods. While the authors provide theoretical bounds on the accuracy of their approximation, it would be valuable to see a more in-depth discussion of the practical implications and potential mitigation strategies.
Overall, this work represents an exciting step forward in the quest to solve large, dense linear systems more efficiently. The authors' novel approach to matrix norm approximation is a clever and well-executed idea that deserves close attention from researchers and practitioners in the field.
Conclusion
This paper presents a new method for solving dense linear systems more efficiently than traditional preconditioning techniques. By leveraging a fast matrix norm approximation, the authors are able to construct effective preconditioners that lead to faster convergence of iterative solvers.
The theoretical analysis and extensive experiments showcase the potential of this approach to unlock new possibilities in a wide range of applications, from machine learning and scientific modeling to data analysis and beyond. While there are some limitations and areas for further research, this work represents a significant contribution to the field of numerical linear algebra and is sure to inspire further innovations in this important area of study.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📉
0
Solving Dense Linear Systems Faster Than via Preconditioning
Micha{l} Derezi'nski, Jiaming Yang
We give a stochastic optimization algorithm that solves a dense $ntimes n$ real-valued linear system $Ax=b$, returning $tilde x$ such that $|Atilde x-b|leq epsilon|b|$ in time: $$tilde O((n^2+nk^{omega-1})log1/epsilon),$$ where $k$ is the number of singular values of $A$ larger than $O(1)$ times its smallest positive singular value, $omega < 2.372$ is the matrix multiplication exponent, and $tilde O$ hides a poly-logarithmic in $n$ factor. When $k=O(n^{1-theta})$ (namely, $A$ has a flat-tailed spectrum, e.g., due to noisy data or regularization), this improves on both the cost of solving the system directly, as well as on the cost of preconditioning an iterative method such as conjugate gradient. In particular, our algorithm has an $tilde O(n^2)$ runtime when $k=O(n^{0.729})$. We further adapt this result to sparse positive semidefinite matrices and least squares regression. Our main algorithm can be viewed as a randomized block coordinate descent method, where the key challenge is simultaneously ensuring good convergence and fast per-iteration time. In our analysis, we use theory of majorization for elementary symmetric polynomials to establish a sharp convergence guarantee when coordinate blocks are sampled using a determinantal point process. We then use a Markov chain coupling argument to show that similar convergence can be attained with a cheaper sampling scheme, and accelerate the block coordinate descent update via matrix sketching.
Read more6/10/2024
🚀
0
Faster Linear Systems and Matrix Norm Approximation via Multi-level Sketched Preconditioning
Micha{l} Derezi'nski, Christopher Musco, Jiaming Yang
We present a new class of preconditioned iterative methods for solving linear systems of the form $Ax = b$. Our methods are based on constructing a low-rank Nystrom approximation to $A$ using sparse random sketching. This approximation is used to construct a preconditioner, which itself is inverted quickly using additional levels of random sketching and preconditioning. We prove that the convergence of our methods depends on a natural average condition number of $A$, which improves as the rank of the Nystrom approximation increases. Concretely, this allows us to obtain faster runtimes for a number of fundamental linear algebraic problems: 1. We show how to solve any $ntimes n$ linear system that is well-conditioned except for $k$ outlying large singular values in $tilde{O}(n^{2.065} + k^omega)$ time, improving on a recent result of [Derezi'nski, Yang, STOC 2024] for all $k gtrsim n^{0.78}$. 2. We give the first $tilde{O}(n^2 + {d_lambda}^{omega}$) time algorithm for solving a regularized linear system $(A + lambda I)x = b$, where $A$ is positive semidefinite with effective dimension $d_lambda$. This problem arises in applications like Gaussian process regression. 3. We give faster algorithms for approximating Schatten $p$-norms and other matrix norms. For example, for the Schatten 1 (nuclear) norm, we give an algorithm that runs in $tilde{O}(n^{2.11})$ time, improving on an $tilde{O}(n^{2.18})$ method of [Musco et al., ITCS 2018]. Interestingly, previous state-of-the-art algorithms for most of the problems above relied on stochastic iterative methods, like stochastic coordinate and gradient descent. Our work takes a completely different approach, instead leveraging tools from matrix sketching.
Read more5/10/2024
📉
0
Fine-grained Analysis and Faster Algorithms for Iteratively Solving Linear Systems
Micha{l} Derezi'nski, Daniel LeJeune, Deanna Needell, Elizaveta Rebrova
While effective in practice, iterative methods for solving large systems of linear equations can be significantly affected by problem-dependent condition number quantities. This makes characterizing their time complexity challenging, particularly when we wish to make comparisons between deterministic and stochastic methods, that may or may not rely on preconditioning and/or fast matrix multiplication. In this work, we consider a fine-grained notion of complexity for iterative linear solvers which we call the spectral tail condition number, $kappa_ell$, defined as the ratio between the $ell$th largest and the smallest singular value of the matrix representing the system. Concretely, we prove the following main algorithmic result: Given an $ntimes n$ matrix $A$ and a vector $b$, we can find $tilde{x}$ such that $|Atilde{x}-b|leqepsilon|b|$ in time $tilde{O}(kappa_ellcdot n^2log 1/epsilon)$ for any $ell = O(n^{frac1{omega-1}})=O(n^{0.729})$, where $omega approx 2.372$ is the current fast matrix multiplication exponent. This guarantee is achieved by Sketch-and-Project with Nesterov's acceleration. Some of the implications of our result, and of the use of $kappa_ell$, include direct improvement over a fine-grained analysis of the Conjugate Gradient method, suggesting a stronger separation between deterministic and stochastic iterative solvers; and relating the complexity of iterative solvers to the ongoing algorithmic advances in fast matrix multiplication, since the bound on $ell$ improves with $omega$. Our main technical contributions are new sharp characterizations for the first and second moments of the random projection matrix that commonly arises in sketching algorithms, building on a combination of techniques from combinatorial sampling via determinantal point processes and Gaussian universality results from random matrix theory.
Read more5/10/2024
🔍
0
A Note on Randomized Kaczmarz Algorithm for Solving Doubly-Noisy Linear Systems
El Houcine Bergou, Soumia Boucherouite, Aritra Dutta, Xin Li, Anna Ma
Large-scale linear systems, $Ax=b$, frequently arise in practice and demand effective iterative solvers. Often, these systems are noisy due to operational errors or faulty data-collection processes. In the past decade, the randomized Kaczmarz (RK) algorithm has been studied extensively as an efficient iterative solver for such systems. However, the convergence study of RK in the noisy regime is limited and considers measurement noise in the right-hand side vector, $b$. Unfortunately, in practice, that is not always the case; the coefficient matrix $A$ can also be noisy. In this paper, we analyze the convergence of RK for {textit{doubly-noisy} linear systems, i.e., when the coefficient matrix, $A$, has additive or multiplicative noise, and $b$ is also noisy}. In our analyses, the quantity $tilde R=| tilde A^{dagger} |^2 |tilde A |_F^2$ influences the convergence of RK, where $tilde A$ represents a noisy version of $A$. We claim that our analysis is robust and realistically applicable, as we do not require information about the noiseless coefficient matrix, $A$, and considering different conditions on noise, we can control the convergence of RK. {We perform numerical experiments to substantiate our theoretical findings.}
Read more8/26/2024