Advancing Surgical VQA with Scene Graph Knowledge
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper focuses on improving surgical visual question answering (VQA) by incorporating scene graph knowledge.
- The researchers develop a new surgical VQA dataset called SSG-QA, which contains scene graph annotations for surgical images.
- They propose a model that leverages the scene graph information to enhance VQA performance on surgical tasks.
- The model is evaluated on the SSG-QA dataset and shows improved results compared to existing VQA approaches.
Plain English Explanation
The paper is about making it easier for computer systems to answer questions about surgical images. Surgical images can be very complex, with many different tools, body parts, and actions happening at once. To help computers understand these images better, the researchers created a new dataset called SSG-QA.
This dataset includes not just the surgical images and questions about them, but also "scene graphs" that describe the different objects, relationships, and actions in the images. For example, the scene graph might show that there is a "scalpel" near a "hand" that is "holding" the scalpel.
The researchers then developed a model that can use this scene graph information to better answer questions about the surgical images. By understanding the specific objects and relationships in the image, the model can provide more accurate and detailed answers to questions.
The researchers tested this model on the SSG-QA dataset and found that it performed better than other VQA models that don't use scene graph information. This suggests that incorporating scene graph knowledge can be a helpful way to improve computer understanding of complex surgical images and tasks.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a new approach to improve visual question answering (VQA) for surgical tasks by leveraging scene graph knowledge. The researchers first introduce the SSG-QA dataset, which provides scene graph annotations for a collection of surgical images. The scene graphs describe the objects, attributes, and relationships present in each image.
The core of the paper is a new VQA model that incorporates the scene graph information. The model takes in the image, the question, and the corresponding scene graph as input. It then uses a multi-modal fusion approach to combine the visual, textual, and structural (scene graph) features to produce an answer.
The model architecture is similar to that described in the PITVQA paper, with additional components to process the scene graph data. [The use of large vision-language models fine-tuned on medical data, as in the Surgical-LVLM and Fusion papers](https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/surgical-lvlm-learning-to-adapt-large-vision, https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/fusion-domain-adapted-vision-language-models-medical), also plays a key role.
Experiments on the SSG-QA dataset show that the proposed model outperforms standard VQA approaches that do not leverage scene graph knowledge. The authors attribute this improvement to the model's ability to better understand the complex spatial and semantic relationships present in surgical scenes.
The dataset creation and simulation techniques build on prior work in efficient data-driven scene simulation using robotics, and the open vocabulary scene understanding connects to the broader from pixels to graphs line of research.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach to improving surgical VQA by incorporating scene graph knowledge. The authors have carefully designed the SSG-QA dataset and developed a model that can effectively leverage the additional structural information provided by the scene graphs.
One potential limitation is the size and diversity of the SSG-QA dataset. While the authors have made an effort to create a large and representative dataset, it is still confined to the surgical domain. It would be interesting to see how well the proposed approach generalizes to other complex visual domains beyond surgery.
Additionally, the authors do not provide a detailed analysis of the specific types of questions or tasks where the scene graph-based model excels. Understanding these nuances could help guide future research and application development in this area.
Finally, the authors mention that the scene graph annotations were generated semi-automatically. While this is a reasonable approach, it raises questions about the consistency and accuracy of the annotations, which could impact the model's performance.
Overall, this paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of surgical VQA by demonstrating the potential of leveraging scene graph knowledge. Further research into dataset expansion, model interpretability, and annotation quality could help build upon these promising results.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to improving visual question answering for surgical tasks by incorporating scene graph knowledge. The researchers develop a new dataset, SSG-QA, that provides scene graph annotations for surgical images, and they propose a model that can effectively leverage this structural information to enhance VQA performance.
The results show that the scene graph-based model outperforms standard VQA approaches, highlighting the importance of understanding the complex spatial and semantic relationships present in surgical scenes. This work represents an important step forward in advancing computer vision and language understanding for medical applications, with the potential to improve decision support and knowledge extraction from surgical data.
Future research directions could explore ways to scale the dataset, improve annotation quality, and further investigate the specific strengths and limitations of the scene graph-based approach. Continued advancements in this area could lead to more powerful and reliable tools for surgical training, planning, and real-time assistance.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Advancing Surgical VQA with Scene Graph Knowledge
Kun Yuan, Manasi Kattel, Joel L. Lavanchy, Nassir Navab, Vinkle Srivastav, Nicolas Padoy
Modern operating room is becoming increasingly complex, requiring innovative intra-operative support systems. While the focus of surgical data science has largely been on video analysis, integrating surgical computer vision with language capabilities is emerging as a necessity. Our work aims to advance Visual Question Answering (VQA) in the surgical context with scene graph knowledge, addressing two main challenges in the current surgical VQA systems: removing question-condition bias in the surgical VQA dataset and incorporating scene-aware reasoning in the surgical VQA model design. First, we propose a Surgical Scene Graph-based dataset, SSG-QA, generated by employing segmentation and detection models on publicly available datasets. We build surgical scene graphs using spatial and action information of instruments and anatomies. These graphs are fed into a question engine, generating diverse QA pairs. Our SSG-QA dataset provides a more complex, diverse, geometrically grounded, unbiased, and surgical action-oriented dataset compared to existing surgical VQA datasets. We then propose SSG-QA-Net, a novel surgical VQA model incorporating a lightweight Scene-embedded Interaction Module (SIM), which integrates geometric scene knowledge in the VQA model design by employing cross-attention between the textual and the scene features. Our comprehensive analysis of the SSG-QA dataset shows that SSG-QA-Net outperforms existing methods across different question types and complexities. We highlight that the primary limitation in the current surgical VQA systems is the lack of scene knowledge to answer complex queries. We present a novel surgical VQA dataset and model and show that results can be significantly improved by incorporating geometric scene features in the VQA model design. The source code and the dataset will be made publicly available at: https://github.com/CAMMA-public/SSG-QA
Read more6/26/2024
0
SANGRIA: Surgical Video Scene Graph Optimization for Surgical Workflow Prediction
c{C}au{g}han Koksal, Ghazal Ghazaei, Felix Holm, Azade Farshad, Nassir Navab
Graph-based holistic scene representations facilitate surgical workflow understanding and have recently demonstrated significant success. However, this task is often hindered by the limited availability of densely annotated surgical scene data. In this work, we introduce an end-to-end framework for the generation and optimization of surgical scene graphs on a downstream task. Our approach leverages the flexibility of graph-based spectral clustering and the generalization capability of foundation models to generate unsupervised scene graphs with learnable properties. We reinforce the initial spatial graph with sparse temporal connections using local matches between consecutive frames to predict temporally consistent clusters across a temporal neighborhood. By jointly optimizing the spatiotemporal relations and node features of the dynamic scene graph with the downstream task of phase segmentation, we address the costly and annotation-burdensome task of semantic scene comprehension and scene graph generation in surgical videos using only weak surgical phase labels. Further, by incorporating effective intermediate scene representation disentanglement steps within the pipeline, our solution outperforms the SOTA on the CATARACTS dataset by 8% accuracy and 10% F1 score in surgical workflow recognition
Read more7/30/2024
0
Surgical-VQLA++: Adversarial Contrastive Learning for Calibrated Robust Visual Question-Localized Answering in Robotic Surgery
Long Bai, Guankun Wang, Mobarakol Islam, Lalithkumar Seenivasan, An Wang, Hongliang Ren
Medical visual question answering (VQA) bridges the gap between visual information and clinical decision-making, enabling doctors to extract understanding from clinical images and videos. In particular, surgical VQA can enhance the interpretation of surgical data, aiding in accurate diagnoses, effective education, and clinical interventions. However, the inability of VQA models to visually indicate the regions of interest corresponding to the given questions results in incomplete comprehension of the surgical scene. To tackle this, we propose the surgical visual question localized-answering (VQLA) for precise and context-aware responses to specific queries regarding surgical images. Furthermore, to address the strong demand for safety in surgical scenarios and potential corruptions in image acquisition and transmission, we propose a novel approach called Calibrated Co-Attention Gated Vision-Language (C$^2$G-ViL) embedding to integrate and align multimodal information effectively. Additionally, we leverage the adversarial sample-based contrastive learning strategy to boost our performance and robustness. We also extend our EndoVis-18-VQLA and EndoVis-17-VQLA datasets to broaden the scope and application of our data. Extensive experiments on the aforementioned datasets demonstrate the remarkable performance and robustness of our solution. Our solution can effectively combat real-world image corruption. Thus, our proposed approach can serve as an effective tool for assisting surgical education, patient care, and enhancing surgical outcomes.
Read more9/4/2024
🌀
0
PitVQA: Image-grounded Text Embedding LLM for Visual Question Answering in Pituitary Surgery
Runlong He, Mengya Xu, Adrito Das, Danyal Z. Khan, Sophia Bano, Hani J. Marcus, Danail Stoyanov, Matthew J. Clarkson, Mobarakol Islam
Visual Question Answering (VQA) within the surgical domain, utilizing Large Language Models (LLMs), offers a distinct opportunity to improve intra-operative decision-making and facilitate intuitive surgeon-AI interaction. However, the development of LLMs for surgical VQA is hindered by the scarcity of diverse and extensive datasets with complex reasoning tasks. Moreover, contextual fusion of the image and text modalities remains an open research challenge due to the inherent differences between these two types of information and the complexity involved in aligning them. This paper introduces PitVQA, a novel dataset specifically designed for VQA in endonasal pituitary surgery and PitVQA-Net, an adaptation of the GPT2 with a novel image-grounded text embedding for surgical VQA. PitVQA comprises 25 procedural videos and a rich collection of question-answer pairs spanning crucial surgical aspects such as phase and step recognition, context understanding, tool detection and localization, and tool-tissue interactions. PitVQA-Net consists of a novel image-grounded text embedding that projects image and text features into a shared embedding space and GPT2 Backbone with an excitation block classification head to generate contextually relevant answers within the complex domain of endonasal pituitary surgery. Our image-grounded text embedding leverages joint embedding, cross-attention and contextual representation to understand the contextual relationship between questions and surgical images. We demonstrate the effectiveness of PitVQA-Net on both the PitVQA and the publicly available EndoVis18-VQA dataset, achieving improvements in balanced accuracy of 8% and 9% over the most recent baselines, respectively. Our code and dataset is available at https://github.com/mobarakol/PitVQA.
Read more5/24/2024