On the Stability of Expressive Positional Encodings for Graphs
2310.02579
0
0
🌀
Abstract
Designing effective positional encodings for graphs is key to building powerful graph transformers and enhancing message-passing graph neural networks. Although widespread, using Laplacian eigenvectors as positional encodings faces two fundamental challenges: (1) emph{Non-uniqueness}: there are many different eigendecompositions of the same Laplacian, and (2) emph{Instability}: small perturbations to the Laplacian could result in completely different eigenspaces, leading to unpredictable changes in positional encoding. Despite many attempts to address non-uniqueness, most methods overlook stability, leading to poor generalization on unseen graph structures. We identify the cause of instability to be a hard partition'' of eigenspaces. Hence, we introduce Stable and Expressive Positional Encodings (SPE), an architecture for processing eigenvectors that uses eigenvalues to softly partition'' eigenspaces. SPE is the first architecture that is (1) provably stable, and (2) universally expressive for basis invariant functions whilst respecting all symmetries of eigenvectors. Besides guaranteed stability, we prove that SPE is at least as expressive as existing methods, and highly capable of counting graph structures. Finally, we evaluate the effectiveness of our method on molecular property prediction, and out-of-distribution generalization tasks, finding improved generalization compared to existing positional encoding methods. Our code is available at url{https://github.com/Graph-COM/SPE}.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Positional encodings are crucial for building powerful graph transformers and enhancing message-passing graph neural networks
- Using Laplacian eigenvectors as positional encodings faces two key challenges: non-uniqueness and instability
- Existing methods have tried to address non-uniqueness, but often overlook stability, leading to poor generalization on unseen graph structures
- The paper introduces Stable and Expressive Positional Encodings (SPE), an architecture that addresses both non-uniqueness and instability by "softly partitioning" eigenspaces using eigenvalues
Plain English Explanation
Positional encodings are a way of representing the "position" or structure of a graph, which is key for building advanced graph machine learning models like graph transformers and message-passing graph neural networks. One common way to do this is by using Laplacian eigenvectors, which capture important properties of the graph.
However, this approach faces two major challenges. First, there are many different ways to decompose the Laplacian into eigenvalues and eigenvectors, so the resulting positional encodings are not unique. Second, small changes to the graph can lead to completely different eigenspaces, making the positional encodings unstable and unpredictable.
While some methods have tried to address the non-uniqueness issue, they often overlook the stability problem, which leads to poor performance when applying the models to new, unseen graph structures.
To solve both of these challenges, the researchers introduce Stable and Expressive Positional Encodings (SPE), a new architecture that "softly partitions" the eigenspaces using the eigenvalues. This makes the positional encodings both stable (small changes to the graph won't drastically change them) and universally expressive (able to capture a wide range of graph properties).
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces the Stable and Expressive Positional Encodings (SPE) architecture, which addresses the non-uniqueness and instability challenges of using Laplacian eigenvectors as positional encodings.
The key insight is that the instability issue is caused by a "hard partition" of the eigenspaces, where small changes to the graph can lead to completely different eigenspaces. To fix this, SPE uses the eigenvalues to "softly partition" the eigenspaces, making the positional encodings both stable and universally expressive.
Specifically, SPE is provably stable, meaning small changes to the graph won't drastically change the positional encodings. It is also at least as expressive as existing methods, and can effectively capture a wide range of graph structures, including being highly capable of counting graph motifs.
The researchers evaluate SPE on molecular property prediction and out-of-distribution generalization tasks, finding that it outperforms existing positional encoding methods in terms of generalization performance.
Critical Analysis
The paper thoroughly addresses the key limitations of using Laplacian eigenvectors as positional encodings, and provides a novel solution in the form of the SPE architecture. The stability and expressiveness guarantees are particularly compelling, as they directly tackle the shortcomings of prior approaches.
That said, the paper does not delve into the computational complexity or training requirements of SPE compared to other methods. Additionally, while the evaluation on molecular and out-of-distribution tasks is promising, it would be valuable to see how SPE performs on a wider range of graph learning benchmarks and real-world applications.
Further research could also explore the potential trade-offs or complementary strengths between SPE and other position encoding approaches, or investigate ways to combine SPE with advanced graph neural network architectures for even more powerful and robust graph representation learning.
Conclusion
The Stable and Expressive Positional Encodings (SPE) architecture introduced in this paper represents a significant advance in graph representation learning. By addressing the key challenges of non-uniqueness and instability in Laplacian eigenvector-based positional encodings, SPE enables more reliable and generalizable graph transformers and message-passing neural networks.
The theoretical guarantees of stability and expressiveness, along with the empirical improvements on benchmark tasks, suggest that SPE could have a substantial impact on a wide range of graph-based machine learning applications, from material science and drug discovery to social network analysis and recommendation systems. As the field of graph learning continues to evolve, techniques like SPE will be crucial for building powerful and robust models that can handle the complexity and diversity of real-world graph data.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
✨
Graph Transformers without Positional Encodings
Ayush Garg
0
0
Recently, Transformers for graph representation learning have become increasingly popular, achieving state-of-the-art performance on a wide-variety of graph datasets, either alone or in combination with message-passing graph neural networks (MP-GNNs). Infusing graph inductive-biases in the innately structure-agnostic transformer architecture in the form of structural or positional encodings (PEs) is key to achieving these impressive results. However, designing such encodings is tricky and disparate attempts have been made to engineer such encodings including Laplacian eigenvectors, relative random-walk probabilities (RRWP), spatial encodings, centrality encodings, edge encodings etc. In this work, we argue that such encodings may not be required at all, provided the attention mechanism itself incorporates information about the graph structure. We introduce Eigenformer, a Graph Transformer employing a novel spectrum-aware attention mechanism cognizant of the Laplacian spectrum of the graph, and empirically show that it achieves performance competetive with SOTA Graph Transformers on a number of standard GNN benchmarks. Additionally, we theoretically prove that Eigenformer can express various graph structural connectivity matrices, which is particularly essential when learning over smaller graphs.
5/7/2024
On the Expressive Power of Spectral Invariant Graph Neural Networks
Bohang Zhang, Lingxiao Zhao, Haggai Maron
0
0
Incorporating spectral information to enhance Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) has shown promising results but raises a fundamental challenge due to the inherent ambiguity of eigenvectors. Various architectures have been proposed to address this ambiguity, referred to as spectral invariant architectures. Notable examples include GNNs and Graph Transformers that use spectral distances, spectral projection matrices, or other invariant spectral features. However, the potential expressive power of these spectral invariant architectures remains largely unclear. The goal of this work is to gain a deep theoretical understanding of the expressive power obtainable when using spectral features. We first introduce a unified message-passing framework for designing spectral invariant GNNs, called Eigenspace Projection GNN (EPNN). A comprehensive analysis shows that EPNN essentially unifies all prior spectral invariant architectures, in that they are either strictly less expressive or equivalent to EPNN. A fine-grained expressiveness hierarchy among different architectures is also established. On the other hand, we prove that EPNN itself is bounded by a recently proposed class of Subgraph GNNs, implying that all these spectral invariant architectures are strictly less expressive than 3-WL. Finally, we discuss whether using spectral features can gain additional expressiveness when combined with more expressive GNNs.
6/7/2024
🌀
Graph Positional and Structural Encoder
Semih Canturk, Renming Liu, Olivier Lapointe-Gagn'e, Vincent L'etourneau, Guy Wolf, Dominique Beaini, Ladislav Ramp'av{s}ek
0
0
Positional and structural encodings (PSE) enable better identifiability of nodes within a graph, rendering them essential tools for empowering modern GNNs, and in particular graph Transformers. However, designing PSEs that work optimally for all graph prediction tasks is a challenging and unsolved problem. Here, we present the Graph Positional and Structural Encoder (GPSE), the first-ever graph encoder designed to capture rich PSE representations for augmenting any GNN. GPSE learns an efficient common latent representation for multiple PSEs, and is highly transferable: The encoder trained on a particular graph dataset can be used effectively on datasets drawn from markedly different distributions and modalities. We show that across a wide range of benchmarks, GPSE-enhanced models can significantly outperform those that employ explicitly computed PSEs, and at least match their performance in others. Our results pave the way for the development of foundational pre-trained graph encoders for extracting positional and structural information, and highlight their potential as a more powerful and efficient alternative to explicitly computed PSEs and existing self-supervised pre-training approaches. Our framework and pre-trained models are publicly available at https://github.com/G-Taxonomy-Workgroup/GPSE. For convenience, GPSE has also been integrated into the PyG library to facilitate downstream applications.
6/12/2024
Occlusion Handling in 3D Human Pose Estimation with Perturbed Positional Encoding
Niloofar Azizi, Mohsen Fayyaz, Horst Bischof
0
0
Understanding human behavior fundamentally relies on accurate 3D human pose estimation. Graph Convolutional Networks (GCNs) have recently shown promising advancements, delivering state-of-the-art performance with rather lightweight architectures. In the context of graph-structured data, leveraging the eigenvectors of the graph Laplacian matrix for positional encoding is effective. Yet, the approach does not specify how to handle scenarios where edges in the input graph are missing. To this end, we propose a novel positional encoding technique, PerturbPE, that extracts consistent and regular components from the eigenbasis. Our method involves applying multiple perturbations and taking their average to extract the consistent and regular component from the eigenbasis. PerturbPE leverages the Rayleigh-Schrodinger Perturbation Theorem (RSPT) for calculating the perturbed eigenvectors. Employing this labeling technique enhances the robustness and generalizability of the model. Our results support our theoretical findings, e.g. our experimental analysis observed a performance enhancement of up to $12%$ on the Human3.6M dataset in instances where occlusion resulted in the absence of one edge. Furthermore, our novel approach significantly enhances performance in scenarios where two edges are missing, setting a new benchmark for state-of-the-art.
5/28/2024