Spectrum-Aware Debiasing: A Modern Inference Framework with Applications to Principal Components Regression

Read original: arXiv:2309.07810 - Published 7/23/2024 by Yufan Li, Pragya Sur

🤯

Overview

Debiasing is a crucial concept in high-dimensional statistics.
Degrees-of-freedom adjustment, the state-of-the-art technique for high-dimensional linear regression, is limited to i.i.d. samples and sub-Gaussian covariates.
This paper introduces a new method called Spectrum-Aware Debiasing, which can handle structured dependencies, heavy tails, and low-rank structures.
The approach uses spectral information from the sample covariance matrix to debias the regression estimates.
The method is shown to achieve asymptotic normality in the common modern regime where the number of features and samples scale proportionally.

Plain English Explanation

In high-dimensional statistics, debiasing is an important problem. The current best technique, degrees-of-freedom adjustment, has some limitations - it only works for data that is independently and identically distributed and has a specific type of distribution (sub-Gaussian). This means it can't be used in many real-world situations.

The researchers in this paper introduce a new method called Spectrum-Aware Debiasing. This approach uses information about the spectrum, or the distribution of the eigenvalues, of the sample covariance matrix to debias the regression estimates. This allows it to work in a much wider range of settings, like when the data has dependencies between the features, heavy-tailed distributions, or low-rank structures.

The key idea is to use the spectral information to determine how much to "rescale" the gradient descent step during the debiasing process. This spectral approach enables accurate debiasing in many more real-world scenarios compared to the previous state-of-the-art method.

The paper also shows that this new estimator has desirable statistical properties - it is asymptotically normal under certain conditions. This means as the sample size gets large, the distribution of the estimates becomes a normal distribution, which is a very useful property. The researchers also provide a way to estimate the asymptotic variance of their estimator.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces Spectrum-Aware Debiasing, a novel method for high-dimensional regression. The key innovation is using the spectral information of the sample covariance matrix to derive a rescaling factor that enables accurate debiasing in a much broader context compared to the state-of-the-art degrees-of-freedom adjustment.

The method works by applying a rescaled gradient descent step during the debiasing process. The rescaling factor is computed using the spectrum of the sample covariance matrix. This spectral approach allows the technique to handle structured dependencies, heavy tails, and low-rank structures in the data, which are limitations of the existing degrees-of-freedom adjustment.

The paper studies the common modern regime where the number of features and samples scale proportionally. Under this setting, and assuming the covariates are right-rotationally invariant, the authors establish the asymptotic normality of their proposed estimator (after suitable centering and scaling). They also provide a consistent estimator for the asymptotic variance of their debiased estimator.

As byproducts, the paper uses Spectrum-Aware Debiasing to debias principal components regression (PCR) in high dimensions, providing the first debiased PCR estimator. It also introduces a principled test for checking the alignment between the signal and the eigenvectors of the sample covariance matrix, which is valuable for methods using approximate message passing, leave-one-out, or convex Gaussian min-max theorems.

The technical contributions include connecting approximate message passing algorithms with debiasing and providing the first proof of the Cauchy property of vector approximate message passing (V-AMP).

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and promising approach to debiasing in high-dimensional regression. The key strength is the ability to handle a much broader set of data structures compared to the previous state-of-the-art degrees-of-freedom adjustment.

One potential limitation is the assumption of right-rotationally invariant covariates, which may not hold in all practical situations. The authors acknowledge this and suggest exploring extensions to more general covariate structures as future work.

Additionally, while the paper provides theoretical guarantees for asymptotic normality, the finite-sample performance of the method is not explored in depth. Validating the practical efficacy of Spectrum-Aware Debiasing through extensive simulations and real-world case studies would strengthen the conclusions.

It would also be valuable to compare the Spectrum-Aware Debiasing approach to other debiasing techniques, such as those based on leave-one-out or convex Gaussian min-max theorems, to better understand its relative strengths and weaknesses.

Overall, this work represents an important advancement in high-dimensional debiasing and opens up several directions for further research and practical applications.

Conclusion

This paper introduces Spectrum-Aware Debiasing, a novel method for high-dimensional regression that addresses the limitations of the current state-of-the-art technique. By leveraging the spectral information of the sample covariance matrix, the method can handle a much broader range of data structures, including structured dependencies, heavy tails, and low-rank structures.

The key innovation is the use of a rescaled gradient descent step, where the rescaling factor is derived from the spectrum of the sample covariance. This spectral approach enables accurate debiasing in many real-world scenarios that were previously out of reach.

The paper establishes the asymptotic normality of the proposed estimator under certain conditions, and also provides a consistent estimator for its asymptotic variance. As byproducts, the method is used to debias principal components regression and introduce a principled test for checking the alignment between the signal and the eigenvectors of the sample covariance matrix.

While the paper has some limitations, such as the assumption of right-rotationally invariant covariates, it represents an important advancement in high-dimensional debiasing with the potential for significant impact in various fields that rely on statistical inference in high-dimensional settings.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🤯

Spectrum-Aware Debiasing: A Modern Inference Framework with Applications to Principal Components Regression

Yufan Li, Pragya Sur

Debiasing is a fundamental concept in high-dimensional statistics. While degrees-of-freedom adjustment is the state-of-the-art technique in high-dimensional linear regression, it is limited to i.i.d. samples and sub-Gaussian covariates. These constraints hinder its broader practical use. Here, we introduce Spectrum-Aware Debiasing--a novel method for high-dimensional regression. Our approach applies to problems with structured dependencies, heavy tails, and low-rank structures. Our method achieves debiasing through a rescaled gradient descent step, deriving the rescaling factor using spectral information of the sample covariance matrix. The spectrum-based approach enables accurate debiasing in much broader contexts. We study the common modern regime where the number of features and samples scale proportionally. We establish asymptotic normality of our proposed estimator (suitably centered and scaled) under various convergence notions when the covariates are right-rotationally invariant. Such designs have garnered recent attention due to their crucial role in compressed sensing. Furthermore, we devise a consistent estimator for its asymptotic variance. Our work has two notable by-products: first, we use Spectrum-Aware Debiasing to correct bias in principal components regression (PCR), providing the first debiased PCR estimator in high dimensions. Second, we introduce a principled test for checking alignment between the signal and the eigenvectors of the sample covariance matrix. This test is independently valuable for statistical methods developed using approximate message passing, leave-one-out, or convex Gaussian min-max theorems. We demonstrate our method through simulated and real data experiments. Technically, we connect approximate message passing algorithms with debiasing and provide the first proof of the Cauchy property of vector approximate message passing (V-AMP).

7/23/2024

A variational Bayes approach to debiased inference for low-dimensional parameters in high-dimensional linear regression

Ismael Castillo, Alice L'Huillier, Kolyan Ray, Luke Travis

We propose a scalable variational Bayes method for statistical inference for a single or low-dimensional subset of the coordinates of a high-dimensional parameter in sparse linear regression. Our approach relies on assigning a mean-field approximation to the nuisance coordinates and carefully modelling the conditional distribution of the target given the nuisance. This requires only a preprocessing step and preserves the computational advantages of mean-field variational Bayes, while ensuring accurate and reliable inference for the target parameter, including for uncertainty quantification. We investigate the numerical performance of our algorithm, showing that it performs competitively with existing methods. We further establish accompanying theoretical guarantees for estimation and uncertainty quantification in the form of a Bernstein--von Mises theorem.

6/19/2024

Towards Real World Debiasing: A Fine-grained Analysis On Spurious Correlation

Zhibo Wang, Peng Kuang, Zhixuan Chu, Jingyi Wang, Kui Ren

Spurious correlations in training data significantly hinder the generalization capability of machine learning models when faced with distribution shifts in real-world scenarios. To tackle the problem, numerous debias approaches have been proposed and benchmarked on datasets intentionally designed with severe biases. However, it remains to be asked: textit{1. Do existing benchmarks really capture biases in the real world? 2. Can existing debias methods handle biases in the real world?} To answer the questions, we revisit biased distributions in existing benchmarks and real-world datasets, and propose a fine-grained framework for analyzing dataset bias by disentangling it into the magnitude and prevalence of bias. We observe and theoretically demonstrate that existing benchmarks poorly represent real-world biases. We further introduce two novel biased distributions to bridge this gap, forming a nuanced evaluation framework for real-world debiasing. Building upon these results, we evaluate existing debias methods with our evaluation framework. Results show that existing methods are incapable of handling real-world biases. Through in-depth analysis, we propose a simple yet effective approach that can be easily applied to existing debias methods, named Debias in Destruction (DiD). Empirical results demonstrate the superiority of DiD, improving the performance of existing methods on all types of biases within the proposed evaluation framework.

5/31/2024

Stability of a Generalized Debiased Lasso with Applications to Resampling-Based Variable Selection

Jingbo Liu

Suppose that we first apply the Lasso to a design matrix, and then update one of its columns. In general, the signs of the Lasso coefficients may change, and there is no closed-form expression for updating the Lasso solution exactly. In this work, we propose an approximate formula for updating a debiased Lasso coefficient. We provide general nonasymptotic error bounds in terms of the norms and correlations of a given design matrix's columns, and then prove asymptotic convergence results for the case of a random design matrix with i.i.d. sub-Gaussian row vectors and i.i.d. Gaussian noise. Notably, the approximate formula is asymptotically correct for most coordinates in the proportional growth regime, under the mild assumption that each row of the design matrix is sub-Gaussian with a covariance matrix having a bounded condition number. Our proof only requires certain concentration and anti-concentration properties to control various error terms and the number of sign changes. In contrast, rigorously establishing distributional limit properties (e.g. Gaussian limits for the debiased Lasso) under similarly general assumptions has been considered open problem in the universality theory. As applications, we show that the approximate formula allows us to reduce the computation complexity of variable selection algorithms that require solving multiple Lasso problems, such as the conditional randomization test and a variant of the knockoff filter.

5/7/2024