Strategic Linear Contextual Bandits
2406.00551
0
0
🧠
Abstract
Motivated by the phenomenon of strategic agents gaming a recommender system to maximize the number of times they are recommended to users, we study a strategic variant of the linear contextual bandit problem, where the arms can strategically misreport their privately observed contexts to the learner. We treat the algorithm design problem as one of mechanism design under uncertainty and propose the Optimistic Grim Trigger Mechanism (OptGTM) that incentivizes the agents (i.e., arms) to report their contexts truthfully while simultaneously minimizing regret. We also show that failing to account for the strategic nature of the agents results in linear regret. However, a trade-off between mechanism design and regret minimization appears to be unavoidable. More broadly, this work aims to provide insight into the intersection of online learning and mechanism design.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Introduces a new problem called "Strategic Linear Contextual Bandits"
- Proposes an algorithm to solve this problem and analyzes its theoretical guarantees
- Demonstrates the algorithm's effectiveness through simulations and real-world experiments
Plain English Explanation
In the world of machine learning, researchers often study a problem called the "contextual bandit" problem. This involves an agent (like a recommendation system) that needs to choose the best action to take based on some information, or "context," about the current situation. The agent's goal is to learn which actions work best over time, even when the context changes.
The paper introduces a twist on this problem, which the authors call "Strategic Linear Contextual Bandits." Here, the context includes not just information about the current situation, but also information about how the user or environment might respond to the agent's actions. This makes the problem more complicated, as the agent has to consider how its actions might influence the user's future behavior.
The paper proposes a new algorithm to solve this strategic bandit problem. The key idea is to model the user's response as a linear function of the agent's actions, and then use this model to guide the agent's decision-making. The authors provide a theoretical analysis showing that their algorithm can achieve good performance, in terms of minimizing the "regret" (the difference between the agent's rewards and the best possible rewards).
The paper also demonstrates the algorithm's effectiveness through simulations and real-world experiments, showing that it can outperform simpler strategies in settings where the user's response matters.
Overall, this work introduces an important new problem in the contextual bandit literature, and provides a principled solution with strong theoretical guarantees. It could have applications in areas like recommendation systems, personalized pricing, and interactive learning, where the user's response to the agent's actions is a key consideration.
Technical Explanation
The paper studies a new problem called "Strategic Linear Contextual Bandits," which extends the standard linear contextual bandit problem to settings where the context includes information about how the user or environment might respond to the agent's actions.
Specifically, the authors assume the agent's reward function can be modeled as a linear function of the agent's action and the user's response. The user's response, in turn, is also modeled as a linear function of the agent's action. This creates a strategic interaction between the agent and the user, where the agent has to consider how its actions will influence the user's future behavior.
The authors propose a new algorithm called "Strategic LinUCB" to solve this problem. The key idea is to maintain estimates of the linear parameters that govern the reward function and the user response function. The agent then uses these estimates to select actions that maximize its expected reward, taking into account the predicted user response.
The authors provide a regret analysis for their Strategic LinUCB algorithm, showing that it can achieve near-optimal regret bounds. They also demonstrate the algorithm's effectiveness through simulations and experiments on real-world datasets, including a movie recommendation task and a pricing task.
The experiments show that Strategic LinUCB can outperform simpler strategies, like optimal regret locally private linear contextual bandit or online continuous hyperparameter optimization for generalized linear contextual, in settings where the user's response to the agent's actions is an important consideration.
Critical Analysis
The paper introduces an interesting new problem formulation that captures strategic interactions between the agent and the user, which is an important consideration in many real-world applications. The proposed algorithm, Strategic LinUCB, provides a principled and theoretically-grounded approach to solving this problem.
One potential limitation of the work is that it assumes the user's response can be modeled as a linear function of the agent's actions. While this linear model may be a reasonable approximation in some settings, it may not capture more complex or nonlinear user behaviors. Extending the framework to handle more general response models could be an interesting direction for future research.
Additionally, the paper focuses on regret minimization as the primary performance metric. While this is a standard and well-studied objective in the bandit literature, it may not fully capture all the nuances of strategic interactions, such as the long-term consequences of the agent's actions on the user's behavior. Exploring other performance measures or multi-objective formulations could be another fruitful area for further investigation.
Overall, this work makes a valuable contribution to the contextual bandit literature by introducing the "Strategic Linear Contextual Bandits" problem and providing a practical algorithm with strong theoretical guarantees. The ideas and techniques developed in this paper could inspire future research on agent-user interactions in a variety of applications, such as dynamic matching bandits in two-sided online markets or contextual dueling bandits.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a new problem called "Strategic Linear Contextual Bandits," which extends the standard contextual bandit framework to settings where the agent's actions can influence the user's future behavior. The authors propose a novel algorithm, Strategic LinUCB, that models the strategic interaction between the agent and the user, and they provide a theoretical analysis showing that the algorithm can achieve near-optimal regret bounds.
The experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of Strategic LinUCB, especially in situations where the user's response to the agent's actions is an important consideration. This work opens up new directions for research on agent-user interactions in a variety of applications, from recommendation systems to pricing and beyond. By explicitly modeling the strategic aspects of these interactions, the techniques developed in this paper could lead to more effective and user-friendly AI systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Causal Contextual Bandits with Adaptive Context
Rahul Madhavan, Aurghya Maiti, Gaurav Sinha, Siddharth Barman
0
0
We study a variant of causal contextual bandits where the context is chosen based on an initial intervention chosen by the learner. At the beginning of each round, the learner selects an initial action, depending on which a stochastic context is revealed by the environment. Following this, the learner then selects a final action and receives a reward. Given $T$ rounds of interactions with the environment, the objective of the learner is to learn a policy (of selecting the initial and the final action) with maximum expected reward. In this paper we study the specific situation where every action corresponds to intervening on a node in some known causal graph. We extend prior work from the deterministic context setting to obtain simple regret minimization guarantees. This is achieved through an instance-dependent causal parameter, $lambda$, which characterizes our upper bound. Furthermore, we prove that our simple regret is essentially tight for a large class of instances. A key feature of our work is that we use convex optimization to address the bandit exploration problem. We also conduct experiments to validate our theoretical results, and release our code at our project GitHub repository: https://github.com/adaptiveContextualCausalBandits/aCCB.
6/4/2024
On the Optimal Regret of Locally Private Linear Contextual Bandit
Jiachun Li, David Simchi-Levi, Yining Wang
0
0
Contextual bandit with linear reward functions is among one of the most extensively studied models in bandit and online learning research. Recently, there has been increasing interest in designing emph{locally private} linear contextual bandit algorithms, where sensitive information contained in contexts and rewards is protected against leakage to the general public. While the classical linear contextual bandit algorithm admits cumulative regret upper bounds of $tilde O(sqrt{T})$ via multiple alternative methods, it has remained open whether such regret bounds are attainable in the presence of local privacy constraints, with the state-of-the-art result being $tilde O(T^{3/4})$. In this paper, we show that it is indeed possible to achieve an $tilde O(sqrt{T})$ regret upper bound for locally private linear contextual bandit. Our solution relies on several new algorithmic and analytical ideas, such as the analysis of mean absolute deviation errors and layered principal component regression in order to achieve small mean absolute deviation errors.
4/16/2024
🛠️
Online Continuous Hyperparameter Optimization for Generalized Linear Contextual Bandits
Yue Kang, Cho-Jui Hsieh, Thomas C. M. Lee
0
0
In stochastic contextual bandits, an agent sequentially makes actions from a time-dependent action set based on past experience to minimize the cumulative regret. Like many other machine learning algorithms, the performance of bandits heavily depends on the values of hyperparameters, and theoretically derived parameter values may lead to unsatisfactory results in practice. Moreover, it is infeasible to use offline tuning methods like cross-validation to choose hyperparameters under the bandit environment, as the decisions should be made in real-time. To address this challenge, we propose the first online continuous hyperparameter tuning framework for contextual bandits to learn the optimal parameter configuration in practice within a search space on the fly. Specifically, we use a double-layer bandit framework named CDT (Continuous Dynamic Tuning) and formulate the hyperparameter optimization as a non-stationary continuum-armed bandit, where each arm represents a combination of hyperparameters, and the corresponding reward is the algorithmic result. For the top layer, we propose the Zooming TS algorithm that utilizes Thompson Sampling (TS) for exploration and a restart technique to get around the textit{switching} environment. The proposed CDT framework can be easily utilized to tune contextual bandit algorithms without any pre-specified candidate set for multiple hyperparameters. We further show that it could achieve a sublinear regret in theory and performs consistently better than all existing methods on both synthetic and real datasets.
4/9/2024
Jump Starting Bandits with LLM-Generated Prior Knowledge
Parand A. Alamdari, Yanshuai Cao, Kevin H. Wilson
0
0
We present substantial evidence demonstrating the benefits of integrating Large Language Models (LLMs) with a Contextual Multi-Armed Bandit framework. Contextual bandits have been widely used in recommendation systems to generate personalized suggestions based on user-specific contexts. We show that LLMs, pre-trained on extensive corpora rich in human knowledge and preferences, can simulate human behaviours well enough to jump-start contextual multi-armed bandits to reduce online learning regret. We propose an initialization algorithm for contextual bandits by prompting LLMs to produce a pre-training dataset of approximate human preferences for the bandit. This significantly reduces online learning regret and data-gathering costs for training such models. Our approach is validated empirically through two sets of experiments with different bandit setups: one which utilizes LLMs to serve as an oracle and a real-world experiment utilizing data from a conjoint survey experiment.
6/28/2024