Symmetry Induces Structure and Constraint of Learning
2309.16932
0
0
Abstract
Due to common architecture designs, symmetries exist extensively in contemporary neural networks. In this work, we unveil the importance of the loss function symmetries in affecting, if not deciding, the learning behavior of machine learning models. We prove that every mirror-reflection symmetry, with reflection surface $O$, in the loss function leads to the emergence of a constraint on the model parameters $theta$: $O^Ttheta =0$. This constrained solution becomes satisfied when either the weight decay or gradient noise is large. Common instances of mirror symmetries in deep learning include rescaling, rotation, and permutation symmetry. As direct corollaries, we show that rescaling symmetry leads to sparsity, rotation symmetry leads to low rankness, and permutation symmetry leads to homogeneous ensembling. Then, we show that the theoretical framework can explain intriguing phenomena, such as the loss of plasticity and various collapse phenomena in neural networks, and suggest how symmetries can be used to design an elegant algorithm to enforce hard constraints in a differentiable way.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores how symmetry in machine learning models can lead to structured constraints on the learning process.
- The authors investigate common symmetries, such as rescaling and translation, and analyze their consequences for model training and performance.
- The findings suggest that symmetries can induce sparsity in model parameters, shape the loss landscape, and influence the convergence and generalization of learning algorithms.
Plain English Explanation
Symmetry is an important concept in machine learning. When a model has certain symmetries, it means that certain transformations (like scaling or shifting the inputs) don't change the model's behavior. This paper examines how these symmetries can actually shape and constrain the learning process.
For example, the authors show that a rescaling symmetry - where multiplying all the model parameters by the same constant doesn't change the model's output - can lead to sparsity in the learned parameters. This sparsity can have benefits like improved interpretability and efficiency. The symmetries also affect the "loss landscape" - the shape of the optimization problem the model is trying to solve. This can influence how quickly and reliably the model converges during training, as well as its ability to generalize to new data.
Overall, the key insight is that symmetries are not just an abstract mathematical property, but can have tangible consequences for how machine learning models behave in practice. Understanding these symmetries could help researchers design better model architectures and training procedures.
Technical Explanation
The paper examines how common symmetries in machine learning models, such as rescaling and translation invariance, can lead to structured constraints on the learning process.
The authors first analyze the consequences of rescaling symmetry, where multiplying all the model parameters by a constant does not change the model's output. They show that this symmetry induces sparsity in the learned parameters, as the model can achieve the same function using a wide range of different parameter values.
Next, the paper explores how translation symmetry, where shifting the inputs does not affect the output, can shape the loss landscape of the optimization problem. The authors demonstrate that this symmetry can create "flat" regions in the loss landscape, which can slow down convergence of the training algorithm but also improve the model's ability to generalize to new data.
The paper also discusses how these symmetries can be leveraged to improve model performance. For example, architectures that are designed to be equivariant to certain transformations can better capture the true structure of the data, leading to faster convergence and better generalization.
Overall, the key contribution of the paper is to show that symmetries are not just abstract mathematical properties, but can have significant practical implications for how machine learning models behave and learn.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thoughtful analysis of how common symmetries in machine learning models can constrain and structure the learning process. The authors carefully examine the consequences of rescaling and translation symmetries, and demonstrate how these properties can lead to sparsity, shape the loss landscape, and influence convergence and generalization.
One potential limitation of the work is that it focuses primarily on "toy" examples and theoretical analysis, rather than extensive empirical validation on large-scale, real-world machine learning tasks. While the principles and insights are likely to generalize, further research is needed to fully understand the practical impact of these symmetry-induced phenomena.
Additionally, the paper does not explicitly discuss how these symmetry-based insights could be used to guide the design of more effective machine learning models and training algorithms. While the authors mention potential applications, a more detailed exploration of these ideas could be valuable for practitioners.
Overall, this paper makes an important contribution to our understanding of the role of symmetry in machine learning, and lays the groundwork for further research in this area. By highlighting the structured constraints that symmetries can introduce, the authors open up new possibilities for improving the performance and interpretability of neural networks and other complex models.
Conclusion
This paper demonstrates that symmetry is not just a mathematical curiosity in machine learning, but can have tangible and significant consequences for how models learn and behave. The authors show that common symmetries, such as rescaling and translation invariance, can induce sparsity in model parameters, shape the loss landscape, and influence the convergence and generalization of learning algorithms.
These findings have important implications for the design of more effective and interpretable machine learning models. By understanding and leveraging the structured constraints imposed by symmetries, researchers and practitioners may be able to develop architectures and training procedures that better capture the true structure of the data, leading to improved performance and robustness.
Overall, this paper makes a valuable contribution to the growing body of work exploring the role of symmetry in machine learning, and sets the stage for further advancements in this promising research direction.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
The Empirical Impact of Neural Parameter Symmetries, or Lack Thereof
Derek Lim, Moe Putterman, Robin Walters, Haggai Maron, Stefanie Jegelka
0
0
Many algorithms and observed phenomena in deep learning appear to be affected by parameter symmetries -- transformations of neural network parameters that do not change the underlying neural network function. These include linear mode connectivity, model merging, Bayesian neural network inference, metanetworks, and several other characteristics of optimization or loss-landscapes. However, theoretical analysis of the relationship between parameter space symmetries and these phenomena is difficult. In this work, we empirically investigate the impact of neural parameter symmetries by introducing new neural network architectures that have reduced parameter space symmetries. We develop two methods, with some provable guarantees, of modifying standard neural networks to reduce parameter space symmetries. With these new methods, we conduct a comprehensive experimental study consisting of multiple tasks aimed at assessing the effect of removing parameter symmetries. Our experiments reveal several interesting observations on the empirical impact of parameter symmetries; for instance, we observe linear mode connectivity between our networks without alignment of weight spaces, and we find that our networks allow for faster and more effective Bayesian neural network training.
6/21/2024
Loss Symmetry and Noise Equilibrium of Stochastic Gradient Descent
Liu Ziyin, Mingze Wang, Hongchao Li, Lei Wu
0
0
Symmetries exist abundantly in the loss function of neural networks. We characterize the learning dynamics of stochastic gradient descent (SGD) when exponential symmetries, a broad subclass of continuous symmetries, exist in the loss function. We establish that when gradient noises do not balance, SGD has the tendency to move the model parameters toward a point where noises from different directions are balanced. Here, a special type of fixed point in the constant directions of the loss function emerges as a candidate for solutions for SGD. As the main theoretical result, we prove that every parameter $theta$ connects without loss function barrier to a unique noise-balanced fixed point $theta^*$. The theory implies that the balancing of gradient noise can serve as a novel alternative mechanism for relevant phenomena such as progressive sharpening and flattening and can be applied to understand common practical problems such as representation normalization, matrix factorization, warmup, and formation of latent representations.
6/4/2024
📈
A Generative Model of Symmetry Transformations
James Urquhart Allingham, Bruno Kacper Mlodozeniec, Shreyas Padhy, Javier Antor'an, David Krueger, Richard E. Turner, Eric Nalisnick, Jos'e Miguel Hern'andez-Lobato
0
0
Correctly capturing the symmetry transformations of data can lead to efficient models with strong generalization capabilities, though methods incorporating symmetries often require prior knowledge. While recent advancements have been made in learning those symmetries directly from the dataset, most of this work has focused on the discriminative setting. In this paper, we take inspiration from group theoretic ideas to construct a generative model that explicitly aims to capture the data's approximate symmetries. This results in a model that, given a prespecified broad set of possible symmetries, learns to what extent, if at all, those symmetries are actually present. Our model can be seen as a generative process for data augmentation. We provide a simple algorithm for learning our generative model and empirically demonstrate its ability to capture symmetries under affine and color transformations, in an interpretable way. Combining our symmetry model with standard generative models results in higher marginal test-log-likelihoods and improved data efficiency.
6/24/2024
🖼️
Learning Probabilistic Symmetrization for Architecture Agnostic Equivariance
Jinwoo Kim, Tien Dat Nguyen, Ayhan Suleymanzade, Hyeokjun An, Seunghoon Hong
0
0
We present a novel framework to overcome the limitations of equivariant architectures in learning functions with group symmetries. In contrary to equivariant architectures, we use an arbitrary base model such as an MLP or a transformer and symmetrize it to be equivariant to the given group by employing a small equivariant network that parameterizes the probabilistic distribution underlying the symmetrization. The distribution is end-to-end trained with the base model which can maximize performance while reducing sample complexity of symmetrization. We show that this approach ensures not only equivariance to given group but also universal approximation capability in expectation. We implement our method on various base models, including patch-based transformers that can be initialized from pretrained vision transformers, and test them for a wide range of symmetry groups including permutation and Euclidean groups and their combinations. Empirical tests show competitive results against tailored equivariant architectures, suggesting the potential for learning equivariant functions for diverse groups using a non-equivariant universal base architecture. We further show evidence of enhanced learning in symmetric modalities, like graphs, when pretrained from non-symmetric modalities, like vision. Code is available at https://github.com/jw9730/lps.
4/16/2024