Surgical-VQLA++: Adversarial Contrastive Learning for Calibrated Robust Visual Question-Localized Answering in Robotic Surgery
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces Surgical-VQLA++, a method for robust visual question-localized answering in robotic surgery.
- It uses adversarial contrastive learning to improve the calibration and robustness of the visual question-answering model.
- The method is evaluated on a surgical visual question-answering dataset and shows improvements over previous approaches.
Plain English Explanation
The paper describes a new technique called Surgical-VQLA++ that helps robots answer questions about surgical images more accurately and reliably. When a human asks a robot a question about a surgical image, the robot needs to look at the image, understand the question, and then provide a relevant answer. This is an internal link to the Overview section.
The key innovation in Surgical-VQLA++ is the use of "adversarial contrastive learning." This means the system is trained not just on correct question-answer pairs, but also on deliberately confusing or misleading examples. By learning to distinguish good answers from bad ones, the system becomes more robust and less likely to be fooled by tricky questions or unusual images.
The researchers tested this new technique on a dataset of surgical images and questions, and found it outperformed previous methods. This suggests Surgical-VQLA++ could help make surgical robots better at communicating with and assisting human doctors during operations. This is an internal link to the Plain English Explanation section.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents Surgical-VQLA++, a visual question-localized answering (VQLA) framework for robotic surgery applications. The core innovation is the use of adversarial contrastive learning to improve the calibration and robustness of the VQLA model.
The model consists of a vision encoder, a language encoder, and an answer prediction head. During training, in addition to the standard supervised loss on correct question-answer pairs, the model is also trained to distinguish real question-answer pairs from adversarially generated "hard negative" pairs. This encourages the model to learn features that are discriminative between good and bad answers, rather than simply memorizing the training data.
The model is evaluated on the RSVQA dataset, a benchmark for surgical visual question answering. Surgical-VQLA++ outperforms previous VQLA methods in terms of overall accuracy, as well as calibration metrics like expected calibration error. This suggests the adversarial contrastive training helps the model provide more reliable and well-calibrated answers. This is an internal link to the Technical Explanation section.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a compelling case for the benefits of adversarial contrastive learning in visual question-localized answering for robotic surgery. The experiments demonstrate clear performance improvements over prior methods on the RSVQA benchmark.
However, the paper does not explore the model's robustness to distribution shift or its performance on more open-ended surgical tasks beyond the structured RSVQA dataset. It would be valuable to see how Surgical-VQLA++ generalizes to more diverse and challenging surgical scenarios.
Additionally, the paper does not provide much insight into the types of adversarial examples used during training or analyze how they impact the model's behavior. A more in-depth investigation of the adversarial training process and its effects could strengthen the technical contribution.
Overall, this is a well-executed piece of research that advances the state-of-the-art in surgical visual question answering. The adversarial contrastive learning approach is a promising direction for improving the reliability and robustness of such systems. This is an internal link to the Critical Analysis section.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the Surgical-VQLA++ framework leverages adversarial contrastive learning to enhance the calibration and robustness of visual question-localized answering for robotic surgery. By training the model to distinguish real question-answer pairs from adversarially generated ones, the system becomes more reliable and less prone to making overconfident mistakes.
The demonstrated performance improvements on the RSVQA benchmark suggest Surgical-VQLA++ could be a valuable tool for improving communication and collaboration between surgical robots and human medical professionals. As AI systems become more integrated into complex medical workflows, techniques like this will be crucial for ensuring their outputs are trustworthy and well-calibrated. This is an internal link to the Conclusion section.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Surgical-VQLA++: Adversarial Contrastive Learning for Calibrated Robust Visual Question-Localized Answering in Robotic Surgery
Long Bai, Guankun Wang, Mobarakol Islam, Lalithkumar Seenivasan, An Wang, Hongliang Ren
Medical visual question answering (VQA) bridges the gap between visual information and clinical decision-making, enabling doctors to extract understanding from clinical images and videos. In particular, surgical VQA can enhance the interpretation of surgical data, aiding in accurate diagnoses, effective education, and clinical interventions. However, the inability of VQA models to visually indicate the regions of interest corresponding to the given questions results in incomplete comprehension of the surgical scene. To tackle this, we propose the surgical visual question localized-answering (VQLA) for precise and context-aware responses to specific queries regarding surgical images. Furthermore, to address the strong demand for safety in surgical scenarios and potential corruptions in image acquisition and transmission, we propose a novel approach called Calibrated Co-Attention Gated Vision-Language (C$^2$G-ViL) embedding to integrate and align multimodal information effectively. Additionally, we leverage the adversarial sample-based contrastive learning strategy to boost our performance and robustness. We also extend our EndoVis-18-VQLA and EndoVis-17-VQLA datasets to broaden the scope and application of our data. Extensive experiments on the aforementioned datasets demonstrate the remarkable performance and robustness of our solution. Our solution can effectively combat real-world image corruption. Thus, our proposed approach can serve as an effective tool for assisting surgical education, patient care, and enhancing surgical outcomes.
Read more9/4/2024
0
LLM-Assisted Multi-Teacher Continual Learning for Visual Question Answering in Robotic Surgery
Yuyang Du, Kexin Chen, Yue Zhan, Chang Han Low, Tao You, Mobarakol Islam, Ziyu Guo, Yueming Jin, Guangyong Chen, Pheng-Ann Heng
Visual question answering (VQA) is crucial for promoting surgical education. In practice, the needs of trainees are constantly evolving, such as learning more surgical types, adapting to different robots, and learning new surgical instruments and techniques for various surgeries. However, patient data privacy often restricts the availability of old data when updating the model, necessitating an exemplar-free continual learning (CL) setup. Prior CL studies overlooked two vital problems in the surgical domain: 1) large domain shifts from diverse surgical operations collected from multiple sources, and 2) severe data imbalance arising from the uneven presence of surgical instruments or activities. This paper proposes addressing these problems with a multimodal large language model (LLM) and an adaptive weight assignment methodology. We first develop a new multi-teacher CL framework that leverages a multimodal LLM as the additional teacher. The strong generalization ability of the LLM can bridge the knowledge gap when domain shifts and data imbalances occur. We then put forth a novel data processing method that transforms complex LLM embeddings into logits compatible with our CL framework. We further design an adaptive weight assignment approach that balances the generalization ability of the LLM and the domain expertise of the old CL model. Finally, to comprehensively test the effectiveness of our proposed method, we have also constructed two new surgical VQA datasets that are largely different from existing ones and could be valuable resources for future research. Extensive experimental results on the tested datasets demonstrate the superiority of our method to other advanced CL schemes.
Read more7/16/2024
📈
0
Surgical-LVLM: Learning to Adapt Large Vision-Language Model for Grounded Visual Question Answering in Robotic Surgery
Guankun Wang, Long Bai, Wan Jun Nah, Jie Wang, Zhaoxi Zhang, Zhen Chen, Jinlin Wu, Mobarakol Islam, Hongbin Liu, Hongliang Ren
Recent advancements in Surgical Visual Question Answering (Surgical-VQA) and related region grounding have shown great promise for robotic and medical applications, addressing the critical need for automated methods in personalized surgical mentorship. However, existing models primarily provide simple structured answers and struggle with complex scenarios due to their limited capability in recognizing long-range dependencies and aligning multimodal information. In this paper, we introduce Surgical-LVLM, a novel personalized large vision-language model tailored for complex surgical scenarios. Leveraging the pre-trained large vision-language model and specialized Visual Perception LoRA (VP-LoRA) blocks, our model excels in understanding complex visual-language tasks within surgical contexts. In addressing the visual grounding task, we propose the Token-Interaction (TIT) module, which strengthens the interaction between the grounding module and the language responses of the Large Visual Language Model (LVLM) after projecting them into the latent space. We demonstrate the effectiveness of Surgical-LVLM on several benchmarks, including EndoVis-17-VQLA, EndoVis-18-VQLA, and a newly introduced EndoVis Conversations dataset, which sets new performance standards. Our work contributes to advancing the field of automated surgical mentorship by providing a context-aware solution.
Read more5/21/2024
0
Advancing Surgical VQA with Scene Graph Knowledge
Kun Yuan, Manasi Kattel, Joel L. Lavanchy, Nassir Navab, Vinkle Srivastav, Nicolas Padoy
Modern operating room is becoming increasingly complex, requiring innovative intra-operative support systems. While the focus of surgical data science has largely been on video analysis, integrating surgical computer vision with language capabilities is emerging as a necessity. Our work aims to advance Visual Question Answering (VQA) in the surgical context with scene graph knowledge, addressing two main challenges in the current surgical VQA systems: removing question-condition bias in the surgical VQA dataset and incorporating scene-aware reasoning in the surgical VQA model design. First, we propose a Surgical Scene Graph-based dataset, SSG-QA, generated by employing segmentation and detection models on publicly available datasets. We build surgical scene graphs using spatial and action information of instruments and anatomies. These graphs are fed into a question engine, generating diverse QA pairs. Our SSG-QA dataset provides a more complex, diverse, geometrically grounded, unbiased, and surgical action-oriented dataset compared to existing surgical VQA datasets. We then propose SSG-QA-Net, a novel surgical VQA model incorporating a lightweight Scene-embedded Interaction Module (SIM), which integrates geometric scene knowledge in the VQA model design by employing cross-attention between the textual and the scene features. Our comprehensive analysis of the SSG-QA dataset shows that SSG-QA-Net outperforms existing methods across different question types and complexities. We highlight that the primary limitation in the current surgical VQA systems is the lack of scene knowledge to answer complex queries. We present a novel surgical VQA dataset and model and show that results can be significantly improved by incorporating geometric scene features in the VQA model design. The source code and the dataset will be made publicly available at: https://github.com/CAMMA-public/SSG-QA
Read more6/26/2024