A Survey of Deep Learning-based Radiology Report Generation Using Multimodal Data

Read original: arXiv:2405.12833 - Published 5/22/2024 by Xinyi Wang, Grazziela Figueredo, Ruizhe Li, Wei Emma Zhang, Weitong Chen, Xin Chen

🤿

Overview

This paper provides a comprehensive survey of the latest advances in automatic radiology report generation using deep learning-based methods.
Automatic radiology report generation can help alleviate the workload for physicians and address regional disparities in medical resources, making it an important topic in medical image analysis.
The paper proposes a general workflow for deep learning-based report generation with five main components: multi-modality data acquisition, data preparation, feature learning, feature fusion/interaction, and report generation.
The survey highlights the state-of-the-art methods for each of these components and summarizes training strategies, public datasets, evaluation methods, current challenges, and future directions in this field.
The authors also conducted a quantitative comparison between different methods under the same experimental setting.

Plain English Explanation

Radiology reports are an essential part of healthcare, as they provide detailed information about medical images and help doctors diagnose and treat patients. However, writing these reports can be a time-consuming task for physicians, especially in areas with limited medical resources. To address this issue, researchers have been exploring the use of deep learning to automatically generate radiology reports.

The process of automatically generating radiology reports is quite complex, as the computer system needs to understand the information in the medical images, as well as any additional clinical data or medical knowledge, and then produce a comprehensive and accurate report. This requires advanced techniques in areas like multi-modal data fusion and natural language generation.

In this survey paper, the authors provide an overview of the latest developments in this field, including the key components of a typical deep learning-based report generation system. They also highlight the current challenges and future research directions, as well as conduct a comparison of different methods to help researchers in this area develop even more advanced algorithms.

Overall, the ability to automatically generate radiology reports has the potential to greatly improve the efficiency of healthcare delivery and ensure that patients in underserved regions can still receive high-quality medical care.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a general workflow for deep learning-based radiology report generation, which consists of five main components:

Multi-modality Data Acquisition: The system needs to gather various types of input data, such as medical images, clinical information, and medical knowledge, to support the report generation process.
Data Preparation: The input data must be preprocessed and organized in a way that can be effectively used by the deep learning models.
Feature Learning: Deep learning models, such as transformers, are employed to extract relevant features from the input data.
Feature Fusion/Interaction: The features from different modalities are combined and their interactions are modeled to capture the complex relationships between the input data.
Report Generation: The final step is to use the fused features to generate the actual radiology report, often with the help of natural language generation techniques.

The paper surveys the state-of-the-art methods for each of these components, highlighting the key technical advances. For example, the authors discuss the use of contrastive learning to improve feature learning from medical images.

In addition to the workflow, the paper also covers important aspects such as training strategies, public datasets, evaluation methods, current challenges, and future research directions in this field. The authors also conducted a quantitative comparison of different methods under the same experimental setting, providing valuable insights for researchers.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a comprehensive and well-structured survey of the latest developments in automatic radiology report generation using deep learning. The proposed workflow and the detailed discussion of the key components are particularly useful for researchers in this field.

One potential limitation of the paper is that it focuses primarily on the technical aspects of the problem, with relatively less emphasis on the real-world implications and potential challenges in deploying such systems in clinical settings. For example, the paper does not delve into issues such as the interpretability of the generated reports, the need for clinician oversight, and the potential ethical concerns around the use of AI in medical decision-making.

Additionally, while the quantitative comparison of different methods is a strength of the paper, the authors could have provided more detailed analysis and discussion of the results, highlighting the specific strengths and weaknesses of each approach.

Overall, this survey paper is a valuable resource for researchers interested in automatic radiology report generation and medical image analysis, especially when using multimodal inputs. It provides a solid foundation for understanding the current state-of-the-art and identifying future research directions in this important and rapidly evolving field.

Conclusion

This survey paper presents a comprehensive overview of the latest advances in automatic radiology report generation using deep learning-based methods. The proposed general workflow and the detailed discussion of the key technical components provide a clear roadmap for researchers working in this field.

The ability to automatically generate radiology reports has the potential to significantly improve the efficiency of healthcare delivery and address regional disparities in medical resources. By alleviating the workload for physicians, these AI-powered systems can help ensure that patients, even in underserved areas, have access to high-quality medical care.

While the paper focuses primarily on the technical aspects, it also highlights the current challenges and future research directions, which will be crucial for the successful deployment of these systems in real-world clinical settings. As the field continues to evolve, further research is needed to address issues such as interpretability, clinician oversight, and ethical considerations.

Overall, this survey paper is a valuable resource for researchers interested in automatic clinical report generation and medical image analysis, particularly when using multimodal inputs. It provides a solid foundation for understanding the state-of-the-art and shaping the future of this important and impactful field.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🤿

A Survey of Deep Learning-based Radiology Report Generation Using Multimodal Data

Xinyi Wang, Grazziela Figueredo, Ruizhe Li, Wei Emma Zhang, Weitong Chen, Xin Chen

Automatic radiology report generation can alleviate the workload for physicians and minimize regional disparities in medical resources, therefore becoming an important topic in the medical image analysis field. It is a challenging task, as the computational model needs to mimic physicians to obtain information from multi-modal input data (i.e., medical images, clinical information, medical knowledge, etc.), and produce comprehensive and accurate reports. Recently, numerous works emerged to address this issue using deep learning-based methods, such as transformers, contrastive learning, and knowledge-base construction. This survey summarizes the key techniques developed in the most recent works and proposes a general workflow for deep learning-based report generation with five main components, including multi-modality data acquisition, data preparation, feature learning, feature fusion/interaction, and report generation. The state-of-the-art methods for each of these components are highlighted. Additionally, training strategies, public datasets, evaluation methods, current challenges, and future directions in this field are summarized. We have also conducted a quantitative comparison between different methods under the same experimental setting. This is the most up-to-date survey that focuses on multi-modality inputs and data fusion for radiology report generation. The aim is to provide comprehensive and rich information for researchers interested in automatic clinical report generation and medical image analysis, especially when using multimodal inputs, and assist them in developing new algorithms to advance the field.

5/22/2024

Automated Radiology Report Generation: A Review of Recent Advances

Phillip Sloan, Philip Clatworthy, Edwin Simpson, Majid Mirmehdi

Increasing demands on medical imaging departments are taking a toll on the radiologist's ability to deliver timely and accurate reports. Recent technological advances in artificial intelligence have demonstrated great potential for automatic radiology report generation (ARRG), sparking an explosion of research. This survey paper conducts a methodological review of contemporary ARRG approaches by way of (i) assessing datasets based on characteristics, such as availability, size, and adoption rate, (ii) examining deep learning training methods, such as contrastive learning and reinforcement learning, (iii) exploring state-of-the-art model architectures, including variations of CNN and transformer models, (iv) outlining techniques integrating clinical knowledge through multimodal inputs and knowledge graphs, and (v) scrutinising current model evaluation techniques, including commonly applied NLP metrics and qualitative clinical reviews. Furthermore, the quantitative results of the reviewed models are analysed, where the top performing models are examined to seek further insights. Finally, potential new directions are highlighted, with the adoption of additional datasets from other radiological modalities and improved evaluation methods predicted as important areas of future development.

5/30/2024

A Systematic Review of Deep Learning-based Research on Radiology Report Generation

Chang Liu, Yuanhe Tian, Yan Song

Radiology report generation (RRG) aims to automatically generate free-text descriptions from clinical radiographs, e.g., chest X-Ray images. RRG plays an essential role in promoting clinical automation and presents significant help to provide practical assistance for inexperienced doctors and alleviate radiologists' workloads. Therefore, consider these meaningful potentials, research on RRG is experiencing explosive growth in the past half-decade, especially with the rapid development of deep learning approaches. Existing studies perform RRG from the perspective of enhancing different modalities, provide insights on optimizing the report generation process with elaborated features from both visual and textual information, and further facilitate RRG with the cross-modal interactions among them. In this paper, we present a comprehensive review of deep learning-based RRG from various perspectives. Specifically, we firstly cover pivotal RRG approaches based on the task-specific features of radiographs, reports, and the cross-modal relations between them, and then illustrate the benchmark datasets conventionally used for this task with evaluation metrics, subsequently analyze the performance of different approaches and finally offer our summary on the challenges and the trends in future directions. Overall, the goal of this paper is to serve as a tool for understanding existing literature and inspiring potential valuable research in the field of RRG.

4/26/2024

🤿

Integrating Medical Imaging and Clinical Reports Using Multimodal Deep Learning for Advanced Disease Analysis

Ziyan Yao, Fei Lin, Sheng Chai, Weijie He, Lu Dai, Xinghui Fei

In this paper, an innovative multi-modal deep learning model is proposed to deeply integrate heterogeneous information from medical images and clinical reports. First, for medical images, convolutional neural networks were used to extract high-dimensional features and capture key visual information such as focal details, texture and spatial distribution. Secondly, for clinical report text, a two-way long and short-term memory network combined with an attention mechanism is used for deep semantic understanding, and key statements related to the disease are accurately captured. The two features interact and integrate effectively through the designed multi-modal fusion layer to realize the joint representation learning of image and text. In the empirical study, we selected a large medical image database covering a variety of diseases, combined with corresponding clinical reports for model training and validation. The proposed multimodal deep learning model demonstrated substantial superiority in the realms of disease classification, lesion localization, and clinical description generation, as evidenced by the experimental results.

5/29/2024