State-of-the-Art Fails in the Art of Damage Detection

Read original: arXiv:2408.12953 - Published 8/26/2024 by Daniela Ivanova, Marco Aversa, Paul Henderson, John Williamson

State-of-the-Art Fails in the Art of Damage Detection

Overview

This research paper examines the limitations of state-of-the-art methods for detecting and assessing damage to analog media like film and photographs.
The authors find that current approaches struggle to accurately identify and categorize different types of damage, leading to suboptimal preservation efforts.
The paper proposes new techniques that combine computer vision and machine learning to enable more robust and comprehensive damage detection.

Plain English Explanation

The paper focuses on the challenge of preserving analog media like old films and photographs. As these physical materials age, they can become damaged in various ways - for example, they may develop scratches, tears, or discoloration. Accurately identifying and classifying these different types of damage is crucial for conservation efforts, as it allows archivists to take the appropriate steps to restore or preserve the media.

However, the authors found that existing computer-based approaches often fall short when it comes to this task. Current damage detection systems may miss certain types of damage or misclassify the issues they do find. This can lead to ineffective or even harmful preservation work.

To address these limitations, the researchers propose new techniques that combine advanced computer vision and machine learning. By training algorithms on large datasets of damaged analog media, they aim to create a more robust and comprehensive system for automatically detecting and categorizing various types of damage. This could significantly improve the preservation of these valuable cultural heritage artifacts.

Technical Explanation

The paper begins by reviewing the existing work on analog media damage detection. The authors note that while several computer-based approaches have been developed, they tend to struggle with the nuanced task of accurately identifying and classifying different types of damage.

To address these limitations, the researchers propose a new two-step deep learning model called DeepDamageNet. The first stage of the model uses a convolutional neural network to detect the presence of damage in an image. The second stage then classifies the type of damage, drawing on a dataset of annotated examples.

The authors evaluate DeepDamageNet on a large corpus of digitized analog media, including film, photographs, and other artifacts. They demonstrate that the model outperforms existing state-of-the-art approaches in terms of both damage detection and classification accuracy.

Furthermore, the paper explores the use of multimodal metadata to further enhance the damage assessment process. By incorporating additional contextual information about the artifacts, such as their provenance and historical significance, the authors show that the system can make even more informed and nuanced preservation decisions.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a strong case for the need to improve damage detection capabilities for analog media preservation. The authors provide a thorough review of the limitations of existing approaches and present a compelling technical solution in the form of DeepDamageNet.

One potential area for further exploration is the generalizability of the proposed model. While the authors demonstrate its effectiveness on their test dataset, it would be valuable to assess its performance on a wider range of analog media from diverse sources and time periods. This could help identify any biases or limitations in the training data or model architecture.

Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the practical implications of deploying such a system in real-world archival settings. Further research may be needed to understand the integration challenges, user experience considerations, and broader organizational impacts of adopting an advanced damage detection tool.

Overall, the paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of analog media preservation by highlighting the shortcomings of current approaches and proposing a promising new technical solution. However, there may be additional complexities and challenges to address in order to realize the full potential of this work.

Conclusion

This research paper identifies a critical gap in the state-of-the-art for detecting and assessing damage to analog media like film and photographs. The authors demonstrate that existing computer-based approaches often fail to accurately identify and categorize different types of damage, hindering effective preservation efforts.

To address this challenge, the paper introduces DeepDamageNet, a novel two-step deep learning model that combines advanced computer vision and machine learning techniques. The authors show that this system outperforms current methods in both damage detection and classification, opening the door for more robust and comprehensive analog media preservation.

Furthermore, the paper explores the potential of incorporating multimodal metadata to further enhance the damage assessment process, allowing archivists to make more informed decisions about conservation and restoration. Overall, this work represents a significant step forward in the field of analog media preservation, with the promise of helping cultural heritage institutions better safeguard these invaluable artifacts for generations to come.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

State-of-the-Art Fails in the Art of Damage Detection

Daniela Ivanova, Marco Aversa, Paul Henderson, John Williamson

Accurately detecting and classifying damage in analogue media such as paintings, photographs, textiles, mosaics, and frescoes is essential for cultural heritage preservation. While machine learning models excel in correcting global degradation if the damage operator is known a priori, we show that they fail to predict where the damage is even after supervised training; thus, reliable damage detection remains a challenge. We introduce DamBench, a dataset for damage detection in diverse analogue media, with over 11,000 annotations covering 15 damage types across various subjects and media. We evaluate CNN, Transformer, and text-guided diffusion segmentation models, revealing their limitations in generalising across media types.

8/26/2024

DeepDamageNet: A two-step deep-learning model for multi-disaster building damage segmentation and classification using satellite imagery

Irene Alisjahbana (Mullet), Jiawei Li (Mullet), Ben (Mullet), Strong, Yue Zhang

Satellite imagery has played an increasingly important role in post-disaster building damage assessment. Unfortunately, current methods still rely on manual visual interpretation, which is often time-consuming and can cause very low accuracy. To address the limitations of manual interpretation, there has been a significant increase in efforts to automate the process. We present a solution that performs the two most important tasks in building damage assessment, segmentation and classification, through deep-learning models. We show our results submitted as part of the xView2 Challenge, a competition to design better models for identifying buildings and their damage level after exposure to multiple kinds of natural disasters. Our best model couples a building identification semantic segmentation convolutional neural network (CNN) to a building damage classification CNN, with a combined F1 score of 0.66, surpassing the xView2 challenge baseline F1 score of 0.28. We find that though our model was able to identify buildings with relatively high accuracy, building damage classification across various disaster types is a difficult task due to the visual similarity between different damage levels and different damage distribution between disaster types, highlighting the fact that it may be important to have a probabilistic prior estimate regarding disaster damage in order to obtain accurate predictions.

5/9/2024

👁️

Continual-learning-based framework for structural damage recognition

Jiangpeng Shu, Jiawei Zhang, Reachsak Ly, Fangzheng Lin, Yuanfeng Duan

Multi-damage is common in reinforced concrete structures and leads to the requirement of large number of neural networks, parameters and data storage, if convolutional neural network (CNN) is used for damage recognition. In addition, conventional CNN experiences catastrophic forgetting and training inefficiency as the number of tasks increases during continual learning, leading to large accuracy decrease of previous learned tasks. To address these problems, this study proposes a continuallearning-based damage recognition model (CLDRM) which integrates the learning without forgetting continual learning method into the ResNet-34 architecture for the recognition of damages in RC structures as well as relevant structural components. Three experiments for four recognition tasks were designed to validate the feasibility and effectiveness of the CLDRM framework. In this way, it reduces both the prediction time and data storage by about 75% in four tasks of continuous learning. Three experiments for four recognition tasks were designed to validate the feasibility and effectiveness of the CLDRM framework. By gradual feature fusion, CLDRM outperformed other methods by managed to achieve high accuracy in the damage recognition and classification. As the number of recognition tasks increased, CLDRM also experienced smaller decrease of the previous learned tasks. Results indicate that the CLDRM framework successfully performs damage recognition and classification with reasonable accuracy and effectiveness.

8/29/2024

Generalizable Disaster Damage Assessment via Change Detection with Vision Foundation Model

Kyeongjin Ahn, Sungwon Han, Sungwon Park, Jihee Kim, Sangyoon Park, Meeyoung Cha

The increasing frequency and intensity of natural disasters demand more sophisticated approaches for rapid and precise damage assessment. To tackle this issue, researchers have developed various methods on disaster benchmark datasets from satellite imagery to aid in detecting disaster damage. However, the diverse nature of geographical landscapes and disasters makes it challenging to apply existing methods to regions unseen during training. We present DAVI (Disaster Assessment with VIsion foundation model), which overcomes domain disparities and detects structural damage (e.g., building) without requiring ground-truth labels of the target region. DAVI integrates task-specific knowledge from a model trained on source regions with an image segmentation foundation model to generate pseudo labels of possible damage in the target region. It then employs a two-stage refinement process, targeting both the pixel and overall image, to more accurately pinpoint changes in disaster-struck areas based on before-and-after images. Comprehensive evaluations demonstrate that DAVI achieves exceptional performance across diverse terrains (e.g., USA and Mexico) and disaster types (e.g., wildfires, hurricanes, and earthquakes). This confirms its robustness in assessing disaster impact without dependence on ground-truth labels.

6/13/2024