SynTQA: Synergistic Table-based Question Answering via Mixture of Text-to-SQL and E2E TQA
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- SynTQA is a novel approach to table-based question answering that combines text-to-SQL and end-to-end table question answering models.
- It aims to leverage the strengths of both methods to improve overall performance on table-based question answering tasks.
- The paper presents the SynTQA model architecture and experimental results on several benchmark datasets.
Plain English Explanation
SynTQA is a new system for answering questions about information stored in tables. It combines two different approaches to try to get the best of both worlds:
-
Text-to-SQL: This method first translates the question into a SQL query, and then runs that query on the table to get the answer. This works well for certain types of questions, but can struggle with more complex or open-ended questions.
-
End-to-end table question answering: This method tries to directly predict the answer from the question and the table, without going through SQL. This can handle a wider range of question types, but may not be as precise as the SQL-based approach.
SynTQA combines these two methods, using them together to try to get the best of both. The idea is that the strengths of one method can make up for the weaknesses of the other, leading to better overall performance on table-based question answering tasks.
The paper describes the SynTQA model architecture and presents experimental results showing that it outperforms either method used alone on several benchmark datasets.
Technical Explanation
The table question answering task involves answering natural language questions about information stored in tables. Traditional approaches have used either text-to-SQL models, which translate the question into a SQL query, or end-to-end table question answering models, which directly predict the answer from the question and table.
The SynTQA model proposed in this paper combines these two approaches. It has a text-to-SQL module that generates a SQL query, and an end-to-end table question answering module that predicts the answer directly. These two modules are trained jointly and their predictions are combined to produce the final answer.
The key innovation of SynTQA is the way it synergistically combines the text-to-SQL and end-to-end approaches. The text-to-SQL module helps the end-to-end module by providing relevant information about the structure of the table and the types of queries that may be needed. Conversely, the end-to-end module helps the text-to-SQL module by providing additional context that can aid in generating the correct SQL query.
The experiments reported in the paper show that SynTQA outperforms both the text-to-SQL and end-to-end approaches on several benchmark datasets for table question answering. This demonstrates the benefits of the synergistic combination of the two methods.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough evaluation of the SynTQA model and its performance on relevant benchmarks. However, a few potential limitations or areas for further research are worth noting:
-
Generalization to more complex tables: The experiments focused on relatively simple tables, and it's unclear how well SynTQA would scale to more complex, real-world tables with a larger number of columns and rows. Further research may be needed to understand the model's performance on more challenging table structures.
-
Explainability and interpretability: As a complex, hybrid model, SynTQA may be less interpretable than simpler, single-module approaches. Investigating ways to improve the model's transparency and explain its reasoning could be valuable.
-
Robustness to noise and perturbations: The paper does not address the model's robustness to common issues like typos, missing data, or adversarial attacks. Evaluating the model's ability to handle noisy or perturbed inputs would be an important next step.
Overall, the SynTQA approach seems promising, but further research is needed to fully understand its strengths, limitations, and potential real-world applications.
Conclusion
The SynTQA model presented in this paper represents an innovative approach to table-based question answering that leverages the strengths of both text-to-SQL and end-to-end table question answering methods. By combining these two techniques, SynTQA is able to outperform either approach used alone on several benchmark datasets.
This synergistic combination of models could have significant implications for practical applications that require answering questions about structured data stored in tables, such as in business intelligence, scientific research, or customer support. As the authors note, further research is needed to explore the model's performance on more complex, real-world tables and its robustness to various types of noise and perturbations. But the promising results reported in this paper suggest that SynTQA is an important step forward in the field of table-based question answering.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
SynTQA: Synergistic Table-based Question Answering via Mixture of Text-to-SQL and E2E TQA
Siyue Zhang, Anh Tuan Luu, Chen Zhao
Text-to-SQL parsing and end-to-end question answering (E2E TQA) are two main approaches for Table-based Question Answering task. Despite success on multiple benchmarks, they have yet to be compared and their synergy remains unexplored. In this paper, we identify different strengths and weaknesses through evaluating state-of-the-art models on benchmark datasets: Text-to-SQL demonstrates superiority in handling questions involving arithmetic operations and long tables; E2E TQA excels in addressing ambiguous questions, non-standard table schema, and complex table contents. To combine both strengths, we propose a Synergistic Table-based Question Answering approach that integrate different models via answer selection, which is agnostic to any model types. Further experiments validate that ensembling models by either feature-based or LLM-based answer selector significantly improves the performance over individual models.
Read more9/26/2024
0
QDA-SQL: Questions Enhanced Dialogue Augmentation for Multi-Turn Text-to-SQL
Yinggang Sun, Ziming Guo, Haining Yu, Chuanyi Liu, Xiang Li, Bingxuan Wang, Xiangzhan Yu, Tiancheng Zhao
Fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) for specific domain tasks has achieved great success in Text-to-SQL tasks. However, these fine-tuned models often face challenges with multi-turn Text-to-SQL tasks caused by ambiguous or unanswerable questions. It is desired to enhance LLMs to handle multiple types of questions in multi-turn Text-to-SQL tasks. To address this, we propose a novel data augmentation method, called QDA-SQL, which generates multiple types of multi-turn Q&A pairs by using LLMs. In QDA-SQL, we introduce a novel data augmentation method incorporating validation and correction mechanisms to handle complex multi-turn Text-to-SQL tasks. Experimental results demonstrate that QDA-SQL enables fine-tuned models to exhibit higher performance on SQL statement accuracy and enhances their ability to handle complex, unanswerable questions in multi-turn Text-to-SQL tasks. The generation script and test set are released at https://github.com/mcxiaoxiao/QDA-SQL.
Read more6/18/2024
0
Seek and Solve Reasoning for Table Question Answering
Ruya Jiang, Chun Wang, Weihong Deng
Table-based Question Answering (TQA) involves answering questions based on tabular data. The complexity of table structures and question logic makes this task difficult even for Large Language Models (LLMs). This paper improves TQA performance by leveraging LLMs' reasoning capabilities. Inspired by how humans solve TQA tasks, we propose a Seek-and-Solve pipeline that instructs the LLM to first seek relevant information and then answer questions. The two stages are integrated at the reasoning level, and their Chain of Thought (CoT) paths are integrated into a coherent Seek-and-Solve CoT (SS-CoT). Furthermore, we present a compact single-stage TQA-solving prompt distilled from the pipeline. Experiments demonstrate that under In-Context Learning settings, using samples with SS-CoT paths as demonstrations, the TQA-solving prompt can effectively guide the LLM to solve complex TQA tasks, resulting in improved performance and reliability. Our results highlight the importance of properly eliciting LLMs' reasoning capabilities in solving complex TQA tasks.
Read more9/10/2024
0
LG AI Research & KAIST at EHRSQL 2024: Self-Training Large Language Models with Pseudo-Labeled Unanswerable Questions for a Reliable Text-to-SQL System on EHRs
Yongrae Jo, Seongyun Lee, Minju Seo, Sung Ju Hwang, Moontae Lee
Text-to-SQL models are pivotal for making Electronic Health Records (EHRs) accessible to healthcare professionals without SQL knowledge. With the advancements in large language models, these systems have become more adept at translating complex questions into SQL queries. Nonetheless, the critical need for reliability in healthcare necessitates these models to accurately identify unanswerable questions or uncertain predictions, preventing misinformation. To address this problem, we present a self-training strategy using pseudo-labeled unanswerable questions to enhance the reliability of text-to-SQL models for EHRs. This approach includes a two-stage training process followed by a filtering method based on the token entropy and query execution. Our methodology's effectiveness is validated by our top performance in the EHRSQL 2024 shared task, showcasing the potential to improve healthcare decision-making through more reliable text-to-SQL systems.
Read more5/21/2024