Sum of Squares Circuits
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper discusses the expressive power of "structured-decomposable monotonic circuits" compared to a single squared circuit with real parameters.
- The authors show that structured-decomposable monotonic circuits can be exponentially more expressive than a single squared circuit.
- The authors introduce a class of circuits called "Inception PCs" to overcome this limitation, similar to their "sum of compatible squares" model class.
- The results were obtained concurrently with independent work by Wang and Van den Broeck (2024).
Plain English Explanation
The paper examines a specific type of mathematical model called a "structured-decomposable monotonic circuit." These circuits can be used to represent and work with certain types of data or information. The authors show that these circuits can be much more expressive and powerful than a simpler model called a "single squared circuit with real parameters."
To explain this further, the authors introduce a new type of circuit they call "Inception PCs." This new circuit design is similar to their previous work on "sum of compatible squares" models. The key idea is that the Inception PCs can overcome the limitations of the single squared circuits, allowing for more complex and powerful representations of data.
Importantly, the authors note that their results were developed at the same time as independent work by other researchers, Wang and Van den Broeck. Both teams appear to have arrived at similar conclusions about the advantages of the more complex circuit designs over simpler models.
Technical Explanation
The paper demonstrates that structured-decomposable monotonic circuits can be exponentially more expressive than a single squared circuit with real parameters. This is shown through the introduction of a specific family of separating functions.
To address this limitation of single squared circuits, the authors introduce a new class of circuits called Inception PCs. These circuits are designed to be more expressive and powerful than the single squared circuits, similar to the authors' previous work on sum of compatible squares model class.
The authors note that these results were obtained concurrently with independent work by Wang and Van den Broeck (2024), who also demonstrated the limitations of structured-decomposable monotonic circuits and introduced Inception PCs as a solution.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough analysis of the expressive power of different circuit designs, but does not delve into the practical implications or real-world applications of these findings. It would be helpful to see more discussion on how these theoretical results could be leveraged in hardware-efficient inference of probabilistic circuits or other relevant areas.
Additionally, the paper does not address potential challenges or limitations in the implementation of Inception PCs, such as computational complexity or the difficulty of training these more complex models. Further research may be needed to understand the tradeoffs and practical considerations when deploying these circuits in actual applications.
Conclusion
The key takeaway from this paper is that structured-decomposable monotonic circuits have inherent limitations in their expressive power, which can be overcome by using more complex circuit designs like Inception PCs. This work contributes to the ongoing research on building expressive and tractable probabilistic generative models and demystifying probabilistic generating circuits. The findings could have important implications for the development of more powerful and versatile machine learning models in the future.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Sum of Squares Circuits
Lorenzo Loconte, Stefan Mengel, Antonio Vergari
Designing expressive generative models that support exact and efficient inference is a core question in probabilistic ML. Probabilistic circuits (PCs) offer a framework where this tractability-vs-expressiveness trade-off can be analyzed theoretically. Recently, squared PCs encoding subtractive mixtures via negative parameters have emerged as tractable models that can be exponentially more expressive than monotonic PCs, i.e., PCs with positive parameters only. In this paper, we provide a more precise theoretical characterization of the expressiveness relationships among these models. First, we prove that squared PCs can be less expressive than monotonic ones. Second, we formalize a novel class of PCs -- sum of squares PCs -- that can be exponentially more expressive than both squared and monotonic PCs. Around sum of squares PCs, we build an expressiveness hierarchy that allows us to precisely unify and separate different tractable model classes such as Born Machines and PSD models, and other recently introduced tractable probabilistic models by using complex parameters. Finally, we empirically show the effectiveness of sum of squares circuits in performing distribution estimation.
Read more8/22/2024
0
On the Relationship Between Monotone and Squared Probabilistic Circuits
Benjie Wang, Guy Van den Broeck
Probabilistic circuits are a unifying representation of functions as computation graphs of weighted sums and products. Their primary application is in probabilistic modeling, where circuits with non-negative weights (monotone circuits) can be used to represent and learn density/mass functions, with tractable marginal inference. Recently, it was proposed to instead represent densities as the square of the circuit function (squared circuits); this allows the use of negative weights while retaining tractability, and can be exponentially more compact than monotone circuits. Unfortunately, we show the reverse also holds, meaning that monotone circuits and squared circuits are incomparable in general. This raises the question of whether we can reconcile, and indeed improve upon the two modeling approaches. We answer in the positive by proposing InceptionPCs, a novel type of circuit that naturally encompasses both monotone circuits and squared circuits as special cases, and employs complex parameters. Empirically, we validate that InceptionPCs can outperform both monotone and squared circuits on image datasets.
Read more8/6/2024
💬
0
Building Expressive and Tractable Probabilistic Generative Models: A Review
Sahil Sidheekh, Sriraam Natarajan
We present a comprehensive survey of the advancements and techniques in the field of tractable probabilistic generative modeling, primarily focusing on Probabilistic Circuits (PCs). We provide a unified perspective on the inherent trade-offs between expressivity and tractability, highlighting the design principles and algorithmic extensions that have enabled building expressive and efficient PCs, and provide a taxonomy of the field. We also discuss recent efforts to build deep and hybrid PCs by fusing notions from deep neural models, and outline the challenges and open questions that can guide future research in this evolving field.
Read more6/7/2024
👁️
0
Subtractive Mixture Models via Squaring: Representation and Learning
Lorenzo Loconte, Aleksanteri M. Sladek, Stefan Mengel, Martin Trapp, Arno Solin, Nicolas Gillis, Antonio Vergari
Mixture models are traditionally represented and learned by adding several distributions as components. Allowing mixtures to subtract probability mass or density can drastically reduce the number of components needed to model complex distributions. However, learning such subtractive mixtures while ensuring they still encode a non-negative function is challenging. We investigate how to learn and perform inference on deep subtractive mixtures by squaring them. We do this in the framework of probabilistic circuits, which enable us to represent tensorized mixtures and generalize several other subtractive models. We theoretically prove that the class of squared circuits allowing subtractions can be exponentially more expressive than traditional additive mixtures; and, we empirically show this increased expressiveness on a series of real-world distribution estimation tasks.
Read more4/29/2024