Statistical Distance-Guided Unsupervised Domain Adaptation for Automated Multi-Class Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance Image Quality Assessment

Read original: arXiv:2409.00375 - Published 9/4/2024 by Shahabedin Nabavi, Kian Anvari Hamedani, Mohsen Ebrahimi Moghaddam, Ahmad Ali Abin, Alejandro F. Frangi

🤷

Overview

This paper proposes an unsupervised domain adaptation model for assessing the quality of cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) images.
The model consists of a feature extractor, a label predictor, and a statistical distance estimator.
It aims to overcome the domain shift between labeled source data and unlabeled target data with different statistical distributions.
The model was evaluated on four datasets for identifying four common CMR imaging artifacts: respiratory and cardiac motion, Gibbs ringing, and aliasing.

Plain English Explanation

The researchers developed a machine learning model to automatically assess the quality of cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) images. CMR is a medical imaging technique used to take pictures of the heart and blood vessels. However, these images can sometimes have quality issues, like blurriness or distortion, due to things like patient movement or technical limitations.

To address this, the researchers created a domain adaptation model. This means the model can learn from a set of labeled training images (the source data) and then apply that knowledge to evaluate the quality of new, unlabeled images (the target data) - even if the new images have different statistical properties than the training data.

The model has three main components:

A feature extractor that analyzes the images and identifies important visual characteristics.
A label predictor that uses the extracted features to predict the quality of the images, based on the labeled training data.
A statistical distance estimator that measures how different the features of the new, unlabeled images are compared to the training data. This helps the model adapt to the new data.

The researchers tested this model on four different datasets, looking for four common CMR image quality issues: motion blur, Gibbs ringing (ripple-like artifacts), and aliasing (distortion caused by undersampling). The results showed the model was able to effectively identify these problems, even when applied to new datasets that were quite different from the original training data.

Overall, this research demonstrates a promising approach for automating CMR image quality assessment, which could be useful for clinical workflows or large-scale medical studies, without requiring extensive manual labeling of image data.

Technical Explanation

The proposed model uses an attention-based statistical distance-guided unsupervised domain adaptation approach for multi-class CMR image quality assessment. It consists of three key components:

Feature Extractor: This module extracts visual features from the input CMR images or k-space data (the raw data collected by the MRI scanner).
Label Predictor: This module uses the extracted features to predict the quality labels (e.g., presence of motion blur, Gibbs ringing, aliasing) for the source domain data, which has known labels.
Statistical Distance Estimator: This module approximates the Wasserstein distance between the feature vectors of the source and target domain data in each mini-batch during training. This statistical distance is used to guide the adaptation process.

The model is trained using a combination of cross-entropy loss, center loss, and the estimated Wasserstein distance. This encourages the model to learn features that are both predictive of the source domain labels and invariant to the domain shift between the source and target data.

The researchers evaluated the proposed model on four CMR datasets, both for image-based and k-space-based analysis. The model was able to effectively identify the four common CMR imaging artifacts across these diverse datasets, demonstrating its ability to generalize and adapt to new, unlabeled target domains.

The paper also includes model explainability evaluations and ablation studies, which confirm the importance and effectiveness of the individual model components.

Critical Analysis

The researchers have presented a comprehensive and well-designed study, with a thorough evaluation of their proposed domain adaptation model for CMR image quality assessment. The use of multiple datasets, including both image and k-space data, strengthens the generalizability of the findings.

One potential limitation is the relatively small number of artifact classes (four) considered in this study. While these are common issues, there may be other, rarer artifacts that the model has not been tested on. Expanding the scope to a wider range of quality problems could further demonstrate the model's capabilities.

Additionally, the paper does not provide much discussion on the computational efficiency or inference speed of the model. For real-world clinical applications, these factors may be important considerations.

Another area for further research could be investigating the model's performance on more challenging domain shifts, such as those caused by differences in imaging hardware, patient demographics, or imaging protocols. Pushing the limits of the model's adaptability could lead to even more robust and versatile quality assessment tools.

Overall, this study represents a valuable contribution to the field of medical image analysis, providing a promising approach for automating CMR image quality control in a way that can adapt to diverse data sources without extensive manual labeling.

Conclusion

This research paper proposes an attention-based, statistical distance-guided unsupervised domain adaptation model for assessing the quality of cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) images. The model is able to effectively identify common imaging artifacts, such as motion blur, Gibbs ringing, and aliasing, even when applied to new, unlabeled datasets that differ from the original training data.

The key strengths of this approach are its ability to adapt to domain shifts without requiring exhaustive manual labeling of target data, and its demonstrated performance across a variety of CMR imaging and k-space datasets. This makes the model a promising tool for automating quality control in clinical workflows and large-scale medical studies involving CMR imaging.

While the current scope is limited to four common artifact types, the demonstrated adaptability of the model suggests it could be extended to cover a wider range of quality issues. Further research on computational efficiency and generalization to more challenging domain shifts could also enhance the practical applicability of this approach.

Overall, this study represents an important step forward in developing robust and versatile quality assessment tools for cardiovascular magnetic resonance imaging, with the potential to improve clinical decision-making and research outcomes in this vital field of medical imaging.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🤷

Statistical Distance-Guided Unsupervised Domain Adaptation for Automated Multi-Class Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance Image Quality Assessment

Shahabedin Nabavi, Kian Anvari Hamedani, Mohsen Ebrahimi Moghaddam, Ahmad Ali Abin, Alejandro F. Frangi

This study proposes an attention-based statistical distance-guided unsupervised domain adaptation model for multi-class cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) image quality assessment. The proposed model consists of a feature extractor, a label predictor and a statistical distance estimator. An annotated dataset as the source set and an unlabeled dataset as the target set with different statistical distributions are considered inputs. The statistical distance estimator approximates the Wasserstein distance between the extracted feature vectors from the source and target data in a mini-batch. The label predictor predicts data labels of source data and uses a combinational loss function for training, which includes cross entropy and centre loss functions plus the estimated value of the distance estimator. Four datasets, including imaging and k-space data, were used to evaluate the proposed model in identifying four common CMR imaging artefacts: respiratory and cardiac motions, Gibbs ringing and Aliasing. The results of the extensive experiments showed that the proposed model, both in image and k-space analysis, has an acceptable performance in covering the domain shift between the source and target sets. The model explainability evaluations and the ablation studies confirmed the proper functioning and effectiveness of all the model's modules. The proposed model outperformed the previous studies regarding performance and the number of examined artefacts. The proposed model can be used for CMR post-imaging quality control or in large-scale cohort studies for image and k-space quality assessment due to the appropriate performance in domain shift coverage without a tedious data-labelling process.

9/4/2024

A Domain Adaptation Model for Carotid Ultrasound: Image Harmonization, Noise Reduction, and Impact on Cardiovascular Risk Markers

Mohd Usama, Emma Nyman, Ulf Naslund, Christer Gronlund

Deep learning has been used extensively for medical image analysis applications, assuming the training and test data adhere to the same probability distributions. However, a common challenge arises when dealing with medical images generated by different systems or even the same system with varying parameter settings. Such images often contain diverse textures and noise patterns, violating the assumption. Consequently, models trained on data from one machine or setting usually struggle to perform effectively on data from another. To address this issue in ultrasound images, we proposed a Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) based model in this paper. We formulated image harmonization and denoising tasks as an image-to-image translation task, wherein we modified the texture pattern and reduced noise in Carotid ultrasound images while keeping the image content (the anatomy) unchanged. The performance was evaluated using feature distribution and pixel-space similarity metrics. In addition, blood-to-tissue contrast and influence on computed risk markers (Gray scale median, GSM) were evaluated. The results showed that domain adaptation was achieved in both tasks (histogram correlation 0.920 and 0.844), as compared to no adaptation (0.890 and 0.707), and that the anatomy of the images was retained (structure similarity index measure of the arterial wall 0.71 and 0.80). In addition, the image noise level (contrast) did not change in the image harmonization task (-34.1 vs 35.2 dB) but was improved in the noise reduction task (-23.5 vs -46.7 dB). The model outperformed the CycleGAN in both tasks. Finally, the risk marker GSM increased by 7.6 (p<0.001) in task 1 but not in task 2. We conclude that domain translation models are powerful tools for ultrasound image improvement while retaining the underlying anatomy but that downstream calculations of risk markers may be affected.

7/9/2024

🤷

Unsupervised Domain Adaptation for Low-dose CT Reconstruction via Bayesian Uncertainty Alignment

Kecheng Chen, Jie Liu, Renjie Wan, Victor Ho-Fun Lee, Varut Vardhanabhuti, Hong Yan, Haoliang Li

Low-dose computed tomography (LDCT) image reconstruction techniques can reduce patient radiation exposure while maintaining acceptable imaging quality. Deep learning is widely used in this problem, but the performance of testing data (a.k.a. target domain) is often degraded in clinical scenarios due to the variations that were not encountered in training data (a.k.a. source domain). Unsupervised domain adaptation (UDA) of LDCT reconstruction has been proposed to solve this problem through distribution alignment. However, existing UDA methods fail to explore the usage of uncertainty quantification, which is crucial for reliable intelligent medical systems in clinical scenarios with unexpected variations. Moreover, existing direct alignment for different patients would lead to content mismatch issues. To address these issues, we propose to leverage a probabilistic reconstruction framework to conduct a joint discrepancy minimization between source and target domains in both the latent and image spaces. In the latent space, we devise a Bayesian uncertainty alignment to reduce the epistemic gap between the two domains. This approach reduces the uncertainty level of target domain data, making it more likely to render well-reconstructed results on target domains. In the image space, we propose a sharpness-aware distribution alignment to achieve a match of second-order information, which can ensure that the reconstructed images from the target domain have similar sharpness to normal-dose CT images from the source domain. Experimental results on two simulated datasets and one clinical low-dose imaging dataset show that our proposed method outperforms other methods in quantitative and visualized performance.

6/4/2024

Augmentation-based Unsupervised Cross-Domain Functional MRI Adaptation for Major Depressive Disorder Identification

Yunling Ma, Chaojun Zhang, Xiaochuan Wang, Qianqian Wang, Liang Cao, Limei Zhang, Mingxia Liu

Major depressive disorder (MDD) is a common mental disorder that typically affects a person's mood, cognition, behavior, and physical health. Resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging (rs-fMRI) data are widely used for computer-aided diagnosis of MDD. While multi-site fMRI data can provide more data for training reliable diagnostic models, significant cross-site data heterogeneity would result in poor model generalizability. Many domain adaptation methods are designed to reduce the distributional differences between sites to some extent, but usually ignore overfitting problem of the model on the source domain. Intuitively, target data augmentation can alleviate the overfitting problem by forcing the model to learn more generalized features and reduce the dependence on source domain data. In this work, we propose a new augmentation-based unsupervised cross-domain fMRI adaptation (AUFA) framework for automatic diagnosis of MDD. The AUFA consists of 1) a graph representation learning module for extracting rs-fMRI features with spatial attention, 2) a domain adaptation module for feature alignment between source and target data, 3) an augmentation-based self-optimization module for alleviating model overfitting on the source domain, and 4) a classification module. Experimental results on 1,089 subjects suggest that AUFA outperforms several state-of-the-art methods in MDD identification. Our approach not only reduces data heterogeneity between different sites, but also localizes disease-related functional connectivity abnormalities and provides interpretability for the model.

6/10/2024